Farewell Jesse Hogan

[Gator 17,332]

1 hour ago, old dee said:

I find it very funny that just 6 weeks ago when BB and some others raised the issue of Hogan being traded they were castigated in the extreme by some folk on here as idiots. Seems they were not such idiots after all.

It seems significant that no one has said it is BS he is staying at the MFC. Not him, his agent, no MFC person and no one from Freo.

That tells me it is going to happen.

Aren't there two separate and distinct issues at play here ?

1. Posters actively advocating trading Hogan before any murmurs that he wanted to head home.

2. Posters trying to discuss the best scenarios available for the MFC in light of the strong rumours that Hogan does want to head home. 

You can think posters were ill-considered to want to trade out a talent like Hogan and also discuss the best possibilities if he does go. 

My preference is still for him to stay, but I can see potential benefits if he goes. 

Edited October 1, 2018 by ProDee

[monoccular 17,427]

On 7/17/2018 at 12:45 PM, whatwhatsaywhat said:

hogan's mum now lives in melbourne and he grew up going for the crows

why on earth would he go back to wa now?

 

43 minutes ago, johndemonic said:

You want our club to be captained by clingy Tex Walker?

Now that would be a fantastic trade, and Tex could be reunited with his mate Lever. ?

Trade one big forward with questionable attitude for another, one who has shown contempt for teammates even when they are playing in a GF together? ?

[old dee 23,790]

1 minute ago, ProDee said:

Aren't the two separate and distinct issues at play here ?

1. Posters actively advocating trading Hogan before any murmurs that he wanted to head home.

2. Posters trying to discuss the best scenarios available for the MFC in light of the strong rumours that Hogan does want to head home. 

You can think posters were ill-considered to want to trade out a talent like Hogan and also discuss the best possibilities if he does go. 

My preference is still for him to stay, but I can see potential benefits if he goes. 

Me too however it appears that is not going to happen.

So what is the best we can achieve from the move?

To honest I have little idea but you would hope we get as good a deal as Adelaide got for Lever.

[daisycutter 29,613]

2 minutes ago, monoccular said:

 

Now that would be a fantastic trade, and Tex could be reunited with his mate Lever. ?

Trade one big forward with questionable attitude for another, one who has shown contempt for teammates even when they are playing in a GF together? ?

i'm sure i remember a get tex thread not long after bernie came over

[beelzebub 23,367]

4 minutes ago, ProDee said:

Aren't the two separate and distinct issues at play here ?

1. Posters actively advocating trading Hogan before any murmurs that he wanted to head home.

2. Posters trying to discuss the best scenarios available for the MFC in light of the strong rumours that Hogan does want to head home. 

You can think posters were ill-considered to want to trade out a talent like Hogan and also discuss the best possibilities if he does go. 

My preference is still for him to stay, but I can see potential benefits if he goes. 

You base everything on what you know.

Got news..one you dont know everything.

Two. Some people know what you don't.

So sometimes discussion might actually be based on something you're not privy to.

Lots of little birdies fly around.

[Macca 16,967]

27 minutes ago, Ethan Tremblay said:

Is there a chance @stuie is back? 

I'm guessing someone else ... been here before though.

 

[Elegt 872]

Feel like I am the only person who doesn't like Hogan, never really warmed to his attitude on field

[FlashInThePan 1,893]

18 minutes ago, ProDee said:

Aren't the two separate and distinct issues at play here ?

1. Posters actively advocating trading Hogan before any murmurs that he wanted to head home.

2. Posters trying to discuss the best scenarios available for the MFC in light of the strong rumours that Hogan does want to head home. 

You can think posters were ill-considered to want to trade out a talent like Hogan and also discuss the best possibilities if he does go. 

My preference is still for him to stay, but I can see potential benefits if he goes. 

This

This thread has multiple parts. It started with speculation based on something Boomer Harvey of all people said on SEN. Now we are discussing what sounds like the inevitable loss of a young key forward with mountains of potential. Seems like many are trying to equate one discussion with the other. 

[Moonshadow 17,676]

14 minutes ago, ProDee said:

Aren't the two separate and distinct issues at play here ?

