Jump to content

Post match discussion

Featured Replies

One of the best posts I have read on here in quite a while.

You are dead right. While Jack does need to harden up and get more competitive, the answer in doing so mightn't be the suburban footy/1980's VFL way of giving a tongue lashing. I remember reading, in of all places Max Walker's biography, of how Norm Smith got some form out of him. One night he was called to Norm's office, who was sitting on a pile of footy jumpers gently tossing a footy from hand to hand, Maxy had heard of his propensity for fearful sprays and thought his time had come. Norm then simply asked him if he wanted to play seniors on the weekend and took him around for dinner at his home. Checker Hughes after that incident then summed up the coaching staff's opinion on Max 'You aren't a good player or a bad player. You are a confidence player. Think about that son.' Maxy then went on to play a pretty decent game against the Roos the next week.

While Big Max wasn't much of a footballer (we knew where his talents lie; cricket and playing the Wired World of Sports theme on a handkerchief), it does show how sometime the carrot does work besides the stick.

That being said, the stick may need to come out at some stage with Jack. As for now, he was probably one of the players in mind when Roos said the playing list needed a cuddle.

Good points here - I was livid at JW's lack of intent yesterday but I think so much of his performance is to do with his self belief and focus. Against St Kilda he showed what he is capable of, displaying intent and focus. Yesterday he looked lost and you could almost see him trying to will himself to go when it was his turn only to put in a token looking effort.

Roos has the whole season to check out our list and I think guys like Nev, Evans, McKenzie deserve a string of at least 4-5 games to prove their spot. Watts is a required player and I'd rather set him the challenge to respond next week v Sydney.

 

Good points here - I was livid at JW's lack of intent yesterday but I think so much of his performance is to do with his self belief and focus. Against St Kilda he showed what he is capable of, displaying intent and focus. Yesterday he looked lost and you could almost see him trying to will himself to go when it was his turn only to put in a token looking effort.

Roos has the whole season to check out our list and I think guys like Nev, Evans, McKenzie deserve a string of at least 4-5 games to prove their spot. Watts is a required player and I'd rather set him the challenge to respond next week v Sydney.

trouble is for the last 5 years all weve heard is.

needs help from mates.

needs to outside to best use the footy.

needs to play down back.

needs to play forward.

needs to play wing.

on the ball.

needs cuddling

needs a rocket up his clacker.

needs time.

needs gametime.

needs contract.

needs time off.

needs love.

needs a new coach.

needs to shave beard.

needs to grow beard.

needs to grow moustache.

needs to shave off moustache.

needs another preseason.

every time we lose,people say somebody else was worse,somebody else didnt do this didnt do that.

unfortunately for JW its all about...........

WHAT WE NEED

As bad as Watts was he has still been better than Tyson or Vince have the last two weeks, Jordie was also terrible yesterday,so you cant really blame our woes on him, its a collective effort.

Roos conceded taking Tyson off was a mistake.

All of Jack Watts problems exist between his ears ( though some might suggest within his chest )

 

All of Jack Watts problems exist between his ears ( though some might suggest within his chest )

every week i see.

dunn=not very good ,gets all the krap jobs,never whinges and actually no matter how bad it is,always holds his head high,has a GO

tommy mac=aint there yet,gets horrible job and holds his head high and has a GO.

pedders=gets rotten jobs,holds his head up and has a GO.

grimes=aint much good,gets tough jobs,holds his head up.leaves the ground with pride.

n jones=aint very good,trained his arse off and became better,never gives up and has a GO.

JW,had every chance and im sick of the namby pamby,we love jack,give him a chance,he tries,hes playing in a bottom team.pppffffttt absolute rubbish,lack of heart,and you cant put gutz into cowards.

at every club ive played,there are times where you are injured,out of form,not good enough,this is something that happens australia wide on a weekly basis.for these reasons you get DROPPED.after every effort by the coach to get you into form in senoirs.

for the last 3 years,frawley,sylvia,morton and watts have bludged off this club,unfortunately theirs a new coach in town and im hoping this is currently being sorted out and acted upon,for our future.

thanks,jones,tmac,dunn and pedders for having some pride in being undermanned and fighting for your place in the team.

Youd think the boys would be sick of losing....that effort in the second quarter was putrid.


A lot of venting on here, i'm sick of losing too. I think most of us pre-season would have liked to see the Dees in games longer, and the odd upset here and there. So far this is how the season is panning out (taking away the west coast game).

