Injury List: Round 10

[Jaded No More 68,974]

Davey might be out with knee soreness, apparently: http://www.theage.co...0524-1f2ik.html

I smell bullsh*t

[Guest Artie Bucco]

If he doesn't play for Casey, I'd say he's being rested due to soreness.

If he's just being dropped for poor form, he'd be playing for Casey.

Fairly logical, yes?

[beelzebub 23,383]

I smell bullsh*t

less than aromatic isnt it ??

That friday business is just rubbish...

Memo to club.......dont d!ck us around

[H_T 3,049]

If he doesn't play for Casey, I'd say he's being rested due to soreness.

If he's just being dropped for poor form, he'd be playing for Casey.

Fairly logical, yes?

Is the club locked into a particular specialist ?

If not, why can't they see someone else before Friday who is a specialist and free from appointments ?

And if Connoll's says it's not an ACL, strained, Medial, etc, how does he know it could only be a week or two at worst with "discomfort", without having checked with the specialist ?

"It came up early in the week.." ..When ? During a meeting ?!

"If" they're holding him back from playing due to last weeks poor form, they should be transparent. And "if" that is the case I would suggest the same for Wonaeamirri too. Both players walked off fine, untroubled. Suddenly both have been referred to as having knee soreness. Coincidence ?

I hope it's not a be careful not to tread on eggshells moment, just in case you don't hurt confidence or feelings, because such stances are a soft approach and a very different path from the ruthless club we were promised.

[jabberwocky 2,301]

"If" they're holding him back from playing due to last weeks poor form, they should be transparent. And "if" that is the case I would suggest the same for Wonaeamirri too. Both players walked off fine, untroubled. Suddenly both have been referred to as having knee soreness. Coincidence ?

I hope it's not a be careful not to tread on eggshells moment, just in case you don't hurt confidence or feelings, because such stances are a soft approach and a very different path from the ruthless club we were promised.

Very unhappy with the club on this at the moment.

Any chance we can trade for some testicles mid season.

[Jaded No More 68,974]

Very unhappy with the club on this at the moment.

Any chance we can trade for some testicles mid season.

Agreed.

Pathetic move if this injury is indeed a ploy to mask Davey being dropped, especially if it means we can't even play him with Casey.

He is not above being dropped for poor form. Sorry but as a leader he should feel more pressure than anyone to perform and if he doesn't, he should be made accountable for his poor form.

[Tricky 341]

Is the club locked into a particular specialist ?

If not, why can't they see someone else before Friday who is a specialist and free from appointments ?

And if Connoll's says it's not an ACL, strained, Medial, etc, how does he know it could only be a week or two at worst with "discomfort", without having checked with the specialist ?

"It came up early in the week.." ..When ? During a meeting ?!

"If" they're holding him back from playing due to last weeks poor form, they should be transparent. And "if" that is the case I would suggest the same for Wonaeamirri too. Both players walked off fine, untroubled. Suddenly both have been referred to as having knee soreness. Coincidence ?

I hope it's not a be careful not to tread on eggshells moment, just in case you don't hurt confidence or feelings, because such stances are a soft approach and a very different path from the ruthless club we were promised.

+1

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

you guys are just bagging the club without any information (geeee that never happens here does it)

if they are dropping him it would be to make a statement, why would you then cover up the statement with a fake injury it makes NO SENSE

think about it

[Tricky 341]

Whilst he hasn't been great, I hardly think he deserves to be dropped, considering the terrible quality of the delivery he has had to contend with.

OK, I haven't had a chance to watch a replay, but I was at the game and can't recall a single moment when he was in the F50 whilst we were going forward.

Were there (m)any?

[beelzebub 23,383]

I would have thought in order to get any form of strain injury ( and what could it be if not all the others described) then first some form of effort is required!!

I don't think he got close enough to anyone to get knocked.. Lol

[Tricky 341]

you guys are just bagging the club without any information (geeee that never happens here does it)

if they are dropping him it would be to make a statement, why would you then cover up the statement with a fake injury it makes NO SENSE

think about it

I think HT has asked some pretty legitimate questions...

Cover up or not I don't know, but would hate to think so.

