old55 23,860 Posted October 19, 2016 Posted October 19, 2016 3 hours ago, Demon Jack said: Unless the recruiting team have their eyes on a certain player, I don't really see much need to trade back into the first/second round. Weideman is essentially our first pick this year and we have enough young guys at the club now as it is. Agree. We might have our eye on someone like Hunt and have a fair idea of where the competition is - I think that's why we took him at 57 when we did. If so we will know whether 57 this year covers us or we need to upgrade. Dunn + 57 + 59 for 47 could be a win-win anyway if we're only looking to draft 1 and upgrade 2. Quote
Satyriconhome 10,880 Posted October 19, 2016 Posted October 19, 2016 9 minutes ago, bingers said: Is Hibberd a better player than Melksham? Are they similar types? Did MFC need both? Are there any other questions I should be asking? If yes, what are they? No questons, two good pickups along with Lewis you need a minimum of 30 AFL ready players each week these days Quote
Demonland 74,430 Posted October 19, 2016 Posted October 19, 2016 9 minutes ago, bingers said: Is Hibberd a better player than Melksham? Are they similar types? Did MFC need both? Are there any other questions I should be asking? If yes, what are they? Everyone looks great in highlights so take from these what you will. Melksham - http://www.melbournefc.com.au/video/2015-10-15/jake-melksham-highlights Hibberd - http://www.afl.com.au/video/2016-10-19/get-excited-by-michael-hibberd Quote
M_9 2,216 Posted October 19, 2016 Posted October 19, 2016 7 minutes ago, Demonland said: Everyone looks great in highlights so take from these what you will. Melksham - http://www.melbournefc.com.au/video/2015-10-15/jake-melksham-highlights Hibberd - http://www.afl.com.au/video/2016-10-19/get-excited-by-michael-hibberd Hibberd not lacking any G&D and I like his kick. The left footers now on our list approaching Hawk proportions. Quote
Satyriconhome 10,880 Posted October 19, 2016 Posted October 19, 2016 Believe Cam Pedersen re signing was a big factor in Hibberd signing with MFC 8 Quote
GawnWithTheWind 604 Posted October 19, 2016 Posted October 19, 2016 Welcome Michael! Looking forward to seeing you stream out of the backline along side Melksham, Salem and Hunt. We now have a 'warchest' of HBFers that can seriously break the game open (TBC for melky) 1 Quote
Jaded No More 68,976 Posted October 19, 2016 Posted October 19, 2016 My Essendon mate texted me as soon as the deal went through and said "he's a f*&cking fighter, you'll love him" 6 Quote
ThreeOneSix 954 Posted October 19, 2016 Posted October 19, 2016 1 hour ago, bingers said: Is Hibberd a better player than Melksham? Are they similar types? Did MFC need both? Are there any other questions I should be asking? If yes, what are they? Hibberd is twice the player Melksham is. Ive watched most Essendon games the past 15 years (my old man is an Essendon fanatic). He laughed when they lost Melksham, he wasnt laughing when he found out they were losing Hibberd. Hibberd is actually a gun, he is very very good. 9 Quote
Adam The God 30,730 Posted October 19, 2016 Posted October 19, 2016 5 hours ago, Lucifer's Hero said: All those interpretations are correct. Re pick 84 - Newton's future is also in the balance and would can give us another list spot to fill - then we can use #84 at the draft... Another general comment: I am keeping the 2016 Contract thread upto date with all changes re demons. People should look at it before positing scenarios. I'd be astounded if Newton was still on our list next year. Quote
Adam The God 30,730 Posted October 19, 2016 Posted October 19, 2016 3 hours ago, bingers said: Is Hibberd a better player than Melksham? Are they similar types? Did MFC need both? Are there any other questions I should be asking? If yes, what are they? IMO Hibberd is a much better ball user. Hibberd is more defensive, plays as a defender, a good, long kick and is reasonably strong one-on-one. Melksham is a winger that could play off half back or half forward, use his pace and break some lines. But he's not extreme pace like Hunt. Personally, I think Melksham butchers it by foot, but can occasionally kick a good goal. A highly rated junior that crumbled a little bit IMO at AFL level. Will be interesting to see how he adjusts to Melbourne. Particularly with a year out of the game. 1 Quote
DeeSpencer 26,675 Posted October 19, 2016 Posted October 19, 2016 A little disappointed that his goals on the run from 50 seem to only just carry the line and don't go thumping over the fence. I thought he had more kicking penetration than that. But he can still hoof it and we don't have a defender who can regular get forward and goal so it's hard to complain there. I think he'll need time to get back in to peak form and fitness but he's a good all around defender who does everything pretty well. That combination should really help our backline. Quote
