GAME DAY - Round 4, 2017

[Adzman 2,154]

Too early to put in a request for a priority pick

[WattsUp2312 63]

Good effort in Q4 - disgraceful Q3 where our coaches did nothing also, cost us the game. 

I think at start of season we'd be disappointed with 2/2. If Lewis and Hogan were on we'd be 4 zip.

[Stevienic23 1,183]

James harmes is a butcher of the highest order. Missed a set shot in the third and freo go on and kick the next 7 and he constantly under hits passes 

[Moonshadow 17,675]

Hope Pedo is fit.

[BAMF 4,298]

Gotta say, that was a really [censored] annoying game. The ball would spill out and go their way. They would pump it into their forward line and look dangerous and we would do the same and look terrible.

Weideman has gotta spend some time at Casey. He did well to fly at the ball at times but simply doesnt give enough. 

Hannan hasnt done enough since round 1.

Melkshem.... ffs. Just butchers it too often.10 kicks for the game. 4 Clangers. 

Fyfe, Mundy, Neale, Sandilands. All so good.

[John Crow Batty 8,860]

I thought we got rid of Lucas Cook years ago.

[DSP 1,488]

Really, really could of used hogan and lewis today.

[demoniac 1,330]

I'm not a big stats guy but I reckon when you kick all of 3 points in the 3rd quarter but let the other team kick 7.4 you aint gonna win many games.

 

[waynewussell 5,209]

Weideman obviously carrying an injury... Poor selection. Jones obviously carrying an injury. Spencer did well. Great final qtr. Melbourne of old in 3rd Qtr. Garlett exceptional given his opportunities.

 

[olisik 4,060]

Just now, Moonshadow said:

Hope Pedo is fit.

Hope anyone is fit. Even Filipovic would've had a better game then the Weeds. Poor choice to drop Tim Smith

[leave it to deever 17,511]

2 minutes ago, Colin B. Flaubert said:

Great game to watch.

However, this is a reality check for us. We have work to do.

Spencer played fairly well. I liked Watts' game. Jeffy was great too.

However, Weid needs to go back to Casey to develop. Bring in Pedo to team up with Hoges next week.

Yea thats what people called for all week but the FD didnt listen

[Kiss of Death 747]

Hogan and Lewis.

[leave it to deever 17,511]

This loss will come back and bite us......wait and see.

[Jaded No More 68,855]

Can someone explain to me why the hell Frost got a game ahead of Oscar?! Frost is a defensive liability. Got torn a new one today. 

[DSP 1,488]

No way oscar mac is worse than milkshake. Hannin and weeds both need to go as well.

[Biffen 12,940]

Jesse Hogan just smoked a whole pack whilst sipping Martinis on his boat off Rottnest Island.-That was stressful for him.

I know how he feels.

That was a game of two halves,and also four quarters.It had it all.

Ross Lyon is a wily old egomaniac.Different outwardly to Roos but ultimately they are both stats men.

I'm hoping to see a lift in game day player switches during momentum shifting quarters like the third.

Im not comfortable with those lapses and I want it eradicated from our system .

[Rodney (Balls) Grinter 10,798]

So mad with our selection decisions right now.  For the fourth week in a row Weideman was [censored] useless.

Smith, Pedesen, Bradshaw, anyone would have done better playing full forward today.  In a game that we lost by 3 points playing Weideman has cost us the 4 point.

I'm putting all the blame on one player here, but I don't think it is unwanted.  I can excuse him getting out muscled in the air, but what I absolutely despised about his game today, was that when he lost the arial contest he gave NOTHING at ground level - looked almost disinterested at times.  Complete passenger - back to Casey and show some intent.

[waynewussell 5,209]

Every week is a new game... we might not even be this close next week... but we have no doubt that we would have been a better team today with T Smith or Pederson instead of Weed. We will welcome Hibberd with open arms when he is ready. Tom McDonald had an ordinary game... compared to his best. All focus should be on the third Qtr because we played reasonably well in the other three.

[DSP 1,488]

Goody needs to answer for that 3rd qtr as well. Static as hell. 7 goals kicked on us and nothing happened

[reynolds46 1,231]

The dockers never kick 100 points   But luckily for them they got to play against traffic cones in the 3rd quarter 

 

[brendan 3,434]

Hogan and Lewis cost us that win, hogan needs to repay next week 

[leave it to deever 17,511]

Just now, Rodney (Balls) Grinter said:

So mad with our selection decisions right now.  For the fourth week in a row Weideman was [censored] useless.

Smith, Pedesen, Bradshaw, anyone would have done better playing full forward today.  In a game that we lost by 3 points playing Weideman has cost us the 4 point.

I'm putting all the blame on one player here, but I don't think it is unwanted.  I can excuse him getting out muscled in the air, but what I absolutely despised about his game today, was that when he lost the arial contest he gave NOTHING at ground level - looked almost disinterested at times.  Complete passenger - back to Casey and show some intent.

Im putting the blame where it bloody belongs....the selection panel

[waynewussell 5,209]

Yes, we remain borderline top 8. We need a bit of luck...

[Guest]

1 minute ago, leave it to deever said:

Yea thats what people called for all week but the FD didnt listen

If this result is what it takes, then that is disappointing.

The kid had a decent start to his career. He has had a taste. Don't bloody completely stuff his confidence now by playing him when he clearly isn't ready.

If the mantra is to give people games when they deserve it, sadly, Weid doesn't. It's not a whipping boy thing. It's just the facts. 

The club realized Oscar Mc needed some time at Casey as he wasn't ready. The same call has to be made with Weid.

[waynewussell 5,209]

Weideman has got to go, injured or not... he has barely contributed. It will take a very good year at Casey before I am convinced he is up to it. I would rather see Keilty, Pederson, T Smith and even Hulett before I have to watch Weed again