Farewell Jesse Hogan

[Dee Dubya 220]

7 minutes ago, beelzebub said:

Next year's picks

Pick 18 won't be worth much. ?

[loges 6,767]

1 hour ago, Fifty-5 said:

Massive accusation totally unsupported by evidence.

http://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/2018-08-14/hogan-eager-to-help-teammates

“The doc told me there was a bit of a stress over the navicular [bone], so it’s three to four weeks completely off it, and then three to four weeks in the moon boot. I’m just trying to prepare for 2019.

Did he wear a moon boot for 3-4 weeks for laughs?

Your response to that post is way too kind.

[Older demon 2,736]

It was mentioned that GWS get pick 5 and hand over Lobb and 14. Has anyone done the points calculation on this trade. I ask because is what is 6 and 14 worth to us especially if pick 14 isn't enough for May? Would GC want pick 6 for May ?

What would Freemantle's first round pick next year be worth?  Would that be more attractive to GC than pick 14. So pick 6 this year and next years first round for Hogan.

[beelzebub 23,311]

2 minutes ago, old dee said:

After a comment from a wise man I think Mr. Hogan will be out and for less than we all think!!!!!!

I suspect this will not play out the way many imagine OD.

I think the FD know exactly what all the constraints are. The only real variables now are where 'others' picks will fall and therefore domino.

Trade week often throws up surprises.

Reminds me a bit of 'murder on the orient"'. Everyone had their story but the truth was a whole other matter. 

[Pennant St Dee 13,031]

6 minutes ago, McQueen said:

To be fair there was pretty slim pickings after Pav retired.

My mail off a credible WA media personality is that the players aren't 'connecting' to Fyfes style.

Mundy was voted in when Pav moved on and my mail was the older players got that vote over the line. One year later as the list profile changed Fyfe was voted in and the players voted him in this year for a second time so he's doing something right.

We shall see what happens next year 

[Older demon 2,736]

Re Jessie's foot injury. I know one of the professional's at the club who were looking after his foot. Let me put to rest those who think he was faking, he very definitely had a crack in the Navicular bone. The club was grateful that it was early on and not a full fracture requiring surgery. Seriously some of the conjecture and conspiracy theories stated are way out of line.

[Redleg 40,775]

1 hour ago, beelzebub said:

   Both clubs will have been circling this for some time. Disregard the spin... it's spin.

I can't disregard the spin, my head is in a spin.

I am like the girl from the exorcist.

Edited October 9, 2018 by Redleg

[DV8 2,271]

1 hour ago, SFebes said:

14 & Tyson to GC for May

14 & Tyson for May and KK !

[Redleg 40,775]

29 minutes ago, Alex Flood said:

Just a quick one fellas ?

Do we have enough room to keep Hogan while picking up May ?

I think JM said no.

[chook fowler 19,430]

maybe his foot in gangrenous

[Redleg 40,775]

24 minutes ago, beelzebub said:

Next year's picks

And maybe Tyson.

[Dockett 32 1,239]

1 minute ago, Redleg said:

I think JM said no.

Still think Freo are desperate for a key forward. 

No I think Freo are really desperate for a key forward.

[qwerty7 326]

19 minutes ago, Older demon said:

It was mentioned that GWS get pick 5 and hand over Lobb and 14. Has anyone done the points calculation on this trade. I ask because is what is 6 and 14 worth to us especially if pick 14 isn't enough for May? Would GC want pick 6 for May ?

What would Freemantle's first round pick next year be worth?  Would that be more attractive to GC than pick 14. So pick 6 this year and next years first round for Hogan.

GC will want a top 5 pick for sure. I do not necessarily think May is worth a top 5 pick but since Gold Coast will likely finish bottom three-five next year, they will just retain him for another year and then wait for compensation, which should guarantee them a top five pick anyway. For GC to accept the trade, I don't think pick 14 will do the job unfortunately, but also fair enough - I would hope Melbourne do the same if we were in their position.

This is why I think Melbourne are so adamant about pick 5 and 6; we obviously want to take one to the draft and use the other to secure May. If it were pick 5 and say pick 12, we would have to use pick 5 on May and pick 12 in the draft, which will still get us a pretty nifty player, but perhaps not who we are after (…hopefully Rankine ?)

Edited October 9, 2018 by qwerty7

[DV8 2,271]

31 minutes ago, Alex Flood said:

Just a quick one fellas ?

Do we have enough room to keep Hogan while picking up May ?

