4 minutes ago, 48 Year Now said:

Very average stats for the position and style he plays. Take second rounder

yeah... so exactly what we got for him

I’m on Juddys side, he should be a rebounding half back and not a defender. He and Bowey would compliment each other. So question is, who do we have to play the lock down small defender role? Kolt, Woey, Viney or Salo? AMW was a lock, but we won’t see him for a while.

I see Starcevich is contemplating a move, could he be a piece of the puzzle we need.

Juddys signature is a must!!

38 minutes ago, SPC said:

I’m on Juddys side, he should be a rebounding half back and not a defender. He and Bowey would compliment each other. So question is, who do we have to play the lock down small defender role? Kolt, Woey, Viney or Salo? AMW was a lock, but we won’t see him for a while.

I see Starcevich is contemplating a move, could he be a piece of the puzzle we need.

Juddys signature is a must!!

That was suppose to happen and promisedby Goody,then injury hit but somehow Windsor started playing the running back

17 hours ago, Deeko2 said:

I'd be intrigued to know what his manager actually expects from the club if he/she is disappointed.

He has had quite a few chances and sadly for the romantics (me included) he really hasn't set the world on fire and always looks a step or two to slow in the bigtime.

He hardly sets the world on fire in the twos either averaging about 16-17 touches a game and a goal every 4 weeks. He looks nothing more than an average twos player which although admirable and better than most will achieve, is just too far away from having an impact in the ones.

If he was playing rebounding half back role and playing it well then I'd be far more interested in going harder to retain him.

Just from my own memories of late last year when he was played up the ground and a lot more midfield minutes, he just looked completely lost there.

There is nothing wrong with that and he still has a ripping 'one wood' as a high quality back pocket.

I just think we have greater needs and as he has currency, I wouldn't be against him moving if the right deal popped up.

He played 2 games there with no midfield training,2nd game on Daicos who was playing for 3 brownlow votes and Melbourne had already cashed out

1 hour ago, doomsday dee said:

That was suppose to happen and promised by Goody, then injury hit but somehow Windsor started playing the running back

Is this common knowledge that he was promised the role - been reported somewhere? Or just a bit of internet gossip from people trying to make sense/reasons of why he hasn't re-signed yet?

1 hour ago, doomsday dee said:

He played 2 games there with no midfield training,2nd game on Daicos who was playing for 3 brownlow votes and Melbourne had already cashed out

In fairness, he wasn't the first and won't be the last to cop a torching from young Daicos. But that performance from the team was shocking that night and I'd say it was by far the worst game I've seen Judd play and probably the reason why I think him playing up the ground isn't warranted.

If you're keen for midfield minutes then when given the opportunity you'd think that the player would be giving there 100% all at every contest. He was lead to 40 odd contests from Daicos and only touched the pill a few times and from what I remember, went at about 5% DE and gave away as many free kicks as he had touches.

Now one poor performance shouldn't and won't put a complete line through someone but he his holding off re-signing due to frustrations of not getting more game time up the ground, I'd ask simply ask him what his preferences are:

• Develop up the ground in the twos

• Continue being a very important role player as a lock down defender in the ones

I'm wondering if during his junior days he was playing up the ground further to an average standard which is the reason every team looked passed him during the draft.

He should be feeling incredibly lucky and thankful we have a defined role for him that he clearly excels in.

12 minutes ago, Deeko2 said:

Is this common knowledge that he was promised the role - been reported somewhere? Or just a bit of internet gossip from people trying to make sense/reasons of why he hasn't re-signed yet?

In fairness, he wasn't the first and won't be the last to cop a torching from young Daicos. But that performance from the team was shocking that night and I'd say it was by far the worst game I've seen Judd play and probably the reason why I think him playing up the ground isn't warranted.

If you're keen for midfield minutes then when given the opportunity you'd think that the player would be giving there 100% all at every contest. He was lead to 40 odd contests from Daicos and only touched the pill a few times and from what I remember, went at about 5% DE and gave away as many free kicks as he had touches.

Now one poor performance shouldn't and won't put a complete line through someone but he his holding off re-signing due to frustrations of not getting more game time up the ground, I'd ask simply ask him what his preferences are:

• Develop up the ground in the twos

• Continue being a very important role player as a lock down defender in the ones

I'm wondering if during his junior days he was playing up the ground further to an average standard which is the reason every team looked passed him during the draft.

He should be feeling incredibly lucky and thankful we have a defined role for him that he clearly excels in.

