Jump to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.
Demonland

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

The Jesse Hogan Panic Room - all contract talk here

Grapeviney
in Melbourne Demons

Featured Replies

Im not rewriting history. That's laughable. So is introducing strawman arguments. 

No bigger stage than a GF. 

Be interesting to compare , should Hogan get to play finals, irrespective for whom.

A different tempo and pressure than h & a 

 

 

You make your name in Grand Finals.

To everyone except MFC supporters Boyd in a $million player who was instrumental in helping his side win a GF the first for 60+ years.

It matters not what Hogan has done Boyd is the top dog.

At this point it would appear Boyd has many more finals games to go.

Jessie has yet to play in one and probably won't till at least 2018 let alone be instrumental in winning a GF.

Boyd has the Chocolates at this point IMO. 

 
12 minutes ago, Return to Glory said:

By my reckoning, Redleg, it's been a string of finals culminating in a great Grand Final performance.

Western Bulldogs - 2016
Gm   Opponent   Rd   R   #   KI   MK   HB   DI   GL   BH   HO   TK   RB   IF   CL   CG   FF   FA   BR   CP   UP   CM   MI   1%   BO   GA   %P  
  Totals 15 (11-0-4) 82 49 98 180 13 12 127 39 3 27 23 33 24 13   100 89 18 16 28   2  
24 Fremantle 1 W 17 7 6 3 10 1   5 3     1 3 1 1   4 7 1 3       79
25 St Kilda 2 W 17 7 3 4 11 3 1 4     1   3 3 2   5 5 1 1       78
26 Hawthorn 3 L 17 8 4 6 14 1 2 5 1   2 1 4   2   5 9 1 2 1     71
27 Carlton 4 W 17 5 1 2 7   1 4 5   2   4 2 2   4 3     2     82
28 Gold Coast 17 W 17 5 3 6 11 1 1 8 4   1 1 1 2     6 5 2 1       86
29 St Kilda 18 L 17 4 1 4 8   1 13 1 1 1   2 2 1   6 3   1 2     86
30 Geelong 19 L 17 10 4 8 18 3   6 1 1 2 3 3 5 1   9 10   2 1     93
31 North Melbourne 20 W 17 2 1 2 4     5 4       2   1   2 2 1   3     90
32 Collingwood 21 W 17 3 2 10 13     9 5   2 2 2 2 1   9 4 1         88
33 Essendon 22 W 17 6 6 7 13 1 1 13 2   1 1 2 2 1   7 7 3 1 3   1 87
34 Fremantle 23 L 17 4   7 11     5 1   3 4 2 3     8 4     1     71
35 West Coast EF W 17 6 5 8 14   2 8 5   4 2   1     8 7 2 2 6   1 86
36 Hawthorn SF W 17 3 4 15 18   1 7 5     3         9 11   1 5     75
37 Greater Western Sydney PF W 17 2 1 12 14     21 2 1 4 5 3 1 1   9 6     3     90
38 Sydney GF W 17 10 8 4 14 3 2 14     4   2       9 6 6 2 1     86

[Top]

Pity the stats don't support you.

He is a 200cm forward/ruckman on $1m plus a year.

No goals in first 3 finals.

3.5 kicks ave in first 3 finals. 3 marks ave in first 3 finals. 15 disposals in first 3 finals ( not bad )

Hitouts 12 ave in first 3 finals.

Anyway he has a medallion in his best game.

Can we go back to the days of having two Hogan threads? One for his contract and another for all other Hogan (or should that be Boyd) stuff. The other thread was called "The Incredible Hulk: Jesse Hogan" but has disappeared into oblivion.

Would make things easier for those that come into this thread with no interest in reading through inane debates and are just anxious about Hogan re-signing or being traded soon. I can't be the only one in that boat.


Just now, old dee said:

You make your name in Grand Finals.

To everyone except MFC supporters Boyd in a $million player who was instrumental in helping his side win a GF the first for 60+ years.

It matters not what Hogan has done Boyd is the top dog.

At this point it would appear Boyd has many more finals games to go.

Jessie has yet to play in one and probably won't till at least 2018 let alone be instrumental in winning a GF.

Boyd has the Chocolates at this point IMO. 

