Decision Not Made!

[Deetastic 0]

Did anyone notice last night how Chris had to pull the microphone away from Rebecca when the reporter asked "What colours Chris would look best in?" After pulling the microphone away from Bruce Macalvanys hand and away from Rebecca’s mouth Chris said "You are not allowed to ask that question?" and the telecast went to a commercial break.

This is a clear sign that the decision has indeed been made and Rebecca knows the destination. Who is it? Who knows but my father is very close friends with one of our board members and my father told me last night that he had been told by the board member that it was between Melbourne and Collingwood. That the Melbourne board think they are favourites and they expect an announcement this week.

I note that on another post which came originally from Demonogy that similar things have been said. This information is completely independent of that which is also meant to come from a board member and thus I have come to the conclusion that there is a high likelihood that this is true.

[grazman 7,504]

Did anyone notice last night how Chris had to pull the microphone away from Rebecca when the reporter asked "What colours Chris would look best in?" After pulling the microphone away from Bruce Macalvanys hand and away from Rebecca’s mouth Chris said "You are not allowed to ask that question?" and the telecast went to a commercial break.

This is a clear sign that the decision has indeed been made and Rebecca knows the destination. Who is it? Who knows but my father is very close friends with one of our board members and my father told me last night that he had been told by the board member that it was between Melbourne and Collingwood. That the Melbourne board think they are favourites and they expect an announcement this week.

I note that on another post which came originally from Demonogy that similar things have been said. This information is completely independent of that which is also meant to come from a board member and thus I have come to the conclusion that there is a high likelihood that this is true.

I don't think it's anything more than educated guess work at the moment. If Melbourne is one of the two favoured clubs then that's a massive coup. If we are his preferred destination then it will be a feel good football story all round. If he wants to go to the Pies I'd expect that West Coast would make them pay dearly...

[Rod Grinter Riot Squad 5,654]

Either way I hope the decision is soon and goes our way. I can't ever remember wanting to get a player to Melbourne anywhere near as much as I want us to get Judd. The suspense is killing me and the sooner we find out the better IMO.

Come home Chris.

[Demon15 0]

Did anyone notice last night how Chris had to pull the microphone away from Rebecca when the reporter asked "What colours Chris would look best in?" After pulling the microphone away from Bruce Macalvanys hand and away from Rebecca’s mouth Chris said "You are not allowed to ask that question?" and the telecast went to a commercial break.

This is a clear sign that the decision has indeed been made and Rebecca knows the destination. Who is it? Who knows but my father is very close friends with one of our board members and my father told me last night that he had been told by the board member that it was between Melbourne and Collingwood. That the Melbourne board think they are favourites and they expect an announcement this week.

I note that on another post which came originally from Demonogy that similar things have been said. This information is completely independent of that which is also meant to come from a board member and thus I have come to the conclusion that there is a high likelihood that this is true.

What any of the above say doesn't count.

West Coast make the final decsion - where Judd wants to go is irrelevant.

West coast want a certain type of deal and nothing less. They have to be happy first

[beelzebub 23,390]

West Coast make the final decsion - where Judd wants to go is irrelevant.

I think you'll find its the other way around !!

[Deetastic 0]

Judd makes the final decision and then its upto the club involved to satisfy WC demands. If they can't Pre Season Draft.

[Demon15 0]

I think you'll find its the other way around !!

How do you figure that?

His sole reason for leaving Perth , publicly stated, was to join his family in melb, and he wouldnt enter the PSD.

To now impose a further condition is unlikely to be his style, given the Eagles have acceded to his key request.

The rest now is up to west coast to get what they see as a fair trade deal.

[Kit Walker 225]

I think you'll find its the other way around !!

It's both ways. If WC think they're getting screwed, why wouldn't they make a deal with Richmond for Pick 2 plus Deledio for some WC muppet that will never play a game, knowing the tigers would get Judd in the PSD anyway?

Port weren't bright enough to do that with Stevens but Hawthorn were with Rawlings.

[beelzebub 23,390]

How do you figure that?

His sole reason for leaving Perth , publicly stated, was to join his family in melb, and he wouldnt enter the PSD.

To now impose a further condition is unlikely to be his style, given the Eagles have acceded to his key request.

The rest now is up to west coast to get what they see as a fair trade deal.

You purport that WCE will decide for him where he's going. If that was at all close to the truth then Judd wouldnt be talking to clubs, he'd just go where Nisbett wanted him to go. Makes no sense whatso ever.

He, and he alone is driving all of this, WCE is absolutely and very much a apssenger. Alll they can do is 'react' to what Judd decides and then make the best fist of a trade that they can. if they dont. They get nothing. Its as simple as that.