I'm sure we can, If it's lightly 1st Yr loaded.

But we might have other things cooking.

[DV8 2,271]

3 minutes ago, qwerty7 said:

GC will want a top 5 pick for sure.

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2018-09-30/indicative-draft-order-post-grand-final-edition

Well they can pick him themselves then as they hold 2 of the top 5 picks now. ?

[Redleg 40,775]

6 minutes ago, qwerty7 said:

GC will want a top 5 pick for sure. I do not necessarily think May is worth a top 5 pick but since Gold Coast will likely finish bottom three-five next year, they will just retain him for another year and then wait for compensation, which should guarantee them a top five pick anyway. For GC to accept the trade, I don't think pick 14 will do the job unfortunately, but also fair enough - I would hope Melbourne do the same if we were in their position.

This is why I think Melbourne are so adamant about pick 5 and 6; we obviously want to take one to the draft and use the other to secure May. If it were pick 5 and say pick 12, we would have to use pick 5 on May and pick 12 in the draft, which will still get us a pretty nifty player, but perhaps not who we are after (…hopefully Rankine ?)

But Tyson going to GC would lower the pick.

[old dee 23,682]

17 minutes ago, Redleg said:

I can't disregard the spin, my head is in a spin.

I am like the girl from the exorcist.

You have my deepest sympathy Mr  Leg.

[Dee tention 616]

If the Dockers want to give us say Pick 6 & 14 for Hogan.

I think we say ok! However, that includes Ed Langdon for our Pick 41. 

If the Dockers are going to try and screw us on the Hogan deal then we have to screw them back. We should be talking to Ed if haven’t already!

 

[Diamond_Jim 12,503]

6 minutes ago, qwerty7 said:

GC will want a top 5 pick for sure. I do not necessarily think May is worth a top 5 pick but since Gold Coast will likely finish bottom three-five next year, they will just retain him for another year and then wait for compensation, which should guarantee them a top five pick anyway. For GC to accept the trade, I don't think pick 14 will do the job unfortunately, but also fair enough - I would hope Melbourne do the same if we were in their position.

This is why I think Melbourne are so adamant about pick 5 and 6; we obviously want to take one to the draft and use the other to secure May. If it were pick 5 and say pick 12, we would have to use pick 5 on May and pick 12 in the draft, which will still get us a pretty nifty player, but perhaps not who we are after (…hopefully Rankine ?)

some good logic there but GCS seem to be sick of May and remember although GCS get a low pick next year the recipient club pay nothing as well. So it's not quite the same.

Well argued though

[whatwhat say what 22,551]

12 minutes ago, Dee tention said:

If the Dockers want to give us say Pick 6 & 14 for Hogan.

I think we say ok! However, that includes Ed Langdon for our Pick 41. 

If the Dockers are going to try and screw us on the Hogan deal then we have to screw them back. We should be talking to Ed if haven’t already!

i wouldn't be including any further picks of ours in the trade with them

5 and 14 and langdon for hogan i would consider

5 and next year's future first and langdon i would consider, and then probably say, sure, and cerra for our future first too

no matter what happens i want the pick BEFORE them in this year's draft

then 14 or freo future first, 41 and tyson to gc17 for may and kk

Edited October 9, 2018 by whatwhatsaywhat

[M_9 2,078]

2 hours ago, Tim said:

Not necessarily.

Trust me, if you're a surfer, as I am, you'll stay well away from a surf spot that has ideal waves day in, day out, if you can't surf.

[Dee tention 616]

Melb, GC & Freo scenario;

OUT - Hogan, Pick 41(Freo), Pick 14 & 2019 MFC First Round (GC), Tyson & Frost (GC), 

IN - Pick 5, May, KK, Pick 26 (from GC), Ed Langdon, 

Melbourne to try and get Tom Langdon from the Pies.

[Matsuo Basho 1,053]

I sincerely hope we reject 6 & 14 and demand 6 & Freo’s 2019 first rounder.

Put the onus on Freo to rise up the ladder with Hogan.

I highly doubt the Suns would accept 14 for May as many on here hope. 

Edited October 9, 2018 by EnterTheDragon

[DemonLad5 1,642]

Apparently clubs want future 1st rounders rather than current firsts because this years draft really falls away after pick 6 or 7.

Via Paul Connors

[DemonLad5 1,642]

Is there any merit to the rumour of Hogan for pick 6 and 14? Or just hypothetical