Jump to content
  • Podcast: Glen Bartlett Interview &      

Sign in to follow this  
DirtyDees DDC

THE TOM SCULLY TO GWS THREAD

Recommended Posts

thank you for actually posting some CONTENT on the topic, unlike some others

I believe the VFL was struggling a bit when national expansion started happening, and yes, it helped bring it back to life

However, the situation NOW is that it is NOT struggling - the current model seems perfectly sustainable

All that's going to happen is that smaller clubs like us and North will get shafted, beginning with this player poaching

It's AFL expansion that has lead to the current state and that expansion is incomplete. The only reason North and Melbourne exist let alone have an opportunity of winning a flag is because of AFL policies - salary cap, draft, equalisation - even if there was an equal fixture if you took away these AFL rules then we would be unable to compete and probably unable to survive. It's part of the whole package - it's the height of hypocrisy to suggest that the AFL are stealing our opportunity.

The AFL is in a special position where there is only one top level league in the world, it means we can retain the best players in our league - similar to NFL. This is not possible with soccer or the fragmented rugby codes - salary cap is impossible in soccer. The AFL wants to consolidate as the national football code, dominant in every state and has the attractive code, funds and determination to do it. AFL has the upper hand, soccer took a massive blow with the WC decision - no further opportunty until 2030 and a guaranteed 2nd or 3rd rate local competition - now's the time for the AFL to put the other codes to the sword. It's a long road that we've embarked on and there'll be some collateral casualties - I'd absolutely hate to lose Tom Scully to GWS but I understand he's only at Melbourne because the AFL made it so.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Maybe it's selfish reasons for you and you're only concerned about MFC?

That's exactly right. I don't think i'm talking garbage when I say T.Scully may well be the best player in the comp in a few years, and by extension I don't think it is entirely unreasonable to suggest that his retention or his loss could be the difference between premiership or runner-up for us. So if the AFL gives these clubs a gift basket that ultimately robs us of a flag you can bet I'm against it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's AFL expansion that has lead to the current state and that expansion is incomplete. The only reason North and Melbourne exist let alone have an opportunity of winning a flag is because of AFL policies - salary cap, draft, equalisation - even if there was an equal fixture if you took away these AFL rules then we would be unable to compete and probably unable to survive. It's part of the whole package - it's the height of hypocrisy to suggest that the AFL are stealing our opportunity.

The AFL is in a special position where there is only one top level league in the world, it means we can retain the best players in our league - similar to NFL. This is not possible with soccer or the fragmented rugby codes - salary cap is impossible in soccer. The AFL wants to consolidate as the national football code, dominant in every state and has the attractive code, funds and determination to do it. AFL has the upper hand, soccer took a massive blow with the WC decision - no further opportunty until 2030 and a guaranteed 2nd or 3rd rate local competition - now's the time for the AFL to put the other codes to the sword. It's a long road that we've embarked on and there'll be some collateral casualties - I'd absolutely hate to lose Tom Scully to GWS but I understand he's only at Melbourne because the AFL made it so.

I just cannot see this vision that people seem to have of footy losing some sort of war to soccer. How is it ever going to happen? Perhaps I lack your big picture vision but I preferred the game the way it used to be, it was tougher (now cleaned up to appease the mothers) clubs had tradition (unlike Freo, Port etc) players were more loyal because everything wasn't about money, the draw was more even because it wasn't all about TV rights etc etc etc It just seems that every decision gets made on the basis of what makes the AFL more cash, even if it is to the detriment of the game or to the distinct disadvantage of the minnow clubs

PS yes the AFL gave us Tom Scully, but they gave Hawthorn Franklin and Hodge, Collingwood Thomas and Pendlebury etc etc and they got their flags out of it, Carlton, Richmond etc have all been just as gifted as we

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That's exactly right. I don't think i'm talking garbage when I say T.Scully may well be the best player in the comp in a few years, and by extension I don't think it is entirely unreasonable to suggest that his retention or his loss could be the difference between premiership or runner-up for us. So if the AFL gives these clubs a gift basket that ultimately robs us of a flag you can bet I'm against it.

