2014 National Under 18 Championships

[rjay 25,088]

petracca looks more like jordan lewis than fyfe.

and i think he'll go top three.

the much ballyhooed phalanx of talls has failed to arrive at this championships. they all look pretty average.

Wright looks like a long term development pick but I think McCartin is probably the one. Injury interrupted but had some good form as a bottom ager last year.

Petracca is very strong overhead, Brayshaw disappointing today but I did like Gore. Laverde has got some tricks, made some poor decisions at times but showed real class at others.

[spirit of norm smith 16,589]

Our pick must be CHRISTIAN PETRACCA. He was clearly AFL ready and will be a star.

If he goes before our pick, Angus Brayshaw would be a likely option.

[DeeSpencer 26,081]

brayshaw and petracca worked their way into the game, but south australia won the game, and the championships.

some impressive players, including sos.

caleb daniel is tiny but geez he can play.

It was comical watching all the tall skinny kids try to catch the tiny little fella.

I wonder if he's so short that he'd be good because you wouldn't even expect anything in the air from him. And imagine how many high tackles he would get. His shoulders are seriously waist high for taller AFL players.

I'd love to pick him up with our last rookie pick just to see what happened.

[Demanding Success 298]

Sorry to say it for him but he is too small. 167cm. He won't be able to put on enough weight too not get pushed off the ball. He can play though. I don't think he will get drafted but you never know.

I wouldn't write off durdin. He has broken his thumbs at the wrong time as far as the carnival is concerned. Played 1 game before the carnival. He would have done no football work or weights in the lead up which would have affected has grab on the ball. He played mostly forward today and I think he is a better back.

I would like petracca but I wouldn't be unhappy with Brayshaw. I think petracca might be gone before we get a pick, but both won't be.

I didn't think there was much consistency from most players even in the one game.

Stretch will be robbed if he doesn't get A/A.

[Whispering_Jack 30,669]

South Australia wins back-to-back U18 championships

Vic Metro 1.3.9 5.6.36 7.9.51 10.10 (70)

South Australia 4.1.25 5.6.36 8.8.56 11.13 (79)

GOALS

Vic Metro: Laverde 3, Miller 2, Ahern, Moore, Payne, Castagna, De Goey

South Australia: Hone 4, Daniel 3, Carey 2, Read, Rose

BEST

Vic Metro: Laverde, De Goey, Petracca, Ahern, Miller, Brayshaw

South Australia: Daniel, Hone, Neal-Bullen, Stretch, Rose, Carey

[Machsy 2,858]

Hone performed well and should have had a few more goals but for wayward kicking in the breeze.

Not much taller than Caleb Daniel.

But I don't reckon he'll get drafte, even as a rookie.

Despite getting lots of marks and shots on goal, a player that size will never work at AFL level as a leading marking forward.

He's about 15-20cm shorter than Tim Membrey!

[Return to Glory 8,448]

Hone performed well and should have had a few more goals but for wayward kicking in the breeze.

Not much taller than Caleb Daniel.

But I don't reckon he'll get drafte, even as a rookie.

Despite getting lots of marks and shots on goal, a player that size will never work at AFL level as a leading marking forward.

He's about 15-20cm shorter than Tim Membrey!

Hone plays as a small forward.

[Ted Lasso 19,549]

De goey seems to be in the bests alot, what's the go with him

[Jerry Lundergard 420]

Whoever did the best players for SA and didnt put Gore in there needs to have a good hard look in the mirror...he reminds me a lot of Dunstan from SA last year. A ready to go inside mid from Rnd 1 next year, but will probably be overlooked for what he doesn't do rather than what he does.

Really impressed with Stretch. If Roosy was after some more classy mids, he has one for his taking in Stretch. Rarely wastes a disposal, very clean and composed.

[ChaserJ 5,157]

De goey seems to be in the bests alot, what's the go with him

Tall h/f flanker/midfielder. Skilful, good kick and has a bit of aggression.

