Watts almost traded?

[Demon Head 292]

Poor Greg is still [censored] off that Mitch Clark is at the Dees when Greg wanted him to go to Freo.

Just cannot bring himself to say or write anything positive about the Dees.

A right [censored] of the highest order.

Even more so at the thought that Cameron Schwab was heavily involved in the negotiations to get him to the club.

[monoccular 17,573]

I guess several clubs may have been interested in trading for Watts, as many were for Choke.

If the only reason it didn't happen is that "they ran out of time" then it would surely be a serious indictment on Norf that they couldn't get it done in 4 weeks!

And what they offered wasn't enough. Question is: what would have been?

Irrelevant [censored] IMO.

[Undeeterred 3,124]

If Richmond said "we'll give you Cotchin for Watts" you'd take it.

I wouldn't.

[jumbo returns 6,741]

I reckon 2013 will be a make or break year for JW.

Every player has a price.

[Sir Why You Little 37,125]

Every player is tradeable no doubt.

But Watts for a Nought 2nd round pick? Please.

But i do expect to see Watts ramp it up in 2013.

It is his 5th year...

[Hannibal 5,814]

I wouldn't.

Arguably the most extraordinary post I've ever seen on here.

[mauriesy 7,353]

I suppose amongst all the vitriol, the idea that Denham is right, or even half right, is out of the question?

[Guest José Mourinho]

I suppose amongst all the vitriol, the idea that Denham is right, or even half right, is out of the question?

I considered that, but then considered this...

For a 2nd round pick?

You'd have to be joking or making it up.

[diesel 420]

I suppose amongst all the vitriol, the idea that Denham is right, or even half right, is out of the question?

I think it's acknowledged by most that he may be half right i.e. North wanted Watts for a 2nd rounder. That it didn't happen because they couldn't get a deal done is ONE interpretation of the fact that Watts was NEVER going to be traded for a 2nd round draft pick.

If there is one thing the average Melbourne supporter has learnt in the last 12 months it is that there are levels of truth and the way events can be interpreted in Journo speak. Some, such as Denham like to stretch it.

[rjay 25,087]

I suppose amongst all the vitriol, the idea that Denham is right, or even half right, is out of the question?

His record is not good with his call on Carlton and as for the stuff about not getting on with the coach or being on the outer it sounds like Misfud all over again.

...but hey stranger things have happened.

[Bitter but optimistic 22,246]

Arguably the most extraordinary post I've ever seen on here.

I don't know why you would consider this thread "extraordinary" BH, when so many are based on guesses, baseless supposition, pure invention or, best of all, "knowing" or having some connection to, an anonymous but highly credentialled sauce. (spelling intentional).

[Guest José Mourinho]

Post, not thread.

And I'd have to agree with him.

[Left Field 313]

Jose - A-Grade smart arse work

BBO - agree and similarly frustrated by "sauce" and other abominations.

[Sir Why You Little 37,125]

The bit that got me fired this morning was the way Denham said Neeld was all for the idea.

It is just Rubbish.

[Guest José Mourinho]

Thankyou.

Honestly though, I do agree.

I'm emotionally attached to Watts, have faith in him becoming a decent player, and would hate to see him go... but to get a player like Cotchin, I wouldn't bat an eyelid.

If the offer is there, get it done.

Not just because I think Cotchin will be a better player than Watts ever will, but I think a player of his type is more integral to our success as a club.

We need elite mids, not a better Andrew Mackie.

[diesel 420]

The bit that got me fired this morning was the way Denham said Neeld was all for the idea.

It is just Rubbish.

Using my 'Journo' interpretive speak skills I would say Neeld may well have been for it in WJ's scenario of on trading the 2nd round pick to the Hawks for Buddy & Cyril.

[Sir Why You Little 37,125]

Using my 'Journo' interpretive speak skills I would say Neeld may well have been for it in WJ's scenario of on trading the 2nd round pick to the Hawks for Buddy & Cyril.

Yes that is a nice "Pipe Dream" but it was in reference to a Nought Melb 2nd Round pick this morning.

Denham just Flatly lies and keeps talking.

[Mazer Rackham 14,971]

I suppose amongst all the vitriol, the idea that Denham is right, or even half right, is out of the question?

Let's see now ... it's months after the trading season, and there hasn't been a sniff of this.

But suddenly ... a rumour pops up ... and guess who's spreading it? Melbourne's Friend, Denham.

Sorry, but the sheer fact that it's Denham decreases its likelihood.

[baysidedave 246]

Venom Denim just reported on SEN that Nth Melbourne approached Melbourne wanting to trade a second round pick for Watts.

Apparently the coach was not adverse to the idea,but they ran out of time to get the deal done.

Denim goes further saying Watts is on the outer at Melbourne and may not be there next year.

Personally i think its rubbish that Watts is on the outer,but quite possible that North tried to snare him.

If you believe anything Denham says there's something wrong with you. Everybody knows Denham hates MFC and just makes up things to get a response from the supporters, the guy is actually worse than Wilson as a journo and thats saying something, he's lower than shark shyte

[Hannibal 5,814]

If you believe anything Denham says there's something wrong with you. Everybody knows Denham hates MFC and just makes up things to get a response from the supporters, the guy is actually worse than Wilson as a journo and thats saying something, he's lower than shark shyte

How could anyone argue against that type of acumen.

[Jesse Christ 2,884]

I have to say I am also emotionally invested in Watts, but I must confess if a swap for Cotchin was on offer I would pack Watts' bags myself

[Carrot Top 947]

I can see an enquiry. I can see us saying 'what's he worth to you'. I can see Nth saying 'maybe a second round pick and something else?'. And I can see us telling them to make a serious offer or move onto something else.

I can also see trade month ending with that being about the limit of the conversation.

Of course I don't listen to that Denham fella (one of the few bonuses of living in rugby land) so I can also understand that all of this might just be him bored and looking to light up the phone lines.

[Whispering_Jack 30,640]

I suppose amongst all the vitriol, the idea that Denham is right, or even half right, is out of the question?

Let's assume that North contacted Melbourne with an offer for Watts and the offer was for a first rounder and a player and that Melbourne rejected the offer.

Would that make Denham half right or would it make him wrong?

Either way, as a journalist he's a waste of space and when it comes to matters relating to Melbourne, he's irrelevant these days.

[At Least I Saw a Flag 5,274]

Greg "the tool" denham

the bloke is a dead set joke and anything that comes out of his mouth is dribble.

Perhaps even drivel?

[Jonesbag 487]

Perhaps even drivel?

Settle down mate, this isnt our first rodeo