Facilities Excuse is BS

[Redleg 38,056]

It was widely reported that Judd's interview was at the G and that Melbourne were clever in not taking him to the Junction oval. Therefore he does not personally know the state of our facilities. His manager might but it is certainly sounding like a rubbish excuse. The real reason may have something to do with millions of dollars.

[Diablo 1]

The real reason may have something to do with millions of dollars.

At first I thought you were just spouting what we'd been discussing all day. But then you came up with this gem and it saved the post. Well Done.

[mick2007 0]

I would believe we knocked him back because we simply couldn't afford him

[pantaloons 2,019]

I wonder if Melbourne are still pursuing Judd as the club's official mascot after it was revealed this morning that he is in fact the devil.

[Diablo 1]

I wonder if Melbourne are still pursuing Judd as the club's official mascot after it was revealed this morning that he is in fact the devil.

Haha.

I don't think I had the devil picked as such a pansy!

[occo 2]

It was widely reported that Judd's interview was at the G and that Melbourne were clever in not taking him to the Junction oval. Therefore he does not personally know the state of our facilities. His manager might but it is certainly sounding like a rubbish excuse. The real reason may have something to do with millions of dollars.

thats correct. He wants $. Think of what eddie can bring him. More promotion, more time on the footy show and more player payments. He also wants to be in a team with good chances of sucsess...something i dont think melbourne can do till 2010.

[Yencks 8]

apparantly, its not about the facilities and his manager screwed up but hes not talking at the moment because he is upset about the death of chris manwerring. maybe we should leave him alone until we hear it from his own mouth..however i cant talk, ive been pretty rude about him

[grazman 6,653]

I would believe we knocked him back because we simply couldn't afford him

But we knew what he wanted when we met him, but maybe it turned into a bidding war, maybe we weren't prepared to give up what West Coast were asking, maybe it was just the whole package was too expensive.

[mick2007 0]

West Coast probably wanted pick 4 sylvia and frawley and we said no

[Jaded No More 59,158]

But we knew what he wanted when we met him, but maybe it turned into a bidding war, maybe we weren't prepared to give up what West Coast were asking, maybe it was just the whole package was too expensive.

Considering that we've been looking at possible Judd deals and scenarios for a long time now, and had a committee set up, I doubt it.

We would have known going into this whole thing, that getting Judd would be expensive.

Besides, if that was the truth, why would we not just say that? Why come out with the lamest excuse possible?

[mick2007 0]

Considering that we've been looking at possible Judd deals and scenarios for a long time now, and had a committee set up, I doubt it.

We would have known going into this whole thing, that getting Judd would be expensive.

Besides, if that was the truth, why would we not just say that? Why come out with the lamest excuse possible?

Lamest excuse possible always works ask George Bush

[beelzebub 22,368]

fear not fine folk...the kharma faeiries will take care of all !! What goes around comes around !!!

[emubitter 0]

m thoughts i posted on bigfooty

think about the 'facts" presented so far.

MFC have issued a statement saying judd rejected the club because of inadequate facilities.

he knew that before he nomited us as a contender.

until it's proven, i cannot believe the club would fabricate the story.

if anything, it was a lame excuse given to the club by judds manager, probably thinking the club wouldn't put those words in an official statement and now coping some blacklash for the excuse and back peddling as quickly as possible.

it was all a charade to cover up the deal collingw#@d has been working on for the past 12 months.

hope the eagles feel like they've been shafted and hit back.

gee, i hope this bites the scum on the arse.

[Redleg 38,056]

He also wants to be in a team with good chances of sucsess...something i dont think melbourne can do till 2010.

What are you saying. We belted them with half a team in June. We lost to them with 15 players out in round 20 by 11 points when we had no one on the bench after half time. In my opinion with a full list we would kick their arse every time. If they had our injuries they would have been where we were. After they lose more players to fit him in the cap, like Wakelin, Buckley, Burns, Licuria, Holland and maybe even Presti, they will struggle, even with their 18 games on the G each year, in our rigged competition.

[beelzebub 22,368]

Hope Eddie has a job for Twiggy.. think she's just fallen off the 7-wagon !! lol

[Redleg 38,056]

Hope Eddie has a job for Twiggy.. think she's just fallen off the 7-wagon !! lol

She is Lou Richards assistant on the handball on the Sunday Footy show next year.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

It was widely reported that Judd's interview was at the G and that Melbourne were clever in not taking him to the Junction oval. Therefore he does not personally know the state of our facilities. His manager might but it is certainly sounding like a rubbish excuse. The real reason may have something to do with millions of dollars.

Completely agree and Harris's handling of this matter has matched the state of our facilities.

What are you saying. We belted them with half a team in June. We lost to them with 15 players out in round 20 by 11 points when we had no one on the bench after half time. In my opinion with a full list we would kick their arse every time. If they had our injuries they would have been where we were. After they lose more players to fit him in the cap, like Wakelin, Buckley, Burns, Licuria, Holland and maybe even Presti, they will struggle, even with their 18 games on the G each year, in our rigged competition.

Agree once more.

On fire tonight Redleg!

[ol' Grimey Knackers 0]

Chris had been somewhat surprised by the quality of our club presentation and strategies, and it was a difficult decision

Ok. So he must have been expecting our presentation and strategies to be [censored]?

If he was expecting that, why was he talking to us? To waste everyone's time? To confirm his expectations?

However the club's training facilities at Junction Oval and the need to train at a variety of grounds over summer was an issue.

So what? Judd had to go through the 'quality of our ... presentation' to come to this conclusion?

we do have this comparative disadvantage

So Judd's decision is the correct one?

While it is very disappointing that Chris will be playing elsewhere next year, the club ought to be quietly satisfied that it had got itself from being a rank "no hope" outsider to being very competitive in the pursuit

Quietly satisfied? That he told us to go forth and multiply FIRST. How is that competitive?

Or did he inform the Dungs at the same time as us yet we were first with the news? If so, out of the four, we finished in the bottom half. Familiar?

Thank God we weren't a 'rank "no hope" outsider'.

ahead of many clubs who failed to even get his attention

Whoopee! They must be spewin'.

This outcome will only sharpen the need for the whole club to work together to ensure we have fully competitive facilities and resources.

Again, Judd's decision is the correct one?

And we know that we have a team very capable of quickly overcoming the 2007 disappointment and getting back into the finals as we were in the three previous years.

Could be the mission statement of this Club since '98. WE MADE THE FINALS.

With a new coach and new football manager, a healthier playing list and with Pick 4 still in our hand, we have plenty of reasons to look forward to the 150th anniversary year in 2008

Only downside is that our facilities render us a 'comparative disadvantage'. Great.

.............................

In short, on the basis of Harris' statement, it appears that either:

1. Judd has involved himself is a sham process and wasted our Clubs time; or

2. We are [censored] and Harris has told us so.

Over reaction by me? Probably. Regardless, either Judd's management or Harris spinning [censored]? Absoutely.