Jump to content

The Josh Smillie Thread

spirit of norm smith
in Melbourne Demons

Featured Replies

Posted

Josh Smillie. Wow. Super talented youngster. At the start of 2024, he was probably pick 1 or 2 for this years draft pool alongside O’Sullivan.  
194cm midfielder.  Great skills. Excellent overhead. Strong. Can kick goals. Easily kicks 50 metres. Hits targets. Tackles.  A complete package. Wins clearances and drives forward with good metres gained.  Dominated several Coates League games this year.   Plays like Patrick Cripps.
However he had an average national championships and missed All Australian selection.
Still he’s a star and would be amazed if he slipped.  I had him at pick 5 in my phantom draft so still potentially available for the Dees. Or he could go pick 1 or 2 still. It’s an even top 5/6 in my view.  

  • Quote
    • Like 3
    • Love 1
    • Clap 2
     

    He certainly looks the goods SONS, would fill a big hole in our list if we can land him.

  • Quote
    • Like 1

    Have heard great things about him which are reinforced by the highlight package.  Yes please

  • Quote
    • Like 1
     

    The thing about Smillie is his kicking to advantage. It's very noticeable. Contrast that with our mids and half forwards, he'd fit in nicely.

    I'd like 2 or 3 picks in the top 15 this year, there's so much scope in this crop. 

    I'll trust JT though. 

  • Quote
    • Like 5
    • Clap 2
    • Author
    37 minutes ago, Adam The God said:

    The thing about Smillie is his kicking to advantage. It's very noticeable. Contrast that with our mids and half forwards, he'd fit in nicely.

    I'd like 2 or 3 picks in the top 15 this year, there's so much scope in this crop. 

    I'll trust JT though. 

    Agreed. Super talented year.   I think Tigers also see the top 30 talent in this draft and want 5-6 choices. 

  • Quote
    • Like 2

    32 minutes ago, spirit of norm smith said:

    Agreed. Super talented year.   I think Tigers also see the top 30 talent in this draft and want 5-6 choices. 

    They also need to desperately rebuild quickly before Tassie.

    We just need one or two good years to re-set our list profile.

    Edited by Adam The God

  • Quote
    • Like 3

    Looks a great talent. Not sure if I'd prefer him over Langford, but he's clearly got the attributes to succeed as an AFL player. 194cms is a big mid, Cripps size. He looks to link well and be a good kick. I didn't watch any carnival, but curious he didn't perform well or make the underage All Aus team.

    Langford on the other hand won the Larke medal as best player, made the All Aus team, and at 190cms is a big midfielder too. He appears to have good drive and skills too. We likely won't have the choose anyway and just take whoever is left at pick 5, but if we did have to choose I'd trust JT to make the right call. 

  • Quote
    • Like 4
     

    Great size, absolutely ragdolls opponents in juniors which will still happen a bit at the next level at his size.

    My questions are around whether he has the work rate and natural inside midfield ability to go with his size. There’s absolutely no reason to have any doubts on the ability of someone like him to be a great AFL inside midfielder, yet somehow I still have some. 

    Has some unique attributes but is definitely not a finished product.

    Edited by Axis of Bob

  • Quote
    • Like 5

    If I was a likely no. 1 pick, I wld deliberately drop my form as a way of sliding down the draft order and getting picked up by a better club. 

  • Quote
    • Like 1

    1 hour ago, seventyfour said:

    Yes. I love tall midfielders. Cripps, Bont, Tom Greene. 

    Yep a big bodied beast and he is someone we can market the new era of the club around along with Kolt, Windsor, Judd etc. 

     

  • Quote
    • Like 2
    23 hours ago, adonski said:

    Are we absolutely convinced he isn't Will Setterfield

    Reminds me more of Ollie Wines 

  • Quote
    3 minutes ago, DeeSpencer said:

    Reminds me more of Ollie Wines 

    Thats Just as bad!

  • Quote
    7 minutes ago, adonski said:

    Thats Just as bad!

    That’s a whole lot better than Setterfield but not a top 5 pick! 

