M Jones actually plays as a defensive forward really well. Locks the ball in well and causes stoppages

and gets little of the footy. A fwd who causes a few stoppages is actually a tagger or defender. M Jones is a list clogger

Do you only have to nominate rookie upgrades by today ? i.e This isnt the last list lodgement so you might possibly be in limbo until the last lodgement ?

this is only list lodgement 1, i believe... so depending on who are released by other clubs thru the remaining list lodgement's, may make or break, some of ours. ?

So we'll find out today for certain whether Michie was contracted for 2016 or not.

2:00pm is the deadline for OOC players to nominate for the draft, with the 2nd list lodegement dut tomorrow.

Looks like it must have been a 3 year deal he was initially on.

Hope so. He showed a bit towards the end of the season.

If thats the case looks like we'll only take 3 pocks into the draft.

Hope so. He showed a bit towards the end of the season.

Yes agree Ron.

Last 4 rounds of this year he averaged 20 touches (9 contested), 3 tackles and 4 marks. Not huge numbers but promising enough for a bloke who has only played 18 games.

Viv almost certainly offers more over the than pick 46 in a shallow draft.

I really hope we stick with him.

I think Viv has shown something when he has had a chance to play.
As said earlier, it looks like he is on a three year deal. Give him his last year then reassess. Unlike a lot of the players we want to give 'one more year' to, I think he might come good next year.

I think Viv has shown something when he has had a chance to play.

As said earlier, it looks like he is on a three year deal. Give him his last year then reassess. Unlike a lot of the players we want to give 'one more year' to, I think he might come good next year.

Could be famous last words CBF?

.Could be your contribution to the "Confessions" thread in 12 months time

Edited November 9, 201510 yr by old dee

Really hope we don't give up on this bloke. I've wanted him to do well since coming over from Freo and always watch him closely. He was one of our best in the four rounds and showed he has the tools to make it.

Surely he offers more than a late pick.

So we'll find out today for certain whether Michie was contracted for 2016 or not.

2:00pm is the deadline for OOC players to nominate for the draft, with the 2nd list lodegement dut tomorrow.

Looks like it must have been a 3 year deal he was initially on.

Nope To the rookie list. Stupid move in my view.

Nope To the rookie list. Stupid move in my view.

Agreed.

Are you a relative of Viv btw?

Agreed.

Are you a relative of Viv btw?

No. Spoken to him once. Just know people who know people. I take an interest in Viv because of his time at freo and more particularly Peel. Then moved here and he was over here. People at Peel will tell you what a great talent he is but has had serious injuries so never gets a real run at it. Even at MFC he split an eyelid first game and could not wear contact lens, dropped to the 2s and gets a broken Jaw. Never let the set backs get in his way. Just hope he gets another go but that looks like some sort of injury will be the main hope which no one wants. His biggest problem is he is such am introvert. Looking forward to his year and watching Tyson this year. Hes another good talent.

May or may not, but when I look at the list he and Matt Jones are the only players I truly shudder at.

Rewind to 3 years ago.... there were probably 15 players we shuddered at. The list turnover and replenishment has been huge.

Jack Grimes and then I'm with you.

Viv Michie has just been delisted. However the club is likely to redraft him as a rookie

http://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/2015-11-10/michie-delisted-in-second-list-lodgement

Interesting. Glad we're committed to re-drafting him as a rookie.

I suppose this is effectively confirms that Terlich will remain on the list for 2016.

Seems like the right decision to me.

The question is would he have played in the later part of the season if we had not had so many injuries?

The answer IMO is No.

Poor Viv.. if i was him id be shitty the fact Terlich is still on the senior list..

Anyway i guess that leaves us with 4 spots to take into the draft.

Nope To the rookie list. Stupid move in my view.

taking 4 draft picks is the way to go and if there are any early injuries he will be easily upgraded, and im not to sure about the rookie list but he can surely be a nominated rookie.

Of our rookie list last year, three were able to play games with Vandenberg playing round 1 and both Harmes and White earning a spot in the side later in the year, so it has no effect on his ability to play in the 1s.

Terlich being contracted meant that Melbourne had no other choice and it would have been stupid to not take a shot at a 4th pick in the draft. No doubt would we have asked Terlich if he wanted to be paid out of his contract but the offer was obviously not as good as one more year of AFL for Terls.

Poor Viv.. if i was him id be shitty the fact Terlich is still on the senior list..

Anyway i guess that leaves us with 4 spots to take into the draft.

I doubt it.

If the shoe was on the other foot, and Viv was contracted but Terlich wasn't and we cut Viv loose mid contract, he would be a lot more annoyed.

We have to honour contracts, I'm sorry that we made crappy list management decisions, but it isn't Terlich's fault.

It is the best solution given we need list space for draft and rookie promotions.

Viv only needs to speak to Jetta to understand that this is not the end of the world.

The only reason he was cut was because both of Jones and Terlich had a year to run on their contracts.

Hopefully he'll be back on the senior list soon, better than ever. Get Nev Jetta into his ear.

The only reason he was cut was because both of Jones and Terlich had a year to run on their contracts.

ironically. If i were to bet ...id say come this time next year M jones and Turls will both be gone.

Viv might also but of these three id only give Michie a chance of succeeding.

Its his to take if he's up for it.

Can't see Michie getting much game time this year.

Will be delisted with jones and terlich at years end.

Will be replaced with better players

Nope To the rookie list. Stupid move in my view.

Agreed.

I thought if we were to delist a player and then look to re-rookie them, then Jauden Hunt would have been most likely. Or even do it with Terlich, just like St Kilda have with Josh Saunders who's also contracted.

I thought Michie had shown enough to warrant a new deal, even for only 12 months ahead of a speculative Pick 50 (to be amneded) in a shallow draft.

I'm guessing the club think there was greater chance of Michie lasting until whichever rookie draft pick we select him at then there was of Hunt. Why they didn't look at rookie listing Terlich I don't know?

Either way, I hope we're able to re-draft Michie, as there's a very good chance someone else may swoop.

Agreed.

I thought if we were to delist a player and then look to re-rookie them, then Jauden Hunt would have been most likely. Or even do it with Terlich, just like St Kilda have with Josh Saunders who's also contracted.

I thought Michie had shown enough to warrant a new deal, even for only 12 months ahead of a speculative Pick 50 (to be amneded) in a shallow draft.

I'm guessing the club think there was greater chance of Michie lasting until whichever rookie draft pick we select him at then there was of Hunt. Why they didn't look at rookie listing Terlich I don't know?

Either way, I hope we're able to re-draft Michie, as there's a very good chance someone else may swoop.

First you would have to get his agreement.

If I were Terlich I would do as he has apparently done and say No Deal.

As for Michie ordinary is the best I saw