Has a bit of Mundy about his game, but with a bit of x-factor. Probably ranked in the mid teens at the moment, but like many in that range, could rise with a good finish to the season for Oakleigh.

[rjay 25,088]

Whoever did the best players for SA and didnt put Gore in there needs to have a good hard look in the mirror...he reminds me a lot of Dunstan from SA last year. A ready to go inside mid from Rnd 1 next year, but will probably be overlooked for what he doesn't do rather than what he does.

Really impressed with Stretch. If Roosy was after some more classy mids, he has one for his taking in Stretch. Rarely wastes a disposal, very clean and composed.

Agree with this, he looked good to me and may well be a steal at the draft.

[dazzledavey36 55,352]

I will be very disappointed if we overlook Petracca aswell.

Stretch is all class. He is worth the 2nd rounder.

[Grimes is Great 183]

Wright is a smooth mover and great kick for 203cm. IMO will go top 3 in the draft.

[hayz 27]

I really like Petracca, Laverde, Webb, Stretch and Daniel.

I hope we get at least 3 of them. I really hope we give Caleb Daniel a

chance though, he looked really good today and can play.

I don't think his height will be an issue, he reminds me a lot of Boomer Harvey.

[Adam The God 30,413]

I missed the coverage today, but I just wanted to throw this question out there. I hope I'm not derailing the thread, but would people prefer to take a Petracca with our first pick (if he's there) or trade that pick for Shiel or Treloar (if available and willing)? We know the latter two can perform at AFL level, they'll have three years under their belts and they're plug and plays. I'll trust the FD's decision, but at this stage of our development, I'd be luring a GWS mid.

[DeeSpencer 26,081]

I missed the coverage today, but I just wanted to throw this question out there. I hope I'm not derailing the thread, but would people prefer to take a Petracca with our first pick (if he's there) or trade that pick for Shiel or Treloar (if available and willing)? We know the latter two can perform at AFL level, they'll have three years under their belts and they're plug and plays. I'll trust the FD's decision, but at this stage of our development, I'd be luring a GWS mid.

Trade. Bird in hand is worth two in the bush. Sure Petracca is a bit taller and heavier than those guys and therefore stronger in the air but he's not all that tall when translating to AFL. He's not that fast and whilst he's got himself fit he's probably a few preseasons away from being a midfielder at AFL level. He's good but I think you'd take an almost certain B+ player at worst who's already had a few seasons in to him like Shiel or Treloar rather than the risk on Petracca.

[Theo 276]

I really like Petracca, Laverde, Webb, Stretch and Daniel.

I hope we get at least 3 of them. I really hope we give Caleb Daniel a

chance though, he looked really good today and can play.

I don't think his height will be an issue, he reminds me a lot of Boomer Harvey.

This would be my dream draft plus maybe Ahern (Vic M).or Howe (SA).

Brayshaw had a shocker yesterday. Never imposed himself and lacked composure in the few possessions he had. Not in the same class as Petracca. I hope we don't draft Brayshaw.

Caleb Daniel will be a cult figure whoever drafts him. Please let it be us. This kid can really play and be could unstoppable as a small forward/midfielder. .

[Pennant St Dee 13,305]

This would be my dream draft plus maybe Ahern (Vic M).or Howe (SA).

Brayshaw had a shocker yesterday. Never imposed himself and lacked composure in the few possessions he had. Not in the same class as Petracca. I hope we don't draft Brayshaw.

Caleb Daniel will be a cult figure whoever drafts him. Please let it be us. This kid can really play and be could unstoppable as a small forward/midfielder. .

Yes Daniel looked good but he is only giving away 5-10kg to the opposition at U/18level at AFL level being 67kg he will be giving away 15-25 kg to midfielders. He may not come into direct contact with the big bodied key position players but IMO he still has a lot of work to do in the gym to make it at the next level

May get rookied

[Machsy 2,858]

Hone plays as a small forward.

I know.

But the vast majority of his touches and goals have come from leading and marking in the F50, not from crumbing.

He plays like he thinks he's a tall forward.