We are coming from a long way back, we have to remember this. The fact I was still getting excited about winning a game in the last quarter was good. Sad but true.

#DeesLife

The problem with having a considered and balanced opinion, especially in the wake of a loss, is that other's rage will lead them to misinterperate it.

Agree with your points, especially the 'knowing how' in relation to work rate. I wonder if this also the case for him with the physical stuff. There's always been a lack of 'want' in Jack's game and it's the coaches job to find out why and rectify it. For those that think stringing him up in the city centre for 100 lashes is the answer, it isn't, Neeld tried that and it didn't work. Hopefully there is another way.

Everything's been tried it's not up to the coaches anymore it's up to Jack. He can sort it out at Casey and come back once he has otherwise his career will be over before it begins.

The one clear thing that was evident from yesterday was that if you feed a new club enough talent at the expense of others they cannot help but succeed and weaker clubs cannot help but remain somewhat stranded. And let's not forget that, on top of the unprecedented draft concessions, they were also able to pay for the greatest player (possibly) of our generation.

For this reason alone, I wish Gold Coast nothing but ill will and if that makes me a bitter prack then so be it.

 

Gotta love iPhones and demonland.

I am cooking a BBQ, reading demonland on my iPhone while having a rum

All I need now is for the team to win and my life is complete!

I've loved and always defended Jack Watts talents, but:



I don't know, but is Jack still living with his parents? Does anyone remember the interview with Jacks mum just after he was drafted? Please correct if I'm wrong but I recall her saying things like, "Don't worry, Jack's got his head screwed on correctly, he knows it's only a game of football," she said depreciatingly. She seemed as lovely a mum as anyone could possibly have, but her attitude towards the game seemed appropriate for someone playing school footy, who's going on to a serious career later (she'd mean non-football career as nothing football would be serious enough to risk injury over). I've meet plenty of Brighton Grammar type mothers like that (I was at Scotch) and can imagine her saying, "Now don't you get hurt out there Jack, it's not worth it," and Jack, being a good boy would agree.



Jack needs to share a home with some intelligent but tough footballers. Preferably lighter weight like himself. He should move in to the Viney household for awhile!! ..to have some of their urgency rub off on him, learn more about how to navigate physically tough scenarios while still avoiding injury yet pressuring/intimidating the opposition. Also to learn that this IS his serious job, can pay well and lead to post playing jobs also.


I've meet plenty of Brighton Grammar type mothers like that (I was at Scotch) and can imagine her saying, "Now don't you get hurt out there Jack, it's not worth it," and Jack, being a good boy would agree.

I really don't think this is about schools or certain schools producing harder [or softer] footballers. Dawes was also a product of Brighton Grammar [ar was also Hunt and last year's No. 2 draft pick] and I fail to see a common 'Brighton Grammar type'!

I've meet plenty of Brighton Grammar type mothers like that (I was at Scotch) and can imagine her saying, "Now don't you get hurt out there Jack, it's not worth it," and Jack, being a good boy would agree.

I really don't think this is about schools or certain schools producing harder [or softer] footballers. Dawes was also a product of Brighton Grammar [ar was also Hunt and last year's No. 2 draft pick] and I fail to see a common 'Brighton Grammar type'!

I agree with you CDDees, but that was 100% NOT my point at all and I shouldn't have mentioned the school because it's triggered a reflex. Everything else written I did mean though. The values at home are very, very influential and specifically I found Jacks mothers interview alarming. She seemed a lovely mum, but not one to encourage physically tough play from Jack at all, nor to believe footy's a serious career.

I've loved and always defended Jack Watts talents, but:

I don't know, but is Jack still living with his parents? Does anyone remember the interview with Jacks mum just after he was drafted? Please correct if I'm wrong but I recall her saying things like, "Don't worry, Jack's got his head screwed on correctly, he knows it's only a game of football," she said depreciatingly. She seemed as lovely a mum as anyone could possibly have, but her attitude towards the game seemed appropriate for someone playing school footy, who's going on to a serious career later (she'd mean non-football career as nothing football would be serious enough to risk injury over). I've meet plenty of Brighton Grammar type mothers like that (I was at Scotch) and can imagine her saying, "Now don't you get hurt out there Jack, it's not worth it," and Jack, being a good boy would agree.

