My 3 word player analysis V StKilda

[chook fowler 19,694]

It’s easy in such a loss to forget how immense Maxxy was - one of the most complete games I’ve seen from a ruckman in my nearly 60 years of watching footy. 

I also love watching Fritsch - the silkiest player we have had since dear old Tulip. 

 

[beelzebub 23,390]

7 minutes ago, chook fowler said:

It’s easy in such a loss to forget how immense Maxxy was - one of the most complete games I’ve seen from a ruckman in my nearly 60 years of watching footy. 

I also love watching Fritsch - the silkiest player we have had since dear old Tulip. 

 

Gawn: 3 Brownlow votes

[Dee Zephyr 19,269]

Gawn- Better than Grundy.

[Earl Hood 6,142]

3 minutes ago, chook fowler said:

It’s easy in such a loss to forget how immense Maxxy was - one of the most complete games I’ve seen from a ruckman in my nearly 60 years of watching footy. 

I also love watching Fritsch - the silkiest player we have had since dear old Tulip. 

 

I agree in part as I was thinking during the match how Max’s amazing performance was reminding so much of that other number 11 circa 1991. Jimmy was amazing in that year. It was a different game back then where he could get to many more contests than any modern day player could, but gee he was a one man force to be reckoned with in those years. And Jimmy is still the perfect prototype ruckman in today’s footy, tall enough, huge endurance, incredible resilience, great mark, reasonable kick. 

[picket fence 17,978]

Introducing Fencescore ( A trip down memory lane where in the late 70ts every player was given a rating out of 10 in the Sun)

Here's mine for the week ( Please note even had we have won I wouldn't change a score)

Jones  7

Viney  7 

Fritsch - 8 

Hogan  6

Harmes  8 

Brayshaw 7 

Lewis  5 

Melksham  4 

T.McDonald 4 

Neal-Bullen 2 

Petracca 2

Tyson 1 

Weideman 4

Gawn  9 

Hannan 2 

Hibberd 5 

Oliver 6 

Petty 1 

Salem 3  

Smith 4

Jetta 4 

O.McDonald 2 

[WERRIDEE 5,576]

Just now, picket fence said:

Introducing Fencescore ( A trip down memory lane where in the late 70ts every player was given a rating out of 10 in the Sun)

Here's mine for the week ( Please note even had we have won I wouldn't change a score)

Jones  7

Viney  7 

Fritsch - 8 

Hogan  6

Harmes  8 

Brayshaw 7 

Lewis  5 

Melksham  4 

T.McDonald 4 

Neal-Bullen 2 

Petracca 2

Tyson 1 

Weideman 4

Gawn  9 

Hannan 2 

Hibberd 5 

Oliver 6 

Petty 1 

Salem 3  

Smith 4

Jetta 4 

O.McDonald 2 

Good idea maybe you should have your own thread for this?

Gawn deserves a 10. Everybody else is rated too high.

Fritsch and Viney 6

The rest 4 and below.

[hemingway 7,633]

19 minutes ago, chook fowler said:

It’s easy in such a loss to forget how immense Maxxy was - one of the most complete games I’ve seen from a ruckman in my nearly 60 years of watching footy. 

I also love watching Fritsch - the silkiest player we have had since dear old Tulip. 

 

And scary to think not only what would have happened against the Saints without Max but what would happen for the rest of the season if he went down. 

On Sunday, it was as close to a one man team as you could get. 

[picket fence 17,978]

7 minutes ago, WERRIDEE said:

Good idea maybe you should have your own thread for this?

Gawn deserves a 10. Everybody else is rated too high.

Fritsch and Viney 6

The rest 4 and below.

Happy to see others opinions !?

[george_on_the_outer 7,843]

Come on Fence.....looks like a great idea.  Joeboy does the 3 word every week, you can do the Fencescore

[picket fence 17,978]

18 minutes ago, george_on_the_outer said:

Come on Fence.....looks like a great idea.  Joeboy does the 3 word every week, you can do the Fencescore

Hnmm let me ponder, a few have criticized over the journey that i'm too ahh ,in your face!

