Bitter but optimistic

You're correct TPM but who cares? The more pain, infighting, dissent and general shite for Carlton the happier I'll be!

I saw him and liked him. But is he only 193?. We really need another biggy for that key CHF slot.

Let me know if you find a good therapist. Certain mental instability comes with being a Melbourne supporter.

Jesus RR. Even I think this "Mummy love" stuff is getting a bit bizarre and now Trengove comes into it. Are you undergoing counselling?

Yeah. I was never sold on Cloke but we really need a player to fill that CHF gap. No one on our list has been able to do it with either consistency or authority. And, as we have seen, if Clarke goes down, we are snookered. Tippett?

We need to have a poll on whether or not this thread has any interest left.

Like you, OD I've followed the dees for a long time. I also remeber the two purple patches since 64 - two grand finals. We had the shite kicked out of us in both. Hardly something to hand one's hat on.

"needs to be punished" . Is dropping him enough? Perhaps some time in the stocks? Or, perhaps you could give him a jolly good flogging RR?

"F**k you Mick!"

Well whoever you are bringing in, make sure you get their money and sign them up before you allow them to read Demonland.

You're fighting the good fight stuie but I don't think you'll ever win. I f Watts racks up 40 possies next week and kicks 6 from the backline, it will be a case of- he was left loose, his opponent was injured, favourable umpiring, easy possessions, lucky. You get the drift. Christ who would want to be a first draft pick at Melbourne.

Watching Carlton get stitched up last was one of my most enjoyable footy highlights for years. Even my dog was confused - I'm sure he couldn't work out what all the yelling was about when Melbourne wasn't involved.

For Melbourne supporters, I'd suggest that this season has been about 18 weeks too long!

I'm not sure that that is the case. Let's wait and see.

Correct! But my point is we should move heaven and earth to to keep him on the park.

Christ what's happening? Extending the welcome mat to septic tanks? Before you know it we'll be opening our arms to reformed filth supporters or, God help us Kiwis!

I don't care if it's a one way street. Let's stick with this guy. The fact is we are short of geniuses.

Rumour from where? Surely you made this up.

If Jurrah's prepared to have a go and stick with the club through a pre season then we must stick with him. In fact, more than stick with him we must encourage and support him to continue with his career. The guy is a genius. We have only seen flashes of his potential. PLease, please do anything needed to keep him

There really is a serious amount of shite posted on this site. The sooner Melb. starts winning games and we can talk positive footy stuff the better.

That is very clever stuie. Gave me a great laugh to start the day.

I see it the other way. Think back to all the times over the last few years when we have taken the ball into the forward 50 but lacked the firepower to make the most of it. A fit Clarke and another big body for the opposition to worry about and we're in the game!

Interesting isn't it? MFC is frequently slated for poor development of players yet Sellar, who was on the scrapheap, has developed into a servicable part of the list. Good luck to hikmj!

We reselect Brad Miller (thus saving us millions on Cloke) . Clarke is moved out to CHF and Miller kicks 100 - including 7 in the GF. I won't spoil the surprise by telling you who wins.

I'm half optimistic.