No official injury report update MFC

[John Crow Batty 8,831]

Why is it that there hasn't been an official injury report update from the club on their website? 18 days since the last report and two NAB cup games in between. Very unusual. Anything to hide or just slackness?

Edited February 28, 2011 by america de cali

[Guest Thomo]

Why is it that there hasn't been an official injury report update from the club on their website? 18 days since the last report and two NAB cup games in between. Very unusual. Anything to hide or just slackness?

I'm pretty sure it means Scully is gone.

[DeezMan 4]

I'm pretty sure it means Scully is gone.

LOL!

[John Crow Batty 8,831]

I'm pretty sure it means Scully is gone.

I wouldn't go as far as that. But if so it is good they are not telling official porky's. Then again ostrich farming is not widely considered a profitable business.

[Whispering_Jack 29,359]

I'm not sure what an official injury list means but the afl.com.au site usually publishes an injury list for all clubs every Tuesday.

Such lists aren't usually accurate but sometimes the players listed are actually injured.

[No16 1]

Updated:

Melbourne injury list

Campbell (achilles) - 6-8 weeks

Davis (thyroid disorder) - 6-8 weeks

Fitzpatrick (foot) - 3-5 weeks

Frawley (shoulder) - 4 weeks

Garland (calf) - test

Gawn (knee) - test

McKenzie (groin) - 1-2 weeks

Morton (hand) - 5-6 weeks

Newton (hand) - 4 weeks

Scully (knee) - Test

[Je Roos Salem 661]

Updated:

Melbourne injury list

Campbell (achilles) - 6-8 weeks

Davis (thyroid disorder) - 6-8 weeks

Fitzpatrick (foot) - 3-5 weeks

Frawley (shoulder) - 4 weeks

Garland (calf) - test

Gawn (knee) - test

McKenzie (groin) - 1-2 weeks

Morton (hand) - 5-6 weeks

Newton (hand) - 4 weeks

Scully (knee) - Test

I'm quite pleased to see Frawley is only 4 away. That'd mean a Round 2 return? Sad about Campbell, however

[Jaded No More 68,691]

Chip down to 4 weeks. Excellent!!!!!!

[Keyser Söze 0]

I'd question the accuracy of that - he is listed as having a shoulder injury, when everyone knows it is his pectoral muscle.

He's fit when I see him on the park, and until then I couldn't care less about these token lists...

[John Crow Batty 8,831]

Wish Troy Davis a speedy recovery for his thyroid disorder.

[45HG 1,539]

I'm not sure what an official injury list means but the afl.com.au site usually publishes an injury list for all clubs every Tuesday.

Such lists aren't usually accurate but sometimes the players listed are actually injured.

and sometimes those not listed are actually injured, but then again some aren't. And sometimes some players are not listed as injured but don't appear listed anywhere as being uninjured and as such able to play for the firsts, seconds or thirds.

[bing181 9,138]

Biggest worry there is McKenzie ... has the look of something that could drag on and on ... and on. We need him, especially with Junior gone.

We have some great young players coming into the midfield, but with McKenzie, Blease, Gysberts (and Scully) still not playing, it's looking fairly thin at the moment.

Good opportunity for the likes of Jetta - if he can take it.

As for some of the other comments here re the injury list in general, there's a difference between 'injured' and 'not fit'. Wonna (for example) isn't on the injury list, but isn't ready to play yet. Presumably, same goes for the likes of Tapscott and Gysberts, both of whom are coming off injuries.

[dee-luded 2,959]

I'd question the accuracy of that - he is listed as having a shoulder injury, when everyone knows it is his pectoral muscle.

He's fit when I see him on the park, and until then I couldn't care less about these token lists...

A lot of everday punters are not up with the proper names of muscles &/or bones. Many wouldn't know what a pec' is.

But it does effect, in a major way, the use of the shoulder & arm associated. So it could be an easy explanation to loosely describe the issue.

[DeezMan 4]

My inside knowledge of McKenzie having OP is looking like a good thing... unfortunately.

[Keyser Söze 0]

A lot of everday punters are not up with the proper names of muscles &/or bones. Many wouldn't know what a pec' is.

But it does effect, in a major way, the use of the shoulder & arm associated. So it could be an easy explanation to loosely describe the issue.

Hahaha you are kidding, aren't you?

Who the hell doesn't know what a pec is?

Or at the very least what a pectoral muscle is?

I refuse to accept that they assume people are that ignorant.

Hamstring injuries can (do) affect your back.

They still list it as a hamstring, rather than a back injury.

You're clutching at straws.

[old dee 23,557]

Here is a big prediction Folks

"Campbell will not play a game for the demons at AFL level!"

Reason: big guys with poor injury records do not get over serious Achilles problems easily.

I have the feeling our gamble with him we be a flop.

Probably not a big loss however dissapointing he may not get on the park.

Edited March 2, 2011 by old dee

[Good Times Grimes 2,396]

My inside knowledge of McKenzie having OP is looking like a good thing... unfortunately.

How long is one usually out with osteitis pubis for? I remember Rivers had it, but I can't recall how long we missed him.

[DeezMan 4]

How long is one usually out with osteitis pubis for? I remember Rivers had it, but I can't recall how long we missed him.

It varies. Remember Moloney's OP?? He was out for ages - played 18 games over three years!!!

It can be quite a hampering injury but, if treated early, can be overcome more quickly.

Fingers crossed for Jordie!!

[dee-luded 2,959]

Hahaha you are kidding, aren't you?

Who the hell doesn't know what a pec is?

Or at the very least what a pectoral muscle is?

I refuse to accept that they assume people are that ignorant.

Hamstring injuries can (do) affect your back.

They still list it as a hamstring, rather than a back injury.

You're clutching at straws.

I was at a MFc get together recently and was asked by a footy follower, what the patella was. I know plenty of people, usually of the older generations, that have No Idea about medical names of the body.

You need to get out amongst a wider circle of the population. there are many who aren't so obseesive about their passion as your good self. It may help you to understand those people a lilttle more.

Other than that, the MFC may not have wanted to be more explicit.

Really is cyclone abbott in a thymbol. Isn't it.

[Deestroy All 14,262]

I was at a MFc get together recently and was asked by a footy follower, what the patella was. I know plenty of people, usually of the older generations, that have No Idea about medical names of the body.

You need to get out amongst a wider circle of the population. there are many who aren't so obseesive about their passion as your good self. It may help you to understand those people a lilttle more.

Other than that, the MFC may not have wanted to be more explicit.

Really is cyclone abbott in a thymbol. Isn't it.

What does the thing that makes an aeroplane go have to do with footy?

[John Crow Batty 8,831]

It varies. Remember Moloney's OP?? He was out for ages - played 18 games over three years!!!

It can be quite a hampering injury but, if treated early, can be overcome more quickly.

Fingers crossed for Jordie!!

Didn't Stephen Powell miss heaps of games with this injury? Never the same when he returned.

[Jaded No More 68,691]

What does the thing that makes an aeroplane go have to do with footy?

The medical secretary who works for my orthopedic surgeon made an appointment for me with another specialist, for my "shoulder". When I said to her it was for my knee, she said "well why does your file say patella?". Words don't do justice to how much stupidity exists in this world

Edited March 2, 2011 by Jaded