1. Posters actively advocating trading Hogan before any murmurs that he wanted to head home.

2. Posters trying to discuss the best scenarios available for the MFC in light of the strong rumours that Hogan does want to head home. 

You can think posters were ill-considered to want to trade out a talent like Hogan and also discuss the best possibilities if he does go. 

My preference is still for him to stay, but I can see potential benefits if he goes. 

Both 1 and 2 were shouted down about a month or 6 wks ago. Some children demanding the thread be closed, others claiming trade scenarios were a waste of time as he was 'settled'. The usual suspects telling us what we are allowed to think. There was some good discussion on what his value might be both on our list and as a trade.

I'd like him to stay, but understand now is a good time to maximize trade benefits if he is open to a move. He's a quality player, but we have the ability to significantly improve our list should he go. Doubt we'd get 2 x 1st rounders next year, certainly not when he becomes a FA. 

[Sydee 4,426]

1 minute ago, FlashInThePan said:

This

This thread has multiple parts. It started with speculation based on something Boomer Harvey of all people said on SEN. Now we are discussing what sounds like the inevitable loss of a young key forward with mountains of potential. Seems like many are trying to equate one discussion with the other. 

I suspect everyone would be better off commenting after there is some clarity one way or another 

From Bernie Vince's comments he is very much liked by the playing group and they would be happy to see him stay and hopefully enjoy success with them - they also seem happy to accept that if its better for him personally to consider another option then that's OK too - in such circumstances we all need to have faith in the Football Dept to get fair value for a trade and ensure overall we are closer to the ultimate prize as a result

  

[Macca 16,967]

1 hour ago, EnterTheDragon said:

For me it’s not a hindsight thing. Yes players sometimes do sign two year extensions (usually because that’s all a club is willing to commit to) but the difference there between the Vic boy Tommy Mac is the fact that Hogan was an interstater with intense speculation forever swirling about the possibility of him heading home.There was a real opportunity at his last contract signing to conclusively win over the hearts and minds of Demons fans with a Norm Smith-like “I’m Melbourne, Tony. I’m Melbourne.” But the lad chose not to do it. As I said, one foot in and one foot out. A bob each way on the nags.

Let's face it,  the 2 year only extension was the 'tell' ... I felt like saying something here at the time but who needs an ongoing argument with half the site?  I reckon many were grateful that he'd decided to stay back then but 2 years down the track,  the landscape has changed.

Anyway,  a pro sportsperson is entitled to do as they wish ... keeping one's options open is fine by me.  The whole ownership business is a 2-way street.  We had the option of offering Jesse an offer he couldn't refuse back 2 years ago which might have got his signature.  That might have happened anyway - who knows?

Away from the internet just about everyone I know was questioned the 'short' deal.  Not that it matters all that much in the whole scheme of things ... he was either a player for us or an asset we could sell for other assets.  And that is where we've landed.

[Mt. Dee-Maaan 608]

24 minutes ago, Elegt said:

Feel like I am the only person who doesn't like Hogan, never really warmed to his attitude on field

have you flicked through this thread at all?! it overwhelmingly feels like the majority on here dislike jesse due to his 'lack of passion', chase, blah blah blergh.... 

surely a poll is needed. something like, 'if jesse is happy to stay at mfc on a new long-term contract, are you?'. the fact i had a dream last night where i met him for a beer to say it'd all be ok and it was t too late to stay, obvs shows where my vote would go.

also, polls solve everything.

Edited October 1, 2018 by Rocky

[Leoncelli_36 2,264]

I reckon a bit will play out at the Bluey tonight. Usual platform for a bit of Gossip and players to flag their intentions or have the intentions of the club aired 

[GCDee 3,199]

1 hour ago, dl4e said:

I think there may be more to it than how well he gets on with his team mates. A couple of weeks ago all we heard is how happy he is here in melbourne and it has become another home to him. Now it seems to have completly changed. Does he have a girlfriend from Perth ? Does he do stuff that some of his team mates disapprove of ? There may be something going on we don't know about.

Maybe he would like to knock on cousins door than win a flag. Hope not.

I came down to Melbourne for the Hawks game and my brother told me he saw Jesse in a night club lighting a dart the weekend prior. 

Players clearly aren't chained to the club outside of their commitments but maybe he just doesnt quite have what it takes to be great? 