[H_T 3,049]

you guys are just bagging the club without any information (geeee that never happens here does it)

if they are dropping him it would be to make a statement, why would you then cover up the statement with a fake injury it makes NO SENSE

think about it

I'm questionning the club and the statement (the information you're looking for) provided by Connolly. Bagging would be jumping to conclusions.

[Guest Artie Bucco]

The only thing I question is the seemingly clumsy attempt at explaining the circumstances, rather than just a bog standard "Davey has knee soreness and as a result is in doubt for next week's match."

It's going into unnecessary and vague detail by Connolly, which has only led to doubt.

Maybe poor handling of the matter, but I think some would still come out with the conspiracy theories whether we got more or less info anyway.

[beelzebub 23,383]

Me thinks they ( or someone ) protests too much

[Guest Thomo]

Davey cant see someone until Friday? I assume this must be because MFC are on the Medicare waiting list like others that can't afford private healthcare.

[Jaded No More 68,974]

Davey cant see someone until Friday? I assume this must be because MFC are on the Medicare waiting list like others that can't afford private healthcare.

Yep that sounds pretty weird to me given I've had my appointments bumped by artho surgeons before because they had 'emergency appointments' to attend to with footballers.

I've had Colin Garland steal my appointment before. Bastard!

[... 11]

you guys are just bagging the club without any information (geeee that never happens here does it)

if they are dropping him it would be to make a statement, why would you then cover up the statement with a fake injury it makes NO SENSE

think about it

"Pot... This is kettle-black, come in Pot!"

See your input to the medical staff thread where it was their fault for suspensions and concussions.

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

"Pot... This is kettle-black, come in Pot!"

See your input to the medical staff thread where it was their fault for suspensions and concussions.

there needs to be a question asked when you go many consecutive years with a huge injury list

if you don't ask the question, and instead put it down to luck and move on, you're a muppet

especially when your club is broke

[dee-luded 2,959]

I smell bullsh*t

You know Jaded, I just watched a bit of the replay, (yet to sit down & watch it through) when Davey took himself off, we were about 4 points down... And fighting hard for the Lead. He went to the bench for a checkover and a sitout, then went back on.

Needless to say we went down. The body language I noticed by players @ the start of the Qtr in Daveys area didn't look good. I'll go back for a more 'in perspective' Look, at the whole thing.

It's incredible the things you notice, with the 'Sound off', whilst watching the recorded game.

[dee-luded 2,959]

If he doesn't play for Casey, I'd say he's being rested due to soreness.

If he's just being dropped for poor form, he'd be playing for Casey.

Fairly logical, yes?

Not necessarily.

[dee-luded 2,959]

Is the club locked into a particular specialist ?

If not, why can't they see someone else before Friday who is a specialist and free from appointments ?

And if Connoll's says it's not an ACL, strained, Medial, etc, how does he know it could only be a week or two at worst with "discomfort", without having checked with the specialist ?

"It came up early in the week.." ..When ? During a meeting ?!

"If" they're holding him back from playing due to last weeks poor form, they should be transparent. And "if" that is the case I would suggest the same for Wonaeamirri too. Both players walked off fine, untroubled. Suddenly both have been referred to as having knee soreness. Coincidence ?

I hope it's not a be careful not to tread on eggshells moment, just in case you don't hurt confidence or feelings, because such stances are a soft approach and a very different path from the ruthless club we were promised.

The Aroma sounds very much like a job for Sig' Freud. Seriously, it does, but illness can cause these things, and persistent Stress can bring on "Illness". That can cause poor form. And poor form can cause "Stress".

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

"Pot... This is kettle-black, come in Pot!"

See your input to the medical staff thread where it was their fault for suspensions and concussions.

OK so Tapscott, davey, Bartram out injured this week

still just putting it down to bad luck are we smart guy

[Rogue 585]

So it looks like Scully and Wona made it through the test, but Bartram and Davey (?!?) have been added to the unavailability list.

Anyone know more about Bart's injury?

Yep that sounds pretty weird to me given I've had my appointments bumped by artho surgeons before because they had 'emergency appointments' to attend to with footballers.

I've had Colin Garland steal my appointment before. Bastard!

Literally taking it for the team; nice one.