jnrmac 20,375 Posted October 19, 2016 Posted October 19, 2016 2 hours ago, ThreeOneSix said: Hibberd is twice the player Melksham is. Ive watched most Essendon games the past 15 years (my old man is an Essendon fanatic). He laughed when they lost Melksham, he wasnt laughing when he found out they were losing Hibberd. Hibberd is actually a gun, he is very very good. And we paid pick 23 for melksham and pick 29 for Hibberd. Its just the way it is sometime. You have to break an egg to make an omelete.... 2 Quote
Lord Travis 10,819 Posted October 19, 2016 Posted October 19, 2016 Hibberd is a great pick up for the club and immediately becomes our best halfback flanker. He's good defensively, has a bit of fight in him, and is a good rebounding halfback who can accumulate 20+ possessions easy. He'll be good for guys like Hunt and Salem to learn more off, but also so they can push further up and play on the wings. 29 is a bargain for him. He's borderline All Australian and Cats just gave up a first rounder for Tuohy, who is on par if not worse than Hibberd! 3 Quote
Ted Lasso 19,586 Posted October 19, 2016 Posted October 19, 2016 Lewis and Hibberd are both beautiful kicks of the ball, our skill level just got a really timely boost! as well as composure, experienced leaders. 7 Quote
Adam The God 30,730 Posted October 19, 2016 Posted October 19, 2016 40 minutes ago, Abe said: Lewis and Hibberd are both beautiful kicks of the ball, our skill level just got a really timely boost! as well as composure, experienced leaders. And hopefully Salem staying on the park helps this too. 1 Quote
Pates 9,697 Posted October 19, 2016 Posted October 19, 2016 (edited) This is a really good pick up in my opinion, something we have lacked is some polish out the half back line (Salem was meant to be that this year but had his Thyroid issues). Now we've got Hibberd, Melksham, (Vince as well), and Salem as options back there plus Hunt with his run and carry. Welcome to the Dees Michael! Edited October 19, 2016 by Pates Quote
Kwala 57 Posted October 19, 2016 Posted October 19, 2016 Geez I'm pumped for round one. Think I'm going to go hibernate to pass the time. Off season is like a car trip interstate when you're a kid. It's better just to sleep it out. Joking aside. Hilarious as it was. This is the first time in my rationally thinking life that it feels like we could really go somewhere. The pickups we have secured arent speculative, hopeful (although maybe I am) or stopgaps. They are good players that fill roles we are ready to fill, not desperately need to fill. 4 Quote
DEE fence 5,054 Posted October 19, 2016 Posted October 19, 2016 TBH i really wanted to shaft Essendon. Tjat is the only thing i ront like about the deal 29 is fair they just dont deserve it 2 Quote
What 18,810 Posted October 19, 2016 Posted October 19, 2016 19 minutes ago, DaisyDeeciple said: TBH i really wanted to shaft Essendon. Tjat is the only thing i ront like about the deal 29 is fair they just dont deserve it We did shaft them. Hibberd is a ready made gun and if he had nominated another club with a higher pick, he would have gone for that. 1 Quote
xarronn 384 Posted October 19, 2016 Posted October 19, 2016 6 hours ago, Satyriconhome said: Believe Cam Pedersen re signing was a big factor in Hibberd signing with MFC Is this a serious comment, or have I missed a joke earlier in this thread? What's the connection? Quote
Males 578 Posted October 19, 2016 Posted October 19, 2016 10 hours ago, AngryAtCasey said: Next move. Dunn, Pick 57 & 59 (340 points) to the filth for Picks 47 (316) & 83 (0) . Puts them in a better position re father/sons. The trade next years future 2nd Round Pick to Saints for 36. Instead of Pick 47 in this scenario, would it be worth more to us to try for their next years 3rd round pick? Quote
FarNorthernD 5,863 Posted October 19, 2016 Posted October 19, 2016 32 minutes ago, xarronn said: Is this a serious comment, or have I missed a joke earlier in this thread? What's the connection? Lewis said Hogan signing played a part in him coming to the Dees. Saty has made a joke Quote
Mazer Rackham 14,972 Posted October 19, 2016 Posted October 19, 2016 38 minutes ago, xarronn said: Is this a serious comment, or have I missed a joke earlier in this thread? What's the connection? You know ... coz Lewis said Hogan signing was a big factor ... take it down a notch in class for Hibberd/Pedo ... oh never mind. 2 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.