4 minutes ago, BoBo said:

I dunno man, this space feels like a real community and I like that these guys put in so much effort for no pay to reinforce that feeling. This isn’t fox footy, it’s Demonland. 
 

There’s enough corporate feeling podcasts out there, I personally like that I feel like I’m listening to people that I engage with on this platform. 
 

I’m sure the guys wouldn’t mind constructive feedback, but maybe like the OP, send them a private message. Could feel like a kick in the teeth airing this on public forum that they didn’t ask for feedback on… as again, they do it for free. 

Fair enough mate and can see your point of view with all those points.

Certainly wasn’t meant to be an attack on anyone and hope it wasn’t taken that way. I’m a lover not a fighter!

32 minutes ago, Dee Boys said:

Oh absolutely - by all means include the questions, they’re often great.

But if it’s just someone going “Hi Andy, love the podcast, I reckon binman is the best thing since sliced bread and my favourite ever player was Rod Grinter. Go Dees etc etc”, that sort of stuff to me is a waste of time and I wonder what the benefit is. That’s just a review and feedback for you as a host, not sure why anybody else would be interested.

But it’s your podcast, and your prerogative to run it as you please!
 

 

DB - as has been pointed out, play those bits at 2x speed or jump forward 15 or 30 seconds. 

27 minutes ago, BoBo said:

I personally would prefer if the whole podcast was sung as a musical to the tune of Bohemian Rhapsody. 

Surely the Grand Old Flag would be a more appropriate tune. Though the Bohemian start above was pretty promising. 

1 hour ago, Skuit said:

 

It's likely WCW will end up with more than one arm tied behind her back if she dares visit The Manor. Think below.

 

Both arms tied behind my back AND blindfolded… I’d still take down those two sad-sacks without even raising a sweat.

👊🏼

Note ⬆️ there’s no spaces between the periods in my ellipsis, precisely how it should be. 😉 

Edited April 9, 20241 yr by WalkingCivilWar

2 hours ago, Binmans PA said:

Uber creepy, Bitters.

In BBO’s world ‘creepy’ and ‘romantic’ are interchangeable 🙃

@DeeBloodhas the opportunity to do the funniest thing ever and leave a 5 star review, but in the review complain about @binman's ums so that @Demonlandneeds to read it out on the pod.

6 hours ago, Dee Boys said:

With all due respect to the contributors, there’s absolutely zero doubt that the podcast would be twice as good if it were half as long.

@Dee Boys I listen on 1.5 or double speed and it sounds fine.

I much prefer the depth to other pods that are very superficial but the time can be hard to squeeze in.

 

18 minutes ago, deanox said:

@DeeBloodhas the opportunity to do the funniest thing ever and leave a 5 star review, but in the review complain about @binman's ums so that @Demonlandneeds to read it out on the pod.

Spoiler Alert. I’ll be reading his post out on the pod anyway. 

7 hours ago, WalkingCivilWar said:

Both arms tied behind my back AND blindfolded… I’d still take down those two sad-sacks without even raising a sweat.

👊🏼

Note ⬆️ there’s no spaces between the periods in my ellipsis, precisely how it should be. 😉 

Crickey, this thread has become a little more than UM Rated

It’s free, with no ads, is utterly comprehensive, really good-hearted, long enough for a listen on a big drive, long enough to be broken into daily commute or brekky chunks, calls out Demonland community members (which is great for those of us who enjoy the personalised,  ‘community’ aspect of Demonland), takes on callers (non-judgementally), and sometimes provides great interviews. Um, really the podcast is just critic-proof. 

16 hours ago, Dee Boys said:

With all due respect to the contributors, there’s absolutely zero doubt that the podcast would be twice as good if it were half as long.

I like it in its current form and length. Fits very nicely with the amount of driving I have to do on a Tuesday. You can always play it at 2x if that suits you better. 

If the feedback was actually intended to be positive, thats fine - but did it need its own post? A comment on the pod post or a DM would suffice. 

To echo everyone here, the pod is great. Thanks to those who take the time out of their day to create awesome content for us for free. 

54 minutes ago, Smokey said:

If the feedback was actually intended to be positive, thats fine - but did it need its own post? A comment on the pod post or a DM would suffice. 

To echo everyone here, the pod is great. Thanks to those who take the time out of their day to create awesome content for us for free. 

I think he's definitely Dermot 

19 hours ago, Ethan Tremblay said:

I’d much prefer if it was less personable and was narrated more like the Casefile True Crime podcast. 

i'm thinking more john doremus of "the passing parade" format ... lol

On 09/04/2024 at 02:42, DeeBlood said:

Love the idea of the podcast but guys, you've got to improve your public speaking... too many Ums...especially Binman

Just listen to the Adelaide podcast and BInman's stats Its ridiculous....Sorry I had to turn off just couldnt stomach the Ums

I'll try again next week and see if youve fixed it

Cheers 

What a miserable [censored] you are.

lol at the censor filter that made my post seem more aggressive than it was intended but considering the mean spirit of the OP which could have been a PM or here's a thought just keep your [censored] opinions to yourself.

