Top 10 players in the AFL

[Yze_Magic 3]

1. Chris Judd

2. Daniel Kerr

3. Jonathan Brown

4. Ben Cousins

5. Matthew Pavlich

6. Nick Riewoldt

7. Adam Goodes

8. Barry Hall

9. Shaun Burgoyne

10. Chad Cornes

[Nasher 33,617]

Isn't it interesting that in your top 10 (which I don't disagree with), only 6 clubs are represented. I thought this competition was "equal".

[BrownlowBruce 1]

1. Chris Judd

2. Daniel Kerr

3. Jonathan Brown

4. Ben Cousins

5. Matthew Pavlich

6. Nick Riewoldt

7. Adam Goodes

8. Barry Hall

9. Shaun Burgoyne

10. Chad Cornes

i dunno about Riewolt been in there so high ..... i think u could slip him down to 9

and i would put simon black over chad cornes

[QueenC 74]

I thought this competition was "equal".

Hee!!! That was meant to be funny right Nasher :D ?!!!

And not really a high price put on defenders really is there?

Do we underestimate their importance?

[tess 19]

Is this after 4 rounds or would it have been the same done at the start of the season.

[BAMF 4,433]

Scott West above Chad Cornes

[Rivers Run Red 187]

Isn't it interesting that in your top 10 (which I don't disagree with), only 6 clubs are represented. I thought this competition was "equal".

And only 1 from a Victorian club...

[jacey 333]

1. Chris Judd

2. Daniel Kerr

3. Jonathan Brown

4. Ben Cousins

5. Matthew Pavlich

6. Nick Riewoldt

7. Adam Goodes

8. Barry Hall

9. Shaun Burgoyne

10. Chad Cornes

1.Judd

2.Kerr

3.Brown

4.Pavlich

5.Hall

6.Black

7. Brad Johnson

8.Power

9. Shaun Burgoyne

10. Dal Santo

[Demon Jim 149]

1.Judd

2.Kerr

3.Brown

4.Pavlich

5.Hall

6.Black

7. Brad Johnson

8.Power

9. Shaun Burgoyne

10. Dal Santo

Dal Santo, you're joking right

[demon magik 0]

no i think luke ball from the saints has gotta be in there somewhere ......

[Johnny Karate 559]

1. Chris Judd

2. Daniel Kerr

3. Jonathan Brown

4. Ben Cousins

5. Matthew Pavlich

6. Nick Riewoldt

7. Adam Goodes

8. Barry Hall

9. Shaun Burgoyne

10. Chad Cornes

I'd get rid of Cousins (only because he's not currently in the AFL), bump the others up 1 spot and sneak Lloyd in at 10.

Other than that I don't fundamentally disagree with the above.

Simon Black could sneak in.

Glass and Scarlett would be on the fringes but I wouldn't call them top 10 just yet.

It'd be interesting to see where the highest Melbourne player would be ranked - would we have one in the top 50?

[WonnaJurah 5]

Scott Lucas,Brad Johnson anyone?

Scott West

[brey9186 102]

I'd get rid of Cousins (only because he's not currently in the AFL), bump the others up 1 spot and sneak Lloyd in at 10.

Lloyd...

i was at essendon vs st kilda on the weekend, and Matthew Lloyd is a disgrace

did not earn one of his goals, dived everywhere, sooked all the time

how he can be described as a champion is beyond me

on the other hand, nick reiwoldt is a champion, he faught hard all day, double teamed all the time, and just played football

[Guest Schtacker]

1 bloke from 10 victorian lists!

[deeboy 40]

1. Judd

2. Kerr

3. Pavlich

4. Hall

5. Brown

6. Riewoldt

7. Johnson

8. West

9. Goodes

10. Mcleod

[TheJunkYardDog 0]

1. Judd

2. Pavlich

3. Brown

4. Reinwoldt

5. Goodes

6. Johnson

7. McLeod

8. Harris

9. Hamish McIntosh (He is on the way up)

10. Kosi

Gday boys, JYD a loyal Kangas supporter and Demons fortune follower.

[demon_fanatic 4]

people continue to overate dal santo... sure he has good games but he has to do it more than 5-6 times a year... Mcleod is definately still top 10.... class is permanent and he is back to his best....

