On: Dunn

Off: Sellar

Make it happen please Mark.

effort improved.

decision making with and without ball needs work but we already knew that.

Moloney needs to get his own ball, lurking around for the easy one. He could learn something from Morton.

Also, looks almost like Clark has become a "de facto" captain... he was standing there hand-slapping his team mates as they exited the rooms and giving each player words of encouragement.

He and Jones are the two players that have played every minute they've been on the field this season with their hearts on their sleeves. We need that from everyone else on the list.

I thought the same thing Hardtack. Mitch might not be tossing the coin but he's playing like a leader.

Thank god for him and Jonesy.

On: Dunn

Off: Sellar

Make it happen please Mark.

Nice in theory, but what if Jamar goes down in the first minute?

We don't even have Watts in there to ruck.

It's a great analogy. You get a reprieve and think "yay it's over", then again.

If you think we are not that bad you are kidding yourself. We are lucky Geelong can't convert. Minus 60 in uncontested possessions and it's only half time!

Just because we are not 100 points down doesn't mean it's happy days. Trying hard is not good enough, it's a bloody given.

I appreciate that we are not lying down and giving up, but our skills and decision making is just woeful. I doubt Mark Neeld is in there praising them.

No-one's saying it's happy days - but I agree with the earlier post, I checked here at half time and can't believe how unrelentingly bleak many of the posts are. Clark great, Tapscott better than he's been all year, Davey getting going, McDonald showing a bit ...

Also, looks almost like Clark has become a "de facto" captain... he was standing there hand-slapping his team mates as they exited the rooms and giving each player words of encouragement.

Agree. He's a gun. He cares about the jumper and he would be a brilliant captain.

sellar not a player...how he gets a game ahead of petterd or watts is beyond me

When an umpire pulls a free like that you know he is sweating on an opportunity to make a margin.... Some cricket teams are familiar with this tactic

Sellar ain't no player.

Spud

People would disagree, but Stef Martin is surely a better option. Quicker, better ruck chop out, and does actually take a grab. As a spoiling defender Sellar may have a role against bigger bodies, but he is useless in the forward line.

Happy with:

The scoreline; should be worse, but they didn't take all their chances, thankfully we have.

Clark is worth what we're paying, get a more competitive midfield he'll look even better.

Morton has back up last week with a good showing in the first half, some good tackles and isn't over thinking things.

Davey quiet but what he's has been good.

Mackenzie was doing a good job on Bartel, let him kick a goal and the umpires gifted him another

Not happy with:

Intensity still isn't there, both quarters we were lucky not to have 4 goals kicked on us in the first 5-10min.

Silly mistakes, moving the ball in the wrong direction in the wrong way.

THAT free kick at the end of the half, disgraceful.

grimes slung and no free

Where's our cheap 25 metres out directly in front gift?

Losing is one thing - getting a fair go something else.

Need to get it into 25m first. One step at a time...

Moloney needs to get his own ball, lurking around for the easy one. He could learn something from Morton.

He's what I call a front runner, once the ball isn't an option for him, he stops running and isn't accountable.

sellar not a player...how he gets a game ahead of petterd or watts is beyond me

Sadly looks like the Crows were right to delist him.

Support your team! fer chrissake.

Even if it's only an internet forum.

The amount of negative talk is unbelievable.

I was gonna go with "understandable"

Mitch Clark, recruit of the year so far.

All up pretty happy with what I am seeing today, and must say have been a big pessimist this year. We seem to be working a bit more together as a team each week which is great to see. 3 glaring issues with our game appear to be:

1. Running. When every possession we have is contested and then other teams find loose men everywhere coming back the other way, it says we are not spreading hard enough when we get the ball, and manning up/chasing hard enough when we don't.

2. Tackling. Way too many of our tackles don't stick, and as a result we have two or three blokes trying to complete a tackle on the one opponent. This inevitably results in loose opposition players around the contest able to receive and run free if the ball does come out.

3. Kicking to advantage. As frustrating as it is that every time we go forward we are not kicking to an open forward or hitting up one on a lead,it is far worse that whe we kick to a contest it seems we kick to the advantage of the opposition. Surely senior AFL players should have enough control over their disposal to at least put the ball to the same side of a contest that our bloke is standing.

These 3 areas have been consistent shortfalls of our play every game this year. At the very least if we can improve our running I would think we would have picked up the games against WB and the Saints.

All that being said, I have been happy to see the improvement this week, just hope we can make some gains in these 3 areas and really pick up our competitiveness every week!

Garland having a shot from 70m, no faith in teammates in the f50 one out.

God our disposal is poor. It's just killing any hope of momentum. You realise how poor when you plays the Cats.

Fantastic goal by Bate from 55

Trengove to Garland to Bate inside 50. 2 good passes in a row. And Bate goals to capitalise on the good work.

Better 2nd half

2 good kicks from Tommy MAC!

We are hanging in there.

Fantastic goal by Bate from 55

Aided by a stiff breeze, we'll take it.

That was a nice passage of play off HB.