People have officially gone mad

[BigBadBustling 336]

10 hours ago, Demonstone said:

PETA has a history of organising stunts like this to get publicity.  They always make outrageous, unrealistic claims/demands that inevitably evoke a knee-jerk reaction from the gullible and perpetually offended.  

Don't take it seriously, just have a chuckle then ignore it and the whole thing will disappear very quickly.

That's an entire political spectrum Stoney!

[Freddy Fuschia 730]

As a dog lover, I am deeply offended by the suggestion that they change the name to the “Mutts” which is derogatory to all canines. 

If they must change the name then why not the more elegant “Dachshunds”?

[Dee Dee 1,105]

4 minutes ago, Freddy Fuschia said:

As a dog lover, I am deeply offended by the suggestion that they change the name to the “Mutts” which is derogatory to all canines. 

If they must change the name then why not the more elegant “Dachshunds”?

Or how about Footscray ! That has a nice traditional ring to it!

[picket fence 16,982]

13 hours ago, chook fowler said:

Unspeakably stupid wokeness. Time to say enough is enough. How about spending time and energy on something that really matters. 

Can we change this heading to "THE WORLD HAS GONE WOKE"?

[Standard Deviation 36]

12 hours ago, Beetle said:

I’ve got a bulldog and he’s as fit as a fiddle. Walks up to 5km without any issue and high intensity exercise not a problem. 

Their origins date back to the year 1210. 

I understand where you are coming from though, French Bulldogs tend to struggle more-so than British or Australian. 

PETA can get [censored] pushing this barrow. 

This is getting off topic a bit but have you got evidence for that claim of 1210, the word bulldog only shows up in the English language in the 17th century.

The thing is though, that's all moot.  The modern British Bulldog isn't even the same dog that was running round in the early 19th century, they were bred from the Old English Bulldog specifically as a companion dog (as opposed to a working dog).

The famous bulldog ferocity which has led teams like Footscray to adopt them as a mascot is actually not a trait of the modern bulldog, it's a reputation from its predecessor.

As with many non-working dogs the breeders have got over-obsessed with certain traits, which has led to a stack of health problems in the breed - you sound like you got one of the good ones. 

This is a stunt by PETA, and I don't think anyone seriously thinks Footscray should rebrand.  But I like dogs and seeing them having to live with horrible health issues because they look "cute" on an instagram/tiktok/whatever annoys me.

[sue 9,096]

14 hours ago, DemonWheels said:

Definitely agree this is over-the-top.

BUT, in saying that, my very limited experiences with true bulldogs is that they really do struggle to breathe and any sort of over stimulation and exercise seems like a real struggle for them. Not something I’ve thought about for a long time and I’m not a campaigner by any sense, just an opinion formed from someone who loves dogs.

An aquaintance of mine paid for an expensive opertation on his variety of bulldog to open up its breathing passages.  Their average life expectancy is about 15% of my aging terrier (no, not the aquaintance, the bulldog).

[old55 23,309]

31 minutes ago, Standard Deviation said:

This is getting off topic a bit but have you got evidence for that claim of 1210, the word bulldog only shows up in the English language in the 17th century.

The thing is though, that's all moot.  The modern British Bulldog isn't even the same dog that was running round in the early 19th century, they were bred from the Old English Bulldog specifically as a companion dog (as opposed to a working dog).

The famous bulldog ferocity which has led teams like Footscray to adopt them as a mascot is actually not a trait of the modern bulldog, it's a reputation from its predecessor.

As with many non-working dogs the breeders have got over-obsessed with certain traits, which has led to a stack of health problems in the breed - you sound like you got one of the good ones. 

This is a stunt by PETA, and I don't think anyone seriously thinks Footscray should rebrand.  But I like dogs and seeing them having to live with horrible health issues because they look "cute" on an instagram/tiktok/whatever annoys me.

It's a real animal cruelty problem that as @Demonstone says PETA have chosen a high profile target to illustrate.

The popularity of the French Bulldog along with Bulldogs and Pugs has really increased the incidence of pets with beathing problems and associated high vet bills.

[sue 9,096]

15 hours ago, chook fowler said:

Unspeakably stupid wokeness. Time to say enough is enough. How about spending time and energy on something that really matters. 

