Latest murmurings of a crazy time

[Vipercrunch 2,818]

my feelings too. Rivers was a good solid servant to the club. We must recruit a replacement.

Good luck Jared.

We've already recruited 2 for the role he played for the 2nd half of last season. Dawes for now and Hogan for the future.

He's role as a defender was already covered which is why he moved forward.

Good player for us, but wouldn't be critical for our next 5 years. FA is ideal for situations like this.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

Give me Rivers over Garland.

[rpfc 27,637]

Give me Rivers over Garland.

Rivers 4 years older running out of time.

Rivers better defender, Garland more flexible and better chance of playing a role as we get better.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

Rivers 4 years older running out of time.

Rivers better defender, Garland more flexible and better chance of playing a role as we get better.

Rivers has a football brain.

[Bluey's Dad 3,419]

Rivers 4 years older running out of time.

Rivers better defender, Garland more flexible and better chance of playing a role as we get better.

Interesting that Neeld has said that versatility is one of the things he wanted to work on at the Dees. Seems to match up with your assessment of Garland/Rivers.

[Hannibal 5,814]

Rivers will be a star at Geelong... of that I am certain.

No. Rivers wouldn't be a "star" anywhere. He's a good ordinary footballer. Star = Carey, Voss, Hird, etc.

[olisik 4,060]

Anyone have any goss on whose on the Dees radar at the moment besides Pederson and Gumby.

Anyone else being looked at? Mids/small forwards?

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

Interesting that Neeld has said that versatility is one of the things he wanted to work on at the Dees. Seems to match up with your assessment of Garland/Rivers.

Rivers was better forward than Garland. Garland plays on smaller forwards but not as well as people make out.

It was apt that Garland came second in the "Coach Killers" award for one of his many brain fades.

[Bluey's Dad 3,419]

Anyone have any goss on whose on the Dees radar at the moment besides Pederson and Gumby.

Anyone else being looked at? Mids/small forwards?

Well we've already taken Byrnes and I remember reading that they were looking at Ray.

Surely pick 4 is earmarked for a mid.

[Bluey's Dad 3,419]

Rivers was better forward than Garland. Garland plays on smaller forwards but not as well as people make out.

It was apt that Garland came second in the "Coach Killers" award for one of his many brain fades.

Never heard of those awards - I'd love to see them, is it a DL thing?

Can I assume Morton won it?

I'm not sure Rivers was a better forward than Garland. Either way neither have had an extended period in that position to test themselves.

[rpfc 27,637]

Rivers was better forward than Garland. Garland plays on smaller forwards but not as well as people make out.

It was apt that Garland came second in the "Coach Killers" award for one of his many brain fades.

I really didn't think Rivers was much better than Garland. I thought they were both C level forwards - Garland had some good games with the Essendon game coming to mind and Rivers provided a target.

Again, Garland is far more flexible and Rivers' best position was one he was pushed out of. Garland is an awful decision maker but so was Jones. And Garland is a better leader than Rivers.

[nutbean 8,837]

.

Again, Garland is far more flexible and Rivers' best position was one he was pushed out of. Garland is an awful decision maker but so was Jones. And Garland is a better leader than Rivers.

I dont think Garland is necessarily a bad decision maker I just think that on the odd occasion he makes a decision that is fifty miles past the town of "bad decision" and that decision is so bad that the taste stays in your mouth for days after like a 4 day old fried dim sim from a roadhouse bain marie.

I thinks Garlands footskills are better than Rivers and better speed(for talls and smalls) but I think Rivers third up work and zoning off skills are better than Garlands- not much between them

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

Never heard of those awards - I'd love to see them, is it a DL thing?

Just a silly Fox Footy thing.

[s-t-i-n-g-a 439]

Who is better pedderson or brown from Geelong?

[olisik 4,060]

I think it would be great if we drafted that Chinese kid who attended the combine. Has a good build for an outside mid and would come as a freebie. Wouldn't even take up a spot on our senior list as he would go onto our international list. Also could help raise interest in the club from some Chinese living in Melbourne.

[Jordie_tackles 354]

No. Rivers wouldn't be a "star" anywhere. He's a good ordinary footballer. Star = Carey, Voss, Hird, etc.

Dont you get sick of the same arguements, not everyone sees stars the way you do

[Demon16 69]

Rivers was/is significantly harder than Garland.

[Hannibal 5,814]

Dont you get sick of the same arguements, not everyone sees stars the way you do

Never.

And yes, I'm well aware that many footy followers have flawed perceptions of our great game.

[nutbean 8,837]

Dont you get sick of the same arguements, not everyone sees stars the way you do

I don't - the most overused word on these boards are "star" and "champion" - words that have no relevance to our list today.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

I don't - the most overused word on these boards are "star" and "champion" - words that have no relevance to our list today.

Please, "elite" is the most overused word in football history.

[nutbean 8,837]

Rivers was/is significantly harder than Garland.

Agreed - again it may be the brain thing but Garland trails to a lot of contests

[nutbean 8,837]

Please, "elite" is the most overused word in football history.

yes - I forgot about that little pearl.

[PaulRB 6,041]

With our best player (jones) coming in at 50 in the herald sun top 50 I'd have to agree we have no champs or stars at the moment.

Lots of potential though.

[olisik 4,060]

I think it would be great if we drafted that Chinese kid who attended the combine. Has a good build for an outside mid and would come as a freebie. Wouldn't even take up a spot on our senior list as he would go onto our international list. Also could help raise interest in the club from some Chinese living in Melbourne.

Guangdong Province, Chao Zhou (China) 20 184 cm 72 kg Kevin Sheehan says: “Medium defender type with brilliant leg power. His vertical jump is in the rare category. A standing jump of 86cm and a running jump of 99cm at the China Combine in July were reflective of his background in volleyball and basketball. An exciting athlete that has excelled at school in short distance track events and displays a real desire to learn the game and improve. Is the first player to be selected from the AFL China Academy program in Guangshou, Southern China.”

[Deestroy All 14,262]

Guangdong style.