Welcome to Demonland: Shane McAdam

[Demonland 71,275]

 

[Jaded No More 68,855]

Adelaide pulling a Dodoro. How embarrassing. 

[Deebauched 1,220]

I dont get it with McAdam. He's been playing for a while and hasnt set the house on fire not to mention injury issues. 

Is our cupboard that bare. I dont think so. If we have better luck in 24 he will struggle to get a game.

Fwds... Petty Jvr Fritsch Pickett Anb Smith and possibly Melksham and a fit BBB with backups Chandler Sparrow and Spargo.

Just another depth player like Dunstan.

[Diamond_Jim 12,527]

Are we being held over for the Wednesday night special.

If so it underscores what a low interest trade period this has been

[mo64 5,853]

49 minutes ago, Deebauched said:

I dont get it with McAdam. He's been playing for a while and hasnt set the house on fire not to mention injury issues. 

Is our cupboard that bare. I dont think so. If we have better luck in 24 he will struggle to get a game.

Fwds... Petty Jvr Fritsch Pickett Anb Smith and possibly Melksham and a fit BBB with backups Chandler Sparrow and Spargo.

Just another depth player like Dunstan.

As a forward, he's well ahead of ANB, Sparrow, Spargo, Chandler, and Smith. 

Mcadam has X factor that our forward line needs. 

[Bates Mate 4,467]

Collingwood just got Schulze for a second round + future second.

Absolute steal IMHO. By that yardstick McAdam for second round pick is more than fair

[Jaded No More 68,855]

Just now, Bates Mate said:

Collingwood just got Schulze for a second round + future second.

Absolute steal IMHO. By that yardstick McAdam for second round pick is more than fair

That really is a steal. [censored] Collingwood

[Nascent 9,093]

Second and future first for Schultz. Unless trade tracker is wrong again.

[DistrACTION Jackson 8,552]

3 minutes ago, Bates Mate said:

Collingwood just got Schulze for a second round + future second.

Absolute steal IMHO. By that yardstick McAdam for second round pick is more than fair

It was a future first... which is actually a fair amount to give up 

[Bates Mate 4,467]

9 minutes ago, DistrACTION Jackson said:

It was a future first... which is actually a fair amount to give up 

My bad, one of the feeds on twitter had it as 2 2nd roundres.

pick 34 + future first is quite high a price but I rate him and wouldn't be upset if we paid that. Mcadam still only worth 2nd rounder

[IRW 1,386]

45 minutes ago, mo64 said:

As a forward, he's well ahead of ANB, Sparrow, Spargo, Chandler, and Smith. 

Mcadam has X factor that our forward line needs. 

Neither Petty ( despite what Tim Lamb said) or Melksham are likely  to be playing before the King's Birthday which means McAdams " depth" may be useful. 

Of course BBB and TMac may be cherry ripe and training the house diwn

[old55 23,359]

15 minutes ago, IRW said:

Neither Petty ( despite what Tim Lamb said) or Melksham are likely  to be playing before the King's Birthday which means McAdams " depth" may be useful. 

Of course BBB and TMac may be cherry ripe and training the house diwn

What do you base your Petty return prediction on?

[SthSea22 612]

1 hour ago, Deebauched said:

I dont get it with McAdam. He's been playing for a while and hasnt set the house on fire not to mention injury issues. 

Is our cupboard that bare. I dont think so. If we have better luck in 24 he will struggle to get a game.

Fwds... Petty Jvr Fritsch Pickett Anb Smith and possibly Melksham and a fit BBB with backups Chandler Sparrow and Spargo.

Just another depth player like Dunstan.

 

He is a walk up starter in our 23

 

Go back and watch what he did to us this year

[whatwhat say what 22,668]

21 minutes ago, IRW said:

Neither Petty ( despite what Tim Lamb said) or Melksham are likely  to be playing before the King's Birthday which means McAdams " depth" may be useful. 

Of course BBB and TMac may be cherry ripe and training the house diwn

curious to know why you think petty will be absent for that length of time

[deejammin' 2,370]

A question about McAdam is if he comes how do we clear list spots to use our draft picks? 

We currently have two senior list spots and two A Rookie spots (according to the excellent work of the list thread). 

If we bring in McAdam we only have one senior list spot left. And that’s if we move Melksham to the rookie list to fill one of the two A rookie spots (if that’s even allowed?). 

