Narrowing in on either Grimes or Trengove for Captain

[Lutz 76]

he has a chronic back injury that he will have to manage all his life, not just for his football career. Every single game we get out of Frank is a bonus.

Fear-mongering and hyperbole at its finest.

[Sir Why You Little 37,052]

Fear-mongering and hyperbole at its finest.

Not at all. It's a fact, from the horses mouth a couple of years back. I want him to play but it won't be easy.

Once your back goes it is a case of management. My mum was a nurse and heavy lifting cursed her 40 years ago. Acupuncture is great, but AFL plays havoc with a back injury

[Lutz 76]

Not at all. It's a fact, from the horses mouth a couple of years back. I want him to play but it won't be easy.

Once your back goes it is a case of management. My mum was a nurse and heavy lifting cursed her 40 years ago. Acupuncture is great, but AFL plays havoc with a back injury

Yes, a lot of people have back injuries and are forced to manage them.

So what?

It has not been a problem for years - he has managed it - as many do.

And if Grimes is so close to shattering his porcelain body, why is he still on the list?

Why haven't we traded him and cashed in on him while there's still time??

If he's on the list, it's because he's expected to play.

If he were guaranteed to play all 22 games for the next 3 years, would you then make him captain?

Edited January 13, 2012 by Lutz

[Barney Rubble 1,576]

I'd actually pick Grimes.

And he has won the club's leadership award the last 2 seasons, so the football dept might agree.

Trengove is still a kid.

Grimes is actually a man.

I don't think that FD would agree. They're not here anymore

Remember the words of NEELD. It's a clean slate, the past counts for nothing.

Edited January 13, 2012 by Chippy

[rpfc 28,539]

I have said it before - we have no perfect candidate (or near it).

We are like the Republicans over in the US - arguing over the merits of every faulty candidate.

The new Captain will have his flaws because there is no flawless candidate.

So the FD should choose a flawed leader that will help the club. Either inspire that player, inspire his teammates, or help develop that player.

[Sir Why You Little 37,052]

If he were guaranteed to play all 22 games for the next 3 years, would you then make him captain?

of course that would make for serious consideration. But i doubt it will become reality. If it does E25 drinks will be had.

[Lutz 76]

I have said it before - we have no perfect candidate (or near it).

We are like the Republicans over in the US - arguing over the merits of every faulty candidate.

The new Captain will have his flaws because there is no flawless candidate.

So the FD should choose a flawed leader that will help the club. Either inspire that player, inspire his teammates, or help develop that player.

Very true, but the question is, who do you think is the best of the flawed candidates..?

[DEELIGHTED 16]

I think as neeld says he knows who he wants it will be green for sure. We know the players rate him with what they have said. The opposition coaches rate him re eade giving him the Australian honors and finally from what I know there would not be many at the club that are as professional. Too many questions remain over grimes and trenners is a tear or 2 away. Let the kid develop.

[rpfc 28,539]

Very true, but the question is, who do you think is the best of the flawed candidates..?

Wouldn't have a clue if it is based primarily on what Neeld and co. see every day in PS and team meetings.

My inkling is Moloney.

I would like Grimes to be able to stay on the pitch but he is a born leader so if they think his body is right he would be a huge chance.

Trengove has to show the FD that he can force himself upon the group and get most to follow - could he have done that at 20? I don't know.

Jones should be a chance given his record but I just don't see it. I can't see him demanding his teammates to do what is required (but we don't have many that fit that criteria).

Jamar should be looking at the LG before thinking about captaincy.

Green should concentrate on being a valuable member of the 22.

Davey should do the same.

Rivers has awful body language and is surprised when asked about his captaincy credentials.

Watts will grow into a very confident leader but he has to continue his development and from Neelds comments a few months ago - the microscope will be on him in house. He will have enough to worry about.

I think that is all of them.

[Lutz 76]

...

Good appraisal.

[McQueen 17,865]

Can anyone share details on what the criteria is for the RDB leadership award that Grimes won last season?

Is it voted on by team-mates, FD, etc..?

[Dr. Gonzo 24,235]

Fear-mongering and hyperbole at its finest.

He's had chronic injuries since his junior days playing with Hurstbridge and was the reason he slipped in the draft.

Look I don't think anyone here disputes he is a great leader but just think Trengove is a better fit long term. The way you're going on it sounds like you reckon the place has gone to the dogs if we appoint Trengove as captain.

[Carlos Danger 380]

JT BOG's will lift the team...& all of us in the stands!! If he also tosses the coin then it is a bonus...

