Changes For Next Week

[picket fence 17,059]

Is Mitch White a chance for this week? Obviously the kid is not ready but he has been consistent at Casey, shown he has some AFL qualities and he could slot into Nev's back pocket. It's a nice time to give Mitch a look at the tempo of an AFL game at the end of the season so that he knows what it's going to take to make the grade in 2016.

I have been saying this for weeks! Not sure of his "Upgrade" status but what an opportunity against a weak Carltank.

As I have been telling anyone who would listen, this kid is going o be a 200 gamer.

Has Pace and time, Elite left foot kick, Plays taller than what he is, reads play beautifully, did I mention he can also kick a goal!

After consistent bests I really think its time Selectors "Blood" for next year,

That means play him and anyone else with pace

its time Roosy!

Edited August 16, 2015 by picket fence

[Dr. Mubutu 831]

Although he deserves to be dropped, I wouldn't be surprised if Howe is named, even if his leg fell off.

Gotta get him to that magic 100 games.

The Lumumba experiment has also failed. Time for him to just go. I have no idea what he is supposed to be bringing the team, but whatever it is, it's not helping.

[Demonic Faves 39]

I have been saying this for weeks! Not sure of his "Upgrade" status but what an opportunity against a weak Carltank.

As I have been telling anyone who would listen, this kid is going o be a 200 gamer.

Has Pace and time, Elite left foot kick, Plays taller than what he is, reads play beautifully, did I mention he can also kick a goal!

After consistent bests I really think its time Selectors "Blood" for next year,

That means play him and anyone else with pace

its time Roosy!

Your Brother PF?

[Samael 560]

Out MFC men. In MFC women's side.

With Hogan at FF

[spirit of norm smith 16,296]

White must come in

[La Dee-vina Comedia 16,693]

I have no evidence to support this, but given Salem was out ill (flu?) and the claim that some others may have been similarly afflicted last week, I'm going to assume that some more of our players were playing under the weather yesterday. It helps me to process the scope of the loss (although not the loss itself. I think that was always going to happen). If I want some evidence, given his performances in the last few weeks, I can't believe Gawn wasn't unwell yesterday. I accept that Tom McDonald going into the ruck might have been because Gawn was playing poorly, but maybe his poor performance was illness related.

So, changes next week might depend on who played ill and who just played badly. I'm impressed with the efforts Bail and M Jones have delivered over the last few years but I don't see them in our team going forward so I would look at replacing them. Salem is an obvious in; Tyson if fit. If Tyson isn't fit, then perhaps Toumpas should be given the last three games so we can see what he's got one more time. Jetta plays if fit, but if he can't play, maybe Stretch should return.

[picket fence 17,059]

One other in

Daisy Pearce!

[Ethan Tremblay 30,826]

Out MFC men. In MFC women's side.

They have bigger balls.

[Coup Cooper 610]

Out: Michie, Bail, Lumumba, M. Jones, Garland, Harmes, McDonald

In: Salem, Tyson, Stretch, Newton, Riley, JKH, Fitzpatrick

I like your agressive selection ideas..

McDonald had 29 touches... Won't be dropped..

Lumumba needs a wake up call but won't get one.. He needs to get 20 touches a game.. Struggles to 15..

[Coup Cooper 610]

I have no evidence to support this, but given Salem was out ill (flu?) and the claim that some others may have been similarly afflicted last week, I'm going to assume that some more of our players were playing under the weather yesterday. It helps me to process the scope of the loss (although not the loss itself. I think that was always going to happen). If I want some evidence, given his performances in the last few weeks, I can't believe Gawn wasn't unwell yesterday. I accept that Tom McDonald going into the ruck might have been because Gawn was playing poorly, but maybe his poor performance was illness related.

So, changes next week might depend on who played ill and who just played badly. I'm impressed with the efforts Bail and M Jones have delivered over the last few years but I don't see them in our team going forward so I would look at replacing them. Salem is an obvious in; Tyson if fit. If Tyson isn't fit, then perhaps Toumpas should be given the last three games so we can see what he's got one more time. Jetta plays if fit, but if he can't play, maybe Stretch should return.

Toumpus was taken off at half time with concussion.. And appatently Fitz kicked 4 goals before his sugar level went crazy.. The Toump is finished..

[FireOath 290]

Out: Michie, Bail, Lumumba, M. Jones, Harmes
In: Salem, Tyson, Stretch, Newton, Fitzpatrick

Please don't make Grimes the sub again. He deserves to be on the field.

[hells bells 2,023]

I have no evidence to support this, but given Salem was out ill (flu?) and the claim that some others may have been similarly afflicted last week, I'm going to assume that some more of our players were playing under the weather yesterday. It helps me to process the scope of the loss (although not the loss itself. I think that was always going to happen). If I want some evidence, given his performances in the last few weeks, I can't believe Gawn wasn't unwell yesterday.