  • Quote

    Please get him on board

     

  • Quote
    On 29/08/2024 at 11:40, Axis of Bob said:

    Great size, absolutely ragdolls opponents in juniors which will still happen a bit at the next level at his size.

    My questions are around whether he has the work rate and natural inside midfield ability to go with his size. There’s absolutely no reason to have any doubts on the ability of someone like him to be a great AFL inside midfielder, yet somehow I still have some. 

    Has some unique attributes but is definitely not a finished product.

    Work rate and running capacity have been the knocks so far.

  • Quote
    • Like 2
    57 minutes ago, ChaserJ said:

    Work rate and running capacity have been the knocks so far.

    Definitely, although this is not necessarily an unusual thing for monster mids. I'm also not convinced he's a natural inside midfielder in the contest at the moment, as he is quite poor at winning the ball in stoppages unless the ball is hit straight at him and he monsters his opponent. I also don't think he has great composure in the contest either. 

    But he's a 6'4-6'5 monster, with a unique trait that will definitely translate across to AFL level and good coaching could have him develop into a very good player. I just have concerns int he back of my head that he's actually not as good a footballer as people think. 

    But I'm just a YouTube judge, so I am likely wrong with some or all of this.

  • Quote
    • Like 5
    • Thanks 1

    This is a good little analysis of the effectiveness big bodied mids using Smillie as primary example and how he could develop. He could be the Patrick Cripps of this draft with so many similarities. 

     

  • Quote

    Smillie looks a bit slow and looks a reasonable but not outstanding kick.

    Cripps and Tom Green are similar players but they obviously have elite reflexes and decision making skills. It is hard to determine if he as at their level in terms of ball winning and disposal in tight.

  • Quote

    1 hour ago, Axis of Bob said:

    Definitely, although this is not necessarily an unusual thing for monster mids. I'm also not convinced he's a natural inside midfielder in the contest at the moment, as he is quite poor at winning the ball in stoppages unless the ball is hit straight at him and he monsters his opponent. I also don't think he has great composure in the contest either. 

    But he's a 6'4-6'5 monster, with a unique trait that will definitely translate across to AFL level and good coaching could have him develop into a very good player. I just have concerns int he back of my head that he's actually not as good a footballer as people think. 

    But I'm just a YouTube judge, so I am likely wrong with some or all of this.

    Limited viewing but I feel the same. Langford on the other hand at 190cm seems a natural big bodied ball winning mid who has foot skills to go with the clearance work. He hits the scoreboard too so looks a genuine mid-forward type. 

    Edited by Lord Travis

  • Quote
    54 minutes ago, Fat Tony said:

    Smillie looks a bit slow and looks a reasonable but not outstanding kick.

    Cripps and Tom Green are similar players but they obviously have elite reflexes and decision making skills. It is hard to determine if he as at their level in terms of ball winning and disposal in tight.

    I would say not quick (but wouldn't say slow). The one thing I did really like is the weighting of his kicks (something we lack).In saying that Jagga, Draper, Langford, Lalor preferred by me )and possibly Reid).

  • Quote
    • Like 2
    11 minutes ago, Lil_red_fire_engine said:

    I would say not quick (but wouldn't say slow). The one thing I did really like is the weighting of his kicks (something we lack).In saying that Jagga, Draper, Langford, Lalor preferred by me )and possibly Reid).

    He would be slow at AFL level.

  • Quote
    •  

    Definitely prefer Langford or Lalor.

  • Quote
    • Like 2
    • Love 1
    On 29/08/2024 at 12:05, Winter Dan said:

    If I was a likely no. 1 pick, I wld deliberately drop my form as a way of sliding down the draft order and getting picked up by a better club. 

    Danger! Danger! You'll start another argument about in-season loading!

    But it is an interesting conundrum. If you are sure you're going to get drafted, there would be no reason except ego to strive to be at the really pointy end of the draft so you might well, you know, spend more time on your schooling or play out of position a bit to develop your game. Those who remember the years where osteitis pubis ruined the start of several careers would have a lot of sympathy for taking it easy for spells during the season. There might even be a bit of altruism involved if you want to give a less prominent teammate a run in your usual position.

