Just now, Diamond_Jim said:

GC will want a better than mid first rounder....( Bulldogs pick 7 a possibility) or a late first rounder and a player. No ...Hunt won't fly

We really don't have a player to offer

Hard to see us getting back into this deal

The deal is cooked without pick 5. Time to move on.

Just now, Demonland said:

I thought we can't use our 2019 first round pick due to the rules of trading more than 2 in a 4 year period (unless getting AFL approval to do so).

well yes, that is the question

some have posted an afl quote which indicates all clubs have been cleared this year to use future picks (but it wasn't specific enough for my liking)

Just now, daisycutter said:

well yes, that is the question

some have posted an afl quote which indicates all clubs have been cleared this year to use future picks (but it wasn't specific enough for my liking)

Fair enough but do we really want another year out of the race for topping up on young talent.

5 minutes ago, Demonland said:

The deal is cooked without pick 5. Time to move on.

So it's off to the dogs for young May.

I feel strangely sorry for whoever ends up as pick 7 in the draft

8 minutes ago, Demonland said:

The deal is cooked without pick 5. Time to move on.

What happened if May came out and requested a trade to Melbourne? would that force GCS hand to do the best possible deal.  It isnt very often a club refuses to deal these days, players get to where they want to go (which i dont agree with, unless they want to come to us of course).

1 minute ago, BrisbaneDemon said:

What happened if May came out and requested a trade to Melbourne? would that force GCS hand to do the best possible deal.  It isnt very often a club refuses to deal these days, players get to where they want to go (which i dont agree with, unless they want to come to us of course).

Or May stays committed to GCS for one more year and we get him in next trade period and costs us nothing

Just now, BrisbaneDemon said:

What happened if May came out and requested a trade to Melbourne? would that force GCS hand to do the best possible deal.  It isnt very often a club refuses to deal these days, players get to where they want to go (which i dont agree with, unless they want to come to us of course).

He's still a contracted player. Same situation as Jesse at the moment. The difference is May is a free agent next year so we can pinch him for free then if he's still available and we're still interested and he still wants to come to us.

1 minute ago, BrisbaneDemon said:

What happened if May came out and requested a trade to Melbourne? would that force GCS hand to do the best possible deal.  It isnt very often a club refuses to deal these days, players get to where they want to go (which i dont agree with, unless they want to come to us of course).

I'll also add that it seems he really wants out and will probably be swooped up by someone else in this trade period despite seeming to want to come to us. Given our poor pick status we just aren't in the hunt now.

2 minutes ago, Demonland said:

I'll also add that it seems he really wants out and will probably be swooped up by someone else in this trade period despite seeming to want to come to us. Given our poor pick status we just aren't in the hunt now.

He might have his heart set on us in which case he may be willing to sit it out and wait until next year (not literally sit it out). 

But as we know a lot can change in a year. Who knows Hogan may find a hot girlfriend and refuse to leave Melbourne at the end of next year. 

20 minutes ago, Demonland said:

Fair enough but do we really want another year out of the race for topping up on young talent.

do we really need may now?  would be good but i'm not the football mgr

18 minutes ago, daisycutter said:

do we really need may now?  would be good but i'm not the football mgr

Same said footy mngr wanted Hogan out... May in.

Ponder if you will ....why. 

1 hour ago, beelzebub said:

Watch Collingwood swoop

Aren't they orchestrating all this... since they had to sign tiler Moore back on.

They're trying to make JTaylor look like  Derek Hine's biatch.

Edited October 12, 20187 yr by DV8

1 hour ago, Demonland said:

The deal is cooked without pick 5. Time to move on.

Lets NOT be negative, Deefeatist.... get creative.!

We have 4 options:

the Hogan deal kicks back in (unlikely)

May requests a trade to us and they move him on at a lower rate to start their rebuild.

He goes FA next year and we get him then.

He ends up requesting a trade elsewhere

low probabilities for this year, moderate for next if he stays at GCS.

1 minute ago, buck_nekkid said:

We have 4 options:

the Hogan deal kicks back in (unlikely)

May requests a trade to us and they move him on at a lower rate to start their rebuild.

He goes FA next year and we get him then.

He ends up requesting a trade elsewhere

low probabilities for this year, moderate for next if he stays at GCS.

Or We trade something to CGSuns. this is not dunn with, Yet.

Unfortunately we can't get May hopefully next year?

1 hour ago, Jaded said:

He might have his heart set on us in which case he may be willing to sit it out and wait until next year (not literally sit it out). 

But as we know a lot can change in a year. Who knows Hogan may find a hot girlfriend and refuse to leave Melbourne at the end of next year. 

Hopefully a Dee's fan.

Still think GC will want to move May along.

Pick 7 from the Dogs will do it.

Will May stand on his digs and wait another year.... not sure

1 hour ago, beelzebub said:

Why would you not want May ?

He is being massively overrated. What has Steven May ever done to warrant MFC parting with a first round pick?

11 minutes ago, DV8 said:

Or We trade something to CGSuns. this is not dunn with, Yet.

Leave Lynden out of this.

1 hour ago, Demonland said:

Fair enough but do we really want another year out of the race for topping up on young talent.

Melb v Eagles Prelim

games played Melb 2000 v WC 2600

im comfortable with sitting out another year and picking up players who fit our age profile now

19 minutes ago, KingDingAling said:

He is being massively overrated. What has Steven May ever done to warrant MFC parting with a first round pick?

ask Mahoney...hes pretty keen

43 minutes ago, KingDingAling said:

He is being massively overrated. What has Steven May ever done to warrant MFC parting with a first round pick?

Yeah, what would our FD know? They should listen to a guy who's a king dingaling.

FMD!

Next years 1st round + this year's 2nd round for May

Edited October 12, 20187 yr by Moonshadow

29 minutes ago, Moonshadow said:

Yeah, what would our FD know? They should listen to a guy who's a king dingaling.

FMD!

Next years 1st round + this year's 2nd round for May

Had our great FD not sold the farm for a 3rd up back with an ACL history (who subsequently did an ACL in his first year at the club), then maybe we would already have May this year. FMD!

can't we just package up ex-banana benders Brad Miller and Ricky Petterd in a straight swap for May?