Collingwood v Casey Scorpions

[KC from Casey 7,059]

Collingwood v Casey Scorpions

Saturday 18th August

Victoria Park at 1:00 PM

Collingwood

Backs Mooney Ceglar Cribbin

Half backs Thomas McNamara K Pendlebury

Centreline Young Krakouer Ugle

Half forwards Gault Macaffer Smith

Forwards Rounds Witts Buckley

Followers Wood Johnson Yagmoor

Interchange (from) Cathcart Corr Ferraro Hine Riddle Stubbs Sundberg Wallace

Casey Scorpions

Backs Clay Davis Riseley

Half backs Petropoulos Panozza Hill

Centreline Sheahan Gysberts L Tynan

Half forwards Nicholls Collins Moloney

Forwards Corry Bate Smith

Followers Fitzpatrick Lindsay McGough

Interchange (from) Cook Fieldsend Gent Matthews Page Patti Pollard J Tynan Viney*

* 23rd player

Brett Lovett coaches his 150th game on Saturday.

The AFL Development League  side has a bye.

[Brian Wilson 331]

Viney? Viney!

[olisik 4,060]

Cook on the bench...

[dazzledavey36 54,282]

Leigh Williams?

[kieranbj 111]

Leigh Williams hurt himself last week at Casey. Looked like an ankle. I don't understand why he wasn't named on the injury list or mentioned in the weekly Dave Misson interview.

Is that Kyle Matthews on the bench? If so that is fantastic, a wonderful player to watch.

[Whispering_Jack 29,788]

Leigh Williams hurt himself last week at Casey. Looked like an ankle. I don't understand why he wasn't named on the injury list or mentioned in the weekly Dave Misson interview.

Is that Kyle Matthews on the bench? If so that is fantastic, a wonderful player to watch.

Leigh Williams did get hurt at Casey but let's face it, we need a mystery injury every week and Williams looks like he's it this week. He was doing well before injured.

And it is Kyle Matthews who has recovered from two shoulder injuries. He kicked five goals about this time last year on his return from injury, so here's hoping!

[Matt Demon 1,418]

Viney? Viney!

School footy has finished for the year so I suggest we'll see Viney playing the last few rounds. I wonder if he's eligible to play finals? KC?

[Pates 9,660]

Don't go too well Jack, we still want to take you with a 2nd rounder!

[Little Richard 6,262]

Leigh Williams did get hurt at Casey but let's face it, we need a mystery injury every week and Williams looks like he's it this week. He was doing well before injured.

And it is Kyle Matthews who has recovered from two shoulder injuries. He kicked five goals about this time last year on his return from injury, so here's hoping!

Was it Kyle Matthews who was king hit a couple of years ago and ended up in a pretty bad way? If so great to see him playing again, good on him and hopefully he kicks a few.

[old dee 23,781]

Was it Kyle Matthews who was king hit a couple of years ago and ended up in a pretty bad way? If so great to see him playing again, good on him and hopefully he kicks a few.

Yes

[Nascent 9,107]

No Pickles or Nicho... disappointing.

[Whispering_Jack 29,788]

No Pickles or Nicho... disappointing.

More candidates for the mystery injury of the week.

Looking at the two line ups, you can see a significant difference between the Magpies and the Demons.

Collingwood has 17 AFL listed players available compared with Casey's eight.

Things are going to be tough for the Scorpions from this point on.

[Dr. Mubutu 831]

Excellent to see Matthews back in again. Inspirational stuff.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

Cook on the bench...

Leigh Williams?

Its telling that while a rookie FF is now out injured it does not result in Cook being named in the 18. Hardly a vote of confidence. Will be watching ABC with interest to see whats on show.

[poita 3,892]

So, by my count, we have 16 players unavailable this week? Our inability to get our players on the field is breathtaking.

[jurrahcane 70]

yes, its that time where Melbourne's contribution to Casey goes from 14-15 players to 10 to 9 to 8. By the end there will be only 3-4 MFC listed players in Caseys finals. Straight sets for the 3 year running !!

39 listed+ 7 rookies = 46

22 Demons

1 reserve - Magner

5 (??) - Nicholson ... rested. Martin ... rested. Jamar ... rested, Evans ... rested (played last week and finsihed the game). Mystery illness - Leigh Williams.

2 Lawrence and Jurrah - leave passes.

8 Season ending injuries- Gawn, Bartram, Clark, Davey, Taggert, Bennell, Morton, Petterd

= 8 to Casey

Imagine us having a standalone team (we have David Misson as the master ???????????)

[rjay 24,883]

Imagine us having a standalone team (we have David Misson as the master ???????????)

Not sure what the point is here but on the injury list we haven't had the soft tissue injuries that a club like Essendon is having, mostly structural which you can't blame the him for.

Think we will see the benefits of Misson in the next couple of seasons, as for Casey well I guess with the Dees struggling we put more focus on Casey, at least one of our sides has been winning. In the end game it's really not that important.

[monoccular 17,413]

Its telling that while a rookie FF is now out injured it does not result in Cook being named in the 18. Hardly a vote of confidence. Will be watching ABC with interest to see whats on show.

It certainly isn't a great vote of confidence that our much maligned first round pick is "coming along nicely".

I know he hasn't had a preseason, talls take time etc but even he must be starting to have his doubts.

Worrying signs even the super optimists would have to concede.

[Redleg 40,837]

It certainly isn't a great vote of confidence that our much maligned first round pick is "coming along nicely".

I know he hasn't had a preseason, talls take time etc but even he must be starting to have his doubts.

Worrying signs even the super optimists would have to concede.

According to some on here it is not his fault, or lack of ability, it is development. He is obviously a great footballer who is being hampered by MFC development. When he takes his eyes off the ball again it is the club's fault. I hope he makes it, but agree it is starting to get worrying.

[Jumping Jack Clennett 1,778]

Its telling that while a rookie FF is now out injured it does not result in Cook being named in the 18. Hardly a vote of confidence. Will be watching ABC with interest to see whats on show.

I hope it IS on ABC, but the programme guide says they're doing the Port Melb game.

[Matt Demon 1,418]

It's NOT on ABC

[KC from Casey 7,059]

Definitely not the televised game this week but next week's game v Sandringham is the ABC1 game.

[nutbean 8,838]

It certainly isn't a great vote of confidence that our much maligned first round pick is "coming along nicely".

I know he hasn't had a preseason, talls take time etc but even he must be starting to have his doubts.

Worrying signs even the super optimists would have to concede.

This is not a comment on Cook - this a comment on teamsheets.

Does anyone take the slightest bit of notice of the positions ? I expect that team selection may be over a couple of hours and they take about a minute and a half to put them in positions. In the seniors this week Grimes in on the wing - I have seen him play in the middle - has anyone ever seen him on the wing ? Scully is on the wing and McKenzie is in the centre - does anyone doubt that McKenzie will start on Scully ? Howe has started nearly every game up the ground - he is named in the forward pocket. Player positions named by clubs should be taken with passing amusement at best.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

This is not a comment on Cook - this a comment on teamsheets.

Does anyone take the slightest bit of notice of the positions ?

Fair point.

If Clark, Gawn, Willams and a couple of others were fit, do you think Cook would maintain his position on the bench?

Pizzed off its not on the ABC especially playing Collingwood!!!

[KC from Casey 7,059]

Scorps kicking to the Yarra Falls end and score the opening goal but not before Jack Fitzpatrick kicks the opening behind of the day (as usual).

Casey 1.1.7 Collingwood 0.0.0