Best and Fairest

[demoniac 1,336]

Life memberships should not be auctioned/sold. They should be earned/presented. Crap. :angry:

Very quick to anger there Mono.

I suspect they were putting lifetime memberships up for auction. As in the successful bidders do not have to pay for a membership for the rest of their lives. Not as in bieng made a life member of the Melbourne Football Club.

[demoniac 1,336]

Bruce wins according to SEN 11pm news.

Can't say he would have got my votes.

[Mono 455]

Very quick to anger there Mono.

I suspect they were putting lifetime memberships up for auction. As in the successful bidders do not have to pay for a membership for the rest of their lives. Not as in bieng made a life member of the Melbourne Football Club.

Oh. Fair enuf.

[Jaded No More 68,974]

Bruce wins according to SEN 11pm news.

Can't say he would have got my votes.

It's so hard sometimes to be enthusiastic about this club and where it's going...

Very disappointing result for mine.

[bjgc 0]

Bruce wins according to SEN 11pm news.

AND MAGIC GOES WILD

[waynewussell 6,237]

Who cares if anyone here would have given Bruce a vote? The reality is that Cameron is a great Melbourne story. How many of you watched him going around in the ressies when they played at Punt road? Bruce continues to defy the odds... He is worthy of support and admiration... yes even from the coulda-beens who frequent these boards.

[Dee tention 617]

There is six people that will not have to pay again for a membership. That's a minimum of $1,000 a year to the club, minimum. The one who paid $7,000 - thats equivalent to nearly 20 years worth of memberships.

Does the money from the life memberships go to Debt Demolition, Dee-tention?

Not sure where the money goes High Tower! I will find out more in the next few days. And Yes. Cam the Bruce win's!

[Arem 0]

Final Result

Cameron Bruce 75

Brock McLean 60

Brad Green 57

Matthew Warnock 47

James McDonald 46

Brad Miller 40

Cale Morton 40

Clint Bartram 39

Paul Wheatley 39

Austin Wonaeamirri 39

Matthew Bate 38

Lynden Dunn 37

Colin Garland 30

Chris Johnson 25

Paul Johnson 24

Jeff White 24

Matthew Whelan 23

Nathan Jones 22

Colin Sylvia 22

Aaron Davey 20

Daniel Bell 19

Mark Jamar 18

Brent Moloney 16

Simon Buckley 14

Stef Martin 12

Russell Robertson 10

Jared Rivers 9

Nathan Carroll 8

James Frawley 6

Addam Maric 6

Adem Yze 6

Ben Holland 5

Shane Valenti 5

Michael Newton 4

[Swampfox 190]

Well done Cameron Bruce

playing all 22 games must have helped

Brock Mclean another Gary Ablett if only story

Excellent result for Mathew Warnock and Cale Morton

[Supreme_Demon 3,899]

Congratulations on Cameron Bruce winning the 2008 Best & Fairest for the Demons.

As harsh as it may sound it probably feels pretty hollow to win the MFC Best & Fairest in a year where the club finishes on the bottom of the ladder.

I'm sure that Yze_Magic has gone completely insane on this news because it wasn't Brad Green.

Who cares? Most of us here support the Melbourne Football Club as a whole not just particular players.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

Warnock fourth?

He improved, but not that much.

EDIT: Bartram eighth? FFS.

[H_T 3,049]

Must of got up in the last two rounds, surely... must be extra votes for errant handballs...well done Brucey.

(Well done No.32)

[H_T 3,049]

I would of thought Wheatley would of finished much higher. Wheatley finished 9th.

edit:

Disappointing for these blokes: -

Nathan Jones 22

Colin Sylvia 22

Aaron Davey 20

Daniel Bell 19

[Mousey 47]

Fantastic to see Cale Morton getting 7th at 18 years old in his first year.

And ozzie 10th!

Pretty suprised about Warnock and Jones positions

[demoniac 1,336]

Who cares if anyone here would have given Bruce a vote? The reality is that Cameron is a great Melbourne story. How many of you watched him going around in the ressies when they played at Punt road? Bruce continues to defy the odds... He is worthy of support and admiration... yes even from the coulda-beens who frequent these boards.

He may be a great Melbourne story but he is not a great player. His kicking and his lack of intensity being his greatest weaknesses. I really hope that the rumours re his contract amount are not true but logic says they have some credence given we were paying 100% of the cap with Neita and Ooze on the veteran's list. If we are to challenge for a flag then we will need better quality best and fairest winners than Cam. Garland would have got my vote over Bruce, Wheatley played better.

Me - A could been? More a never-was. But at the age of 38 definitely a never-seen-his-team-win-a-flag.

[The Fergburger 0]

Well done Cam!

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

Who votes for the B&F?

If it's the coaches then I'm worried because that list is out of whack IMO.

[wisedog 352]

I have to admit that the award feels somewhat hollow in these bad years, you don't really know who's going to win. Robertson won in 2003, and he was good, but hardly what you'd call a prolific forward.

When you've made the finals, it's been a genuine team effort, and there's competition between the players.

This year, there was Green and Bruce, who were solid, but that's all you can really say.

[H_T 3,049]

I would of thought Wheatley would of finished much higher. Wheatley finished 9th.

edit:

Disappointing for these blokes: -

Nathan Jones 22

Colin Sylvia 22

Aaron Davey 20

Daniel Bell 19

Who votes for the B&F?

If it's the coaches then I'm worried because that list is out of whack IMO.

I agree Biz.

STill scratching my head on the above...

[Chook 15,022]

Congratulations to Cam Bruce on winning this years award. Minor recognition to Bailey's Babies for tipping the victory.

[demon_king 13]

Surprirsed Wheatley wasn't further up the order but well done to Bruce.

How many times has green finished top 5 now?

[Chook 15,022]

We are a joke, always have been, always will be.

Hey, that's catchy. Why don't you put that in your sig?

[beelzebub 23,383]

Another nod to medicority

Well lets hope that list reads differently in a few years !! <_<

God who votes for the Bluey

Given Bluey was reknown for his accuracy of disposal...Somewhat ironic surely that the guy who won it cant hit the side of a barn!!

[H_T 3,049]

Interestingly, Cameron Bruce was named best in Herald Sun, and best by both coaches (10 votes) - FC. I noticed in Demonland Voting he was down in the pecking order. Are we at Demonland underestimating him? He's fifth in the overall Demonland votes. But I thought he might of got some 5 and 6 votes, but instead got 2's and 3's.

I think he might be a chance in the B&F.

Just an observation regarding he's B&F chances.

There you go sports fans....Aug 19.

[DEES 0]

congrats to cam, thoroughly deserved even though the team performed poorly. also great to see mclean second, which shows how highly rated he is, hope he gets the captaincy and wins the b&f next year