6 hours ago, Queanbeyan Demon said:

and the evidence for that would be? carltank have had mostly new people on the scene now half a dozen times in the last 30 years. its going very well for them.

We will see how things pan out in the next year or two but Graham Wright has an awesome track record in previous gigs, so hoping he can keep on with the clean out he clearly has commenced.

Dangerfield was phenomenal last night.

in terms of extending his career it would be great if trac could model danger. would be great for us as well.

1 minute ago, BDA said:

Dangerfield was phenomenal last night.

in terms of extending his career it would be great if trac could model danger. would be great for us as well.

I suggest after watching Danger bulldoze the hawks they need a Trac more than they need a Merrett.

Edited September 19Sep 19 by Lil_red_fire_engine

4 minutes ago, Lil_red_fire_engine said:

I suggest after watching Danger bulldoze the hawks they need a Trac more than they need a Merrett.

Honestly what they need is a Clarry. Trac this year might have gotten out of Dangers way.

Just now, Ted Lasso said:

Honestly what they need is a Clarry.

Edited September 19Sep 19 by Jaded No More

13 minutes ago, Ted Lasso said:

Honestly what they need is a Clarry. Trac this year might have gotten out of Dangers way.

Oooh.. Ooh... Someone said the quiet bit loud !!!

Time to make a move: Defeat shows Hawks exactly what they're missing - https://www.afl.com.au/news/14 224 55

Petracca mention

16 minutes ago, john delosa said:

Edited Friday at 23:135 days by Mouseymoo

Danger reminding everyone why you need a Trac-like player come finals

And Geelong showing that you can still carry poor kicks like Danger if you have the right players around them

Hopefully King can bring some of that IP with him and we allow Trac to play to his strengths in a better system

10 minutes ago, demoncat said:

Danger reminding everyone why you need a Trac-like player come finals

And Geelong showing that you can still carry poor kicks like Danger if you have the right players around them

Hopefully King can bring some of that IP with him and we allow Trac to play to his strengths in a better system

I think at this stage he's worth more to someone else, particularly given the fact he's not bought in. Would love to see what Hawthorn offer seeing as Essendon are giving to be [censored] to deal with the whole Merrett situation

47 minutes ago, demoncat said:

Danger reminding everyone why you need a Trac-like player come finals

And Geelong showing that you can still carry poor kicks like Danger if you have the right players around them

Hopefully King can bring some of that IP with him and we allow Trac to play to his strengths in a better system

Ot at worst if Trac wants to leave Sam Mitchell realises he needs a Trac more than a Merrett when September 2026 comes around.

1 hour ago, demoncat said:

Danger reminding everyone why you need a Trac-like player come finals

And Geelong showing that you can still carry poor kicks like Danger if you have the right players around them

Hopefully King can bring some of that IP with him and we allow Trac to play to his strengths in a better system

I think that too, we have a great midfield, problem is they’re all bad ball users. Imagine if we could just get them to use the ball well…

On 16/09/2025 at 16:06, BDA said:

I think we should have appointed Chat GPT as our new coach

FOX FOOTY

Adelaide is growing in confidence Christian Petracca will choose them as his preferred trade destination this off-season.

@WillFaulknerFOX reports >> bit.ly/4px8ONN

—/——-/—-/-////———-

My views:

Crows can offer NOTHING to the Demons. Nothing! Dees would need 2 x 1st round picks that are top 15. Trac is a star. A match winner. Runner up B&F. He’s the type of player that can play into his 30s and be a mid/fwd weapon. Trac should think about that choice, as my view, he would be foolish to pick them or indeed foolish to leave us.

Edited Sunday at 11:134 days by spirit of norm smith
K

7 minutes ago, spirit of norm smith said:

Crows can offer NOTHING to the Demons. Nothing! Dees would need 2 x 1st round picks that are top 15.

They already have 14, so there's one. They then have a) future first and b) LOTS of lower picks that if they're clever they can turn into something higher up. Though which clubs with higher picks would be prepared to trade out of the first round remains to be seen.

Crows pick 14 probably becomes 20 by the time of the draft.

I suspect we need another first rounder to go with that and I doubt the Crows will offer it.

Adelaide love to drag it down to the deadline and pay the bare minimum.

Not a good result for us if Tracc aims to go there.

7 minutes ago, DeeSpencer said:

Crows pick 14 probably becomes 20 by the time of the draft.

I suspect we need another first rounder to go with that and I doubt the Crows will offer it.

Adelaide love to drag it down to the deadline and pay the bare minimum.

Not a good result for us if Tracc aims to go there.

He is contracted, so we keep him unless the offer is to good to refuse..

If its not ganna make us better why would we do it?? simple

I’m hoping (fairly confident) Trac’s management don’t nominate a preferred trading partner until they understand if that partner can satisfy Melbourne. They don’t want this to play out like it did last year / they looked stupid trying to land him at Collingwood when they had absolutely nothing to give us

14 + F1

On trade Crom F1 for Flanders

Take P14 to the draft wouldn't be terrible

High first rounder + Jake Soligo.

Edited Sunday at 12:134 days by Swooper Northey

On 18/09/2025 at 22:58, kurtneverdied said:

The only way to get Walter is if GC go all in for a flag and we give someone like Fritsch as well as Trac in some sort of deal.

Flanders for Trac straight swap would be close. Flanders only turned 24 in July.

Rubbish. Petracca is a gun Flanders has done nothing. People forget we hold the cards if we don't get a great deal he stays. I'd be wanting Flanders and pick 6 minimum. Add Walter or Read and pick 13 and then we are talking. We will not give away Petracca just because he maybe wants out. He signed a contract unless it's a monster trade deal then he stays suck it up Petracca you signed the contract you only have yourself to blame.

These things are usually not straight forward and I suspect a club like Gold Coast may get involved.

Out: Petracca

In: Flanders and Pick 14

Or

Pick 6 (10-12) and 14 (20+)

Not the worst outcome.

Onus is on Adelaide to get the deal done. They'll have motivation to not drag their heals and offer unders as they'll want to secure a piece that could unlock a chance at a premiership.

2 minutes ago, The Jackson FIX said:

I’m hoping (fairly confident) Trac’s management don’t nominate a preferred trading partner until they understand if that partner can satisfy Melbourne. They don’t want this to play out like it did last year / they looked stupid trying to land him at Collingwood when they had absolutely nothing to give us

I suspect that's how most trades of contracted players go down unless the player goes scorch earth like Merrett. But it does rely on list managers sticking to their word and not getting cute.

8 minutes ago, Swooper Northey said:

Pick 14 + Jake Soligo.

Worst deal I've ever heard of.

12 minutes ago, adonski said:

14 + F1

On trade Crom F1 for Flanders

Take P14 to the draft wouldn't be terrible

It would be a terrible outcome 2 ordinary picks a champion give me a break!

Comparing Petracca to Danger, That’ insane. It’s like comparing Robbie Flower to Billy Bunter.