Mathew Pavlich hasn't made his name in a winning grand final, is Boyd better than him also? 

what about Nick Rewoldt?

he played a great game but surely common sense says that you judge a player on a body of work, not just 1 or 2 games

1 minute ago, Sylvia Saint said:

Can we go back to the days of having two Hogan threads? One for his contract and another for all other Hogan (or should that be Boyd) stuff. The other thread was called "The Incredible Hulk: Jesse Hogan" but has disappeared into oblivion.

Would make things easier for those that come into this thread with no interest in reading through inane debates and are just anxious about Hogan re-signing or being traded soon. I can't be the only one in that boat.

Agree SS. 

3 minutes ago, Sylvia Saint said:

Can we go back to the days of having two Hogan threads? One for his contract and another for all other Hogan (or should that be Boyd) stuff. The other thread was called "The Incredible Hulk: Jesse Hogan" but has disappeared into oblivion.

Would make things easier for those that come into this thread with no interest in reading through inane debates and are just anxious about Hogan re-signing or being traded soon. I can't be the only one in that boat.

Actually, there's a Hogan thread on the main board as part of our 2016 Season Review series. Hogan was first up because of his jumper number.

 

Here are the stats of Boyd and Jesse for this year for those who like to compare. Have fun analyzing.

Western Bulldogs - 2016
Gm   Opponent   Rd   R   #   KI   MK   HB   DI   GL   BH   HO   TK   RB   IF   CL   CG   FF   FA   BR   CP   UP   CM   MI   1%   BO   GA   %P  
  Totals 15 (11-0-4) 82 49 98 180 13 12 127 39 3 27 23 33 24 13   100 89 18 16 28   2  
24 Fremantle 1 W 17 7 6 3 10 1   5 3     1 3 1 1   4 7 1 3       79
25 St Kilda 2 W 17 7 3 4 11 3 1 4     1   3 3 2   5 5 1 1       78
26 Hawthorn 3 L 17 8 4 6 14 1 2 5 1   2 1 4   2   5 9 1 2 1     71
27 Carlton 4 W 17 5 1 2 7   1 4 5   2   4 2 2   4 3     2     82
28 Gold Coast 17 W 17 5 3 6 11 1 1 8 4   1 1 1 2     6 5 2 1       86
29 St Kilda 18 L 17 4 1 4 8   1 13 1 1 1   2 2 1   6 3   1 2     86
30 Geelong 19 L 17 10 4 8 18 3   6 1 1 2 3 3 5 1   9 10   2 1     93
31 North Melbourne 20 W 17 2 1 2 4     5 4       2   1   2 2 1   3     90
32 Collingwood 21 W 17 3 2 10 13     9 5   2 2 2 2 1   9 4 1         88
33 Essendon 22 W 17 6 6 7 13 1 1 13 2   1 1 2 2 1   7 7 3 1 3   1 87
34 Fremantle 23 L 17 4   7 11     5 1   3 4 2 3     8 4     1     71
35 West Coast EF W 17 6 5 8 14   2 8 5   4 2   1     8 7 2 2 6   1 86
36 Hawthorn SF W 17 3 4 15 18   1 7 5     3         9 11   1 5     75
37 Greater Western Sydney PF W 17 2 1 12 14     21 2 1 4 5 3 1 1   9 6     3     90
38 Sydney GF W 17 10 8 4 14 3 2 14     4   2       9 6 6 2 1     86

[Top]

Interesting stat and typical of the Bulldogs, about 13.5% of Boyd's possessions come from the umpires while about 5.5% of Jesse's do. Put even simpler, 1 in 7 of Boyd's possessions is a free kick while 1 in 19 of Jesse's is. Maybe if Jesse was a Bulldog he would have a lot more goals and possessions.

