Casey Scorpions v Coburg

[KC from Casey 7,064]

Casey Scorpions v Coburg

Sunday 23 June 2013

at Casey Fields at 2:00pm

Casey Scorpions

Backs Smith Sellar Davis

Half backs J Tynan Gillies Jetta

Centreline Best Nicholls Panozza

Half forwards Tapscott Hughes Bail

Forwards Strauss Hogan L Tynan

Followers Gawn Magner Couch

Interchange (from) Barry Drew* Gent Hill Lindsay Petropoulos Pollard Riseley Taggert

Coburg

Backs Astbury Dea Batchelor

Half backs Carnell Elton Griffiths

Centreline Mcintosh Venditti O'Hanlon

Half forwards Arnot Nahas Helbig

Forwards McBean Stephenson N Maric

Followers Derickx Petterd Lonergan

Interchange (from) Boyd* Clifton Groves Iudica McDonough McGuane Robertella Thomas Verrier

* 23rd player

AFL Victoria Development League

Casey Scorpions v Coburg

Sunday 23 June 2013

at Casey Fields at 11:00am

Casey Scorpions

Backs Matthews Waters Boland

Half backs Corry Westrupp Hillard

Centreline Dearaugo Stark Barry

Half forwards Riseley Irwin Anderson

Forwards Roberts Rutherford Pollard

Followers Hill Lindsay McInnes

Interchange (from) Clay Fusinato Godfrey Jackson Lang Long M Rosier P Rosier Troutman

Coburg

Backs Bean Brown Robertella

Half backs Egglestone Iudica A Saad

Centreline Easton Brandt Abdallah

Half forwards Uysal O Saad Thomas

Forwards Dean Spagnolo Anderson Cleary

Followers Sortino Grgic Keogh

Interchange (from) Barrack Coots Drake Dundon Hogan Robinson T Quinlan Yelland

[titan_uranus 25,016]

Strauss in the forward pocket - is that something regular for him at Casey? Or is this new?

[rhaz 342]

Time for some blokes like Tynan, Taggert etc to step up. Back half of the season, new coach, push for the seniors boys...

[rjay 24,919]

Strauss in the forward pocket - is that something regular for him at Casey? Or is this new?

A bit like Nahas at CHF for Coburg...

[ucanchoose 1,816]

A bit like Nahas at CHF for Coburg...

lol. That's got to be a record for smallest Centre half forward

[BarnDee 287]

is the game on tele ?

[old dee 23,788]

is the game on tele ?

No it is on Sunday

[Whispering_Jack 30,054]

Kyle Matthews was once skipper of the Casey Scorpions, a courageous one and a really personable young bloke. Lately, he's been drifting between the periphery of their senior team and its development league (ressies) side and I've been wondering why. This long article provides some insight.

Men acquitted for brawl that injured VFL star

[Whispering_Jack 30,054]

Tweet by CaseyScorpions

"No comment will be made by the club in relation to the news article in today's Age. We will continue to support Kyle throughout this time."

[rjay 24,919]

Kyle Matthews was once skipper of the Casey Scorpions, a courageous one and a really personable young bloke. Lately, he's been drifting between the periphery of their senior team and its development league (ressies) side and I've been wondering why. This long article provides some insight.

Men acquitted for brawl that injured VFL star

A sad business this 'Jack'...

[monoccular 17,427]

Kyle Matthews was once skipper of the Casey Scorpions, a courageous one and a really personable young bloke. Lately, he's been drifting between the periphery of their senior team and its development league (ressies) side and I've been wondering why. This long article provides some insight.Men acquitted for brawl that injured VFL star

Hardly surprising.

The Australian 'justice' system never gets it right, and our judges are pathetically soft.

Feel for Kyle Matthews right now, but every Australian should be angry and fed up.

If Adrian Bayley cant get the maximum sentence for rape then who can?

I feel angry and fed up that once again a mixture of alcohol and testosterone has resulted in a very serious injury.

However the evidence, at least as outlined in the article, is heavily conflicted and criminal guilt requires a finding beyond reasonable doubt -- from the evidence outlined in the article there does seem doubt as to whom was the aggressor.

And yes I agree with your assertion regarding Bailey and just what, having been found guilty beyond reasonable doubt, what level of depravity and premeditation is required for a maximum sentence to be applied -- and more particularly in his previous offences.

Edited June 22, 2013 by monoccular

[dee-luded 2,959]

I feel angry and fed up that once again a mixture of alcohol and testosterone has resulted in a very serious injury.

