2 hours ago, Lucifers Hero said:

No it is not ok to bag either of them.  It is not ok to bag anyone doing their job.

What do you mean by this? That any criticism of anyone should be avoided?

Cant watch it now that pies beat us and Caro (daughter of Ian) was right about  her beloved tigers. Wilson and Eddie are unbearable. Never stop interupting and hogging the show.

Give me Drew Morphett and Tim Lane on the ABC any day over the current corporate actors.

Only ever watched the ABC for those two and 4 Corners program.

2 hours ago, Lucifers Hero said:

I've already said I didn't see LDcV's post referring to Caro and Eddie. 

No it is not ok to bag either of them.  It is not ok to bag anyone doing their job.

No agenda.  I just find these type of threads tedious.  They and the number of repetitive threads on DL is causing me to post less and less these days.  So maybe I do have an agenda:  enjoy DL a bit more than I have lately. 

And before you tell me to not open a thread if I don't like what is posted, believe me I don't.  After the first 10-20 posts of a new thread the writing is often on the wall and I don't open them again.  To qualify that: if anyone quotes me I will come to a thread to give them the courtesy of reading their comments and if required respond.  This thread is now in that category.

What is wrong with a thread on a footy site, that talks about a footy show compere who constantly mentions his club and himself?

Seriously?

12 minutes ago, BDA said:

Eddie is a relic. In the same category as Sammy Newman. Time to retire to the golf course 

Preferably to a galaxy ... far, far away.

I don't watch many footy shows but when I do I see them bang on about stuff we've been talking about here for months and sometimes years.

 

Cannot stand Caroline Wilson! 😡

Bring back the Footy Show with Sam Newman! Hahahahahaha! 🤣😅😂

2 hours ago, Kozzie4PM said:

What do you mean by this? That any criticism of anyone should be avoided?

Bagging and criticising = two different things. 

4 hours ago, rpfc said:

Faulty, Luci is the lovely person who rounds up the spilled conscious of opposition fans for our benefit every week. 

Not wanting to read more odious takes on the faces we see on the TV is not an agenda.

@Lucifers Herois also the lovely person who gives us detailed reports on player contracts as well as ticketing advice, amongst many other valuable contributions. Anyone wanna talk about someone with an agenda? There’s no shortage on DL, but LH is certainly not one of them. 

38 minutes ago, WalkingCivilWar said:

Bagging and criticising = two different 

Are they? What's the difference? 

9 minutes ago, Kozzie4PM said:

Are they? What's the difference? 

Criticism can be constructive. It can serve a worthwhile purpose. 
Bagging is never constructive and it doesn’t serve a worthwhile purpose. 

2 hours ago, WalkingCivilWar said:

@Lucifers Herois also the lovely person who gives us detailed reports on player contracts as well as ticketing advice, amongst many other valuable contributions. Anyone wanna talk about someone with an agenda? There’s no shortage on DL, but LH is certainly not one of them. 

That contracts stuff I started many years back soooooooo @Lucifers Heroonly gets partial credit…

1 hour ago, WalkingCivilWar said:

Criticism can be constructive. It can serve a worthwhile purpose. 
Bagging is never constructive and it doesn’t serve a worthwhile purpose. 

Bagging opponents and Supporters is fantastic 

 

2 hours ago, WalkingCivilWar said:

Criticism can be constructive. It can serve a worthwhile purpose. 
Bagging is never constructive and it doesn’t serve a worthwhile purpose. 

Hmmm interesting. So does that mean you can't say "politician x is hopeless" or "the umpire has no idea" or even "I hate Essendon"?

9 hours ago, Redleg said:

Or on Wednesdays, should it be called Footy Collingwood or Footy Eddie?

It is now just about unwatchable. All Eddie does, is to involve Collingwood in every segment and every part of the show and even himself, by declaring his production company is doing this that or the other. Additionally whatever is said by another panellist, Eddie adds “yes that is my info or what I have been told “. The big noting.

It is actually sickening.

Whatever they talk about, Collingwood is mentioned by him. There are always clips of Collingwood. No matter what the topic, there is mention of Collingwood.

Enough is enough.

It was one of my favourite footy shows, but on Wednesday is now unwatchable.

Please get Eddie off the panel and bring in anyone else, so that it can get back to being a footy show, not a Collingwood/Eddie one. 

 

The same is happening with SEN, albeit it's been a staged takeover for a number of years now since they started bringing Bucks on in a weekly segment when he was coaching.

Now there's Bucks and Mcrae doing the rounds.

The amount of coverage of the Pies is sickening in the media including their unoffical daily the HUN.  Can only hope they go out in straight sets.