[WERRIDEE 5,576]

19 minutes ago, picket fence said:

Hnmm let me ponder, a few have criticized over the journey that i'm too ahh ,in your face!

C'mon your a legend just behind saty

[DV8 2,271]

14 hours ago, beelzebub said:

And was a very effective spoiler ... unfortunately went better for StKilda than us !!

He might run lots....needs to think lots too

 

12 hours ago, jumbo returns said:

He tried his guts out....better than 13 or 14 others

Yep, and he's only played 58 games;,,, so he and ANB are excellent endurance players, who will learn as the play.  Still immature Re games played.

[DV8 2,271]

5 hours ago, chook fowler said:

It’s easy in such a loss to forget how immense Maxxy was - one of the most complete games I’ve seen from a ruckman in my nearly 60 years of watching footy. 

I also love watching Fritsch - the silkiest player we have had since dear old Tulip. 

 

Yes, he did, and he finally broke double figures for marks taken in a game; with 11 marks. finally.

He had a great game,  Maxy.

 

How assured is Fritsch with the ball in hand.

[joeboy 3,174]

17 hours ago, Satyriconhome said:

That comment on Jetta is your lowest amd most disgusting yet

He was not concussed, he had his lip split open

 

You’re probably the most irritating person I’ve EVER met... and I’ve never met you?

Edited July 3, 2018 by joeboy

[binman 44,533]

2 hours ago, joeboy said:

You’re probably the most irritating person I’ve EVER met... and I’ve never met you?

This reminds me a bit of the lyrics of this fantastic song (arguably the greatest Australian rock n roll song - ever)

'you're my only friend - and you don't even like me'

 

[In Harmes Way 7,840]

I find it interesting that we were actually a better side (defensively, at least) this time last year without Gawn or Hogan.

Our mids has to work harder to win the centre clearances, but we did.

Baffles me that we’ve gone backwards this year with key personnel back in the side.

[samcantstandya 1,068]

16 hours ago, DV8 said:

Yes, he did, and he finally broke double figures for marks taken in a game; with 11 marks. finally.

He had a great game,  Maxy.

 

How assured is Fritsch with the ball in hand.

He is a gun. He is such a good kick. Compare his kicking 2 Hannan & Neal-Bullen

[Demon Dynasty 17,132]

22 hours ago, chook fowler said:

It’s easy in such a loss to forget how immense Maxxy was - one of the most complete games I’ve seen from a ruckman in my nearly 60 years of watching footy. 

I also love watching Fritsch - the silkiest player we have had since dear old Tulip. 

 

Easily BOG for us Chook and his best game for the season.

Fritschkrieg is certainly all class.  I just hope the others start catching a little of his kicking skills and accuracy.  Beautiful to watch.

[Ethan Tremblay 31,243]

Jetta was definitely down on his previous form. Perhaps he still wasn’t 100% after the previous weeks headknock, hope he’s good to go this week. 

Gawn: In Brownlow Contention. 

Edited July 3, 2018 by Ethan Tremblay

[What 18,810]

On 7/1/2018 at 4:41 PM, joeboy said:

Jones - age catching up

Viney - great when unburdened

Fritsch - was all class

Hogan - ten minute game

Harmes - played with heart

Brayshaw - prolific but wasteful 

Lewis - often a liability

Melksham - playing slow motion

T.McDonald - was probably injured

Neal-Bullen - an irrelevant player

Petracca - plenty of nothing

Tyson - a dumb player

Weideman - nothing to commend

Gawn - one man team

Hannan - devoid of ability

Hibberd - reduced to amateurish

Oliver - rarely found space

Petty - debut to forget

Salem - undisciplined and disappointing 

Smith - little to praise

Jetta - was still concussed

O.McDonald - was emphatically embarrassing 

 

Too generous.