Melbourne - 2016
Gm   Opponent   Rd   R   #   KI   MK   HB   DI   GL   BH   HO   TK   RB   IF   CL   CG   FF   FA   BR   CP   UP   CM   MI   1%   BO   GA   %P  
  Totals 21 (9-0-12) 206 149 104 310 41 33 4 29 8 47 1 39 19 10 6 123 18
21 Greater Western Sydney 1 W 1 14 6 3 17 3     3 1 6   4 3     8 10 1 1 2 1   91
22 Essendon 2 L 1 5 4 3 8 1 1   1 1     2   1   3 5 2 3 1   1 91
23 North Melbourne 3 L 1 10 7 9 19 3 2   2 1 3 1 1       7 13 2 3 5   2 92
24 Collingwood 4 W 1 12 9 6 18 2 2     1 5   1       5 13 2 2 3     88
25 Richmond 5 W 1 13 10 3 16   2       2   3 1     6 10 2 3 2     92
26 St Kilda 6 L 1 11 8 5 16 7 1   2   1   3 3 1 2 12 4 5 6 1     95
27 Gold Coast 7 W 1 8 5 1 9 1 3   4 1 1   3 1 2   1 6   3       87
28 Western Bulldogs 8 L 1 10 9 7 17 1 3       3           10 7 5 5 2   3 98
29 Brisbane Lions 9 W 1 13 7 7 20 5 1       5     1   3 8 12 2 3   2 1 84
30 Port Adelaide 10 L 1 13 11 3 16 3 4   1   2   2   1   7 9 5 7       94
31 Hawthorn 11 L 1 5 5 3 8 1             1 1     5 7   1 2   2 92
32 Collingwood 12 W 1 7 6 12 19 3   1 3   1   2 2 1   8 12 3 2       90
33 Sydney 13 L 1 11 5 7 18 1   2 2 2 1   1       8 10   2 1     89
34 Adelaide 15 L 1 11 3 7 18 3 1   2   1   4 4     7 10   2 1   1 91
35 Fremantle 16 W 1 14 12 6 20 4 2 1 5   2   2 1 1 1 4 16 2 4 2     89
36 St Kilda 17 L 1 7 5 3 10 1 2     1 1   2 1 1   3 6 2 2       86
37 West Coast 18 L 1 7 5 6 13   1   1   2   2       6 7 2 1 1     93
38 Gold Coast 19 W 1 10 9 2 12   2   1   2   1       2 9 1 3     1 82
39 Port Adelaide 21 W 1 7 6 2 9   2       1   2       4 5 2 3       88
40 Carlton 22 L 1 11 14 7 18 1 3       5   1       5 13 5 5 1   1 93
41 Geelong 23 L 1 7 3 2 9 1 1   2   3   2 1 2   4 5   2       85

Edited by Redleg

Just now, Abe said:

Mathew Pavlich hasn't made his name in a winning grand final, is Boyd better than him also? 

what about Nick Rewoldt?

he played a great game but surely common sense says that you judge a player on a body of work, not just 1 or 2 games

Sadly the general football public grade you according to the winning games you play in and your contribution.

Nothing that Jessie has played in comes close to the Game yesterday.As I said he has the chocolates and Jessie has a lot of "if"


3 minutes ago, old dee said:

Sadly the general football public grade you according to the winning games you play in and your contribution.

Nothing that Jessie has played in comes close to the Game yesterday.As I said he has the chocolates and Jessie has a lot of "if"

On that basis, Cowan of Geelong is one of the greatest players to have ever played the game.

5 minutes ago, old dee said:

Sadly the general football public grade you according to the winning games you play in and your contribution.

Nothing that Jessie has played in comes close to the Game yesterday.As I said he has the chocolates and Jessie has a lot of "if"

OD, personally I find this comparison nonsense boring and doesn't belong on here, but I think you will find the 'general public' regards great players as players who perform at a very high standard consistently, agreed some of them may win more games than other players including finals, but a lot don't, eg Harvey and Riewoldt from Saints

Boyd has now set his bar, let's see if he can  replicate it on a consistent basis

Same with Jesse

I raised Boyd because he can kick from 50, which is something Hogan struggles with.

as people are talking about contract size and his importance to the team, it was a point of difference that Boyd has over Hogan. We know what Boyd is paid.  Hogans value for mine would double if he could finish off from outside the arc.

I see them as very different players.

looking forward to JH's situation being resolved, and everyone getting on.  

Who gives a stuff?  Seriously.  Boyd plays one decent game and we resort to analysing stats and debating who is better.  What in God's name is the point?

Someone wake me up when a decision is made.  This thread is becoming a joke, if it hadn't become one already.

1 hour ago, Redleg said:

Here are the stats of Boyd and Jesse for this year for those who like to compare. Have fun analyzing.