Jack needs to share a home with some intelligent but tough footballers. Preferably lighter weight like himself. He should move in to the Viney household for awhile!! ..to have some of their urgency rub off on him, learn more about how to navigate physically tough scenarios while still avoiding injury yet pressuring/intimidating the opposition. Also to learn that this IS his serious job, can pay well and lead to post playing jobs also.

I've loved and always defended Jack Watts talents, but:

I don't know, but is Jack still living with his parents? Does anyone remember the interview with Jacks mum just after he was drafted? Please correct if I'm wrong but I recall her saying things like, "Don't worry, Jack's got his head screwed on correctly, he knows it's only a game of football," she said depreciatingly. She seemed as lovely a mum as anyone could possibly have, but her attitude towards the game seemed appropriate for someone playing school footy, who's going on to a serious career later (she'd mean non-football career as nothing football would be serious enough to risk injury over). I've meet plenty of Brighton Grammar type mothers like that (I was at Scotch) and can imagine her saying, "Now don't you get hurt out there Jack, it's not worth it," and Jack, being a good boy would agree.

Jack needs to share a home with some intelligent but tough footballers. Preferably lighter weight like himself. He should move in to the Viney household for awhile!! ..to have some of their urgency rub off on him, learn more about how to navigate physically tough scenarios while still avoiding injury yet pressuring/intimidating the opposition. Also to learn that this IS his serious job, can pay well and lead to post playing jobs also.

maybe do a preseason in Wolf Creek

It's not about Watts' skill, it's all about effort. I like Watts but he is an embarrassment to our football club most of the time. A former number 1 draft pick who's been in the system for 6-7 years should be a lot better than he is. He lopes around with half efforts.

It's not about Mckenzies effort it's about his skill. Combine this with Terlich, Jetta, Bail, Spencer who all put consistent unnecessary pressure on teammates with their disgraceful (for afl) standard disposal.

It really is time for some people to lift their standards & expectations.


Anyone who defends Watts' game but watched it on TV needs to understand that they would have missed 90% of his soft, lazy and weak efforts around the ground.

Most of if happened off the ball so unless you were at the game, please understand this.

I was there, and I saw them - as hard as they were to watch - I don't think you get a full picture from the TV either.

But it cuts both ways, Watts has a good workrate and gets to more contests.

The way he 'affects' most of them isn't good enough. It just isn't. But he will trust his teammate to win the footy and get it to him and that is something. We are like moths to a flame when around the footy, and other clubs have 'release' players and 'outlets' and they destroy us. Watts' skills are suited to that as we all know.

It's the lack of intensity when about to get the footy in contest with another that is frustrating and I am looking at Roos to fix this.

Obviously I don't want all of these gone this week but the following aren't deserving of AFL football at THIS point in time: Bail, Evans, Spencer, Terlich, Jetta. McKenzie, M Jones and Pederson have week reprieves after previous good weeks but also need monitoring.

I think Bail is doing enough and Spencer has no replacement, but the rest are on the money. Jones and Pedersen are (sadly) consistently in our best 7-8 players - they're going nowhere.

Pedo was far more effective in the ruck then Spencer was the whole game. Bring in the Russian!

First time I've been in front of a computer since the game, so apologies for the late post.

I'll start off by saying what an absolute champion Jones is. He has to be one of the most underrated players in the league, if not the most. His pass between 2 opposition players to JKH and his goal in the final quarter were brilliant. I think he's taken his game to another level, the captaincy role seems to sit well with him and he taken the responsibility to try and lift the team at various stages throughout games, it's just a shame that there doesn't seem to be anyone to go with him. Heart and soul player, inspirational captain, throw any of those kind of cliches at him and it works. There should be a few players that are embarrassed to share the same guernsey.

Dawes is another huge positive. A true forward that can influence a game without needing a lot of possessions. I'd like to see him take a few training sessions and teach our team the principles of kicking to advantage.

JKH didn't seem to have a lot of it, but made the most of his opportunities. I'd expect to see improvement over time where he'll impact the game more regularly.

Howe was much better in the forward line, I hope he stays there and the defender experiment is over.

Generally we've got a team of battlers, nowhere near skillful, but players that will generally give effort. I see a lot of these players being just fill ins until we get some quality back or some future talent is brought in. An unfortunate reality.

