1 minute ago, deanox said:

Yes because this is about fitness tests for selected players, not about who gets named emergencies. 

Curious that he would not have been named on the bench if still subject to a fitness test. Aren't Dees liable to be fined if subbing ? 

1 minute ago, beelzebub said:

Curious that he would not have been named on the bench if still subject to a fitness test. Aren't Dees liable to be fined if subbing ? 

Good point. I would have thaught Hogan might not play as well.

1 hour ago, picket fence said:

Trac will NOT PLAY!!

Jeffy probable In!

Where's your source or are you just making it up as usual?

2 hours ago, Jaded said:

I’m surprised about Trac. 

I had to get 2 stitches between my fingers today and I can barely move it. It’s quite sore. How he can play a week after stitches and a skin graft is amazing. 

I couldn’t even put socks on. 

Jaded.  If the sutures were between your fingers ie web space it would be painful even to put gloves (let alone socks) on.

Trac way well wear some sort of protective glove 

1 hour ago, picket fence said:

Trac will NOT PLAY!!

Jeffy probable In!

I guess the precedent was set last year when Jeffy was dropped for poor form, didn't play VFL (I think due to yet another bloody bye) , then was back in the seniors without having to prove anything.  By all accounts he did nothing at Casey to justify reinstatement.  IF he gets back it IMO sends a very bad message.

Edited May 4, 20187 yr by monoccular

53 minutes ago, beelzebub said:

Curious that he would not have been named on the bench if still subject to a fitness test. Aren't Dees liable to be fined if subbing ? 

No. You’re confusing a number of things. It wouldn’t make sense to be fined for replacing an injured player - that’s the whole point of the emergency system.

- The final changes for a Sunday game will always come from the extended bench, and the three not selected will be the emergencies.

- if a player is injured and can’t play (ie late change), he must be replaced by one of the emergencies - the club is fined if it uses a non-emergency as a replacement.

13 minutes ago, monoccular said:

I guess the precedent was set last year when Jeffy was dropped for poor form, didn't play VFL (I think due to yet another bloody bye) , then was back in the seniors without having to prove anything.  By all accounts he did nothing at Casey to justify reinstatement.  IF he gets back it IMO sends a very bad message.

10 tackles?

2 minutes ago, buck_nekkid said:

10 tackles?

it was 7 Bugg got 10. 

That is absolute bullsh*t. If he’s been dropped because of form and been lacklustre in the 2s then why does he get a gold card automatic inclusion back in? 

1 minute ago, Wolfturdo said:

That is absolute bullsh*t. If he’s been dropped because of form and been lacklustre in the 2s then why does he get a gold card automatic inclusion back in? 

Who said Picket is right he's not the most reliable bloke going around?

15 minutes ago, monoccular said:

By all accounts he did nothing at Casey to justify reinstatement

For starters, this isn't correct, if you go by the stats he was amongst the best.

But even there, it depends on what he was asked to do in the game (e.g. tackle?), how he applies himself during the week in training, in the gym etc.  

Also, not sure which out you're referring to last year, but from what I can see, he only missed one game (Round 15) and that was with a hamstring.

14 hours ago, Deemented Are Go! said:

Why is it a worry? 

It is a stronger team but there are form gaps and pace gaps, plus a few who could be very strong against the Saints team that have been overlooked/omitted. I feel that Garlett could have learned his endeavour lesson, Pedo's strength is needed in the fwd line and although largely meaningless, the 'on paper' setup of the fwd line with Hoges at CHF is not a good start. TMac needs to be at CHF with Hoges at FFWd. Another tall / ruck respite needs to be on the bench - unless Goodwin plays the FPocket changes for rucks. Lever just aint a CHB playing better as a floater off the flank for intercepts. The centreline looks slow where the Saints are speedy, and there is concern about the team playing both the slowing Vince and Lewis in the same team, and the ill-directing Tyson across the midline - once again asking a little too much of Jones and Oliver to account for the midfield drive - so lotsa long bombs are going to be the flavour of the MFC gameplan. If TMac was played at the CHB position, and the speed was centred from HFwd into the deep Fwd line, it might work through the release of Hogan, Pedo, Weideman and the smalls like Hannan, Fritz, Spargo and Garlett. at the incomings and bringing the ball to ground. Hibberd needs to be used as the backline utility from the HBFlank to maximise our chances of crossing the centre to the Fwd line setups as reliance on Tyson's kicking and Lewis' speed is rather shaky. Frosty may have been considered to re-stock this HB drive from the bench., as well, instead of Harmes. Just an opinion.... Petracca needs to be 'centred' for midline drive to the fwds and to receive that from the backs - a two-way target for the whole team.

