Hamish Hartlett isn't even in the same boat as Nathan Fyfe.

Same likelihood of them wearing the red and blue.

Have you seen him kick goals? Don't call him the super-boot for nothing.

Has a huge kick on him that would rival Dunn's Torps.

Same likelihood of them wearing the red and blue.

Nah, no way. Fyfe will never ever play for Melbourne in our current situation, Hartlett on the other hand could be persuaded.

Nah, no way. Fyfe will never ever play for Melbourne in our current situation, Hartlett on the other hand could be persuaded.

I just can't see it happening.

Different player to Vince, and I am sure that ND6 can be involved in a deal but we would want more than Hartlett.

I am not getting excited until it becomes more than a rumour that they will move him on.

I would try to do: Hartlett and ND10 for ND6 and ND25.

But, yeah, we can't be choosers... Hartlett and ND30 for ND6.

Edited September 21, 201510 yr by rpfc

We could do plenty worse than Hartlett, but I'm not sure he's worth pick 6 unless we think he is capable of being an every week top 3 midfielder. I certainly wouldn't pay that much for a half back flanker. If Port were to throw in a pick or a player, I'd say yes.

An every week top 3 mid will cost you two first round picks.

Pick 6 for Hartlett is about right and I would be doing backflips if we landed him though I seriously doubt we are in the running.

If we can get Hamish Hartlett for pick 6.. YOU GET IT DONE!! Simple as that. Case closed. End of story. For those of you thinking he isn't worth pick 6 especially with the draft not going deep this year then you are kidding yourselves. Having Hartlett not only adds more depth to our midfield AND experience, but it also ads in another very good player in the midfield to release blokes like Vince, Tyson, & Jones..

Lets start a Nathan Fyffe thread was reported Melbourne have enquired about his services. This is never going to happen I hope I am wrong but he is not coming to Melbourne.

Here, have these, and sprinkle them through that post

,, ..,.

Then run a spellcheck.

Has a huge kick on him that would rival Dunn's Torps.

https://youtu.be/f8i-o-a9ibk

I said Vince's career at Adelaide was inferior to Hartlett's career to date.

Yes, and I disagreed and explained why.

People forgetting we can trade future draft picks.

All this talk of Vince v Hartlett just gets me thinking, we got Vince for just a second rounder, the Sylvia compo. Would be ecstatic to get Hartlett at the same price!

People forgetting we can trade future draft picks.

If only it was as easy to trade past draft picks.

Pick 6 + 2nd Rounder + Insert Player for Hartlett and Kane Mitchell (In a perfect world)

Pick 6 + 2nd Rounder + Insert Player for Hartlett and Kane Mitchell (In a perfect world)

What!?! lol Kane Mitchell? The guy is a massive spud.

I know it's only a rating based on a Supercoach/ DreamTeam style points system, but the AFL site has Hamish Hartlett rated as the 36th best player in the league.

Melbourne's best is Nathan Jones at a distant No. 95. Bernie is 124.

Thats quite a difference but aren't there a lot of discrepencies in the AFL tables? Can't recall how they are formulated but remember reading of some howler's in there.

https://youtu.be/f8i-o-a9ibk

good highlights

What!?! lol Kane Mitchell? The guy is a massive spud.

Wow really? I think he's decent steak knives. Maybe 3rd rounder instead?

Edited September 21, 201510 yr by InVINCEable

https://youtu.be/f8i-o-a9ibk

Oh my, well that was fun to watch.

The goal at 2.08 where he is on the angle, inside the square and his teammates are pointing to the goals made me laugh. What was that, a 70m kick?

The Hulk Hogan and Hamish Hartlett forward line.... perhaps ??

Oh my, well that was fun to watch.

The goal at 2.08 where he is on the angle, inside the square and his teammates are pointing to the goals made me laugh. What was that, a 70m kick?

he can kick...bloody hell

good highlights

Holy hell, Melbourne I don't ask for much, but please try to sign this guy.

Wow really? I think he's decent steak knives. Maybe 3rd rounder instead?

LOL Ok Barry Prendergast

Edited September 21, 201510 yr by dazzledavey36

What we need is something to scare the bezeesus out of backlines and have them on the back foot from the get go. This kind of lad ( who's not shy on backing himself in...and i LIKE that ) together with a ready made running mate.. might just work. We'd have the smaller types to crumb etc...suddenly we go from lethargic in the 50 to lethal.

Definitely be enquiring as to this bloke's availability !!

Only highlights I know...but he shows great awareness and anticipation. That can't be taught ( not really ) . You either have these smarts or you don't. ( we've already got a few that don't )

Edited September 21, 201510 yr by beelzebub

Pick 6 + 2nd Rounder + Insert Player for Hartlett and Kane Mitchell (In a perfect world)

Kane Mitchell for 2nd rounder + player? Have you seen him play? I suppose he could replace Riley and McKenzie as a permanent Casey player.