Apparently there are 24 at the club - players and staff who have been crook with a flu/virus in the past week or so. The club's been hard hit.

[baysidedave 246]

Out: Michie, Bail, Lumumba, M. Jones, Garland, Harmes, McDonald

In: Salem, Tyson, Stretch, Newton, Riley, JKH, Fitzpatrick

McDonald?? Seriously FFS? You know nothing about about football!!

[monoccular 17,413]

I have no evidence to support this, but given Salem was out ill (flu?) and the claim that some others may have been similarly afflicted last week, I'm going to assume that some more of our players were playing under the weather yesterday. It helps me to process the scope of the loss (although not the loss itself. I think that was always going to happen). If I want some evidence, given his performances in the last few weeks, I can't believe Gawn wasn't unwell yesterday. I accept that Tom McDonald going into the ruck might have been because Gawn was playing poorly, but maybe his poor performance was illness related.

So, changes next week might depend on who played ill and who just played badly. I'm impressed with the efforts Bail and M Jones have delivered over the last few years but I don't see them in our team going forward so I would look at replacing them. Salem is an obvious in; Tyson if fit. If Tyson isn't fit, then perhaps Toumpas should be given the last three games so we can see what he's got one more time. Jetta plays if fit, but if he can't play, maybe Stretch should return.

Some will again say this is making excuses but flu or similar illness is certainly a real possibility.

And good to see a considered view rather than an angry knee jerk reaction.

[Dr. Mubutu 831]

Apparently there are 24 at the club - players and staff who have been crook with a flu/virus in the past week or so. The club's been hard hit.

So because the club's receptionist had the sniffles, we lost by 98 points. MFC excuses at their best.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

McDonald?? Seriously FFS? You know nothing about about football!!

I wrote it half time after McDonald had a few blunders, see revised changes down the bottom.

[daisycutter 29,604]

Apparently there are 24 at the club - players and staff who have been crook with a flu/virus in the past week or so. The club's been hard hit.

looked more like bubonic plague to me

[ManDee 7,124]

Girls out Women in.

[Deespicable 2,724]

The Dogs are playing a different game to almost everybody else with their play on at all cost style, which works really well at Etihad where the wind doesn't impact ball delivery as much.

Given we are playing against the tanking Blues, I'm hoping for a few changes, but I can't really see it happening.

Ins: Salem in if well enough. Tyson back if fit. White in to see how he goes. Fitzy in if Blues go tall.

Outs: Could be almost anyone really but without flu, I'd tip Jetta (inj), Neal-Bullen, Bail and possibly even Grimes (coach obviously doesn't rate him much).

Can't see Roosy being disloyal to Lumumba, Garland and other senior men this late in season.

Angus could be sub, but nothing gained by dropping him now. He may as well get used to a 22-game season.

[Jaded No More 68,867]

I just hope Tyson and Salem are good to go. Boy do we need some class back.

Lumumba has to go. He is a huge liability. Bail out too. Jetta hopefully ok.

[CBDees 3,167]

The Dogs are playing a different game to almost everybody else with their play on at all cost style, which works really well at Etihad where the wind doesn't impact ball delivery as much.

Given we are playing against the tanking Blues, I'm hoping for a few changes, but I can't really see it happening.

Ins: Salem in if well enough. Tyson back if fit. White in to see how he goes. Fitzy in if Blues go tall.

Outs: Could be almost anyone really but without flu, I'd tip Jetta (inj), Neal-Bullen, Bail and possibly even Grimes (coach obviously doesn't rate him much).

Can't see Roosy being disloyal to Lumumba, Garland and other senior men this late in season.

Angus could be sub, but nothing gained by dropping him now. He may as well get used to a 22-game season.

I agree with your four suggested 'ins' but I would rather replace HL than Grimes. Using your own rationale we owe more loyalty to Grimes!

[picket fence 17,059]

Out: Michie, Bail, Lumumba, M. Jones, Harmes

In: Salem, Tyson, Stretch, Newton, Fitzpatrick

Please don't make Grimes the sub again. He deserves to be on the field.

Yep on the field at Casey! Sorry, he is far too slow now for the modern game.

[Demon Jack 6,862]

Michie doesn't deserve to be dropped. Had a dip yesterday.

[SaberFang 7,151]

If Michie gets dropped after finally showing some promise at AFL level, I give up.

[Devil is in the Detail 883]

Michie doesn't deserve to be dropped. Had a dip yesterday.

He had 5 or 6 really good disposals where his kicks inside 50 were to our player's advantage.