H_T 3,049 Posted October 23, 2015 Posted October 23, 2015 This is my mock draft top 12 - leave yours below! 1. Jacob Weitering - Carlton 2. Josh Schache - Brisbane 3. Callum Mills - Sydney 4. Darcy Parish - Melbourne .... I would rather Wieideman + Curnow more than Weideman/Curnow + Parish Parish doesn't excite me Thinking about it more i have decided to change 1. Jacob Weitering - Carlton 2. Josh Schache - Brisbane 3. Charlie Curnow - Melbourne 4. Darcy Parish - Essendon ..... I like your enthusiasm DemonLad5, but I have to ask what made you submit your mock draft with Parish as our selection in your OP and in the next breath, you say he doesn't excite you and hence change? Interested to know what changed your mind. And you know Curnow has played as a mid too?
dtrinh 71 Posted October 23, 2015 Posted October 23, 2015 I would rather Wieideman + Curnow more than Weideman/Curnow + Parish Parish doesn't excite me A bit hard considering both Wieideman and curnow played minimal football this year.
DistrACTION Jackson 10,705 Posted October 23, 2015 Posted October 23, 2015 I think looking at that highlights video of Parish he seems underwhelming. Though I think his overall season and U18 championships was very good. I also think that his test results don't do him justice and he is one of those players that doesn't do anything exceptional but does everything very well. I'm not sold on him personally but I think he ticks our biggest need, speed and skill with competitiveness.
olisik 4,060 Posted October 23, 2015 Posted October 23, 2015 Key forward is a must this draft Not a poor mans Jarryd Waite whose already showing he is injured a lot of the time
Mondê 525 Posted October 23, 2015 Posted October 23, 2015 I think looking at that highlights video of Parish he seems underwhelming. Though I think his overall season and U18 championships was very good. I also think that his test results don't do him justice and he is one of those players that doesn't do anything exceptional but does everything very well. I'm not sold on him personally but I think he ticks our biggest need, speed and skill with competitiveness. The highlight reel on youtube doesn't do what he achieved in 2015 justice. This kid can play His season for the Falcons was a class above
DistrACTION Jackson 10,705 Posted October 23, 2015 Posted October 23, 2015 The highlight reel on youtube doesn't do what he achieved in 2015 justice. This kid can play His season for the Falcons was a class above Great news if that's the case. I hate basing judgement off a highlights package as it can be made to look as good or as poor as the person creating it likes. I trust the recruiters have watched enough to know who is the best pick at number 3. I think the most interesting thing will be who we take at number 7. The write ups of Weideman aren't that promising and I definitely wouldn't want to 'reach' for a player just because we think we might need another tall forward. With the way trading gets done these days it's best to just pick best available and then trade in to fill holes.
DistrACTION Jackson 10,705 Posted October 23, 2015 Posted October 23, 2015 No way Weideman slips past 7 I think there is a good chance as he seems fairly limited from what I have read (granted I haven't watched him play). The reason I had Mathieson at pick 5 is that I think the Bombers will likely take one of Francis/Curnow pick 4 and will want another young mid at pick 5 with Watson and Stanton getting on.
Mondê 525 Posted October 23, 2015 Posted October 23, 2015 I think there is a good chance as he seems fairly limited from what I have read (granted I haven't watched him play). The reason I had Mathieson at pick 5 is that I think the Bombers will likely take one of Francis/Curnow pick 4 and will want another young mid at pick 5 with Watson and Stanton getting on. Tend to agree on your thought process behind taking Mathieson at 5. Outside of Watson and Heppell their inside mid depth is quite poor
Bobby McKenzie 2,408 Posted October 23, 2015 Posted October 23, 2015 Thinking about it more i have decided to change 1. Jacob Weitering - Carlton 2. Josh Schache - Brisbane 3. Charlie Curnow - Melbourne 4. Darcy Parish - Essendon 5. Aaron Francis - Essendon 6. Wayne Milera - Gold Coast (again, hoping they don't take Weidman) 7. Sam Weidman - Melbourne If Essendon take Weidman, Gold Coast will take Francis and i reckon we should take Mathieson to bolster our mids Now that makes more sense! Melb with picks no 3 and 7 as against your original picks 4 and 10.
dazzledavey36 56,278 Posted October 23, 2015 Posted October 23, 2015 Weideman is a poor mans Jarryd Waite. Prefer to take Parish and Milera/Mathieson Im guessing that Weideman comment was based on watching him live more then once?