Edited May 4, 20187 yr by Deemania since 56

16 minutes ago, Deemania since 56 said:

It is a stronger team but there are form gaps and pace gaps, plus a few who could be very strong against the Saints team that have been overlooked/omitted. I feel that Garlett could have learned his endeavour lesson, Pedo's strength is needed in the fwd line and although largely meaningless, the 'on paper' setup of the fwd line with Hoges at CHF is not a good start. TMac needs to be at CHF with Hoges at FFWd. Another tall / ruck respite needs to be on the bench - unless Goodwin plays the FPocket changes for rucks. Lever just aint a CHB playing better as a floater off the flank for intercepts. The centreline looks slow where the Saints are speedy, and there is concern about the team playing both the slowing Vince and Lewis in the same team, and the ill-directing Tyson across the midline - once again asking a little too much of Jones and Oliver to account for the midfield drive - so lotsa long bombs are going to be the flavour of the MFC gameplan. If TMac was played at the CHB position, and the speed was centred from HFwd into the deep Fwd line, it might work through the release of Hogan, Pedo, Weideman and the smalls like Hannan, Fritz, Spargo and Garlett. at the incomings and bringing the ball to ground. Hibberd needs to be used as the backline utility from the HBFlank to maximise our chances of crossing the centre to the Fwd line setups as reliance on Tyson's kicking and Lewis' speed is rather shaky. Frosty may have been considered to re-stock this HB drive from the bench., as well, instead of Harmes. Just an opinion.... Petracca needs to be 'centred' for midline drive to the fwds and to receive that from the backs - a two-way target for the whole team.

Whoa.

I did ask , I suppose. 

How about we chat again tomorrow evening? 

12 hours ago, Nasher said:

No. You’re confusing a number of things. It wouldn’t make sense to be fined for replacing an injured player - that’s the whole point of the emergency system.

- The final changes for a Sunday game will always come from the extended bench, and the three not selected will be the emergencies.

- if a player is injured and can’t play (ie late change), he must be replaced by one of the emergencies - the club is fined if it uses a non-emergency as a replacement.

Quite correct. I ill considered that the replacement was coming from the listed emergencies. 

13 hours ago, WERRIDEE said:

Where's your source or are you just making it up as usual?

He's making it up both Trac and Hogan trained this morning, I have the pics to prove it?

Trac took a couple of strong grabs and Hogan moved really well

does that mean you think they will both play

3 minutes ago, Satyriconhome said:

He's making it up both Trac and Hogan trained this morning, I have the pics to prove it?

Trac took a couple of strong grabs and Hogan moved really well

Show us the pics so I can get aroused.?

14 minutes ago, Satyriconhome said:

He's making it up both Trac and Hogan trained this morning, I have the pics to prove it?

Trac took a couple of strong grabs and Hogan moved really well

A big thank you Saty....will be great to see what is almost the whole best 22 on the park tomorrow

11 minutes ago, forever demons said:

does that mean you think they will both play

Don't see why not, both seemed happy at the end of the session and neither sought any attention during it

Only issue Salem, Clarry and Trac playing soccer at end of session, Salem delivered a beautiful 50 metre pass for Trac to head in, made a complete breakfast of it much to everybody's amusement, can see why basketball was second sport

Even though it was a light session emphasis on fast ball movement, marking and goal kicking, Tommy Mc pisses me off, not one miss in the 3 drills they had??

 

Edited May 5, 20187 yr by Satyriconhome
Copied wrong pic bollocks

 

 

9 minutes ago, Satyriconhome said:

 

You're a legend Saty?

Satyricon correcting Picket Fence. 

It’s like choosing to believe Trump or Nixon. 

2 minutes ago, Deestroy All said:

Satyricon correcting Picket Fence. 

It’s like choosing to believe Clinton or Nixon.