Injured list - round 19

[alpha33 325]

We know all about James Frawley and his hamstring injury - Frawley set to miss up to a month

But here's the full injury list:

Rohan Bail (knee) test

Colin Garland (ankle) test

Joel Macdonald (groin) test

Jordie Mackenzie (concussion) test

David Rodan (hamstring) test

James Sellar (hamstring) test

Nathan Stark (ankle) test

Tom Couch (hamstring) 2 weeks

Mark Jamar (foot) 2 weeks

Michael Evans (foot) 3 weeks

James Frawley (hamstring) 3-4 weeks

Mitch Clark (foot) season

[monoccular 17,575]

FCS what have we done?? Have we had a 'first choice' goal to goal line at all this season?

Frawley - a month!! Why even consider him for what would be a final round return? Put him on ice until the preseason.

[Rolling Stone 158]

If all the "tests" are passed then we can still put a competitive team on the ground.

[Ted Lasso 19,549]

Put frawley, jamar and evans on ice, absolutely no good in risking them for 1 or 2 games.

[Whispering_Jack 30,674]

What about two of last week's unexplained "outs" in Dean Terlich and Tom Gillies (I know Gillies isn't strongly fancied by some around here but he's on our list so it would be interesting to know why he missed last week)?

Also would be good to see Nathan Stark getting a run after such an injury affected season.

[jumbo returns 6,741]

If all the "tests" are passed then we can still put a competitive team on the ground.

Errr....no.

[old dee 23,872]

Errr....no.

Agree jr, the only "test" that is AFL standard is Garland

The rest should be playing VFL, SANFL or WAFL

[Vagg 2,439]

What about two of last week's unexplained "outs" in Dean Terlich and Tom Gillies (I know Gillies isn't strongly fancied by some around here but he's on our list so it would be interesting to know why he missed last week)?

Also would be good to see Nathan Stark getting a run after such an injury affected season.

Agreed, Jack. Does anyone know what Terlich's problem was/is? I've not heard or seen anything at all about why he was replaced from last week's side. Could it, maybe, have been illness, given he is not on the injury list with "test" beside his name?

[old dee 23,872]

Agreed, Jack. Does anyone know what Terlich's problem was/is? I've not heard or seen anything at all about why he was replaced from last week's side. Could it, maybe, have been illness, given he is not on the injury list with "test" beside his name?

A couple of sherbets on Friday night?

[jazza 1,323]

We know all about James Frawley and his hamstring injury - Frawley set to miss up to a month

But here's the full injury list:

Rohan Bail (knee) test

Colin Garland (ankle) test

Joel Macdonald (groin) test

Jordie Mackenzie (concussion) test

David Rodan (hamstring) test

James Sellar (hamstring) test

Nathan Stark (ankle) test

Tom Couch (hamstring) 2 weeks

Mark Jamar (foot) 2 weeks

Michael Evans (foot) 3 weeks

James Frawley (hamstring) 3-4 weeks

Mitch Clark (foot) season

j hird {foot in mouth} life

b.thomson{black ops} life

j.watson{shrunken aggetts}2 years

[La Dee-vina Comedia 16,909]

Agreed, Jack. Does anyone know what Terlich's problem was/is? I've not heard or seen anything at all about why he was replaced from last week's side. Could it, maybe, have been illness, given he is not on the injury list with "test" beside his name?

Wasn't it reported as "quad" in the media somewhere? if so, it may make him a doubtful starter for a couple more weeks irrespective of his missing a place in Melbourne's weekly entry into the national fiction awards.