However the evidence, at least as outlined in the article, is heavily conflicted and criminal guilt requires a finding beyond reasonable doubt -- from the evidence outlined in the article there does seem doubt as to whom was the aggressor.

And yes I agree with your assertion regarding Bailey and just what, having been found guilty beyond reasonable doubt, what level of depravity and premeditation is required for a maximum sentence to be applied -- and more particularly in his previous offences.

truth is, most of us, we just don't know. I don't know what happened, but I believe in Kyle Matthews,,,, & I don't know what transpired in court.

[dworship 3,342]

I feel angry and fed up that once again a mixture of alcohol and testosterone has resulted in a very serious injury.

However the evidence, at least as outlined in the article, is heavily conflicted and criminal guilt requires a finding beyond reasonable doubt -- from the evidence outlined in the article there does seem doubt as to whom was the aggressor.

And yes I agree with your assertion regarding Bailey and just what, having been found guilty beyond reasonable doubt, what level of depravity and premeditation is required for a maximum sentence to be applied -- and more particularly in his previous offences.

The problem with this, like the David Hookes case, is that Jury's are inherntly stupid and inexperienced in this environment. They don't understand that legal defense often relies on misrepresentation and arguement to muddy the waters and create doubt.

In this case and the the David Hookes case the victims were trying to leave and yes there was verbal abuse. In both cases the perpertrator CHOSE not to return inside and defuse the situation but to strike out and cause PHYSICAL harm. I don't think I need a lot of evidence and legal arguement to determine where guilt lies. Let the Judge determine severity and mitigating circumstances.

[deanox 9,914]

Without knowing anything other than that article, how can punching someone "because I thigh he was going to punch me" count as self defence?

[Earl Hood 6,086]

Without knowing anything other than that article, how can punching someone "because I thigh he was going to punch me" count as self defence?

It's the old street fighters first rule of defence, if an argument starts get in with the first hit. Usually ends the argument immediately. That a jury fell for the evidence presented where the perpetrator has felt threatened so has gone the king hit is sad but no use blaming the judge when its the jury system. The jury system is not perfect but it is much better than any alternative, a bit like democracy really.

[DeeSpencer 25,687]

If I was a juror and I heard a lawyer asking about killer Kyle as a nickname I would've heard enough to practically get up and leave. Anyone who has ever seen him play knows he isn't a killer. Not to mention he's about 70kg dripping wet.

Anyway they've seen the best defense on offer in the criminal case. Time to go hire a lawyer and win the civil case!

[titan_uranus 25,016]

Without knowing anything other than that article, how can punching someone "because I thigh he was going to punch me" count as self defence?

Essentially, deanox, one acts in self-defence when one perceives an immediate threat to themself. The argument here was that the defendant thought that Matthews was about to hurt him, and so acted in self-defence.

Edited June 22, 2013 by titan_uranus

[fatmanblues 10]

is there radio coverage?

[titan_uranus 25,016]

Really big game today for all MFC players, but in particular Davis, Magner, Couch and Taggert. They're all (largely) untried, but with a new coach and with some underperforming players, the chances will come.

[Whispering_Jack 30,054]

Bound for Glory News site has this MID SEASON REVIEW: CASEY SCORPIONS.

[titan_uranus 25,016]

Bound for Glory News site has this MID SEASON REVIEW: CASEY SCORPIONS.

Has Taggert as a 'big slider'. Not entirely consistent with what's been said about Rory on here, but each to their own I guess.

[KC from Casey 7,064]

Round 11 getting under way with the Scorps taking on one of the Tiger teams - this one's from Coburg!

The Development League team had a 38 point win to move into contention for a final's place.

Casey Scorpions 2.3.15 5.8.38 12.13.85 12.18.90

Coburg Tigers 1.4.10 3.7.25 5.7.37 7.10.52

Goals

Casey Scorpions Lang 3 Boland Rosier 2 Godfrey Dearaugo Godfrey Hill Lindsay McInnes

Coburg Tigers Anderson Robinson 2 Brandt Cleary Yelland

Best

Casey Scorpions Rosier Jackson Troutman Lindsay Lang Hill

Coburg Tigers Robertella Egglestone Drake Yelland Easton Keogh

[The Song Formerly Known As 6,479]

Hogan to kick 4.

[KC from Casey 7,064]

Quarter Time: Casey Scorpions 3.5.23 to Coburg Tigers 1.2.8

Stats Gent 9 Pollard 7 Nicholls Sellar 6

Goals Best Hogan Hughes

[Demon_Tingles 211]

Any updates ?