Western Bulldogs - 2016
Gm   Opponent   Rd   R   #   KI   MK   HB   DI   GL   BH   HO   TK   RB   IF   CL   CG   FF   FA   BR   CP   UP   CM   MI   1%   BO   GA   %P  
  Totals 15 (11-0-4) 82 49 98 180 13 12 127 39 3 27 23 33 24 13   100 89 18 16 28   2  
24 Fremantle 1 W 17 7 6 3 10 1   5 3     1 3 1 1   4 7 1 3       79
25 St Kilda 2 W 17 7 3 4 11 3 1 4     1   3 3 2   5 5 1 1       78
26 Hawthorn 3 L 17 8 4 6 14 1 2 5 1   2 1 4   2   5 9 1 2 1     71
27 Carlton 4 W 17 5 1 2 7   1 4 5   2   4 2 2   4 3     2     82
28 Gold Coast 17 W 17 5 3 6 11 1 1 8 4   1 1 1 2     6 5 2 1       86
29 St Kilda 18 L 17 4 1 4 8   1 13 1 1 1   2 2 1   6 3   1 2     86
30 Geelong 19 L 17 10 4 8 18 3   6 1 1 2 3 3 5 1   9 10   2 1     93
31 North Melbourne 20 W 17 2 1 2 4     5 4       2   1   2 2 1   3     90
32 Collingwood 21 W 17 3 2 10 13     9 5   2 2 2 2 1   9 4 1         88
33 Essendon 22 W 17 6 6 7 13 1 1 13 2   1 1 2 2 1   7 7 3 1 3   1 87
34 Fremantle 23 L 17 4   7 11     5 1   3 4 2 3     8 4     1     71
35 West Coast EF W 17 6 5 8 14   2 8 5   4 2   1     8 7 2 2 6   1 86
36 Hawthorn SF W 17 3 4 15 18   1 7 5     3         9 11   1 5     75
37 Greater Western Sydney PF W 17 2 1 12 14     21 2 1 4 5 3 1 1   9 6     3     90
38 Sydney GF W 17 10 8 4 14 3 2 14     4   2       9 6 6 2 1     86

[Top]

Interesting stat and typical of the Bulldogs, about 13.5% of Boyd's possessions come from the umpires while about 5.5% of Jesse's do. Put even simpler, 1 in 7 of Boyd's possessions is a free kick while 1 in 19 of Jesse's is. Maybe if Jesse was a Bulldog he would have a lot more goals and possessions.

Melbourne - 2016
Gm   Opponent   Rd   R   #   KI   MK   HB   DI   GL   BH   HO   TK   RB   IF   CL   CG   FF   FA   BR   CP   UP   CM   MI   1%   BO   GA   %P  
  Totals 21 (9-0-12) 206 149 104 310 41 33 4 29 8 47 1 39 19 10 6 123 18
21 Greater Western Sydney 1 W 1 14 6 3 17 3     3 1 6   4 3     8 10 1 1 2 1   91
22 Essendon 2 L 1 5 4 3 8 1 1   1 1     2   1   3 5 2 3 1   1 91
23 North Melbourne 3 L 1 10 7 9 19 3 2   2 1 3 1 1       7 13 2 3 5   2 92
24 Collingwood 4 W 1 12 9 6 18 2 2     1 5   1       5 13 2 2 3     88
25 Richmond 5 W 1 13 10 3 16   2       2   3 1     6 10 2 3 2     92
26 St Kilda 6 L 1 11 8 5 16 7 1   2   1   3 3 1 2 12 4 5 6 1     95
27 Gold Coast 7 W 1 8 5 1 9 1 3   4 1 1   3 1 2   1 6   3       87
28 Western Bulldogs 8 L 1 10 9 7 17 1 3       3           10 7 5 5 2   3 98
29 Brisbane Lions 9 W 1 13 7 7 20 5 1       5     1   3 8 12 2 3   2 1 84
30 Port Adelaide 10 L 1 13 11 3 16 3 4   1   2   2   1   7 9 5 7       94
31 Hawthorn 11 L 1 5 5 3 8 1             1 1     5 7   1 2   2 92
32 Collingwood 12 W 1 7 6 12 19 3   1 3   1   2 2 1   8 12 3 2       90
33 Sydney 13 L 1 11 5 7 18 1   2 2 2 1   1       8 10   2 1     89
34 Adelaide 15 L 1 11 3 7 18 3 1   2   1   4 4     7 10   2 1   1 91
35 Fremantle 16 W 1 14 12 6 20 4 2 1 5   2   2 1 1 1 4 16 2 4 2     89
36 St Kilda 17 L 1 7 5 3 10 1 2     1 1   2 1 1   3 6 2 2       86
37 West Coast 18 L 1 7 5 6 13   1   1   2   2       6 7 2 1 1     93
38 Gold Coast 19 W 1 10 9 2 12   2   1   2   1       2 9 1 3     1 82
39 Port Adelaide 21 W 1 7 6 2 9   2       1   2       4 5 2 3       88
40 Carlton 22 L 1 11 14 7 18 1 3       5   1       5 13 5 5 1   1 93
41 Geelong 23 L 1 7 3 2 9 1 1   2   3   2 1 2   4 5   2       85

