4 minutes ago, jane02 said:

I was at the game with a bunch of Collingwood supporters. What a fantastic feeling - nothing like beating the Pies.

Did your husband cry and did you laugh at his pain? 

22 minutes ago, CityDee said:

Frosty !!! Showing why he may be ahead of Dawes with athleticism and effort and some finish . Hasn't played many games but looked to have started  his journey today - what you said . Lols this guy will be massive for us . 

I saw a close up post match and he looked like chunk from Goonies. Anyone else?

2 hours ago, Demon Jack said:

WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER! WAGNER!

Look I must admit I really wondered about his inclusion several weeks ago but today I thought he was very very good, Could be a Josh Gibson type! 

Well done young man! Happy to admit an error of early judgement!

2 minutes ago, pinkshark said:

I would kill for such discipline.  I would be wealthy.  I'd have a body like Usain Bolt (a white one).  And I wouldn't frighten my little children when I watch Melbourne.  Hats off to ya Rusty.

 

 

I'm also not getting any younger Pink and was also extremely nervous so recording it helped me turn down the tension a little lol. This was win or die for this club IMO today. Thankfully the former!

Some useless stats for anyone interested....

We had 18 players with under 100 games today. Pies had 12. They had 10 with 100 or more...we only had 4. Doing ok. Next trade i would be topping up with some solid more experienced players if they fit the mix and have serious talent.

51 minutes ago, Bitter but optimistic said:

"First quarter and a half was some of the worst footy I've seen us play and we were on track for a 3 figure thumping.

To our credit our effort improved and we showed good fight. Our skills around the ground and at goal hurt though (8 goals 11 to 10 goals 4 after quarter time) and we were too stagnant.

If Melbourne supporters are happy and pumping themselves up after that then they're kidding themselves and will never be anything other than a bottom 4 side. Had we turned up for 4 quarters it's a different game and probably a different result."

It's a river in Egypt.

7 minutes ago, jane02 said:

I was at the game with a bunch of Collingwood supporters. What a fantastic feeling - nothing like beating the Pies.

I hope you had a long shower and Dee-scrub when you got home Jane. Those Collingwood supporters can carry filthy diseases.

1 hour ago, Maple Demon said:

If the Pies only have 1 or 2 wins and drop that game as well, Bucks being the first coach to go is actually a distinct possibility.

Eddie will hang on to him for as long as humanly possible.

To sack Buckley will be to admit to a blunder in forcing Malthouse out.

5 minutes ago, picket fence said:

Look I must admit I really wondered about his inclusion several weeks ago but today I thought he was very very good, Could be a Josh Gibson type! 

Well done young man! Happy to admit an error of early judgement!

Wagner and hunt both did very well i thought. Had Wagner ranked 7th in my comparative stats system! Nb.

Edited April 17, 20169 yr by Rusty Nails

Bombers will beat the Pies again next week IMO

and we'll beat the Tigers 

 

3 minutes ago, Ted Fidge said:

Eddie will hang on to him for as long as humanly possible.

To sack Buckley will be to admit to a blunder in forcing Malthouse out.

I don't think it was a blunder forcing Malthouse Out , Carltank supporters will back me up with that  ascertion!

Edited April 17, 20169 yr by picket fence

14 minutes ago, DemonOX said:

Frost was good today but would be good if u could take a bloody mark consistently. 

It wasn't that long ago that one Max Gawn was in and out of the side, lacked confidence and had butter sticks for fingers.  Last year a switch finally flicked during the Geelong game and he's clunked them ever since.  

I sincerely believe that Frost's hands will get stickier, and his kicks will get straighter as his confidence improves.  There was already a notable improvement between the first half and the second half today.  He's got all the required attributes, he just hasn't been able to stitch it all together yet - purely due to confidence I think. 

1 hour ago, sue said:

In Q2 a C'wood player was paid a mark (probably correctly) which I thought came to ground closer to their goal than the point at which he was paid the mark. He picked up the goal and the umpire called play on as he ran into goal.  Surely he should have been forced to play from behind the mark?  Or did I see it wrongly?

Agree, Sue, but the umpire might have been murdered by Collingwood supporters if he'd called that back.

50 minutes ago, Clint Bizkit said:

He dropped at least four, possibly more.

He also took five though and at least a couple were contested. He can certainly tidy up his game, but I've seen him do worse with those hands.

51 minutes ago, old dee said:

Just to finish a very nice day I see the pies will be fined for the late inclusion of White.

Oh the day just gets better and better.

And wasn't he just worth it?

Delete that bombers game and it's a cracker start to the season.

Clinical today. Pies are a bottom four side on current evidence.

Backline held together. Forward line functioned well. Midfield carried on from last week with slick hands, good decisons (generally) and ferocious defence.

Frost easily his best game in the jumper. He and Pedo can play in the same team apparently

Now to tick off two in a row. I'll be making the trip down to watch it happen. Hopefully.

 

Highlight of the day was arguably Howe coughing up that goal. Oh how I enjoyed watching him spud it up all day long.

46 minutes ago, Jesse Christ said:

Did he look tired,  or were they paying him Extra attention? 

He didn't look tired, but I suspect they're still managing his minutes. Does anyone know what percentage of game time he played today?

Just now, P-man said:

Highlight of the day was arguably Howe coughing up that goal. Oh how I enjoyed watching him spud it up all day long.

 Loved that, but preferred the way the boys flew the teams colours after Toovey dumped Tyson after his 2nd goal.

2 hours ago, KingDingAling said:

Hopefully we've ended Nathan Buckley's coaching career as well. That would be the icing on the cake.

No, Buckleys career is the cake, Hardwicks would be the icing.

2 hours ago, Josh said:

Better than sex

Haha said the same thing on post on Instagram 

@ashgalati 

28 minutes ago, Maple Demon said:

Did your husband cry and did you laugh at his pain? 

Almost and yes. It was the best feeling.

2 hours ago, Undeeterred said:

The lid is off.

They could have rattled us a number of times, but we really stuck it out and it was fantastic to see. From memory, they didn't get closer than about 20 points and, each time they looked likely, we pushed back really hard.

I'm waiting for next week. As much as today's win was huge on a number of levels I want us to end Hardwicks career. 

It was a win we had to have, now we need to follow it up with a win against Richmond. one game at a time.

2 minutes ago, ashdemons22 said:

Haha said the same thing on post on Instagram 

@ashgalati 

I'm only following Cotchins wife.

43 minutes ago, jane02 said:

I was at the game with a bunch of Collingwood supporters. What a fantastic feeling - nothing like beating the Pies.

Good on you, Jane. It must be tough being married to a Pie.

1 hour ago, dazzledavey36 said:

I think some need to man up and give Paul Roos an apology. After the Essendon game many wanted him gone and replaced with Goodwin.

At the end of the day Roosy is still the top dog. Forget about Goodwin for now. We know what we'll get from him in the future.

Time to kill off any ounce of confidence the tigers may have next week.

I'll put my hand up for that.