Shane Valenti

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

[Redleg 40,469]

Shane Valenti is Kevin Rudd.

No-one was saying such nice things when he played for us. It's only once he's gone that people think they really liked him all along and were mad to let him go.

How quickly we forget.

We are striving for excellence. Valenti has some excellent attributes. AFL footballer isn't one of them.

He was considered too small and too slow for AFL.

[Lutz 76]

He can do that because it's a VFL match.

At AFL level he'd get run down every time.

[Carlos Danger 380]

He can do that because it's a VFL match.

At AFL level he'd get run down every time.

Must have been on a good day, watched bits and pieces of a Port game earlier this year (think it was against Werribee) where he got done for holding the ball 3 times in 15 minutes.

[ex52k2 238]

Just watched the VFL grand final, posters on here were right, Gary Ayers cant coach. Has no hope of any AFL future, cant get the best out of his players. One word in answer to that. Crap!

Watch the game, see the effort he gets see the pressure, hard at the ball and the opposition. a stand alone club week after week playing against aligned clubs with stacked sides.

2011....... Every game a winner. Lets see Malthouse or anybody else do that. Mighty effort by ALL involved.

Hope to see some of the players drafted, some good small forwards there.

[Dee Fan 3,247]

Rudd was a good poli' at thestart til he worked himself into one foot in the ground and the other in the manic room.

He nearly all but burnt out. His sacking has saved him for another day.

Sorry Taxi Tony. But your days are numbered.

Who'll give odds whether numbskull Tony A, is shot down by friendly fire, before, or just after the next election?

Abbot will win the next election easily, but what prey tell has that got to do with drafting Valenti or his football ability?

For that mater what has that got to do with anything football?

[TheVoice 33]

Loved Valenti when he was on our list and was disappointed not to see him play more. His application and ball smarts were fantastic. Was sad to see him get cut especially when others on the list possessed but a fraction of his heart. Unfortunately heart only gets you so far on an AFL list and his lack of size and whatever else they thought he lacked made the decision for them.

Congratulations on your second Liston and good luck with your future footy endeavours shane. Would love to see you get picked up by another club. All the best.

[Triple Jack 13]

People said he wasn't up to it when at melbourne. Which may be a fair call but i remember him playing about 8 of the last 10 games of his final year and was in our bests a couple of times. I remember loving his hardness and thought that he was a little stiff. But now you look back and think he was only 21 or 22 at the time. We have players like Morton who are that age that played a lot worse then he did back then. His Clearance work in the GF and all year was first class and is a player that wouldn't look totally out of place on any list

[jumbo returns 6,725]

Just watched the VFL grand final, posters on here were right, Gary Ayers cant coach. Has no hope of any AFL future, cant get the best out of his players. One word in answer to that. Crap!

Watch the game, see the effort he gets see the pressure, hard at the ball and the opposition. a stand alone club week after week playing against aligned clubs with stacked sides.

2011....... Every game a winner. Lets see Malthouse or anybody else do that. Mighty effort by ALL involved.

Hope to see some of the players drafted, some good small forwards there.

The Club should have a look at Patrick Rose - small forward, lovely kick, has been in the system for quite a while now and presents with a mature body. Won the goal kicking this year and really knows how to create space for the bigger forwards.

I think he'll make the transition easily.

We've been crying out for a small forward since Wona's horrible year (no fault of his own) and Maric's inability to make the grade.

[Carlos Danger 380]

Looks like he's going to Essendon...

http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/dons-set-to-draft-liston-winner-20111210-1oovf.html

[monoccular 17,360]

I was dissapointed when we delisted him, especially seeing we persist with players like Newton.

And you ain't, as they say, Robertson Caruso on that mate.

I was a great fan of one but not the other.

[Dee Fan 3,247]

Back to the point of the thread I reckon Valenti was hard done by, we dropped him after he played his best game for us and he was certainly better than a few others on the list. I hope he gets picked up but not by Essendon I would hate to have to hate him.

[Nasher 33,607]

I've deleted all the politics related posts in this thread. Choko's reference to Rudd was an anecdotal throwaway, please treat it as such and don't use it to hijack footy related threads. Thanks.

[old55 23,113]

Adam Fisher says hi

[Whispering_Jack 29,387]

Adam Fisher says hi

I hope for your sake Adam Fisher is no relation to Andrew Fisher because, if so, your post is doomed to a short lifetime!

[Mono 455]

Looks like he's going to Essendon...

http://www.theage.co...1210-1oovf.html

I won't re-open the debate.

I hope he gets picked and is a real success.