Radar Detector 1,347 Posted October 23, 2015 Posted October 23, 2015 Now that makes more sense! Melb with picks no 3 and 7 as against your original picks 4 and 10. His first post wasn't incorrect though, just included Academy players where they would slot in
daisycutter 30,004 Posted October 23, 2015 Posted October 23, 2015 I think looking at that highlights video of Parish he seems underwhelming. Though I think his overall season and U18 championships was very good. I also think that his test results don't do him justice and he is one of those players that doesn't do anything exceptional but does everything very well. I'm not sold on him personally but I think he ticks our biggest need, speed and skill with competitiveness. yes but it's not really a highlights video, just showing parish in one game assuming we both saw the same video (and i agree it's not exactly whelming) i'd like to see heaps more video of parish before i make any conclusions additionally those who are rating parish must have seen a lot more of him than that short video so there must be more to him
DemonLad5 1,642 Posted October 23, 2015 Author Posted October 23, 2015 Anyone really think that Weideman could actually be available at pick 7? If we take Curnow then there is no chance, considering the Dons will be looking for a forward, but if we take Parish, Dons take Curnow and Francis, we just have to pray that the suns will take Milera or Matheison or someone along those lines
MadAsHell 4,217 Posted October 23, 2015 Posted October 23, 2015 1. CARLTON: Weitering 2. BRISBANE: Schache (Melbourne bid Pick 3 on Mills) 3. SYDNEY: Mills 4. MELBOURNE: Parish (Essendon bid Pick 5 on Hopper) 5. GWS: Hopper (Essendon bid Pick 6 on Kennedy) 6. GWS: Kennedy 7. ESSENDON: Oliver 8. ESSENDON: Weideman 9. GOLD COAST: Millera 10. MELBOURNE: Curnow (Carlton bid Pick 11 on Keayes) 11. BRISBANE: Keayes 12. CARLTON: Balic
DemonLad5 1,642 Posted October 23, 2015 Author Posted October 23, 2015 1. CARLTON: Weitering 2. BRISBANE: Schache (Melbourne bid Pick 3 on Mills) 3. SYDNEY: Mills 4. MELBOURNE: Parish (Essendon bid Pick 5 on Hopper) 5. GWS: Hopper (Essendon bid Pick 6 on Kennedy) 6. GWS: Kennedy 7. ESSENDON: Oliver 8. ESSENDON: Weideman 9. GOLD COAST: Millera 10. MELBOURNE: Curnow (Carlton bid Pick 11 on Keayes) 11. BRISBANE: Keayes 12. CARLTON: Balic No Francis?
beelzebub 23,392 Posted October 23, 2015 Posted October 23, 2015 Just two best mids. We can pinch hit other roles
Dee-licious 1,954 Posted October 23, 2015 Posted October 23, 2015 Ok Demonlad - lets tango. 1. Carlton - Weitering - future captain and 10-15 year player. Lock and load. 2. Brisbane - Schache - not going to want to come home. He is their forward of the future. 3. Sydney - Mills - bid from Melbourne. We want him like we wanted Heeney. 4. Melbourne - Parish - you dont move heaven and earth to get to pick 3 for someone who might be there at 6 5. GWS - Hopper - bid from Essendon - He is a big bodied midfielder who would be perfect for the Dons. Suckers. 6. GWS - Kennedy - bid from Essendon - see above. 7. Essendon - Francis - Really great reader of the play. Will fill in a hole down back for the Dons to allow Hooker to go forward so with 8 they will take 8. Essendon - Curnow - The more I think about it, the more I don't see this young man lasting to us. The Dons have key position players and they arent planning to be down the ladder for a second time around. Curnow is a game winner, and will compliment Hooker and Danniher. 9. Gold Coast - Mileara - His silk will appeal to GC who have some great inside mids who can feed it out to him on the wing. 10. Melbourne - Weiderman - I think this is high, but we have a clear plan in place. This completes our spine and allows us to bring in the players around them. 11. Carlton - Matherson - They will look for a partner for Cripps in here and then build the talls with their next picks. 12. Adelaide - Balic - There is class here and I think that might work out quite well for them. 13. Brisbane - Hipwood - bid from Carlton - they'll want to complement Weitering at the other end of the ground but he is all Brissy's 14. Carlton - McKay - Although I will change this in a week or two to say Collins, I think that this is what they will be feeling right now. 15. Brisbane - Keays - bid from Richmond. 16. Richmond - Ah Chee - they will be drawn in to the x-factor 17. Adelaide - Bonner - he wont go back to Mogg's creek 18. St Kilda - Tucker - they will be laughing all the way to the bank when they still get an outside mid at pick 14 (18) 19. Sydney - Dunkley - bid from Hawthorn - if he nominates. Hasn't yet. If he doesn't he's a Hawk. 20. Hawthorn - Burton - There is no risk taking him here and if he gets everything right we will be [censored] the Hawks got him so low. For the record, I think that Weiderman will drop to us. If not Curnow. I cant see a way that Essendon takes them both considering that they will have Heppell and thats it in 2 years time.