  • Quote

    • Join the conversation

    You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

    Guest
    Unfortunately, your content contains terms that we do not allow. Please edit your content to remove the highlighted words below.
    Reply to this topic...
    Go to topic listing

    Featured Content

    • NON-MFC: Round 12

      Round 12 kicks off with the Brisbane hosting Essendon at the Gabba as the Lions aim to solidify their top-two position against an injury-hit Bombers side seeking to maintain momentum after a win over Richmond. On Friday night it's a blockbuster at the G as the Magpies look to extend their top of the table winning streak while the Hawks strive to bounce back from a couple of recent defeats and stay in contention for the Top 4. On Saturday the Suns, buoyed by 3 wins on the trot, face the Dockers in a clash crucial for both teams' aspirations this season. The Suns want to solidify their Top 4 standing whilst the Dockers will be desperate to break into the 8.

      • 118 replies
      Demonland

    • PREVIEW: St. Kilda

      The media has performed a complete reversal in its coverage of the Melbourne Football Club over the past month and a half. Having endured intense criticism from all quarters in the press, which continually identified new avenues for scrutiny of every aspect, both on and off the field, and prematurely speculated about the departures of coaches, players, officials, and various employees from a club that lost its first five matches and appeared out of finals contention, the narrative has suddenly shifted to one of unbridled optimism.  The Demons have won five of their last six matches, positioning themselves just one game (and a considerable amount of percentage) outside the top eight at the halfway mark of the season. They still trail the primary contenders and remain far from assured of a finals berth.

        • Clap
        • Thanks
        • Like
      • 12 replies
      Demonland

    • REPORT: Sydney

      A few weeks ago, I visited a fellow Melbourne Football Club supporter in hospital, and our conversation inevitably shifted from his health diagnosis to the well-being of our football team. Like him, Melbourne had faced challenges in recent months, but an intervention - in his case, surgery, and in the team's case, a change in game style - had brought about much improvement.  The team's professionals had altered its game style from a pedestrian and slow-moving approach, which yielded an average of merely 60 points for five winless games, to a faster and more direct style. This shift led to three consecutive wins and a strong competitive effort in the fourth game, albeit with a tired finish against Hawthorn, a strong premiership contender.  As we discussed our team's recent health improvement, I shared my observations on the changes within the team, including the refreshed style, the introduction of new young talent, such as rising stars Caleb Windsor, Harvey Langford, and Xavier Lindsay, and the rebranding of Kozzy Pickett from a small forward to a midfield machine who can still get among the goals. I also highlighted the dominance of captain Max Gawn in the ruck and the resurgence in form in a big way of midfield superstars Christian Petracca and Clayton Oliver. 

        • Clap
        • Love
        • Thanks
        • Like
      • 9 replies
      Demonland

    • PODCAST: Sydney

      The Demonland Podcast will air LIVE on Monday, 26th May @ 8:00pm. Join Binman, George & I as we analyse a crushing victory by the Demons over the Swans at the G. Your questions and comments are a huge part of our podcast so please post anything you want to ask or say below and we'll give you a shout out on the show.

        • Clap
        • Love
        • Thanks
        • Like
      • 51 replies
      Demonland

    • POSTGAME: Sydney

      The Demons controlled the contest from the outset, though inaccurate kicking kept the Swans in the game until half time. But after the break, Melbourne put on the jets and blew Sydney away and the demolition job was complete.

        • Clap
        • Love
        • Like
      • 428 replies
      Demonland

    • VOTES: Sydney

      Max Gawn still has an almost unassailable lead in the Demonland Player of the Year award. Jake Bowey, Christian Petracca, Harvey Langford, Kade Chandler & Ed Langdon round out the Top 5. Your votes please. 6, 5, 4, 3, 2 & 1.

        • Thanks
      • 46 replies
      Demonland
    View All