Finally on the "laconic" Watts, I have simpathy for him. There was someone sitting in front of me whose only comments seem to be directed towards Watts. I'm sure he wasn't the only one that was overly critical of him, but Watts didn't pick himself, he didn't ask for the burden of being a Dees high draft pick, so from that regard I think he cops more than his fair share. Having said that, he frustrates the hell out of me. His talent is unquestionable, he's a very clever player. But we are in the era of contested footy and players need to be more than just clever players. He seems to play more like a small forward, trying to push his opponent under the ball so he can run on to the ball etc. He needs to add something to his game an not just rely on doing the odd clever act, because it doesn't come off enough to persist with. He either needs to bring a bit of hardness to his game, start taking a few contested marks or contested possissions, or he needs to increase his work rate and take the game on. I can't see him really becoming a courageous player overnight, but he can run harder. A lot of possession he stops, composes himself and hits up a good option, that's great, but his work shouldn't stop there. He should continue running to at least be an option or link up player.

Anyway, disappointing loss. but we were in it for most of the game. Even though GC were thrashed by the Hawks, I thought they played reasonably well and was expecting tem to roll us by a lot more. Not much of a consolation, but what can I say, reality sucks!

Agree with Howe going back to the forward line

He struggled there the first couple of weeks as the main target, but we didn't have Dawea and Frawley then

He will dominate now as the 3rd option


Howe as a defender was borne out of necessity due to his form. He just wasn't getting near the ball in the forward line. It's our proactive coaches finding a solution to a hairy problem. Sunday he looked back to his best, marking the ball and just being involved. Having Dawes and Frawley is also a massive help; I think we have now established that Howe can't be the chief target.

I'd be more than happy to see him forward again and Dunn back; when both players are playing at their best, that's our most dangerous set up.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Featured Content

  • WHAT’S NEXT? by The Oracle

    What’s next for a beleagured Melbourne Football Club down in form and confidence, facing  intense criticism and disapproval over some underwhelming recent performances and in the midst of a four game losing streak? Why, it’s Adelaide which boasts the best percentage in the AFL and has won six of its last seven games. The Crows are hot and not only that, the game is at the Adelaide Oval; yet another away fixture and the third in a row at a venue outside of Victoria. One of the problems the Demons have these days is that they rarely have the luxury of true home ground advantage, something they have enjoyed just once since mid April. 

    • 0 replies
  • REPORT: Gold Coast

    From the start, Melbourne’s performance against the Gold Coast Suns at Peoples First Stadium was nothing short of a massive botch up and it came down in the first instance to poor preparation. Rather than adequately preparing the team for battle against an opponent potentially on the skids after suffering three consecutive losses, the Demons looking anything but sharp and ready to play in the opening minutes of the game. By way of contrast, the Suns demonstrated a clear sense of purpose and will to win. From the very first bounce of the ball they were back to where they left off earlier in the season in Round Three when the teams met at the MCG. They ran rings around the Demons and finished the game off with a dominant six goal final term. This time, they produced another dominant quarter to start the game, restricting Melbourne to a solitary point to lead by six goals at the first break, by which time, the game was all but over.

    • 0 replies
  • CASEY: Gold Coast

    Coming off four consecutive victories and with a team filled with 17 AFL listed players, the Casey Demons took to their early morning encounter with the lowly Gold Coast Suns at People First Stadium with the swagger of a team that thought a win was inevitable. They were smashing it for the first twenty minutes of the game after Tom Fullarton booted the first two goals but they then descended into an abyss of frustrating poor form and lackadaisical effort that saw the swagger and the early arrogance disappear by quarter time when their lead was overtaken by a more intense and committed opponent. The Suns continued to apply the pressure in the second quarter and got out to a three goal lead in mid term before the Demons fought back. A late goal to the home side before the half time bell saw them ten points up at the break and another surge in the third quarter saw them comfortably up with a 23 point lead at the final break.

    • 0 replies
  • PREGAME: Rd 17 vs Adelaide

    With their season all over bar the shouting the Demons head back on the road for the third week in a row as they return to Adelaide to take on the Crows. Who comes in and who goes out?

      • Thumb Down
    • 102 replies
  • POSTGAME: Rd 16 vs Gold Coast

    The Demons did not come to play from the opening bounce and let the Gold Coast kick the first 5 goals of the match. They then outscored the Suns for the next 3 quarters but it was too little too late and their season is now effectively over.

      • Sad
    • 231 replies
  • VOTES: Rd 16 vs Gold Coast

    Max Gawn has a massive lead in the Demonland Player of the Year award ahead of Jake Bowey, Christian Petracca, Clayton Oliver and Kysaiah Pickett. Your votes please. 6, 5, 4, 3, 2 & 1.

    • 41 replies