Yes, but you can't possibly expect the AFL to adopt the same mindset.

They are concerned with the future of the game as a whole.

Really drifting off on a tangent though, aren't we?

Not sure how this is relevant to Scully staying or leaving.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Can be bothered checking all 5 pages, can someone tell me if there is an article or source besides what the bloke heard on the radio?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Nope.

All unsubstantiated rumour to the point no media outlet is willing to put it in writing.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The offer was real. He has already declined. Fact.

Who are you and what do you really know?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I hope he does both his knees and is sidelined for 18 months. Only kidding, but I don't think I could bear 6 months of reading and hearing "he might, he will, he won't".

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Newbie with 3 posts. Alert alert.....

Aug 09 isn't exactly a newbie, just someone who is selective with what they post.

For whatever reason.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The offer was real. He has already declined. Fact.

Would be interesting to know the source????

I spoke to Mr Scully who stated he hadn't spoken to anyone about his contract next year including MFC and GWS (maybe he's lying to me ;)

He did say that if GWS were to offer him a sh^t load he would look at it or words to the effect 'I would be stupid not to consider it.' Source: T Scully

Edited by Wolfmother

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think he's right in saying that.

Anyone would be stupid not to consider it in isolation.

It's just that it doesn't take into consideration what we could offer him; that being, much more than Geelong was able to offer Ablett.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Of course he'll take that into consideration but if the figures are true it is double or 2.5 times his MFC salary for next year.... he's not staying for MCG, mates, flags etc etc and why would he

Edited by Wolfmother

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Of course he'll take that into consideration but if the figures are true it is double by 2.5 times his MFC salary for next year.... he's not staying for MCG, mates, flags etc etc and why would he

I'm confused

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Of course he'll take that into consideration but if the figures are true it is double or 2.5 times his MFC salary for next year.... he's not staying for MCG, mates, flags etc etc and why would he

How can you possibly profess to know what MFC would offer him for his new contract next year?

With front-loading we could come close to matching it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Of course he'll take that into consideration but if the figures are true it is double or 2.5 times his MFC salary for next year.... he's not staying for MCG, mates, flags etc etc and why would he

Cannot agree Wolfie. We are not talking about your average wage and salary earners. Theses kids don't grow up with posters on their wall of bags of money, or shares in BHP, or how to set up a self managed super fund. They have posters of their stars or their team holding up the premiership cup (if they're lucky). It's their dream and there is only a limited timeframe for players to achieve their goal - say from 18 to a max of 35 years. Tom will want that to happen sooner rather than later, and Melboune should be pushing for top 4 within 3 years, whereas GWS seem to be looking at an 7-10 year timeframe.

There are also enough chances for a player to earn good money off the field once they finish their career, as coaches or player development officials or even AFL management. They don't have to put all their eggs in one basket and go for broke on player wages. They also increase their employability if they are part of a premiership team.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest Thomo

How can you possibly profess to know what MFC would offer him for his new contract next year?

With front-loading we could come close to matching it.

You think that the MFC can come close to matching $6 mil over 6 years?

Melbourne have Watts, Frawley, Trengove, Davey, Sylvia, Jurrah, Green, Grimes all able to command big dollars now or in their next contract, plus the possibility of other stars emerging, plus mature players one average AFL money, with a standard salary cap.

GWS have a heap of draft picks and an extended salary cap. GWS could have the first two years at $2.5m.

How can MFC possibly be able to match them? How will front loading help when there are half a dozen other big contracts to sign?

Edited by Thomo

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest Rojik of the Arctic
How can MFC possibly be able to match them?

Quite simply you don't. You give him a hefty pay rise (as he would get anyway) and you hope that tradition, direction, culture and mateship are more important to him than money.

You only have to look at the problems the Bears are having with Fev's wage and how little wriggle room they have with signings to see how destructive this sort of game would be to us.

