WELCOME TO THE MELBOURNE FOOTBALL CLUB - CLAYTON OLIVER

[chook fowler 19,266]

it doesn't make sense comparing Cotchin to Jones - very different types of players. In terms of value to his side on a week to week basis I'd choose Chunk any day of the week.

[P-man 13,366]

13 minutes ago, ProDee said:

Cotchin has his faults but is a vastly superior player.

 

2 hours ago, ProDee said:

Cotchin is a B+ footballer and Jones is a B+ footballer.  There's not a lot in it, but there's enough evidence on talent and stats for me to conclude one is better than the other.  

On the same page too.

[P-man 13,366]

Over their careers, Cotchin gets the nod. We're talking about present day, assumedly.  Right now I'm picking Jones and it's not a difficult choice.

[Bombay Airconditioning 6,217]

2 hours ago, Curry & Beer said:

Hogan is a once-in-a-generation freak. That's why he is the only name you can come up.

Kidding yourself

Tom McDonald was also getting big wraps in the first half of last year and his name was being thrown up as an early contender for AA, as his form dropped away so did the discussion surrounding him. 

Kidding myself about Jones at Hawthorn?

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

[Gator 17,261]

38 minutes ago, P-man said:

 

On the same page too.

He's had a vastly superior career and he's certainly more talented.

Right now they're on about par, which is why they've got the same present rating.  I'd still have Cotchin ahead.

Hope that helps.

 

[P-man 13,366]

4 minutes ago, ProDee said:

He's had a vastly superior career and he's certainly more talented.

Right now they're on about par, which is why they've got the same present rating.  I'd still have Cotchin ahead.

Hope that helps.

 

Hehe..nice attempt to save face. 5/10.

You never have been one to shy away from the grand statement. That is what got you in hot water on the subject of this thread if I recall...

The comparison right now is of slightly more interest to who you'd pick in 2012. Hence why 2014 is a reasonable means of comparison, given what we now know about Jones' injury affected 2015.

Anyway, back to Oliver.

[old dee 23,506]

I could have sworn this was a tread about Clayton Oliver

[faultydet 7,594]

1 minute ago, old dee said:

I could have sworn this was a tread about Clayton Oliver

Cotchin is better than Oliver

 

?

 

 

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

1 hour ago, Bombay Airconditioning said:

Tom McDonald was also getting big wraps in the first half of last year and his name was being thrown up as an early contender for AA, as his form dropped away so did the discussion surrounding him. 

Kidding myself about Jones at Hawthorn?

The fact you are arguing with me implies that your position is that Melbourne players get a proportionate amount of praise in the media as the 'big' clubs' players do. I doubt there is one person here that agrees with you.

[Vitamin Dee 855]

Whilst I understand Oliver's skill sets being compared to Dangerfield, I think he may evolve into something more like Mark Ricciuto...with a little more poise.

Can you imagine??

I genuinely feel we have the makings of the midfield we've been waiting for;

Oliver

Brayshaw

Petracca

Viney

Tyson

Salem

VDB

Yes we've been down this road before, but this is different. They're each clean / polished / ferocious / unrelenting / driven / thrive on the contest / love body contact - and THAT is something we haven't had.

They're coming through together and will be driving the momentum shift, all with a reasonable target to kick to and an emerging mobile tap ruckman.

I can smell it.

 

 

 

[faultydet 7,594]

1 hour ago, Lace Out said:

Whilst I understand Oliver's skill sets being compared to Dangerfield, I think he may evolve into something more like Mark Ricciuto...with a little more poise.

Can you imagine??

I genuinely feel we have the makings of the midfield we've been waiting for;

 

Oliver

Brayshaw

Petracca

Viney

Tyson

Salem

VDB

Yes we've been down this road before, but this is different. They're each clean / polished / ferocious / unrelenting / driven / thrive on the contest / love body contact - and THAT is something we haven't had.

They're coming through together and will be driving the momentum shift, all with a reasonable target to kick to and an emerging mobile tap ruckman.

I can smell it.

While I love the look of that, I must admit that I was almost as excited by

Scully

Trengove

Morton

Gysberts

Tapscott

Maric

Jones

Strauss (for a very short time)

 

God, what a bloody awful group of players.

[Whispering_Jack 29,249]

Please keep on topic folks - this thread is about Clayton Oliver.

Thanks

[faultydet 7,594]

11 minutes ago, Whispering_Jack said:

Please keep on topic folks - this thread is about Clayton Oliver.

Thanks

This thread will continue to veer off in various directions, until we have seen him play. Annoying as it is, nobody can give informed comment yet, therefore the conversation gets sidetracked easily.

 

 

[Forest Demon 4,681]

1 hour ago, Lace Out said:

I think he may evolve into something more like Mark Ricciuto...with a little more poise.

 

 

 

An improved version of Mark Ricciuto? Nice to see someone with some realistic expectations on the young kid.

[Return to Glory 8,250]

1 hour ago, Lace Out said:

Whilst I understand Oliver's skill sets being compared to Dangerfield, I think he may evolve into something more like Mark Ricciuto...with a little more poise.

