Who I am? A guessing quiz.

[Jumping Jack Clennett 1,628]

Paul Wheatley

[Miles from Nowhere 199]

Jack Mueller

[DeeVoted 582]

There has been some decent tries on identifying this player,but none correct yet.

Here is the 2nd clue.

Who am I ......... (1st Clue)

My last ever game for Melbourne was in a reserves Grand Final

I am .....?

Who am I ......... (2nd Clue)

I played in a reserves winning GF in my last year, Ian Ridley was my coach

I am .....?

[beelzebub 22,272]

Tassie Johnson ?

[stingrays 24]

Ken Emselle

[Miles from Nowhere 199]

John Townsend

[robbo24 66]

Greg Parke

[skills32 229]

ted fidge

[GM11 699]

Barry Vagg

[durango 1,984]

Phil Rhoden

[H_T 2,941]

Frank Davis?

[DeeVoted 582]

Great to see so many guesses, and amongst all those we do have a winner!!

[DeeVoted 582]

Phil Rhoden

durango is running hot, thats 2 in a row for him.

Who am I ......... (1st Clue)

My last ever game for Melbourne was in a reserves Grand Final

I am .....?

Who am I ......... (2nd Clue)

I played in a reserves winning GF in my last year, Ian Ridley was my coach

I am .....?

Who am I ......... (3rd Cllue)

I originally played for University Blues

I am .....?

Who am I ......... (4th Clue)

I won the Gardiner Medal and another Melbourne player Paul Callery won the Morrish medal in the U19's. both in the same year.

I played only 3 senior games, I also served on the MFC committee.

I am .....?

Ans = Phil Rhoden

Rhoden was recruited by Melbourne from Richmond, who he had trained with, but was originally from the University Blues where he was runner up for the Victorian Amateur Football Association league best and fairest in 1965.

He won the Gardiner Medal in 1968 for his performances in the reserves but played only three senior games for Melbourne.

After leaving Melbourne, Rhoden played three senior matches and four reserves matches for Victorian Football Association team Sandringham in 1972. In 1979 he was a committee member for the Demons.

[Whispering_Jack 28,049]

... and was a prodigious kick of the footy!

[stingrays 24]

I was at that match.

An interesting end to our era. Ridley as coach, Kenneally, Emselle and Vagg the last of them. At least we saw Greg Wells make a start.

Carlton had these great recruits making their way. Bruce Doull, Ricky McLean and David McKay starting their careers.

[DeeVoted 582]

I was at that match.

An interesting end to our era. Ridley as coach, Kenneally, Emselle and Vagg the last of them. At least we saw Greg Wells make a start.

Carlton had these great recruits making their way. Bruce Doull, Ricky McLean and David McKay starting their careers.

I had a wry grin when I seen your guess ... Ken Emselle as I originally had him in mind,then decided to go with Rhoden.

Every time I watched Rhoden play for the 2's he was killing it, I often wondered why he couldnt get more time in the 1sts. I put it down to his bald head,he looked older. But geez he was a handy player to have lurking in the 2nds.

[DeeVoted 582]

... and was a prodigious kick of the footy!

bin awhile.. excellent drop kick wasnt he?

[stingrays 24]

I had a wry grin when I seen your guess ... Ken Emselle as I originally had him in mind,then decided to go with Rhoden.

Every time I watched Rhoden play for the 2's he was killing it, I often wondered why he couldnt get more time in the 1sts. I put it down to his bald head,he looked older. But geez he was a handy player to have lurking in the 2nds.

Yes Rhoden was great, and was admired by supporters other than MFC. Just couldn't take the next step. We've seen plenty of that.

I think this last quizz was your best, and most challenging with so many options as the choices were narrowed with each clue. Hope you can keep them going.

[Whispering_Jack 28,049]

... and was a prodigious kick of the footy!

Correction: As the great Jack Dyer used to say ... he was a prodigerous kick.

[DeeVoted 582]

I think this last quizz was your best, and most challenging with so many options as the choices were narrowed with each clue. Hope you can keep them going.

I am fast running out of ideas for clues , there are plenty of players to choose from. If someone else steps up to the plate for awhile it would be helpful.

[DeeVoted 582]

Correction: As the great Jack Dyer used to say ... he was a prodigerous kick.

and he was a good ordinary footballer.

[DeeVoted 582]

Next Quiz

Who am I ......... (1st Clue)

In my 1st game I kicked 2 goals.My debut has something in common with the number I wore on my back.

I am .....?

[beelzebub 22,272]

James Magner

Edited January 17, 2013 by belzebub59

[stingrays 24]

Peter Tossol: Number 21, 2 goals 1st game

Edited January 17, 2013 by stingrays

[Josh 1,420]

Peter Tossol: Number 21, 2 goals 1st game

Peter Tossol coached our local side Corowa to 2 premierships about ten years ago. His first 2 kicks were goals and his opponent was Mick Malthouse. Apparently Mark Jackson (I may have the wrong player but it was a hot headed power foward) let Tossol know "in no uncertain terms" that the second kick should have gone to him. I thought that was funny!