Redleg, I don't need to read his H & A stats to know that he was an absolute gun in the finals. I watched every final he played. This is not to say that Hogan can't do the same (I truly believe he can) but Boyd's been a revelation come finals time. The GF was not a one off. And I don't particularly like him.

Edited by Return to Glory


1 hour ago, Redleg said:

Here are the stats of Boyd and Jesse for this year for those who like to compare. Have fun analyzing.

Western Bulldogs - 2016
Gm   Opponent   Rd   R   #   KI   MK   HB   DI   GL   BH   HO   TK   RB   IF   CL   CG   FF   FA   BR   CP   UP   CM   MI   1%   BO   GA   %P  
  Totals 15 (11-0-4) 82 49 98 180 13 12 127 39 3 27 23 33 24 13   100 89 18 16 28   2  
24 Fremantle 1 W 17 7 6 3 10 1   5 3     1 3 1 1   4 7 1 3       79
25 St Kilda 2 W 17 7 3 4 11 3 1 4     1   3 3 2   5 5 1 1       78
26 Hawthorn 3 L 17 8 4 6 14 1 2 5 1   2 1 4   2   5 9 1 2 1     71
27 Carlton 4 W 17 5 1 2 7   1 4 5   2   4 2 2   4 3     2     82
28 Gold Coast 17 W 17 5 3 6 11 1 1 8 4   1 1 1 2     6 5 2 1       86
29 St Kilda 18 L 17 4 1 4 8   1 13 1 1 1   2 2 1   6 3   1 2     86
30 Geelong 19 L 17 10 4 8 18 3   6 1 1 2 3 3 5 1   9 10   2 1     93
31 North Melbourne 20 W 17 2 1 2 4     5 4       2   1   2 2 1   3     90
32 Collingwood 21 W 17 3 2 10 13     9 5   2 2 2 2 1   9 4 1         88
33 Essendon 22 W 17 6 6 7 13 1 1 13 2   1 1 2 2 1   7 7 3 1 3   1 87
34 Fremantle 23 L 17 4   7 11     5 1   3 4 2 3     8 4     1     71
35 West Coast EF W 17 6 5 8 14   2 8 5   4 2   1     8 7 2 2 6   1 86
36 Hawthorn SF W 17 3 4 15 18   1 7 5     3         9 11   1 5     75
37 Greater Western Sydney PF W 17 2 1 12 14     21 2 1 4 5 3 1 1   9 6     3     90
38 Sydney GF W 17 10 8 4 14 3 2 14     4   2       9 6 6 2 1     86

[Top]

Interesting stat and typical of the Bulldogs, about 13.5% of Boyd's possessions come from the umpires while about 5.5% of Jesse's do. Put even simpler, 1 in 7 of Boyd's possessions is a free kick while 1 in 19 of Jesse's is. Maybe if Jesse was a Bulldog he would have a lot more goals and possessions.