Edited April 10, 20241 yr by Redjacket

23 hours ago, Bitter but optimistic said:

There is always a "spare room" at The Manor WCW.

( Imagine a lustful font for this post )

 

 

23 hours ago, WalkingCivilWar said:

I’m imagining a bucket for this post

 

A bucket of blue paint WC?

Changing it from red to blue would surely be a huge Manor 'faux pas'. 

Think again sister!

On 09/04/2024 at 16:44, Dee Boys said:

With all due respect to the contributors, there’s absolutely zero doubt that the podcast would be twice as good if it were half as long.

Absolutely disagree. Perhaps millenials and gen z need all their info in short sharp tik toks.

I really like the long form conversations and detailed analysis with the use of stats.

I also love the questions and comments from Demonlanders which provide other viewpoints from the audience and Demonlanders.

I have zero issues with the length and you can fast forward bits if your attention span can't handle it.

The guys put in a lot of work and there is no issues from me in thanking people that take the time to post a review.

@Demonland @george_on_the_outer & @binman don't listen to a couple of sour pusses. I love all the content and the length of the show is fantastic. I consume the show in bits and pieces if I have to to make it last. I crave Dees content and you guys provide it in spades.

Thank you ums and all.

12 minutes ago, Demon Dynasty said:

 

A bucket of blue paint WC?

Changing it from red to blue would surely be a huge Manor 'faux pas'. 

Think again sister!

Thanks DD, but I actually meant a spew bucket. 

22 hours ago, Dee Boys said:

It’s not so much that I’ve got a short attention span, just that I’ve got a young family, have other podcasts I try to also fit in during the week, and consequently barely ever have a free 2.5 hours for it. It wasn’t meant as an insult and glad @binman didn’t take it as such.

For those who are retired or with a bit more time on their hands, I’m sure it’s less of an issue.

The Pod can go for as long as the boys  like as far as i'm concerned.

As long as it finishes by my usual bed time and not after!

I'm even happy to send a coded message in the chat when i'm nodding off so the three amigos know when to wind things up... 

Something really out of left field that only George, Andy or Bin would recognise.

How's about some sort of subtle filler that no one will notice like say "Um" ?

21 hours ago, Dee Boys said:

Just say “thanks for your reviews and feedback”!

Imagine if for instance the Fox footy podcast or the deebrief spent half their shows detailing every positive review they received rather than talking about actual footy, how bored you’d get of them.

For me, I listen to a podcast cos I’m interested in the subject matter and I’d assume that would be the same for most people? Not sure I’m saying anything earth shattering. And if you disagree that’s fine too, I’m not trying to have a blue with anyone!

I don't think the fox footy podcast would get any positive reviews  David Zita groaning at Max Laughton's attempts at humour 10 times a pod. They really should put on two people that don't hate each other. I'd maybe give it another go! Strange one to bring up.

As for the Debrief Podcast: Go Dees! It takes all different types of podcasts for all types of fans in the demonverse and I listen to em all! BUT they are better served spending what I assume is an expensive hourly rate in their rented studio with a producer, discussing the footy rather than the footy AND reviews and guest questions like the DL Pod. Let's let them all be unique in their own ways.

 

Edited April 10, 20241 yr by John Demonic

On 09/04/2024 at 10:40, picket fence said:

Look u all know you want it!!! A hard hitting no holds barred podcast featuring the one and only "PICKET FENCE".. There wont be any ums, ars, pauses or any other nuances, just one hard hitting commentary, that speaks for the voice of Demonland!!! C Mon mods u know u want it!!!😁😎

 

On 09/04/2024 at 16:21, picket fence said:

Hey WCW I have a terrific idea for a podcast panel staring yours truly, your good self and Uncle Bitter! 

We could be the modern day equivalent of the 3 wise persons AKA 

FENCE, UNCLE AND WCW!in a podcast!!! WHAT A HOOT!😁

 

On 09/04/2024 at 17:06, WalkingCivilWar said:

Would we have to be in the same room?

So that's a yes from you WC!

DEMON TEAMS... with Bitters, Civil & Picket Fence!

Producer - Mr Leg on the 7 second delay "mute" button (more for the panel than live callers!) 

It's a yes from me!

Edited April 10, 20241 yr by Demon Dynasty

On 09/04/2024 at 16:21, picket fence said:

Hey WCW I have a terrific idea for a podcast panel staring yours truly, your good self and Uncle Bitter! 

We could be the modern day equivalent of the 3 wise persons AKA 

FENCE, UNCLE AND WCW!in a podcast!!! WHAT A HOOT!😁

This would be a pure kook cast.