Llloyd i wouldnt even have in my top 10..... yes it is painful watching him always looking over his shoulder for a free it looks so ridiculous.... grhhhhhhhhh

[deanox 10,045]

Gday boys, JYD a loyal Kangas supporter and Demons fortune follower.

gday mate welcome to the forums. are you hedging your bets in case the north kangaroos really become the north kangaroos? i ope they dont but we'll happily have you on board if they do...

[Ash35 425]

Cousins out, Brad Johnson in.

Other than that, not bad.

Perhaps you could argue that Burgoyne may be replaced by a Lloyd or a Del Santo, but I think it's not a bad top 10. Well done Yze_Magic.

[Ash35 425]

Lloyd...

i was at essendon vs st kilda on the weekend, and Matthew Lloyd is a disgrace

did not earn one of his goals, dived everywhere, sooked all the time

how he can be described as a champion is beyond me

How can he be described as a champion? Hmmmm....lets see.

217 games, 784 goals [top 10 on the all time goalkicking list].

Coleman medal 3 times : 2000, 2001, 2003

All Australian 5 times : 1998, 1999, 2000, 2001, 2003

Essendon leading goalkicker 9 times, every year from 1997 to 2005.

Top 3 in our B & F three times : 1997, 1998, 2001

International Rules Series : 1998, 2001

Jim Stynes Medal in 2001

AFL Rising Star nominee in 1996

Premiership side in 2000

Pre-season premiership side in 2000

Club captain 2006-

Yeah, he's just a talentless hack.

You obviously didn't notice a couple of Lloyds chases and tackles against St Kilda. Stuff like that seems to go unnoticed when people bag Lloyd. And that's a couple of weeks after Sheedy described his game in Round 1 against Adelaide as one of the best and most unselfish he has seen from captain in his time at Essendon.

[jacey 333]

people continue to overate dal santo... sure he has good games but he has to do it more than 5-6 times a year... Mcleod is definately still top 10.... class is permanent and he is back to his best....

dal santo is a star however i do concede that putting him in my top ten was a bit rich considering i left out a superstar in Mcleod and maybe Scott West, maybe Goodwin/Edwards, Black/Power etc.

[Garry Lyon's Leg Hair 0]

What about: (in no particular order)

Heath Shaw

Dane Swan

Kouta

Hird

Bartel

Sandilands

Hayes

McLean

Bruce

Hodge

Crawford

Scarlett

Didak

Kirk

Bolton of the Jude variety

Tredrea

Robert Murphy

Daniel Cross

Brad Johnson

Goodwin

Delidio

the list goes on and on.......

[occo 2]

Ill do mine for the last 4 rounds (best of 5)

5. Daniel Kerr

4. Chad Cornes - love this guy

3. Heath Shaw

2. Adam Goods

1. Barry Hall

[The Backyard Charizard 1,202]

Ill do mine for the last 4 rounds (best of 5)

5. Daniel Kerr

4. Chad Cornes - love this guy

3. Heath Shaw

2. Adam Goods

1. Barry Hall

Agree totally!!!

Kerr is ripping it up and sticking it to his detractors!

Cornes is an absolute gun and would be a walk-up start in any one of the other 15 clubs!

Heath Shaw is one of the surprise packets in my view! Having a stellar start to the season!

Goodes is a great player who has not been at his best so far this season, but is ticking along nicely!

Barry Hall is unreal.... For a bloke who injured his knee early on this year, he is not showing any sign of it!

Another 5 I would add....

Andrew McLeod - Well on the way to a stellar year and maybe another Charlie?!?!?

Chris Judd - No need to even comment!

Scott Lucas - Wish we had this sort of option up forward!

Simon Black - Leading by example to a great group of young cubs!

Matthew Pavlich - A hard running, strong leading, mark taking leader!

[occo 2]

Adelaide - McLeod

Brisbane - Black

Carlton - Gibbs

Collingwood - Heath Shaw

Essendon - Lucus

Freo - Pavlich

Geelong - Ablett

Hawks - Sewell

Kangaroos - ??? no one

Melbourne - ??? no one

Port Adel - Chad Cournes

Richmond - Raines

St Kilda - Montania

Sydney - Hall

WCE - Kerr

WB - Johnson