He might get away with it at junior level, but...

[Demonland 73,140]

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2014-07-04/under18-all-australian-team?utm_medium=RSS

2014 UNDER-18 ALL AUSTRALIAN TEAM

DEFENDERS: Harrison Wigg (South Australia), Ed Vickers-Willis (Vic Metro), Josh McGuinness (Tasmania), Darcy Tucker (Vic Country), Caleb Marchbank (Vic Country), Angus Brayshaw (Vic Metro)

MIDFIELDERS: Paul Ahern (Vic Metro), Christian Petracca (Vic Metro), Billy Stretch (South Australia), Peter Wright (Vic Metro), Isaac Heeney (NSW/ACT), Jake Johansen (South Australia)

FORWARDS: Callum Mills (NSW/ACT), Darcy Moore (Vic Metro), Rhys Mathieson (Vic Country), Jayden Laverde (Vic Metro), Patrick McCartin (Vic Country), Caleb Daniel (South Australia)

INTERCHANGE: Jack Steele (NSW/ACT), Darcy Parish (Vic Country), Ben Keays (Queensland), Connor Blakely (Western Australia)

COACH: Jason Saddington (NSW/ACT)

ASSISTANT COACH: Brenton Phillips (South Australia)

[Whispering_Jack 30,669]

Two sons of former Demons there in Billy Stretch and Darcy Moore. I also wonder if Darcy Parish is related to the late Les "Salty" Parish better known as Fitzroy player who transferred to Melbourne from North Melbourne late in his career.

The way things are going we could have three of those players if we finish low enough (I'm not suggesting anything, nor am I trying to be funny) and we lost James Frawley with a 1st round draft selection as compo.

If that happened we could take Brayshaw, Petracca and Stretch (f/s) - all different types of midfielders to give us a boost in an area where we are slowly improving.

[whatwhat say what 22,947]

in an ideal world i'd love to get brayshaw / petracca, harrison wigg, and stretch with our first three picks.

[Grimes Times 1,278]

Two sons of former Demons there in Billy Stretch and Darcy Moore. I also wonder if Darcy Parish is related to the late Les "Salty" Parish better known as Fitzroy player who transferred to Melbourne from North Melbourne late in his career.

The way things are going we could have three of those players if we finish low enough (I'm not suggesting anything, nor am I trying to be funny) and we lost James Frawley with a 1st round draft selection as compo.

If that happened we could take Brayshaw, Petracca and Stretch (f/s) - all different types of midfielders to give us a boost in an area where we are slowly improving.

While he didn't make the All - Aust teamTom Lamb who played for Vic Country is the son of Wayne Lamb who played a handful of games for the Dess in the early 90's before moving to Fitzroy. Tipped to go first round if not top 10.

[Wiseblood 24,637]

Two sons of former Demons there in Billy Stretch and Darcy Moore. I also wonder if Darcy Parish is related to the late Les "Salty" Parish better known as Fitzroy player who transferred to Melbourne from North Melbourne late in his career.

The way things are going we could have three of those players if we finish low enough (I'm not suggesting anything, nor am I trying to be funny) and we lost James Frawley with a 1st round draft selection as compo.

If that happened we could take Brayshaw, Petracca and Stretch (f/s) - all different types of midfielders to give us a boost in an area where we are slowly improving.

I'd be happy if we got one of Brayshaw/Petracca, Stretch and an established midfielder with some experience under their belt that could help our midfield immediately, giving further support and allowing those younger types a little more time to develop than being thrown into the deep end, something Roos has said he doesn't like doing. If we could do THAT, then we would be seriously going places.

[rjay 25,088]

I'd be happy if we got one of Brayshaw/Petracca, Stretch and an established midfielder with some experience under their belt that could help our midfield immediately, giving further support and allowing those younger types a little more time to develop than being thrown into the deep end, something Roos has said he doesn't like doing. If we could do THAT, then we would be seriously going places.

Brayshaw would want to show a lot more than he did yesterday for me to be happy with giving away a top pick.