Suits a list that needs a mature head. Not a list that already has their mature head recruits, and is struggling to fit in some of the younger players as it is.

On 28/09/2017 at 11:34 AM, Wrecker45 said:

Without having seen a lot of him you make a good case. What are his foot skills like?

We won't be seeing much more of him, he's been delisted.

Why hasn't anyone in here proposed an alternative (Aside from the ungettable gaff) if they're so quick to dismiss the idea?

Edited October 6, 20177 yr by Deeprived Childhood

7 hours ago, Deeprived Childhood said:

Why hasn't anyone in here proposed an alternative (Aside from the ungettable gaff) if they're so quick to dismiss the idea?

Isaac Smith would be a nice but similarly ungettable alternative. Blake Acres would be worth a look

Gibson as a player would be decent at the dees, his age is his greatest enemy at this stage. 

7 hours ago, Deeprived Childhood said:

Why hasn't anyone in here proposed an alternative (Aside from the ungettable gaff) if they're so quick to dismiss the idea?

Because the alternative is that we play one of the players we already have. Most would prefer that.

 

Sam Gibson was delisted by the Kangaroos today after playing every game in 2017 and finishing 6th in their Best and Fairest.

Would be keen to grab Gibson for a year or two. Would be happy with a lifeline and we could get inside info on the one team we can not beat!

Happy to be a 'retirement home' for players of Bernie and Lewis' ilk but Gibson isn't good enough IMO. Plus we don't need another player over the age of 30.

Gibson would be great.  He came 6th in the Best and Fairest in a team that beat us twice. God help us. But he averages 22 touches a game and I think could average but up towards 27 or 28 in our system. Tackles strongly but has outside run which we need. He would be cheap as chips so I think it's definitely worth it. I'm sure we'll be looking at him.

Yes, certainly worth consideration and an interview with the recruitment team.

Desperate to keep playing so should come cheap, and a good backman at that.

Worst comes to worse he plays at Casey for the year. But may very well provide quality depth if one of our tall defenders goes down. Alternatively, he may compete for young O. Mc's spot forcing him to improve his game further.

47 minutes ago, Dr.D said:

Gibson would be great.  He came 6th in the Best and Fairest in a team that beat us twice. God help us. But he averages 22 touches a game and I think could average but up towards 27 or 28 in our system. Tackles strongly but has outside run which we need. He would be cheap as chips so I think it's definitely worth it. I'm sure we'll be looking at him.

How on earth would playing at Melbourne get him an extra 6 possessions a game ??

We already have an oversupply of middle of the road midfielders.  What we need is quick, goalkicking forwards, small defenders, KPP and back up ruckmen.

because he has averaged high 20's before and we are a high possession team.

Na....soft as!

Won't go when it's his turn, tackles with one arm, squibs a contest

Spud

4 minutes ago, Cranky Franky said:

How on earth would playing at Melbourne get him an extra 6 possessions a game ??

We already have an oversupply of middle of the road midfielders.  What we need is quick, goalkicking forwards, small defenders, KPP and back up ruckmen.

we also need players that play 4 qtr footy and losses to freo, coll, kangaroos twice and almost losing to carlton and brisbane suggest we need some intensity around the ball.

1 minute ago, jumbo returns said:

Na....soft as!

Won't go when it's his turn, tackles with one arm, squibs a contest

Spud

this is the gibson thread, not the watts thread 

Hmm, averaged 0.6 more tackles than Watts this season, pass.

Maybe we could recruit him so he can tell us the secret on how to beat nth. 

We don't have much mid Field depth now with trenners gone. Definitely would be a handy get.

Very professional footballer.  Well worth a couple of years I reckon.

Pass.  Good at getting it. Poor on tackle. Not offensive enough. Not worth a spot off Lewis or Tyson.

Consider as a mature rookie for depth purposes 

How does a player who played every game and finish 6th get the axe? Wow.  In 2007 we showed Daniel Ward the exit after 18 games that season, but I don't reckon I've ever seen it for a player who played every game.

FFS this is not Melbourne of 2012-2014 when we were crying out for experience... We have moved passed that. Not a f%$king chance this bloke comes anywhere near our football club

Edited October 11, 20177 yr by JV7

Ew.

This is a Neeld-era thread.

Stop it now.

close minded people  Just see the age and get put off. We have guys like Trengove, Kennedy-Harris and to be honest even Tyson and Vince were pretty dreadful this season. Gibson trumps them all by a fair margin. It's not like our list is impeccable. We came 9th people.