Cast your votes please -

6: jack viney ( future star )

5:jack trengove ( now that is the level he needs consistantly )

4: jordie mckenzie ( i was wrong to give up on him, good job on fyfe )

3: col sylvia ( consistant again )

2: jack watts ( another good game )

1: dean terlich ( good offensively )

First game all year id be comfortable putting Trenners in the votes

1. Jack Viney - MFC heart and soul

2. Trengove - finding the ball a bit more

3. Silvia - strong clearance work

4. Dunn - solid in defence

5. McKenzie - nullified Fyfe and found the ball

6. Spencer - combative

I've had it with Watts, today he was a basketballer with no intensity, wouldn't tackle and consistently beaten 1 on 1.

6: jack viney ( future star )

5:jack trengove ( now that is the level he needs consistantly )

4: jordie mckenzie ( i was wrong to give up on him, good job on fyfe )

3: col sylvia ( consistant again )

2: jack watts ( another good game )

1: dean terlich ( good offensively )

Hahahahahahahaha Watts! So he deserves votes for not chasing, not putting his head over the ball, and genuinely looking like he doesn't want to be part of the team? Give me a break, he was woeful.

Not trying to launch a personal attack on you or anything, but he was shocking.

Viney

more that i didnt know who else dee94 maybe swap him for kent or mcdonald

6-Viney

5- Trengove

4- McKenzie

3- Garland

2- Kent

1- Dunn

Jack Watts doesn't deserve votes. I'm shocked anyone would think of giving him any.

Soft and lazy playing the easiest position on the ground. Shameful display.

Jaded, we were outsized because it sounded like it?

Viney

Dunn

Trenners

Kent

That is all.

6 Viney (fantastic to see a player who gives second and third efforts).

The rest don't really deserve votes but the pick of them in my view were:

5 Tom Mc (did a pretty good job on Pav - not sure why he was off ground when Pav took a ripping pack mark on Dunny to score his second, but then again I'm not sure why jack watts was playing down back and a defender Troy Davis was playing forward.

4 Jordie McKenzie (showed intent all day and worked hard on Fyfe and then Mundy).

3 Trenners (I assume he was told to play wide and be a linkman and he racked up heaps of touches. Just wish some of them had been in middle of park where his next kick could hurt them).

2 Garland (not a great game by his standards but Mayne was BOG last week and was quiet this time).

1 Sylvia (As with Dunn and Terlich, he racked up plenty of the ball, but his effective kicks must have tallied only five or six). He did win quite a few hardballs though.

Players who won their position

6. Viney

5. T McDonald

4. J McKenzie

Players who had the next best impact

3. Trengove

2. Kent

1. Dunn

6.Viney

5.Trengove

4.Fitzpatrick

3.Watts

2.Dunn

1.Terlich

Pretty easy to spot anyone who didn't actually watch the game and are just looking at stats....

Edited August 18, 201312 yr by stuie

6 - Viney

5 - McKenzie

4 - McDonald

3 - Kent

2 - Garland

1 - Dunn

Trengove had a lot of the ball but made some horrendous decisions with it.

Players who won their position

6. Viney

5. T McDonald

4. J McKenzie

Players who had the next best impact

3. Trengove

2. Kent

1. Dunn

very interesting way of summising but im not sure Trenners really impacted. A much better game but Im not too carried away yet. A for effort though I suppose.

I can never understand how someone manages to kick all but straight to the opposition., or into them !!

so for mine

6- Viney

5- Viney

4 - T Mac

3- Jordie Mck

2 - Kent

1- Trengove

and no I havent made a typo !!

6. Viney

5. McKenzie

4. Kent

3. Sylvia

2. Garland

1. McDonald

Watts was a complete waste today we played with 17 men, today craig confirmed he doesn't want to coach to allow watts to stand 25m in front of Freo goal allowing players to run past him avoiding contact a all cost he was a disgrace and Craig should have addressed this.

Viney

Trengove

Dunn

6-Viney

5-jordie mck

4-Trengove

3-Sylvia

2-Dunn

1-Kent

6- Viney (Hard at it, in so many contests, running, moving well, great snap goal, only made one kicking error, his best game to date to give him a rising star nomination)

5- Trengove (Best game of the year by a mile, ran a lot harder and didn't stop running after one possession)

4- Dunn (Finally seemed to have his head screwed on properly and was decent with ball use)

3- Terlich (Did an honest job like Dunn all game and found a lot of the ball)

2- McDonald (Very good in contests)

1- Kent (Fell away after half time and his kicking wasn't great, but was really lively and desperate)

(A very surprising top 6)

Apologies to McKenzie, Sylvia and also Watts, not because he was good but because of how he was used.

I'm also shocked that N.Jones was clearly not in our best 6 today. Must be the first time in 2 years this has happened

Edited August 18, 201312 yr by TBD Aniher-Watts

6. Viney - I know who I'd want with me in the trenches!
5. Trengove - probably his best for a couple of years
4. Mckenzie - subdued the influence of Fyfe / Mundy

3. Dunn - mostly dependable, with only a couple of 'brain fades'

2. Silvia - worked hard, but disposal let him down too often

1. Spencer - continues to make it harder for Jamar

?, no names, but there are a couple I definitely wouldn't want with me in the trenches!

We should defer the 'Demonland Player of the Year' until 2014.

No Melbourne B&F this year either.

6. Viney

5. Trengove

4. Mckenzie

3. Dunn

2. McDonald

1. Sylvia

Can we start give negative votes, please? Howe & Byrnes, along with a few others * cough* Jack Watts *cough* would be in with a show.

6. Viney - this kid is a footballer and has a lot of Joel Selwood about him in the way he wills himself to a contest and wants for his team to succeed

5. Trenners - showed what he can do worked hard as he always does but was rewarded for his effort today, JT this should be standard performance week in week out

4. Mckenzie - not talented but our midfield is better with him in there to provide the contest and nullify an opponent _ Fyfe today.

3. TMac - provided a good contest down back couldn't be faulted with goals from lace out delivery from Freo mids

2. Kent - I love this kid will get better the more time he spends in this environment, dropped off in the 2nd half as he tired

1 Dunn - same as TMac in providing 1 on 1 contest and has a lot of haters but IMO always provides an effort, despite brain fades

Unlucky - Sylvia tried today but didn't really come off in a choice between he and JW for signature I will choose him every day of the week, Terlich gets plenty of it and always gives 100% but his disposal lets him down and teams hurt us the other way by feeding his direct opponent