I can't imagine the likes to Jones, Viney & Lewis approving of this recovery/prep into a new game of footy. 

[Mt. Dee-Maaan 608]

1 minute ago, GCDee said:

I came down to Melbourne for the Hawks game and my brother told me he saw Jesse in a night club lighting a dart the weekend prior. 

Players clearly aren't chained to the club outside of their commitments but maybe he just doesnt quite have what it takes to be great? 

I can't imagine the likes to Jones, Viney & Lewis approving of this recovery/prep into a new game of footy. 

lol.. lighting a dart in a nightclub? for starters, smoking has been illegal in doors since when - 2005? i seriously doubt that a pro footy player like jesse was that wasted that he did a dean martin.. also,  fyi, the kids go to the discotheques these days anyway.

[Leoncelli_36 2,264]

Just now, Rocky said:

lol.. lighting a dart in a nightclub? for starters, smoking has been illegal in doors since when - 2005? i seriously doubt that a pro footy player like jesse was that wasted that he did a dean martin.. also,  fyi, the kids go to the discotheques these days anyway.

Coz clubs don’t have smoking rooms? Last year before the bnf he posted on Instagram a photo of his room at Crown, forgetting he had a pack of darts and rolling papers sitting on the table. Wake up 

[GCDee 3,199]

1 minute ago, Rocky said:

lol.. lighting a dart in a nightclub? for starters, smoking has been illegal in doors since when - 2005? i seriously doubt that a pro footy player like jesse was that wasted that he did a dean martin.. also,  fyi, the kids go to the discotheques these days anyway.

Sorry mate. Should have been more clear... 

IN THE SMOKING AREA OF A NIGHT CLUB. 

 

[beelzebub 23,367]

5 minutes ago, Leoncelli_36 said:

I reckon a bit will play out at the Bluey tonight. Usual platform for a bit of Gossip and players to flag their intentions or have the intentions of the club aired 

wont be attending. Look forward to any insight  and/or snippets from anyone going who cares to share

[Mt. Dee-Maaan 608]

lol, you guys really don't like smokers huh?.. funny.

[layzie 33,796]

It's gonna be an interesting Bluey..

[GCDee 3,199]

3 minutes ago, Rocky said:

lol, you guys really don't like smokers huh?.. funny.

Not if they are the CHF of our footy club we all clearly love. 

 

[Mt. Dee-Maaan 608]

6 minutes ago, GCDee said:

Not if they are the CHF of our footy club we all clearly love. 

 

a ciggie every few weeks doesn't bother me personally.. better than boozing at least once a week like most do. whatever.. 

[Mazer Rackham 14,971]

42 minutes ago, Rocky said:

surely a poll is needed. something like, 'if jesse is happy to stay at mfc on a new long-term contract, are you?'. the fact i had a dream last night where i met him for a beer to say it'd all be ok and it was t too late to stay, obvs shows where my vote would go.

I bet he didn't smile, made you pay, told you the beer was no good, then drove your car home leaving you to walk. Just shows the kind of guy he is! We're better off without him (in your dreams). In my dream, we got 3 first rounders and 2 players and a guarantee that Ross Lyon would never coach the Demons.

[Mt. Dee-Maaan 608]

Just now, Mazer Rackham said:

I bet he didn't smile, made you pay, told you the beer was no good, then drove your car home leaving you to walk. Just shows the kind of guy he is! We're better off without him (in your dreams). In my dream, we got 3 first rounders and 2 players and a guarantee that Ross Lyon would never coach the Demons.

? lollll.. nup, he said he loved my company, would buy me a house, that i could've made it in the afl and that we should go for a few surfs down the coast over the summer.. we then sat and smoked a pack of holiday 40's, listening to really modern JJJ dance music with lots of strobe lights

[Ethan Tremblay 30,856]

2 minutes ago, Rocky said:

? lollll.. nup, he said he loved my company, would buy me a house, that i could've made it in the afl and that we should go for a few surfs down the coast over the summer.. we then sat and smoked a pack of holiday 40's, listening to really modern JJJ dance music with lots of strobe lights

Do not let Saty see this, he’ll feel cheated on. 

Edited October 1, 2018 by Ethan Tremblay