Judd's Worth

[Nasher 33,166]

Hahaha. Some of these calls about Judd to Carlton I find more than a little amusing. Oh it was but a couple of months back that you could replace the word 'Judd' with 'Voss' in some of the above comments. Even the same phrases 'signed sealed and delievered' and other such rubbish.

Lol he won't be at Carlton.

I agree. I lost count of the number of people who reckon they had a source at Carlton with the whole Voss saga. No doubt they had a source, but in most cases the sources turned out to just be rumourmongers who liked the sound of their own voices.

Forgive me for being just a little bit skeptical of anyone who claims to have a "source" at Carlton.

[Redleg 38,062]

Not calling u a liar but i find it hard to believe a deal's done 2 days after their season finished.

From all reports John Worsfold hasn't even talked to Judd about it and i refuse to believe Judd's gonna accept a deal without even telling Worsfold he's going.

Hell for all we know, Judd's still tossing the idea around of should he stay or go.

To me, it sounds like typical arrogant Blues supporter who thinks they can get anybody.

Remember Voss to Carlton. Zero from one.

You could be right that it is just another big mouth Carlton supporter ( hoping). However I note that Judd has called a press conference at 6.00 PM tonight that should enlighten us a little more. Also Worsfold was quoted as saying he would not stand in Judd's way if he wanted to come home and that suggests he knows a bit about it. Further I was amazed that the WCE kept playing Judd when he was obviously seriously injured, ( the papers call it a career ending type of injury if not fixed). If they knew he was going, they could have decided what the hell, make him play and his new club can suffer if he doesn't come up.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

Forgive me for being just a little bit skeptical of anyone who claims to have a "source" at Carlton.

I would say that would apply to sources and "sauces" in general.

[sylvinator 96]

I for one am hoping we go hard for him. It's about time MFC had a player who was dominant in the AFL.

The only concern I would have is that if we are paying him 1.1 million a year. Will that mean we wont be able to get enough quality players around Judd?

[The Fergburger 0]

Judd to the Dees!!!

[Coxy 0]

I for one am hoping we go hard for him. It's about time MFC had a player who was dominant in the AFL.

The only concern I would have is that if we are paying him 1.1 million a year. Will that mean we wont be able to get enough quality players around Judd?

I'm sure Chris isn't the sort of person overly concerned with money when it comes to playing for the team he supported.

[joeboy 2,872]

I would say that would apply to sources and "sauces" in general.

My source is on the Carlton Board .

[Coxy 0]

My source is on the Carlton Board .

My sauce is in the fridge

[Redleg 38,062]

My source is on the Carlton Board .

He may be the same source used by the Carlton supporter i spoke to. If he is correct they have a leaky Board.

[Redleg 38,062]

I'm sure Chris isn't the sort of person overly concerned with money when it comes to playing for the team he supported.

What makes you so sure?

[The Fergburger 0]

I'm sure Chris isn't the sort of person overly concerned with money when it comes to playing for the team he supported.

Very true.

[The Backyard Charizard 1,178]

I have been one of the negative posters that were saying "No" to Chris Judd....

I have now officially changed my mind!

The more I think about it, the more I like it.....

Being a Melbourne boy at heart and wanting to come back to Victoria has pretty much given me a stiffy!

We are struggling to come up with a 100% agreed upon replacement for Neitz as captain of our great club.....

Judd would maybe drop a few hundred thousand $$$ a year to be wearing the colours he was dreaming about as a junior!!

I can't see him going to Carlton, Collingwood, Essendon or Richmond.... If the kid barracked for the Dees then those choices are a disgusting thought!

If we offload TJ, Davey and our 1st draft pick????? I am pretty confident we would have Judd wearing no. 3 for the Red 'n Blue!!

Exciting times at Demonland!

PS. I know this is a huge change of opinion for myself, but I have done some serious thinking this weekend and have decided that things can't get any worse! We've waited long enough!!!

[hangon 0]

My source is on the Carlton Board .

Would you believe and trust 1 word that came out of the Carlton football club.

Would you believe and trust 1 word from the supporters & cheer squad that were barracking for their team to lose ... remember how they mocked us ... taunted us for winning. Remember ... "We got Kreuzer.. Melbourne are losers" ... their words not mine.

Would you believe and trust 1 word when you have ex President, ex-captains and legends of the club saying ... "Yes this is a game we need lose"

The Carlton Football Club has zero creditability.

[w00dy 146]

What makes you so sure?

i've heard his manager talk about him on the radio... he said if there was one thing he would say about Chris Judd, it is that he's a man not motivated by money, and the way the man comes across in the media, it doesn't surprise me one bit...

lets hope he loved the dees enough that he wants to come back and play for us...

[Yze_Magic 3]

If we offload TJ, Davey and our 1st draft pick????? I am pretty confident we would have Judd wearing no. 3 for the Red 'n Blue!!

I want Judd more than anyone, but that is way too much to give up

[Demonland 66,562]

I want Judd more than anyone, but that is way too much to give up

I wonder if he's going to do an Akermanis and actually name his favoured destination?

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

I wonder if he's going to do an Akermanis and actually name his favoured destination?

If he is 100% on which club he wants to go then I think he will do that.

[Yze_Magic 3]

I wonder if he's going to do an Akermanis and actually name his favoured destination?

Well the press conference is at 6 today

If he has already decided , and it happens to be the Demons...

Then Sunday the 16th of September, 2007 will be the greatest day of my life !!!!

[Hannabal 4]

The thought of him in a Carlton jumper makes me feel ill.

I suspect they'll field offers from interested clubs and make a decision on his preference pretty quickly.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

The thought of him in a Carlton jumper makes me feel ill.

I suspect they'll field offers from interested clubs and make a decision on his preference pretty quickly.

Judd and Carlton just doesn't quite sit with me. It just doesn't seem right and I just can't see it happening.

If Melbourne do get Judd, then forget about needing Sheedy to "promote the club". Just having Judd in the red and blue will be enough promotion as it is.

[demon_king 13]

Just stumbled across this on ninemsn.....

Blow for Eagles as Judd heads east

http://wwos.ninemsn.com.au/article.aspx?id=296384

I will be pretty dirty if the blues land him, after the way they finished out the year and snagged two early picks and now they can use these as leverage to land the best player in the game today just makes the game a shambles.

[Demonic_Inferno 17]

Just stumbled across this on ninemsn.....

Blow for Eagles as Judd heads east

http://wwos.ninemsn.com.au/article.aspx?id=296384

I will be pretty dirty if the blues land him, after the way they finished out the year and snagged two early picks and now they can use these as leverage to land the best player in the game today just makes the game a shambles.

It's my understanding that Carlton cannot use their priority pick in any way, shape or form as trade bait. So that would leave them at best with pick 3 and.........Fevola the headcase?

Comeon Dees!

[WonnaJurah 5]

judd doesnt like tankers , so wont go to carlton i hope hehe

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

It's my understanding that Carlton cannot use their priority pick in any way, shape or form as trade bait.

I've heard that is NOT true.

[demon_king 13]

It's my understanding that Carlton cannot use their priority pick in any way, shape or form as trade bait. So that would leave them at best with pick 3 and.........Fevola the headcase?

Comeon Dees!

Yeah thats what I thought too but my point is they will end up with Kruezer and Judd.