Made the Ozzie team in the U/16s as a midfielder then we all got hit by covid, apparently lived a 4 hr drive to Perth

i'm old enough to remember (and attend) the aussie rules carnival (which was held somewhat erratically)

it was marvellous for its time, but i'm not recommending a revival of its format

just reminiscing

Comeon Judd you know you want to just sign the contract young man so we can get on with things that are more important than going home. If it’s more money comeon FD pay up, you know Juddie we picked YOU time now for You to pick US.❤️💙👍😁

An important player. If we had a 2025 era game plan structures he'd be an important linebreaker off half back which is one of the key roles in 2025 era game plans.

11 minutes ago, demoniac said:

An important player. If we had a 2025 era game plan structures he'd be an important linebreaker off half back which is one of the key roles in 2025 era game plans.

Agreed. I find it surprising some have been very quick to trivialise his abilities and place in the side, seemingly in light of him going back west. He's also one of the only users of the ball that I regularly have full confidence in, something we're sorely lacking in totality.

On 09/07/2025 at 09:18, beelzebub said:

Hypothetical

You're a player in a 'foreign' state playing in a team whose prospects aren't looking too flash. You're asked to play a role you don't particularly find uber satisfying .

You're wind of interest from 'home'.

You decide after talking with your manager to halt current proceedings til season's end .

All hypothetical of course

Wouldn't be far off the mark @beelzebub

Throw in Rivers as another who doesn’t like his role.

I’ve always thought McVee most reminds me of Heath Shaw who played his whole career as a back pocket who locked down when required but also had a sweeper type role and got plenty of the footy (and used it well). You let that guy take the kickouts. Switch to them. And they still get their 20 touches without having to run like mad like a flanker should.

And if you’ve got good upfield defence and mobile talls you alternate the tricky match ups anyway.

I’ll be very annoyed if Judd leaves. A second round pick is a lottery ticket that you lose as often as you win. Sure, you can do better than Judd but odds are you’ll do worse. Plus a 3-4 year lag until the guy starts producing more often than not.

I’ll also be subjected to watching a heap more Blake Howes which might drive me insane. AMW has talent but could never make it through a preseason, was a mile off consistent afl footy in 2024 and then blew his knee to pieces, he’s a hope and a prayer not a solution.

He is a great player. We definitely do not want to lose him. The chances of getting a good player with whatever pick is not great. The last 3 to 5 drafts have seen anything past pick 10 or so being a 1 in 3 lottery at best of getting a half decent player.

Edited Thursday at 05:084 days by Wizard of Koz

2 hours ago, daisycutter said:

i'm old enough to remember (and attend) the aussie rules carnival (which was held somewhat erratically)

it was marvellous for its time, but i'm not recommending a revival of its format

just reminiscing

sorry, wrong thread. was for the thread on state of origin

Hang on. I thought the inside line was the signed and the reporting was just delayed?

I hope we are not being held ransom by him or his management.

3 hours ago, YesitwasaWin4theAges said:

Wouldn't be far off the mark @beelzebub

Throw in Rivers as another who doesn’t like his role.

I queried this earlier in this thread, where does it come out that a player doesn't like his role? I always find it interesting reading these comments and wonder if it's just internet gossip or if people have genuine intel.

Rivers has had a lot of midfield time this year. He's had some good moments there as well although I like him a lot more as a rebounding defender personally.

Does he want more midfield time or does he want to return to the back flank?

4 hours ago, doomsday dee said:

Made the Ozzie team in the U/16s as a midfielder then we all got hit by covid, apparently lived a 4 hr drive to Perth

Yes Juddy is clearly talented and I have no doubt showed some wonderful moments there. But did he peak there as a mid? By his U/18 year I'm fairly certain he was around the 12th to 15th player picked from the WAFL as a rookie. So he again, he clearly wasn't setting the world on fire higher up the ground.

3 hours ago, BLWNBA said:

Agreed. I find it surprising some have been very quick to trivialise his abilities and place in the side, seemingly in light of him going back west. He's also one of the only users of the ball that I regularly have full confidence in, something we're sorely lacking in totality.

I feel I have spoken a lot in this thread and some of my comments might come across like I'm negative towards him. I'm actually not and think he's playing the back pocket role beautifully and is easily best 22 and I definitely don't want to lose him.

I'm happy to hear the club has made its offer and sticking to it. Players have far too much pull. In saying that, kudos to Juddy by cooling his jets and backing himself in for either a longer term or more cashola.