Melbourne - 2016
Gm   Opponent   Rd   R   #   KI   MK   HB   DI   GL   BH   HO   TK   RB   IF   CL   CG   FF   FA   BR   CP   UP   CM   MI   1%   BO   GA   %P  
  Totals 21 (9-0-12) 206 149 104 310 41 33 4 29 8 47 1 39 19 10 6 123 18
21 Greater Western Sydney 1 W 1 14 6 3 17 3     3 1 6   4 3     8 10 1 1 2 1   91
22 Essendon 2 L 1 5 4 3 8 1 1   1 1     2   1   3 5 2 3 1   1 91
23 North Melbourne 3 L 1 10 7 9 19 3 2   2 1 3 1 1       7 13 2 3 5   2 92
24 Collingwood 4 W 1 12 9 6 18 2 2     1 5   1       5 13 2 2 3     88
25 Richmond 5 W 1 13 10 3 16   2       2   3 1     6 10 2 3 2     92
26 St Kilda 6 L 1 11 8 5 16 7 1   2   1   3 3 1 2 12 4 5 6 1     95
27 Gold Coast 7 W 1 8 5 1 9 1 3   4 1 1   3 1 2   1 6   3       87
28 Western Bulldogs 8 L 1 10 9 7 17 1 3       3           10 7 5 5 2   3 98
29 Brisbane Lions 9 W 1 13 7 7 20 5 1       5     1   3 8 12 2 3   2 1 84
30 Port Adelaide 10 L 1 13 11 3 16 3 4   1   2   2   1   7 9 5 7       94
31 Hawthorn 11 L 1 5 5 3 8 1             1 1     5 7   1 2   2 92
32 Collingwood 12 W 1 7 6 12 19 3   1 3   1   2 2 1   8 12 3 2       90
33 Sydney 13 L 1 11 5 7 18 1   2 2 2 1   1       8 10   2 1     89
34 Adelaide 15 L 1 11 3 7 18 3 1   2   1   4 4     7 10   2 1   1 91
35 Fremantle 16 W 1 14 12 6 20 4 2 1 5   2   2 1 1 1 4 16 2 4 2     89
36 St Kilda 17 L 1 7 5 3 10 1 2     1 1   2 1 1   3 6 2 2       86
37 West Coast 18 L 1 7 5 6 13   1   1   2   2       6 7 2 1 1     93
38 Gold Coast 19 W 1 10 9 2 12   2   1   2   1       2 9 1 3     1 82
39 Port Adelaide 21 W 1 7 6 2 9   2       1   2       4 5 2 3       88
40 Carlton 22 L 1 11 14 7 18 1 3       5   1       5 13 5 5 1   1 93
41 Geelong 23 L 1 7 3 2 9 1 1   2   3   2 1 2   4 5   2       85

19+ possession games

Hogan - 4   Boyd -  0

9+ mark games

Hogan - 7  Boyd  -  0

3+ goal games

Hogan - 8   Boyd  -  3

4+ goal games

Hogan - 3   Boyd  -  0

5+ Inside 50 games

Hogan - 4    Boyd  -  0

5+ Contested marks games

Hogan - 4   Boyd - 1

 

Premiership medallion. Hogan 0, Boyd 1.

Steven Armstrong > Robbie Flower

So many idiots.

8 minutes ago, america de cali said:

Premiership medallion. Hogan 0, Boyd 1.

And that is all Hogan's fault and all Boyd's credit.

Do you think if Jesse was a Bulldog, he might have a medallion today?

8 minutes ago, america de cali said:

Premiership medallion. Hogan 0, Boyd 1.

Superb posting, Captain Obvious.

Keep on trolling.


26 minutes ago, Return to Glory said:

Redleg, I don't need to read his H & A stats to know that he was an absolute gun in the finals. I watched every final he played. This is not to say that Hogan can't do the same (I truly believe he can) but Boyd's been a revelation come finals time. The GF was not a one off. And I don't particularly like him.

Actually they included his finals stats as well.

Well we can agree to disagree on whether Boyd was an absolute gun in the finals.

I don't think he was.

I think he played a great game in the GF.

5 minutes ago, Wiseblood said:

Superb posting, Captain Obvious.

Keep on trolling.

Hogan's stats in our two best performances for 2015 and 2016 are........

Edited by america de cali

1 hour ago, old dee said:

You make your name in Grand Finals.

To everyone except MFC supporters Boyd in a $million player who was instrumental in helping his side win a GF the first for 60+ years.

It matters not what Hogan has done Boyd is the top dog.

At this point it would appear Boyd has many more finals games to go.

Jessie has yet to play in one and probably won't till at least 2018 let alone be instrumental in winning a GF.

Boyd has the Chocolates at this point IMO. 

Couldn't disagree more.

I thought Boyd was great yesterday and he did it on the biggest day of the football calendar. 

If you want to argue who has accomplished more - no brainer - footy is a team game and there is no higher prize than a premiership.

If you want to argue who has been the better player over the course of their short careers - it is also a no brainer in my opinion - Hogan. 

I congratulate Boyd on a fantastic game but up until the final series he had been very ordinary with many pundits questioning him and one even suggesting he renegotiate his contract for less money as it was affecting him. He played a serviceable final series up unto the GF and played an absolute pearler in the big one This might be Tom Hawkins revisited - a break out game leading to a prosperous career - however i am not going to revise what has been, on balance, a fairly poor return up until yesterday. 