Tom will make a lot of money out of the MFC if he plays out his career here plus he will get some other bloody nice benefits as well. Can that other plastic team offer that?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Don't know if this has already been mentioned but this is a real offer.

my mates dad is on the board or something and he told me so im pretty sure.

i really hope he stays... obviously

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Don't know if this has already been mentioned but this is a real offer.

my mates dad is on the board or something and he told me so im pretty sure.

i really hope he stays... obviously

Your mates dad is on the Board of what, BHP, NAB or perhaps the Sydney Swans? If you are going to offer up something like that at least get your facts all together.

This is the problem, people can start rumours and they spread even though they are without any real foundation or basis whatsoever.

I could go on to bigfooty and say that player X had been approached by GWS and I guarantee that it would finish as up a thread like this on the particular club's supporter board.

I just love these "I've got a mate whose father's boss is on the board, or is an official I think at (insert any club here) and he reckons that (insert player) is definitely going to GWS next year for 70 Squillion a year for ten years".

Tom Scully may or may not be going to GWS next year but i can bet one thing it is highly unlikely that some North Melbourne Official or whatever knows it for a fact.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You think that the MFC can come close to matching $6 mil over 6 years?

Melbourne have Watts, Frawley, Trengove, Davey, Sylvia, Jurrah, Green, Grimes all able to command big dollars now or in their next contract, plus the possibility of other stars emerging, plus mature players one average AFL money, with a standard salary cap.

GWS have a heap of draft picks and an extended salary cap. GWS could have the first two years at $2.5m.

How can MFC possibly be able to match them? How will front loading help when there are half a dozen other big contracts to sign?

You're right, IF it comes down to coin GWS would blow us out of the water.

MFC could however still make Tom a very attractive offer and after say 3 more years he is still very young and probably still very marketable.

Committing himself at this stage to a club that will struggle for a few years on and off the field seems pointless and unneccesary. At least to me, I hope he doesn't see it differently.

I'll still be nervous until he signs (with us).

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You think that the MFC can come close to matching $6 mil over 6 years?

Melbourne have Watts, Frawley, Trengove, Davey, Sylvia, Jurrah, Green, Grimes all able to command big dollars now or in their next contract, plus the possibility of other stars emerging, plus mature players one average AFL money, with a standard salary cap.

GWS have a heap of draft picks and an extended salary cap. GWS could have the first two years at $2.5m.

How can MFC possibly be able to match them? How will front loading help when there are half a dozen other big contracts to sign?

We won't be able to exactly match any offer from GWS.

I said close.

Depends on your definition of close.

I think close enough to keep him here.

Also, I think his earning power away from the club with endorsements, etc is greater in Melbourne.

But it's not all about money for a kid his age.

Far from it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Social Media

  • Match Previews, Reports & Articles

    PACK YOUR BAGS by George on The Outer

    The scene was captured by the TV camera’s before the match with a view of the Melbourne side’s bags packed next to the team bus to facilitate their flight up north to the AFL hub where they will play their next matches. However, on the basis of the efforts against Richmond, unless things change, and change rapidly, there will be some who will be told to pack their bags on a more permanent basis. Once again, the supporters got much the same story from this match against Richmond, as

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Match Reports

    SOUTH OF THE BORDER by the Oracle

    Thankfully they moved this week’s game from Sydney where the sun shines and the virus breeds ever so slowly and almost nobody returns a positive test. The change of fixture comes at precisely the right time to allow everyone in town to head to the MCG on Sunday at around 3:30pm, not to catch up with what’s going on inside the ground but rather, to do what’s fashionable for woke folk in 2020 — pulling down statues. It’s time for Kevin Bartlett and Leigh Matthews to go but you can’t touch Norm Smi

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Match Previews

    LESSONS IN LOSING by George on the Outer

    Turn up for the game and look like you want to win it.  Melbourne lost this game to Geelong, a game after a couple of extended breaks, looking like they were at the end of a 22 game season. Right from the start there was a lack of intensity across the board, as the Demons played exactly the type of game that the ageing Geelong list wanted. Geelong repeatedly played possession footy, to avoid having to run those ageing legs, something that Melbourne failed to exploit.  To use the oft quot