DemonLad5 1,642 Posted October 23, 2015 Author Posted October 23, 2015 Ok Demonlad - lets tango. 1. Carlton - Weitering - future captain and 10-15 year player. Lock and load. 2. Brisbane - Schache - not going to want to come home. He is their forward of the future. 3. Sydney - Mills - bid from Melbourne. We want him like we wanted Heeney. 4. Melbourne - Parish - you dont move heaven and earth to get to pick 3 for someone who might be there at 6 5. GWS - Hopper - bid from Essendon - He is a big bodied midfielder who would be perfect for the Dons. Suckers. 6. GWS - Kennedy - bid from Essendon - see above. 7. Essendon - Francis - Really great reader of the play. Will fill in a hole down back for the Dons to allow Hooker to go forward so with 8 they will take 8. Essendon - Curnow - The more I think about it, the more I don't see this young man lasting to us. The Dons have key position players and they arent planning to be down the ladder for a second time around. Curnow is a game winner, and will compliment Hooker and Danniher. 9. Gold Coast - Mileara - His silk will appeal to GC who have some great inside mids who can feed it out to him on the wing. 10. Melbourne - Weiderman - I think this is high, but we have a clear plan in place. This completes our spine and allows us to bring in the players around them. 11. Carlton - Matherson - They will look for a partner for Cripps in here and then build the talls with their next picks. 12. Adelaide - Balic - There is class here and I think that might work out quite well for them. 13. Brisbane - Hipwood - bid from Carlton - they'll want to complement Weitering at the other end of the ground but he is all Brissy's 14. Carlton - McKay - Although I will change this in a week or two to say Collins, I think that this is what they will be feeling right now. 15. Brisbane - Keays - bid from Richmond. 16. Richmond - Ah Chee - they will be drawn in to the x-factor 17. Adelaide - Bonner - he wont go back to Mogg's creek 18. St Kilda - Tucker - they will be laughing all the way to the bank when they still get an outside mid at pick 14 (18) 19. Sydney - Dunkley - bid from Hawthorn - if he nominates. Hasn't yet. If he doesn't he's a Hawk. 20. Hawthorn - Burton - There is no risk taking him here and if he gets everything right we will be [censored] the Hawks got him so low. For the record, I think that Weiderman will drop to us. If not Curnow. I cant see a way that Essendon takes them both considering that they will have Heppell and thats it in 2 years time. Have to agree with this
Roger Mellie 4,205 Posted October 23, 2015 Posted October 23, 2015 Everyone's assuming GCS will pick as they have in the past. They've got a new coach. They've lost Dixon. Who's to say they won't go for a tall. I wouldn't be surprised if they went for Weirdoman or Curnow over Mileara / Mathieson. We'll get a clearer picture closer to the draft, when the journos start sniffing things out (the better ones that is).
DemonLad5 1,642 Posted October 23, 2015 Author Posted October 23, 2015 Everyone's assuming GCS will pick as they have in the past. They've got a new coach. They've lost Dixon. Who's to say they won't go for a tall. I wouldn't be surprised if they went for Weirdoman or Curnow over Mileara / Mathieson. We'll get a clearer picture closer to the draft, when the journos start sniffing things out (the better ones that is). That's what i'm worried about
rpfc 29,020 Posted October 23, 2015 Posted October 23, 2015 DL5 - explain what you are doing - this is bloody confusing stuff to footy fans. Can't assume everyone understands the premise (and effect) of academy bidding.
Deecisive 1,709 Posted October 23, 2015 Posted October 23, 2015 our football department will be crawling over video and reports for all of the top 20 looking for the players we want which may or may not reconcile to what everyone else thinks, They have done a pretty good job so far with not much to trade with so happy to sit back and enjoy. And we all know that whoever we do not take this year when we have a chance will be our next oli wines thread next year.
What 18,810 Posted October 23, 2015 Posted October 23, 2015 Weideman is a poor mans Jarryd Waite. Prefer to take Parish and Milera/Mathieson Wiedemannn does seem like this years slider. Something not quite right about him. Mathiseon butchers the ball by foot, no thanks. Milera does look the goods, would like to get him at 7.
DemonLad5 1,642 Posted October 23, 2015 Author Posted October 23, 2015 Don't see GC taking Weideman considering they have Peter Wright to step straight into Dixon's role
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.