If we lose to Freo ( we can then afford to win one more game without losing PP ) would you rather

- a - beat Carlton

- b - beat St Kilda

My choice ( probably totally unrealistic, but one can dream)- beat St Kilda by 1 point - we would end their winning streak ( if they are still undefeated by then) - but it would give us a great morale boost . AND I HATE ST KILDA !!

Edited August 12, 200916 yr by pben

Carlton

Carlton

Saints by a point. My fiance's a saints fan so would love it!

Carlton, thus derailing their top 4 hopes, and consigning them to an away final vs Brisbane or Adelaide.

Sweet.

If we lose to Freo what makes anyone think we are capable of beating carlton or sainters. This week is the only real last chance to taste victory this year.

Edited August 12, 200916 yr by belzebub59

St.Kilda, after the siren, after a free, by a point.

Carltank.

Revenge from those 2 games back in 2006- we somehow lost to them when we had top 4 on the line.

As if we'd beat either team though.

Carlton.

If we lose to Freo what makes anyone think we are capable of beating carlton or sainters. This week is the only real last chance to taste victory this year.

Nice side-step. What's your answer?

Carton by 100+ and Matty Whelan to break Judds leg a la Brown

Carlton.

But it won't happen.

St Kilda thus breaking the streak and I wouldn't mind taking a few players down too !!!

Carton by 100+ and Matty Whelan to break Judds leg a la Brown

Carlton. Then we can say "they know we're coming - and catching up quickly"

To wish injury of any type on a player let alone one that bad is disgraceful.

Edited August 12, 200916 yr by big_red_fire_engine

Carlton.

And the Russian to belt Fev!

Carltank.Revenge from those 2 games back in 2006- we somehow lost to them when we had top 4 on the line.

As if we'd beat either team though.

Why do people insist on still using the name Carltank??? We are no better than them.

I'd prefer to beat Carlton though.

Carton by 100+ and Matty Whelan to break Judds leg a la Brown

Disgraceful comment.

...and I couldn't agree more

Carlton.

Nice side-step. What's your answer?

I consider any such scenario implausible.. simple isnt it

Carlton, if we can mess up their top 4 ambitions! That would be soooo sweet.

Although, i kinda like the idea of the wooden spoon side beating an all conquering St Kilda team, sitting pretty at 21-0, hoping to go thru a whole season undefeated. Has a nice, full-circle kind of feel to it.

we won't win any of those 3 in all likelihood, so it's kinda useless deciding which one we 'should' try to win...

Ideally, all I'm hoping for is that we can get 22 fit players out on the park at this stage for all 3...

Having said that, I would love to see us end Carlton's finals aspirations. I couldn't think of anything better...

Edited August 12, 200916 yr by Scully The Tank Engine

Carlton. Then we can say "they know we're coming - and catching up quickly"

To wish injury of any type on a player let alone one that bad is disgraceful.

Yep. But in some ways I am a small bitter man.

Carlton. What have the saints ever done to us?

CARLTANK!!!

i dont mind saints

You can dream. We'll lose all three. Season over. Bring on the draft and pre-season.

Lose to Freo and the Saints, but beat the Filth Mark 2, in Carlton.

Carlton. i have family that follow the Blues so would be sweet to give it to them at last.

If it stuffs up their finals campaign a bit well all the better!