6. Vince

5. Gawn

4. Watts

3. Viney

2. Jones

1. Jetta

Vince

Gawn

Watts

Viney

Jetta

Cross

Stiff: Hogan, Jones, Garland, Dunn

Love that Watts has featured in peoples votes for a while now. Finding his place. Not #1 worthy, but a bloody good pick up.

6- Vince

5- Jetta

4- Watts

3- Gawn

2- N. Jones

1- Cross

6 Vince

5 Viney

4 Gawn

3 Cross

2 Hogan

1 had to fit in the champion N Jones

Edited August 1, 201510 yr by spirit of norm smith

Makes a change having to really think about who gets left out and my apologies to Dom Tyson, Howe, Garland and Dunn who were all good Dawes and Howe both also put in good efforts

6.Vince

5.Watts

4.Gawn

3.Viney

2.Hogan

1.Jones & Jetta

6.Vince

5.Vince

4.Vince

3.Vince

2.Vince

1.Vince

[censored] I love the [censored].

From watching overseas on my computer:

6. Vince

5. Viney

4. Gawn

3. Watts

2. Hogan

1. Jetta

6. Vince

5. Gawn

4. Watts

3. Jones

2. Viney

1 Harmes

Hard to,overlook,Harmes,, coming on as a sub and scoring his first goal,in afl football

Watching overseas jane? I thought Abbott put an end to that on behalf of Rupert?

6 N Jones

5 Vince

4 Watts

3 Gawn

2 Jetta

1 Dunn

6. Vince

5. Gawn

4. Watts

3. Jetta

2. Jones

1. Dunn

Out of interest I wonder if many people that voted were at the game (there weren't many Melbourne supporters there!).

I say that because only a few people have given Dunn votes, yet I thought he was sensational in the way he controlled the backline. He was an absolute beast today - always in the right spot, getting a hand in the way to thwart Collingwood, calm and composed under pressure and directing others around him. I know he wasn't up against much but to me he was really significant in us holding Collingwood to 7 goals and ultimately winning the game.

A lot of what he did may not have been as obvious on TV as it was at the ground. But from my perspective at the ground today, he was clearly in our best six.

Out of interest I wonder if many people that voted were at the game (there weren't many Melbourne supporters there!).

I say that because only a few people have given Dunn votes, yet I thought he was sensational in the way he controlled the backline. He was an absolute beast today - always in the right spot, getting a hand in the way to thwart Collingwood, calm and composed under pressure and directing others around him. I know he wasn't up against much but to me he was really significant in us holding Collingwood to 7 goals and ultimately winning the game.

A lot of what he did may not have been as obvious on TV as it was at the ground. But from my perspective at the ground today, he was clearly in our best six.

He was sensational. Maybe a knock that he didn't beat much, maybe 6 others played really well, but I agree he was great.

6 Vince

5 Dunn

4 Jetta

3 Gawn

2 Vanders

1 Watts

Could've had any of the back 6 (Dunn, McDonald,Garland, Howe, Jetta, Cross). Could've had Jones or Viney. Nothing wrong with Hogan's game either.

6 Vince

5 Jones

4 Gawn

3 Dawes

2 Garland

1 Hogan

6 Vince

5-Watts

4 Jones

3 Viney

2 Gawn

1 Jetta

6. Vince

5. Dunn

4. Garland

3. Viney

2. Gawn

1. Watts

Apologies to Jetta. The defence really held way when Collngwood came at us. Apologies to Jones also.

We don't win that game without Hogan. His strength, competitiveness and structural benefits are huge. Not to mention 16 possessions, 9 marks and 3 goals as the dominant key forward on the ground.

6. Vince

5. Gawn

4. Hogan

3. Watts

2. Dunn

1. Viney

6. Vince

5. Gawn

4. Viney

3. Hogan

2. Watts

1. Dunn

6. Vince

5. Dunn

4. Watts

3. Gawn

2. Hogan

1. Howe

6 Vince

5 Gawn

4 Watts

3 Jetta

2 Hogan

1 Dunn

Out of interest I wonder if many people that voted were at the game (there weren't many Melbourne supporters there!).

I say that because only a few people have given Dunn votes, yet I thought he was sensational in the way he controlled the backline. He was an absolute beast today - always in the right spot, getting a hand in the way to thwart Collingwood, calm and composed under pressure and directing others around him. I know he wasn't up against much but to me he was really significant in us holding Collingwood to 7 goals and ultimately winning the game.

A lot of what he did may not have been as obvious on TV as it was at the ground. But from my perspective at the ground today, he was clearly in our best six.

Dunn had about 6 votes from 34 castings till you mentioned this and then 19 from 8.

Edited August 2, 201510 yr by Skuit

A nice spread of votes this week sees Bernie Vince consolidate his lead.

130. Bernie Vince

114. Nathan Jones

103. Tom McDonald

96. Jesse Hogan

78. Max Gawn Jack Viney

63. Daniel Cross

53. Angus Brayshaw

52. Jeffrey Garlett

44. Colin Garland Aaron vandenBerg

30. Christian Salem

28. Cam Pedersen

25. Jack Watts

22. Neville Jetta

21. Jack Grimes

19. Jimmy Toumpas

17. Lynden Dunn

13. Jeremy Howe

6. Dom Tyson

4. Mark Jamar Heritier Lubumba Viv Michie Ben Newton

3. Chris Dawes

2. Jake Spencer

1. Alex Neal-Bullen

6. Vince

5. Gawn

4. Watts

3. Viney

2. Jetta

1. Hogan

It's the first time where Jones hasn't been in the top 6 for me.

Edited August 3, 201510 yr by Barra17

A nice spread of votes this week sees Bernie Vince consolidate his lead.

130. Bernie Vince

114. Nathan Jones

103. Tom McDonald

96. Jesse Hogan

78. Max Gawn Jack Viney

63. Daniel Cross

53. Angus Brayshaw

52. Jeffrey Garlett

44. Colin Garland Aaron vandenBerg

30. Christian Salem

28. Cam Pedersen

25. Jack Watts

22. Neville Jetta

21. Jack Grimes

19. Jimmy Toumpas

17. Lynden Dunn

13. Jeremy Howe

6. Dom Tyson

4. Mark Jamar Heritier Lubumba Viv Michie Ben Newton

3. Chris Dawes

2. Jake Spencer

1. Alex Neal-Bullen

I just realised that Gawn is equal 5th after playing just 8 games. I think he's been in the votes every week since the Geelong game.

Maxy has finally arrived.

Edited August 3, 201510 yr by Demon Jack