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Match Reports

    QUARRANTINO by Whispering Jack

    At a little after 4.00pm last Saturday, the MCG ceased to be the centre of the AFL universe. That was when the AFL’s el supremo Gil McLaughlin announced that the Bombers’ Conor McKenna had returned a COVID-19 positive result and declared that the game set for the following day between Essendon and Melbourne was postponed.  What followed was truly the stuff of a pulp fiction novel. We witnessed a suitcase load of mental gymnastics and spin calculated to let McKenna (and the Essendon Football

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Match Previews

    WHADDA WE SING? by Whispering Jack

    When the Melbourne team sang “The Grand Old Flag” last Saturday at Marvel Stadium in the absence of skipper Max Gawn, Ed Langford and Adam Tomlinson who were first time winners at their new club and Jayden Hunt, the leading goal kicker of the day it was passed off as an honest mistake. Taken in isolation, it most probably was accidental but the problem is that little accidents have been happening far too often in the club’s recent history and, in this case, it was symptomatic not only of a day t

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Match Previews

    A POINT OF DIFFERENCE by George on the Outer

    It was Melbourne v Carlton at the comics stadium; a game between 16 and 17 in 2019. How could anyone pick a winner?  There had to be a point of difference, and so it would prove to be as the Demons literally fell over the line at the end, by a solitary point. In an almost complete replica of the Richmond v Collingwood game two nights previously, one of the sides (Melbourne in this case) rushed out to a five goal lead in the first quarter, while the Blues failed to bother the goal umpir

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Match Reports

    EXPOSED FORM by The Oracle

    Carlton fancies itself to beat Melbourne at Marvel Stadium on Saturday and, based on exposed form, why not? The Blues took it right up to the reigning premiers in their last up start and the Demons were simply horrible against the Eagles at Optus Stadium. That opening game of the season revived all of the nightmares of 2019 for a team that went inside the 50 metre arc 45 times, an advantage of 10 times over the home side and yet lost by almost five goals. Such statistics sum it up for a gam

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Match Previews

    SOCIAL DISTANCING by George on the Outer

    It was good to see the MFC players practicing the directives about social distancing at the game against West Coast.  Pity was that they continued to do so after the first bounce of the ball, as they allowed numerous WCE players run around un-hindered, with not a Melbourne player within 1.5 metres of them! They then found themselves looking at nearly a 5 goal deficit at the first break, which was to be essentially the final margin for the game. It is difficult to judge exactly what is going

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Match Reports

    BEST IN SHOW by Whispering Jack

    I am writing this knowing that the AFL has deemed that the opening round of competition will proceed but fully believing that it should not.  The world is going through cataclysmic change as a result of the overwhelming spread of the Covid-19 virus and I agree that a distraction like sport would be good for the public. However, while the physical threat to the population is bad enough, there are other  issues to be addressed including the mental health of the community and the effects on th

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Match Previews

    TASSIE DEVILS by Van Demon

    If you were looking for something new from the Demons that wasn’t there last year, you didn’t have to look further than the perfectly trimmed grass surface of UTAS Stadium last night as the team steamrolled the Hawks to record a comprehensive 32-point victory to complete their Marsh Community Series commitments for 2020. One new thing was the fact that for the second Marsh game in a row, the team finished full of running and they dominated the second half without the presence or the dominan

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Match Reports

    SOUTH OF THE BORDER by Paddy Gosch

    The Demons will go into their final Marsh Series match with a strong lineup against the Hawks in Tasmania. Both Max Gawn and Steven May, who were recovering from injuries in first Marsh Series match, have both been named. It is unclear whether Max will be on restricted minutes and will likely get breaks in the ruck with Sam Weideman and rookie Luke Jackson getting their turns in the middle. Angus Brayshaw will be getting his first taste of competitive football despite playing in last week’s

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Match Previews

    KANGAROO CAUGHT by Whispering Jack

    There was a fair amount of debate in our area as to whether the game warranted a full blown match report because it was felt that it was really an elevated version of a training session with match simulation but against a team in opposition colours. Although notionally the stronger side, North seemed to be using the occasion for the purpose of working on aspects of their game plan, one of the features of which seemed to be based on taking the longest possible route out of defence and good luck w

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Match Reports

×
×
  • Create New...