I really hope we keep him and would only let him go if he was part of a plan to bring in another high quality player (Jacko) - not draft picks.

5 hours ago, Deeko2 said:

Is this common knowledge that he was promised the role - been reported somewhere? Or just a bit of internet gossip from people trying to make sense/reasons of why he hasn't re-signed yet?

In fairness, he wasn't the first and won't be the last to cop a torching from young Daicos. But that performance from the team was shocking that night and I'd say it was by far the worst game I've seen Judd play and probably the reason why I think him playing up the ground isn't warranted.

If you're keen for midfield minutes then when given the opportunity you'd think that the player would be giving there 100% all at every contest. He was lead to 40 odd contests from Daicos and only touched the pill a few times and from what I remember, went at about 5% DE and gave away as many free kicks as he had touches.

Now one poor performance shouldn't and won't put a complete line through someone but he his holding off re-signing due to frustrations of not getting more game time up the ground, I'd ask simply ask him what his preferences are:

• Develop up the ground in the twos

• Continue being a very important role player as a lock down defender in the ones

I'm wondering if during his junior days he was playing up the ground further to an average standard which is the reason every team looked passed him during the draft.

He should be feeling incredibly lucky and thankful we have a defined role for him that he clearly excels in.

Big difference between playing a midfield role and a Backman's role fitness wise the time against Daicos you could see that would have thought they would have worked on that pre season obviously not.

2 hours ago, GS_1905 said:

Hang on. I thought the inside line was the signed and the reporting was just delayed?

I hope we are not being held ransom by him or his management.

This.

Was said on here that announcement was meant to occur two weeks ago? Most reports state that he is not way near close to signing a new deal.

6 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

This.

Was said on here that announcement was meant to occur two weeks ago? Most reports state that he is not way near close to signing a new deal.

Nah, it’s just a media vendetta against Melbourne. Something, something Tom Morris, something, something, MFC are the victims. Everything is hunky dory.

Edited Thursday at 08:133 days by BLWNBA

1 hour ago, Deeko2 said:

I queried this earlier in this thread, where does it come out that a player doesn't like his role? I always find it interesting reading these comments and wonder if it's just internet gossip or if people have genuine intel.

Rivers has had a lot of midfield time this year. He's had some good moments there as well although I like him a lot more as a rebounding defender personally.

Does he want more midfield time or does he want to return to the back flank?

Yes Juddy is clearly talented and I have no doubt showed some wonderful moments there. But did he peak there as a mid? By his U/18 year I'm fairly certain he was around the 12th to 15th player picked from the WAFL as a rookie. So he again, he clearly wasn't setting the world on fire higher up the ground.

I feel I have spoken a lot in this thread and some of my comments might come across like I'm negative towards him. I'm actually not and think he's playing the back pocket role beautifully and is easily best 22 and I definitely don't want to lose him.

I'm happy to hear the club has made its offer and sticking to it. Players have far too much pull. In saying that, kudos to Juddy by cooling his jets and backing himself in for either a longer term or more cashola.

I really hope we keep him and would only let him go if he was part of a plan to bring in another high quality player (Jacko) - not draft picks.

Didnt play as a mid in the U/18,was a running back both east freo and state

53 minutes ago, BLWNBA said:

Nah, it’s just a media vendetta against Melbourne. Something, something Tom Morris, something, something, MFC are the victims. Everything is hunky dory.

To be fair, the two posters who said Judd has re-signed have very good track record of posting solid info and not total BS. They most definitely have a better track record than Tom Morris!

35 minutes ago, Jaded No More said:

To be fair, the two posters who said Judd has re-signed have very good track record of posting solid info and not total BS. They most definitely have a better track record than Tom Morris!

For clarity and with all sincerity, that’s not what was implied in my statement, nor were they targeted in my comment.

4 hours ago, Greg Schneider said:

It doesn't look good but devils advocate, he's been pretty poor this year and that's mainly due to injury interrupted preseason/season. Could he be banking on a big 7 weeks to finish the season to raise his stocks? Probably a long shot.

End of the day he has shown he will be a decent player but he's no gamebreaker. If he wants back to WA see what we can get and move on.

this has taken a weird turn

McVee had hope we would stump up four years which we did. Everyone was happy

Now all of a sudden he wants to delay it

Maybe the W.A. Teams have been In his ear

Maybe his real realized the direction of this football club is not a positive one

Let’s just hope the WA teams watched his performance last weekend and decided to leave him alone