Geez, you fall for a publicity stunt easily.   

[Beetle 4,577]

1 hour ago, Standard Deviation said:

This is getting off topic a bit but have you got evidence for that claim of 1210, the word bulldog only shows up in the English language in the 17th century.

The thing is though, that's all moot.  The modern British Bulldog isn't even the same dog that was running round in the early 19th century, they were bred from the Old English Bulldog specifically as a companion dog (as opposed to a working dog).

The famous bulldog ferocity which has led teams like Footscray to adopt them as a mascot is actually not a trait of the modern bulldog, it's a reputation from its predecessor.

As with many non-working dogs the breeders have got over-obsessed with certain traits, which has led to a stack of health problems in the breed - you sound like you got one of the good ones. 

This is a stunt by PETA, and I don't think anyone seriously thinks Footscray should rebrand.  But I like dogs and seeing them having to live with horrible health issues because they look "cute" on an instagram/tiktok/whatever annoys me.

“In the 1938 Blue Book of Bulldogs, William Lawlor wrote that the Bulldog can be traced to 1210, the year of the first official bullbaiting in England. He added that the Bulldog “is generally believed to have come down from the same common stock” developed for that sport. That meant these dogs had to be tough enough to face down a mighty bovine.”

No argument from me regarding selfish, obsessive breeding traits to the detriment to the health of a dog either SD. As stated in my original post this is particularly prevalent with French Bulldogs and Pugs of which many suffer from Brachycephalic Airway Obstruction Syndrome which is horrible.

The sole reason for the development of the Australian Bulldog breed was to help alleviate the health issues of British Bulldogs particularly for warmer climates. The Aussie Bulldog is a taller, leaner dog with a longer ‘snout’ while still maintaining the “look” and beautiful temperament of the Bulldog. This can only be a good thing for the development of the breed, especially in this country.

Like you I’m a dog lover and in particular Bulldog lover, so long may the breed continue, if bred responsibly.

 

[djr 1,430]

3 hours ago, picket fence said:

Can we change this heading to "THE WORLD HAS GONE WOKE"?

Do you actually know what the word means? Educate yourself by looking it up.

[Standard Deviation 36]

18 minutes ago, Beetle said:

“In the 1938 Blue Book of Bulldogs, William Lawlor wrote that the Bulldog can be traced to 1210, the year of the first official bullbaiting in England. He added that the Bulldog “is generally believed to have come down from the same common stock” developed for that sport. That meant these dogs had to be tough enough to face down a mighty bovine.”

No argument from me regarding selfish, obsessive breeding traits to the detriment to the health of a dog either SD. As stated in my original post this is particularly prevalent with French Bulldogs and Pugs of which many suffer from Brachycephalic Airway Obstruction Syndrome which is horrible.

The sole reason for the development of the Australian Bulldog breed was to help alleviate the health issues of British Bulldogs particularly for warmer climates. The Aussie Bulldog is a taller, leaner dog with a longer ‘snout’ while still maintaining the “look” and beautiful temperament of the Bulldog. This can only be a good thing for the development of the breed, especially in this country.

Like you I’m a dog lover and in particular Bulldog lover, so long may the breed continue, if bred responsibly.

 

Thanks, learnt something new there.

I wasn't aware of Australian Bulldogs, they sound a touch closer to the Old English form which, from the photos I've seen was taller, leaner and with a longer snout. 

It's really good to see developments like this addressing health issues, ideally it'd be the norm for all breeds - while bulldogs and pugs tend to attract the most attention, there's plenty of other breeds with genetic issues (German Shepherds and hind leg issues....).

 

 

[Beetle 4,577]

4 minutes ago, Standard Deviation said:

Thanks, learnt something new there.

I wasn't aware of Australian Bulldogs, they sound a touch closer to the Old English form which, from the photos I've seen was taller, leaner and with a longer snout. 

It's really good to see developments like this addressing health issues, ideally it'd be the norm for all breeds - while bulldogs and pugs tend to attract the most attention, there's plenty of other breeds with genetic issues (German Shepherds and hind leg issues....).

 

 

I’ve owned many Boxers before Bulldogs and they are a prime example of a breed with their share of genetic problems. (Yes i’m a sucker for an under bite). 