Assuming we are taking at least one, maybe two or three draft picks who are we dropping from the list?

[old55 23,359]

8 minutes ago, deejammin' said:

A question about McAdam is if he comes how do we clear list spots to use our draft picks? 

We currently have two senior list spots and two A Rookie spots (according to the excellent work of the list thread). 

If we bring in McAdam we only have one senior list spot left. And that’s if we move Melksham to the rookie list to fill one of the two A rookie spots (if that’s even allowed?). 

Assuming we are taking at least one, maybe two or three draft picks who are we dropping from the list?

We currently have Harmes, Grundy, Hibberd, Jordon and Dunstan off the primary list and so far we have Fullarton on and a promise to upgrade D.Turner.  We currently have 3 primary list spots available.

I predict we move Melksham to the Rookie list to make 4 spots, add McAdam, 2 Draft picks and match a bid on K.Brown.

Edited October 16, 2023 by old55

[deelusions from afar 1,776]

26 minutes ago, SthSea22 said:

 

He is a walk up starter in our 23

 

Go back and watch what he did to us this year

Yes - was chatting with an Adelaide supporting mate over the weekend.  He said McAdam is definitely a best 22 player for them but said he didn't play a lot of games due to injury and suspension.

Yes he's 28 (and I'm not saying I don't think our offer is reasonable) - but he's a bit better than some on here are giving him credit for.

[Redleg 40,815]

4 minutes ago, deelusions from afar said:

Yes - was chatting with an Adelaide supporting mate over the weekend.  He said McAdam is definitely a best 22 player for them but said he didn't play a lot of games due to injury and suspension.

Yes he's 28 (and I'm not saying I don't think our offer is reasonable) - but he's a bit better than some on here are giving him credit for.

Will be 29 next May and only played 50 games.

[Redleg 40,815]

Liam Henry just traded to Saints for a F2 and swap of F4's.

He is a more valuable and much younger player than McAdam.

We have offered our F2 for McAdam.

Don't budge Dees, on that Henry trade alone we are overpaying.

[Gawndy the Great 9,011]

7 minutes ago, Redleg said:

Liam Henry just traded to Saints for a F2 and swap of F4's.

He is a more valuable and much younger player than McAdam.

We have offered our F2 for McAdam.

Don't budge Dees, on that Henry trade alone we are overpaying.

I’m really lost why we didn’t chase him or why he didn’t nominate. I get that he has weaknesses but he’d only be chasing one of Hunter or Langdons spots. Or play him as a running HB. 

[IRW 1,386]

1 hour ago, old55 said:

What do you base your Petty return prediction on?

Lis franc  tradition.

He might play earlier, but he quite possibly won't be " right"

 

 

 

Edited October 16, 2023 by IRW

[Redleg 40,815]

22 minutes ago, Gawndy the Great said:

I’m really lost why we didn’t chase him or why he didn’t nominate. I get that he has weaknesses but he’d only be chasing one of Hunter or Langdons spots. Or play him as a running HB. 

I would imagine that Lamb and Taylor don't rate him, or he didn't want to play in the same team as his best mate.

[DeeZone 9,638]

1 hour ago, deejammin' said:

A question about McAdam is if he comes how do we clear list spots to use our draft picks? 

We currently have two senior list spots and two A Rookie spots (according to the excellent work of the list thread). 

If we bring in McAdam we only have one senior list spot left. And that’s if we move Melksham to the rookie list to fill one of the two A rookie spots (if that’s even allowed?). 

Assuming we are taking at least one, maybe two or three draft picks who are we dropping from the list?

I just rechecked the List LH has already included Shane McAdam, Daniel Turner and Tom Fullarton on the senior list.

[Demonland 71,275]

If Adelaide are going to play hard ball I would just walk away, apologise to McAdam's manager and not answer their calls. No disrespect to McAdam but we simply cannot be seen to blink first here. I'm not suggesting we should be an Essendon or Geelong at trade time but we can't be painted the suckers of the trade period. Stand firm Dees.

[mo64 5,853]

1 hour ago, Redleg said:

I would imagine that Lamb and Taylor don't rate him, or he didn't want to play in the same team as his best mate.

If Lamb and Taylor don't rate Henry, then they didn't watch any Dockers games this year. He had a better season than both Langdon and Hunter, and adds outside run that we need.