In his 2 seasons and 37 games, he has polled one Brownlow vote. It's like all the hype and excitement of getting the number 1 and 2 draft picks in such a stacked draft has been put on the shoulders of Trengove since Scully's departure. He has done nothing on field to suggest he is the next Wayne Carey or worthy of being a captain at 20. Obviously he has stacks of potential but lumping all this expectation and demanding him to be made the captain so early doesn't seem healthy.

[Sir Why You Little 37,052]

In his 2 seasons and 37 games, he has polled one Brownlow vote. It's like all the hype and excitement of getting the number 1 and 2 draft picks in such a stacked draft has been put on the shoulders of Trengove since Scully's departure. He has done nothing on field to suggest he is the next Wayne Carey or worthy of being a captain at 20. Obviously he has stacks of potential but lumping all this expectation and demanding him to be made the captain so early doesn't seem healthy.

That is exactly why i question him being captain in 2012...I think his Football is more important than the captaincy...but as others have said we do lack serious leaders on our list at present.

[Biffen 12,944]

In his 2 seasons and 37 games, he has polled one Brownlow vote. It's like all the hype and excitement of getting the number 1 and 2 draft picks in such a stacked draft has been put on the shoulders of Trengove since Scully's departure. He has done nothing on field to suggest he is the next Wayne Carey or worthy of being a captain at 20. Obviously he has stacks of potential but lumping all this expectation and demanding him to be made the captain so early doesn't seem healthy.

Like David Warner ,you either have it or you dont .Jack T has it . A Brownlow is a matter of time .

[Harrisonrules 273]

sorry, left out that i'd 100% respect giving Green another chance, his passion and effort can't be beaten, he'll end up like James McDonald, not the greatest player but gives his all and contributes

I'm totally with you on this one. Leave the kids to play. I'd stick with Greeny, he will have learnt a lot from last years experience.

[old dee 23,801]

If you give the job to Grimes who will be the captain for the other half of the season?

[Lutz 76]

If you give the job to Grimes who will be the captain for the other half of the season?

If he's such a certainty to be injured, why haven't we traded or delisted him?

And if he was to get injured, wouldn't the vice captain take over? Isn't that the whole purpose of the vice captaincy role?

[Sir Why You Little 37,052]

If he's such a certainty to be injured, why haven't we traded or delisted him?

And if he was to get injured, wouldn't the vice captain take over? Isn't that the whole purpose of the vice captaincy role?

wouldn't it be better to just let him play Footy? That is what we are all waiting for...

[McQueen 17,865]

Can anyone share details on what the criteria is for the RDB leadership award that Grimes won last season?

Is it voted on by team-mates, FD, etc..?

Obviously not.

[Lutz 76]

wouldn't it be better to just let him play Footy? That is what we are all waiting for...

That's not an answer and it could be said for every player on the list - just let them play footy.

We've seen he can play.

I'm waiting for him to lead the club.

[Dr. Gonzo 24,235]

That's not an answer and it could be said for every player on the list - just let them play footy.

We've seen he can play.

I'm waiting for him to lead the club.

You obviously don't get it Artie so whatever.

After mulling over this a bit I actually think they would be best leaving it with Green for another season and having Trengove/Grimes as VC/DVC and then changing over the captaincy for 2013. Let Grimes focus on getting through a season uninterrupted and let JT focus on improving his game and developing into a leading midfield role. Lets face it the role of captain is more symbolic these days anyway, regardless of title natural leaders will still lead on the field and the track but giving it to a young and/or injury-plagued player will create additional external pressure through the media and fans which is not needed at this stage.

Having said that whoever they give it to I'm sure will be the right choice. I have confidence in the coaches/FD to make the right choice and they know the playing group more intimately than we do. If they decide to go with a new captain as part of the new "Neeld" era then I'm all for it no matter who that may be.

[Lutz 76]

Don't get it, or don't agree?

I think it's purely a narrow mindset that a player can't be captain because he was injured last year.

[Bossdog 2,002]

Don't get it, or don't agree?

I think it's purely a narrow mindset that a player can't be captain because he was injured last year.

And the year before that and the year before that

[Swampfox 190]

While i dont like having the captaincy shared i have heard Neeld say he has not ruled it out

I predict just one captain though

Captain will come from

Trengove

Grimes

Frawley

Would be really surprised if Green retained the captaincy

My tip is Trengove

Leadership Group will come from

Trengove

Grimes

Frawley

Moloney

Green

Jamar

Jones

I think that Jamar will get into our leadership group

I really dont think Watts is quite ready to be part of the leadership group but i have no doubt his day will come

I wouldnt discount Frawley being captain even though his position is a defender

Maxwell at Collingwood seems to do ok

Edited January 15, 2012 by Swampfox