Can you imagine??

I genuinely feel we have the makings of the midfield we've been waiting for;

 

Oliver

Brayshaw

Petracca

Viney

Tyson

Salem

VDB

Yes we've been down this road before, but this is different. They're each clean / polished / ferocious / unrelenting / driven / thrive on the contest / love body contact - and THAT is something we haven't had.

They're coming through together and will be driving the momentum shift, all with a reasonable target to kick to and an emerging mobile tap ruckman.

I can smell it.

 

 

 

Let's not get ahead of ourselves. I'd hope that he's half as good as Riccuito tbh (who was a great footballer and leader) Let's remember, like Petracca, he's yet to get a kick.

 

[Tessaract 66]

I think he might be special..

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

34 minutes ago, Forest Demon said:

An improved version of Mark Ricciuto? Nice to see someone with some realistic expectations on the young kid.

Ricciuto only got eight all-australian guernseys. Lightweight.

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

1 hour ago, faultydet said:

While I love the look of that, I must admit that I was almost as excited by

 

Scully

Trengove

Morton

Gysberts

Tapscott

Maric

Jones

Strauss (for a very short time)

 

God, what a bloody awful group of players.

That's what tempers my excitement too - add to your group Jurrah, Watts, McKenzie and Frawley.. we certainly looked like we had the cattle about 5 years ago... we certainly didn't though

[faultydet 7,594]

8 minutes ago, Curry & Beer said:

That's what tempers my excitement too - add to your group Jurrah, Watts, McKenzie and Frawley.. we certainly looked like we had the cattle about 5 years ago... we certainly didn't though

4 competitive types in that whole list, and none of them a maniac like Viney.

Oliver (by reputation) certainly signals a continuation of a very un-Melbourne direction. I hope he is as crazy at the ball as we have heard. Madmen with skill, win finals.

 

Wouldnt we all love to see a winning final again?

[rjay 24,616]

3 hours ago, Lace Out said:

Whilst I understand Oliver's skill sets being compared to Dangerfield, I think he may evolve into something more like Mark Ricciuto...with a little more poise.

Can you imagine??

I genuinely feel we have the makings of the midfield we've been waiting for;

 

Oliver

Brayshaw

Petracca

Viney

Tyson

Salem

VDB

Yes we've been down this road before, but this is different. They're each clean / polished / ferocious / unrelenting / driven / thrive on the contest / love body contact - and THAT is something we haven't had.

They're coming through together and will be driving the momentum shift, all with a reasonable target to kick to and an emerging mobile tap ruckman.

I can smell it.

 

 

 

 

2 hours ago, faultydet said:

While I love the look of that, I must admit that I was almost as excited by

 

Scully

Trengove

Morton

Gysberts

Tapscott

Maric

Jones

Strauss (for a very short time)

 

God, what a bloody awful group of players.

I would say that Brayshaw, Viney, Tyson, VDB & Salem have already surpassed those on that list with the exception of Trenners who we can hopefully add to the new list with Oliver & Petracca.

We're already ahead of where we were and moving further forward...

[Deecisive 1,709]

I cannot wait to see him play, he seems to have poise that even when facing someone tackling him, he has time to side step, or the strength to still get the ball away. He seems to like to move the ball on quickly and not afraid to tackle and appears hungry for the ball. All excellent attributed that we have lacked in some of our previous mid fielders.

[picket fence 16,705]

9 hours ago, The Song Formerly Known As said:

sooo... Clayton anyone?

The One thing I noticed startingly was his turn of speed with the ball through heavy traffic! My esteemed Colleague Dazzle man also noticed this!  In many of my vids of "Sir Robert" one thing stood as stark reminder of class and that was the ability to see peripherally those around you and decide in a blink of an eye which way to weave to esape heavy scrutiny from opposition! Probably why Rob lasted so long in the more brutal era's with not too much body damage!

Oliver has I believe, the same 'Uncanny Time" and if he matures as I expect him to will become One of the "Darlings" of the MFC young brigade! 

Bring it on Son!!

Edited January 25, 2016 by picket fence

[Vitamin Dee 855]

3 hours ago, Forest Demon said:

An improved version of Mark Ricciuto? Nice to see someone with some realistic expectations on the young kid.

I mean't that I believe his style of play will be more inside grunt and physically hurting opponents like we saw in Ricciuto, than the tear away pace from a stoppage or forward of the play we see from Dangerfield.

He has poise which is rare for someone so physical.

Ricciuto is one of my all time no Melbourne players and I think Clayton's 'style' may be similar, or, more comparable than Dangerfield.

[RalphiusMaximus 6,012]

8 hours ago, faultydet said:

Cotchin is better than Oliver

?

For now. 

4 hours ago, Tessaract said:

I think he might be special..

Love that film.  Vastly underrated. 

[Coup Cooper 610]

6 hours ago, faultydet said:

While I love the look of that, I must admit that I was almost as excited by

 

Scully

Trengove

Morton

Gysberts

Tapscott

Maric

Jones

Strauss (for a very short time)

 

God, what a bloody awful group of players.

Amen bar Jones & Trengove