Saints are trading with GWS not Bulldogs, because GWS have the outrageous surplus of talent held hostage.

Bulldogs aren't prepared to give up anything good. They'll also be waiting for the father son bidding to finish so they have a clearer idea of what currency everyone has, including our Frawley compo.

Bulldogs will definitely take a punt on Moore and see if Colonwood bite. He's absolutely worth pick 5.

The Dee's need to keep both picks 2 &3 and draft Brayshaw and McCartin. Let's blood our own!

Sam Frost & Harry Lumumba will be great additions.

Kane Lucas is one I would swap a late draft pick for to give us some more midfield depth. Can kick goals as a midfielder too.

Sam Blease and a late pick swap?

The Dee's need to keep both picks 2 &3 and draft Brayshaw and McCartin. Let's blood our own!

Sam Frost & Harry Lumumba will be great additions.

Kane Lucas is one I would swap a late draft pick for to give us some more midfield depth. Can kick goals as a midfielder too.

Sam Blease and a late pick swap?

Lucas is awful, no thanks.

Roos has already said he doesn't like drafting KPFs from the draft so we won't draft McCartin. Let's just do pick 3 to Swans for Mitchell and Membrey and be done with it

Lucas makes Blease look like Michael Long. Horrible footballer.

Keep pick 2 - Brayshaw

Trade pick 3 for player and pick, it's a no brainer.

You want Petracca and Brayshaw, just tell Saints we will take McCartin.

We don't get Petracca if Saints trade the pick to GWS. That is who they want.

Agreed. And St Kilda might still take Petracca themselves which is why I would like them to trade to someone like the Bulldogs who will rate a key forward more than another midfielder.

Agreed. And St Kilda might still take Petracca themselves which is why I would like them to trade to someone like the Bulldogs who will rate a key forward more than another midfielder.

Yes and that's why they won't trade with the Doggies because there is nothing in it for them.

I still like the idea of doing a swap of picks with the Bulldogs as long as they are willing to take a contracted list clogger off our hands.

We trade them Pick 3 & Evans for Pick 6 & Hrovat.

Still allows us to take Brayshaw at 2 and can take Duggan at 6 and Hrovat walks into our 22 for forward half pressure and rotating through the midfield.

Doggies get McCartin at 3, everyone's happy and we get another available spot on our list. Bulldogs can sell the addition of Evans as a like for like replacement to their supporters. They don't need to know Pickles is no good.

I still like the idea of doing a swap of picks with the Bulldogs as long as they are willing to take a contracted list clogger off our hands.

We trade them Pick 3 & Evans for Pick 6 & Hrovat.

Still allows us to take Brayshaw at 2 and can take Duggan at 6 and Hrovat walks into our 22 for forward half pressure and rotating through the midfield.

Doggies get McCartin at 3, everyone's happy and we get another available spot on our list. Bulldogs can sell the addition of Evans as a like for like replacement to their supporters. They don't need to know Pickles is no good.

No, thanks. I'd prefer to keep pick 3 than get rid of one of our list cloggers and gain a mediocre opposition player.

Adam Conney and pick 5 for pick 2 and 3 has been offered by the dogies.

An old injury prone ex blown low winner who has 2 year left in him for 2 10 year players.

No thanks

The Dee's need to keep both picks 2 &3 and draft Brayshaw and McCartin. Let's blood our own!

Sam Frost & Harry Lumumba will be great additions.

Kane Lucas is one I would swap a late draft pick for to give us some more midfield depth. Can kick goals as a midfielder too.

Sam Blease and a late pick swap?

blease for lucas, like for like?

Adam Conney and pick 5 for pick 2 and 3 has been offered by the dogies.

An old injury prone ex blown low winner who has 2 year left in him for 2 10 year players.

No thanks

do they think Roos has left the country already?

I am a NO to Cooney. We would be lucky to get 12 games out of him. Better developing a player.

Adam Conney and pick 5 for pick 2 and 3 has been offered by the dogies.

An old injury prone ex blown low winner who has 2 year left in him for 2 10 year players.

No thanks

Lel

Adam Conney and pick 5 for pick 2 and 3 has been offered by the dogies.

An old injury prone ex blown low winner who has 2 year left in him for 2 10 year players.

No thanks

that is hilarious if true

what a deluded footy club they must be

Adam Conney and pick 5 for pick 2 and 3 has been offered by the dogies.

An old injury prone ex blown low winner who has 2 year left in him for 2 10 year players.

No thanks

Tell em they're dreamin',

They don't even have pick 5 to trade because thanks to the Frawley compo, it's now pick 6.

that is hilarious if true

what a deluded footy club they must be

Tyson as steak knives too I reckon. Only fair

Cooney cooked. Bone on bone in the knees.

Been a good player, but I wouldn't have thought he suits us.

Adam Conney and pick 5 for pick 2 and 3 has been offered by the dogies.

An old injury prone ex blown low winner who has 2 year left in him for 2 10 year players.

No thanks

Adam Conney and pick 5 for pick 2 and 3 has been offered by the dogies.

If that is a serious offer by them then they are deluded, to say the least.

Cooney + pick 5 for pick 2 + 3. LOL.

Cooney has just about had it. If they offered Cooney + pick 5 (now 6) for only one of our picks, well then that makes a little more sense (i'd still laugh at it), the fact that they have asked for both picks is farcical

Adam Conney and pick 5 for pick 2 and 3 has been offered by the dogies.

An old injury prone ex blown low winner who has 2 year left in him for 2 10 year players.

No thanks

Pretty sure your source for this was a 'suggestion' on BigFooty, and, if so, the suggestion was for pick 2 OR 3, not both.

Still, a hilarious thought. Cooney has no value whatsoever anymore.

Adam Conney and pick 5 for pick 2 and 3 has been offered by the dogies.

An old injury prone ex blown low winner who has 2 year left in him for 2 10 year players.

No thanks

"Did IQ's drop sharply while I was away?"

It seems at this time of the draft period ( before the real stuff happens in the last two days ) that many clubs make stupid offers.

I don't get it - why waste peoples time ?

But then again - we have posters on here who rate Mitch Clark anywhere from a first rounder to "let him walk into the PSD - I don't care if we get nothing for him".

I am a NO to Cooney. We would be lucky to get 12 games out of him. Better developing a player.

Under the current regime, yes.

Before that it was very dodgy.