Edited by nutbean

 
2 minutes ago, america de cali said:

Hogan's stats in our two best games for 2015 and 2016 are........

I've never seen someone actively campaign against a player like this before.  You should be ashamed of yourself.

And if we're going by 'stats', then it's clear Hogan is on top.  130 more touches, 100 more marks, 27 more goals... the list goes on.  

I do like how we forget that Boyd stunk it up all year because he played one good game in the finals.  He was poor, at best, all year up until 24 hours ago.

 

Boyd at $1mil, versus Griffen (or equivalent trade value) and pick 6.

I wouldn't say it was 'no Boyd no premiership'. Especially given the Dogs recent recruiting performance. And indeed, just on the value of pick 6, the story is they were looking at either Peter Wright or Jake Lever, both of whom have outperformed Boyd by a respectable margin. Reference

Would we be happy enough with Hogan = equivalent of Ryan Griffen + Pick 6? Would we probably work out with a better list position on paper in that event?

Probably.

And yet, I'd rather Hogan choose to stay and I'd rather the team hold together to build something special.


Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing

Featured Content

  • AFLW PREVIEW: Richmond

    Round four kicks off early Saturday afternoon at Casey Fields, as the mighty Narrm host the winless Richmond Tigers in the second week of Indigenous Round celebrations. With ideal footy conditions forecast—20 degrees, overcast skies, and a gentle breeze — expect a fast-paced contest. Narrm enters with momentum and a dangerous forward line, while Richmond is still searching for its first win. With key injuries on both sides and pride on the line, this clash promises plenty.

    • 5 replies
    Demonland

  • AFLW REPORT: Collingwood

    Expectations of a comfortable win for Narrm at Victoria Park quickly evaporated as the match turned into a tense nail-biter. After a confident start by the Demons, the Pies piled on pressure and forced red and blue supporters to hold their collective breath until after the final siren. In a frenetic, physical contest, it was Captain Kate’s clutch last quarter goal and a missed shot from Collingwood’s Grace Campbell after the siren which sealed a thrilling 4-point win. Finally, Narrm supporters could breathe easy.

    • 2 replies
    Demonland

  • CASEY: Williamstown

    The Casey Demons issued a strong statement to the remaining teams in the VFL race with a thumping 76-point victory in their Elimination Final against Williamstown. This was the sixth consecutive win for the Demons, who stormed into the finals from a long way back with scalps including two of the teams still in flag contention. Senior Coach Taylor Whitford would have been delighted with the manner in which his team opened its finals campaign with high impact after securing the lead early in the game when Jai Culley delivered a precise pass to a lead from Noah Yze, who scored his first of seven straight goals for the day. Yze kicked his second on the quarter time siren, by which time the Demons were already in control. The youngster repeated the dose in the second term as the Seagulls were reduced to mere

    • 0 replies
    Demonland

  • AFLW PREVIEW: Collingwood

    Narrm time isn’t a standard concept—it’s the time within the traditional lands of Narrm, the Woiwurrung name for Melbourne. Indigenous Round runs for rounds 3 and 4 and is a powerful platform to recognise the contributions of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples in sport, community, and Australian culture. This week, suburban footy returns to the infamous Victoria Park as the mighty Narrm take on the Collingwood Magpies at 1:05pm Narrm time, Sunday 31 August. Come along if you can.

    • 9 replies
    Demonland

  • AFLW REPORT: St. Kilda

    The Dees demolished the Saints in a comprehensive 74-pointshellacking.  We filled our boots with percentage — now a whopping 520.7% — and sit atop the AFLW ladder. Melbourne’s game plan is on fire, and the competition is officially on notice.

    • 4 replies
    Demonland

  • REPORT: Collingwood

    It was yet another disappointing outcome in a disappointing year, with Melbourne missing the finals for the second consecutive season. Indeed, it wasn’t even close, as the Demons' tally of seven wins was less than half the number required to rank among the top eight teams in the competition. When the dust of the game settled and supporters reflected on Melbourne's  six-point defeat at the hands of close game specialists Collingwood, Max Gawn's words about his team’s unfulfilled potential rang true … well, almost. 

    • 1 reply
    Demonland
View All

Configure browser push notifications
Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.