Despite any real rhetoric Judd isnt really going to care too much (maybe a litle little bit..lol) about the fortunes of WCE now; he's concerned with his own.

he had no hand in where he went first time...you can be bloody sure he is in control this time

[grazman 7,504]

Judd will state a desire to play for a club.... I think he will probably talk to the Eagles first about whether there is any likelihood that club can satisfy the Eagles demands before any public announcement is made. You can be damn sure that one of them will be able to. No club that is listed as Judd's prefered option wants to be known as the club that let him get away... with maybe the exception of Collingwood. lol.

[deanox 10,045]

i think it is a typical stand off:

what are west coast prepared to accept.

what are the other team prepared to offer.

judd wont go in psd.

judd can say he will agree to a trade to one side only, meaning another side cannot just try and trump in.

but one of the three things have to bend. i hope its what west coast accepts, if its us.

if west coast dont bend they lose him for nothing. if the other club wont offer enough they wont get him. hopefully west coast just want to get whatever they can and run, knowing that they've lost him anyway. i wonder if judd will be part of the negotiating process? im sure he wouldnt be happy if a club traded half their team for him...

[GIRO 63]

Hope it is between two clubs

WC would rather deal with Melbourne rather than Coll

Judd was BORN to wear the red and blue

[beelzebub 23,390]

I agree that in all likely hood Judd wouldnt opt for the PSD; but he can!! And WCE doesnt want to force his hand. A mexican standoff is sort of close.. its just Judd has a gun and WCE doesnt !!! lol

WCE are playing a version of the ol' 3 card shuffle, getting everyone to look one way whilst reality is something else

[Diablo 1]

I'll tell you now, if Judd comes out and says 'Melbourne', WC will be not far short of ecstatic. They would be loathe to give him up to Collingworst, and Essendon to a lesser extent. I'm pretty sure we would be the favoured destination for WC out of the 4. We may have to pull a few interesting strings in trade week, say to get pick 5, to top off the deal, but if Judd says the magic word we WILL do a deal.

[beelzebub 23,390]

Probably the only thing Judd will acede to is to name two clubs. if that happens our stocks go up dramatically

[beelzebub 23,390]

I must confess the inclusion of Essendon in all this has all but mystified me

[beelzebub 23,390]

Despite any yelling and screaming teh real basis of a trade to WCE is an early pick, An early pick plus "something" is the most likely outccome. WCE want some icing as well as cake. They, and quite rightly so ( from their persepctive ) are trying to set the bar as high as possible. Time will tell

[praha 11,253]

Judd makes the final decision and then its upto the club involved to satisfy WC demands. If they can't Pre Season Draft.

Judd won't do that. For three reasons.

1. WC have more power in this whole thing than we all think

2. He doesn't want to go to Carlton and lose for the next 2-3 years.

3. I don't think he is the type of guy to totally ditch the club that gave him a chance and treated him like god. He wouldn't screw them over like that.

If he chooses Collingwood and they can't get something done, he will go to his next option. Either way, WC will get something out of this. He won't enter the PSD.

[Demon15 0]

he had no hand in where he went first time...you can be bloody sure he is in control this time

Good point.

[mick2007 0]

I don't think West Coast will be too greedy when it comes to trade time. They have to remember he is injured and theres is no certainty it wont effect his playing career. I think they'll want early draft pick and a upcoming forward like Newton or Sylvia, or we will give them early draft pick and bulldogs early pick if we trade robbo. Remembering they could have local players they have there eye on which aren't far away from AFL level. When you have priddis, kerr and cousins there will be no need for another midfielder, so TJ is safe.

[beelzebub 23,390]

Judd won't do that. For three reasons.

1. WC have more power in this whole thing than we all think

2. He doesn't want to go to Carlton and lose for the next 2-3 years.

3. I don't think he is the type of guy to totally ditch the club that gave him a chance and treated him like god. He wouldn't screw them over like that.

If he chooses Collingwood and they can't get something done, he will go to his next option. Either way, WC will get something out of this. He won't enter the PSD.

what real power does WC have?? it wil be told..go make a deal with him or him !!

If he didnt want to go to Carlton why would he have them on his shortlist ?

The past is the past.. Judd is lookig forward. At the end of the day he is not the eagles master, they are just sh!tty that the boot is on the other foot and they dont like it.. tough bikkies !! I think they are dead lucky personally that they will even get any chance at dealing inthis whole business. B)

[whelan45 203]

The title of the thread says public announcement this week

Just wondering whether that is fact or an educated guess?

[beelzebub 23,390]

you 'd think it unlikely before the GF.. but hey...this is footy after LL !!

[Deetastic 0]

My understanding is our board expect an announcement this week. However, according to todays Herald Sun, Chris is going into surgery on his groin tomorrow. This being the case you would expect him to make an announcement today, Friday (maybe too close to Grand Final) or next week after the GF.

[mick2007 0]

Eddie will have the contract ready to sign just as Judd is coming out of the anesthetic. Judd will get the paper the next day headlining " Judd to Pies". Judd will be like" WTF i didn't want to go there", The nurse will reply "yeah you signed the contract yesterday"!