3 hours ago, Supreme_Demon said:

Cannot stand Caroline Wilson! 😡

Bring back the Footy Show with Sam Newman! Hahahahahaha! 🤣😅😂

It's easily the worst Footy show doing the rounds.  Rarely watch more than a few minutes and that's mostly an accident.  The remote gets a quick workover as soon as i see/hear Caro or Ed

9 hours ago, Redleg said:

Or on Wednesdays, should it be called Footy Collingwood or Footy Eddie?

It is now just about unwatchable. All Eddie does, is to involve Collingwood in every segment and every part of the show and even himself, by declaring his production company is doing this that or the other. Additionally whatever is said by another panellist, Eddie adds “yes that is my info or what I have been told “. The big noting.

It is actually sickening.

Whatever they talk about, Collingwood is mentioned by him. There are always clips of Collingwood. No matter what the topic, there is mention of Collingwood.

Enough is enough.

It was one of my favourite footy shows, but on Wednesday is now unwatchable.

Please get Eddie off the panel and bring in anyone else, so that it can get back to being a footy show, not a Collingwood/Eddie one. 

 

Wednesday Footy Classified:

Eddie

Collingwood

Eddie

Ross Lyon with a timid interjection

Eddie with former president's cap on

Segment on North Melb coaching job where Eddie crowbars in a Tasmania agenda

Ross the Boss (which is becoming less informative by the week)

Some mention about something only Collingwood members would know like how Frankie Fredericks was a champion for them in the 1929 grand final.

Caro mentioning that the Melb tanking saga was worse than pumping young kids full of drugs

Closing cook 

End 

1 hour ago, Kozzie4PM said:

Hmmm interesting. So does that mean you can't say "politician x is hopeless" or "the umpire has no idea" or even "I hate Essendon"?

It’s ALWAYS ok to say I HATE ESSENDON. 

5 hours ago, WalkingCivilWar said:

Bagging and criticising = two different things. 

I beg to differ.

In my world of 6 + decades they have always been the same thing.

Ps. At a game, have you ever expressed disapproval of an umpire’s decision ?

11 hours ago, Lucifers Hero said:

I've already said I didn't see LDcV's post referring to Caro and Eddie. 

No it is not ok to bag either of them.  It is not ok to bag anyone doing their job.

No agenda.  I just find these type of threads tedious.  They and the number of repetitive threads on DL is causing me to post less and less these days.  So maybe I do have an agenda:  enjoy DL a bit more than I have lately. 

And before you tell me to not open a thread if I don't like what is posted, believe me I don't.  After the first 10-20 posts of a new thread the writing is often on the wall and I don't open them again.  To qualify that: if anyone quotes me I will come to a thread to give them the courtesy of reading their comments and if required respond.  This thread is now in that category.

I hear ya Luci, I've certainly posted a lot less this week after some people showed their true colours. Was just a stern reminder that this is a message board after all and nothing more.

1 minute ago, Abyssal said:

I beg to differ.

In my world of 6 + decades they have always been the same thing.

Ps. At a game, have you ever expressed disapproval of an umpire’s decision ?

Of course I have. That’s criticism. But I don’t yell out “you’re an [censored]” eg. That’s bagging. 

11 hours ago, Action Jackson said:

Have never watched it and never will.

Tbh I can't watch any AFL media anymore. It is a complete joke and it is all sensationalist BS.

At the start of the season we were 'unbeatable', now Geelong are unbeatable and we are worthy of being a bottom 4 side.

 

I like first crack and on the couch.  Don't watch anything else.

2 minutes ago, WalkingCivilWar said:

Of course I have. That’s criticism. But I don’t yell out “you’re an [censored]” eg. That’s bagging. 

I’ve “bagged” plenty over the years without using any expletives or even at times, raising my voice.

Bagging, slagging AKA criticising.

Each to their own.

 

I stopped watching the  footy shows because they have  become irrelevant. Since our 10 game streak has stopped …we have had very little respect considering we haven’t been out of top 4 all year and are the reigning premiers. Now even when we win.. I have zero interest in watching these show …just by reading DL you can pick up what is said if interested:’ It’s all about ego’s “- & click bait “ media.!

2 minutes ago, Deestar9 said:

I stopped watching the  footy shows because they have  become irrelevant. Since our 10 game streak has stopped …we have had very little respect considering we haven’t been out of top 4 all year and are the reigning premiers. Now even when we win.. I have zero interest in watching these show …just by reading DL you can pick up what is said if interested:’ It’s all about ego’s “- & click bait “ media.!

Feeling a bit similar, in fact I can't watch anything during the week now. Its too tiring. 

Anyone else see Donald McDonald on the Front Bar? He coached the last 5 games of 2004 for Hawthorn and blatantly admitted to tanking. Joked around saying - there was a bit of tanking going on in those days

assume Caro n Co will run with this in tomorrow’s paper??

Edited August 18, 20222 yr by DubDee