Unfortunately in most cases Bitsas > Pure bred dogs. Can’t go wrong with a mongrel. 

[I'va Worn Smith 971]

17 hours ago, chook fowler said:

Unspeakably stupid wokeness. Time to say enough is enough. How about spending time and energy on something that really matters. 

What does that mean? 

[Fritta and Turner 4,286]

17 hours ago, Jibroni said:

I imagine Cats would be offended being associated with a bogan club.

You can say that again.

[BDA 22,689]

the only people that annoy me more than wokesters are anti-wokesters. both are sanctimonious and humourless 

[daisycutter 29,596]

3 hours ago, djr said:

Do you actually know what the word means? Educate yourself by looking it up.

if it's like other derogatory words like misogyny, racist, genocidal, colonialist, sexist, etc, then it will have a vast range of differing meanings nowadays (depending on one's ideology) compared to the original meaning.

you do know it is not a "real" word (unless it has been added recently to the dictionaries)

anyway, i think i knew perfectly well what he meant 😂

[Abyssal 465]

1 hour ago, daisycutter said:

if it's like other derogatory words like misogyny, racist, genocidal, colonialist, sexist, etc, then it will have a vast range of differing meanings nowadays (depending on one's ideology) compared to the original meaning.

you do know it is not a "real" word (unless it has been added recently to the dictionaries)

anyway, i think i knew perfectly well what he meant 😂

For those who don’t like the word ‘Woke’.

What about NAW

New Age Wowser

Seems apt as they enjoy to “gnaw ‘’ away at the foundations of things that their ideology doesn’t agree with.

[old55 23,309]

22 hours ago, chook fowler said:

Unspeakably stupid wokeness. Time to say enough is enough. How about spending time and energy on something that really matters. 

Nope, "woke" would be claiming that Bulldogs warrant respect for their attributes and their veterinary expenses should be covered by the NDIS. The PETA position is "anti-woke" if anything.

[Ethan Tremblay 30,798]

22 hours ago, Demonstone said:

I think it's less to do with "woke" (whatever that really means) and more about attracting attention and publicity - and it seems like they've already succeeded with that objective.

I’m woke as. I take every opportunity to resist the plague of cultural appropriation. I believe racial boundaries must be strictly policed. Unlike gender, which is totally fluid.

[Ethan Tremblay 30,798]

My mum’s not woke at all. Like, I was breastfed for the first six months of my life. Did my mother not realise that I was a vegan? Did she even care? Either way, it was abuse.

[daisycutter 29,596]

1 minute ago, Ethan Tremblay said:

My mum’s not woke at all. Like, I was breastfed for the first six months of my life. Did my mother not realise that I was a vegan? Did she even care? Either way, it was abuse.

what did you expect from a binary, white, genocidal colonial ?

[BDA 22,689]

7 minutes ago, Ethan Tremblay said:

I was breastfed for the first six months of my life

it's chestfed you bigot

[Demonstone 22,181]

32 minutes ago, Ethan Tremblay said:

My mum’s not woke at all. Like, I was breastfed for the first six months of my life. Did my mother not realise that I was a vegan? Did she even care? Either way, it was abuse.

You reckon you had it tough?  I was raised by my father as Mum left home before I was even born.

[praha 11,226]

Honestly if I were the Dogs I'd be looking to go back to Footscray as a name. It's their spiritual home and Footscray is a much more lively and respectful suburb these days. It's considered home of the "west". I reckon more people would get around them. Especially the growing expat/student and migrant population in the area.

[picket fence 16,982]

9 hours ago, djr said:

Do you actually know what the word means? Educate yourself by looking it up.

I KNOW what it means but plenty out there just use it as an excuse!

Appeasement by giving the great unwashed and minority a bloody minded voice.... Largely, AND many views people have are IN NODDY land. I'm not talking disadvantaged and down and outers, I'm talikng NUFFIES who will stop Melbourne dead in the street with Bulltish idealogical rubbish., hell bent on causing MAYHEM!! I hope I have educated you further into the intrIcasies of political scaremongering and  rabid, rubbish politics for no good reason other than.... I have an axe.. any axe to grind!

Edited September 27 by picket fence