3 word player analysis V the Roos

[dees2010 4]

Davey- prolific but wasteful

Green- our best player

Moloney-wasnt his best

bruce- outstanding 1st half

batram- kept harvey quiet

garland- not his best

sylvia- was quiet (for his standards)

grimes- alot of possessions

trengove- an okay game

frawley- provided good rebound

mcdonald- worked tirelessly

bennell- wasnt very noticeable

rivers- very disappointing game

macdonald- was good with errors (kicking to the man on the mark, unforgivable)

dunn- a better game

jamar- was beaten early

bate- was very quiet

warnock- a few errors (the dropped mark & hale goal.)

jones- worked very hard

petterd- good in patches (dont know how bad that injury was but didnt look great)

martin- didn't look great

scully- the kid can handball

[Old Gregg 1]

Sylvia - was quiet

McDonald - worked tirelessly

Scully - the kid can handball

MacDonald - was good with errors

3 words?

[dees2010 4]

Sylvia - was quiet

McDonald - worked tirelessly

Scully - the kid can handball

MacDonald - was good with errors

3 words?

sylvia- a quiet game

mcdonald- he worked tirelessly

scully- kis can handball

macdonald- good with errors

happy?

[gOLLy 401]

Sylvia : The Footy Show

[joeboy 3,166]

Bartram - was not disgraced

Bate - second half disappearance

Bennell - just occasional glimpses

Bruce - flawed but persevered

Davey - too rarely involved

Dunn - lots to like

Frawley - crucial diposal errors

Garland - rarely made mistakes

Green - only winning forward

Grimes - outstanding game again

Jamar - was gallant again

Jones - too rarely sighted

MacDonald - game to forget

McDonald - tried against odds

Martin - cannot be retained

Moloney - had no influence

Petterd - not a target

Rivers - a pleasing return

Scully - only fleeting glimpses

Sylvia - no messiah today

Trengove - returned to earth

Warnock - good despite pressure

Edited May 1, 2010 by joeboy

[Choko 493]

Bartram - was not disgraced

Bate - second half disappearance

Bennell - just occasional glimpses

Bruce - flawed but persevered

Davey - too rarely involved

Dunn - lots to like

Frawley - crucial diposal errors

Garland - rarely made mistakes

Green - only winning forward

Grimes - outstanding game again

Jamar - was gallant again

Jones - too rarely sighted

MacDonald - game to forget

McDonald - tried against odds

Martin - cannot be retained

Moloney - had no influence

Petterd - not a target

Rivers - a pleasing return

Scully - only fleeting glimpses

Sylvia - no messiah today

Trengove - returned to earth

Warnock - good despite pressure

I disagree about Warnock. I thought he was poor.

Petterd: Always playing behind

Dunn: Too many errors

[Timmuns 16]

sylvia- a quiet game

mcdonald- he worked tirelessly

scully- kis can handball

macdonald- good with errors

happy?

haha I'm glad we got that sorted, I would've struggled getting to sleep tonight otherwise...

[big tuna 0]

Sylvia : The Footy Show

Thats 3 different threads you have bagged Sylvia. I don't want these guys to get over-exposed or ahead of themselves either but I doubt appearing on a TV show 2 days earlier would effect how he played. He didn't get enough of the ball & missed a set shot but took some good grabs and was serviceable.

[tess 19]

I started reading this thread and thought that Joeboy's 3 word analysis had turned to crap, i then looked up and realized he didnt even start this rip off thread.

Lay off his turf!!

[dees2010 4]

I started reading this thread and thought that Joeboy's 3 word analysis had turned to crap, i then looked up and realized he didnt even start this rip off thread.

Lay off his turf!!

whats crap about it?

[wisedog 352]

whats crap about it?

Nothing, but it's kind of joeboy's thing.

They usually generate a couple of pages of good discussion.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

Can anyone explain to me why Grimes kicked sideways almost every time he had the ball? Even right at the end of the game, when North Melbourne had the game won he went sideways when he could of attacked and he sprayed the kick too.

[dees2010 4]

Nothing, but it's kind of joeboy's thing.

They usually generate a couple of pages of good discussion.

well i saw no-one had posted the 3 word analysis and i thought if no one will do it ill give my 2cents worth. sorry if i offended anyone..

[damon the demon 57]

Can anyone explain to me why Grimes kicked sideways almost every time he had the ball? Even right at the end of the game, when North Melbourne had the game won he went sideways when he could of attacked and he sprayed the kick too.

yeah i noticed that for alot of players - could it have been the dreaded GAMEPLAN? The same one we used in the glory days of 2008/09??

[damon the demon 57]

well i saw no-one had posted the 3 word analysis and i thought if no one will do it ill give my 2cents worth. sorry if i offended anyone..

i am only offended at how kind you were to the team after today's effort

[dees2010 4]

i am only offended at how kind you were to the team after today's effort

then please voice your opinion as that is what this site is for..

[damon the demon 57]

then please voice your opinion as that is what this site is for..

Damn well i can try...

Davey - some poor kicking

Green - a true leader

Moloney- 3 bad quarters

bruce - learn from scully

batram - did a job

garland - our best defender (today)

sylvia - poor game today

grimes - some dodgy disposal

trengove - missing at times (although its only his 5th game so he was fine really this 3 word thing is hard)

frawley - not as composed

mcdonald - could be better

bennell - not enough drive

rivers - fairly benign performance

macdonald - kicking needs work (specifically i mean stop kicking it into the man)

dunn - not doing enough

jamar - vital player again

bate - where was he?

warnock - some clangers today

jones - good disposal again

petterd - some class occasionally

martin- not good enough

scully - brilliant playmaker again

Edited May 1, 2010 by damo_araimbo

[dee-luded 2,959]

Davey- Not running well

Green- our best player

Moloney-wasnt his best

bruce-butchers the ball

batram- kept harvey quiet

garland- not his best

sylvia- wasted up forward

grimes- alot of possessions

trengove- a learning game

frawley- provided good rebound

mcdonald- worked all day

bennell- time for rest

rivers- very disappointing game

macdonald- off his game

dunn- tried but ummn

jamar- off like rest

bate- no good supply

warnock- a few errors

jones- ineffective by'n' large

petterd- good in patches

martin- not ready, forward

scully- give him ahand

[dees2010 4]

i'd also like to know why davey made so many mistakes, & hasnt really progressed since an oustanding year last year. (bar collingwood game)

you can usually breathe easy when Davey has the footy that it will advantage us

[joeboy 3,166]

I started reading this thread and thought that Joeboy's 3 word analysis had turned to crap, i then looked up and realized he didnt even start this rip off thread.

Lay off his turf!!

Thanks Tess - if it happens again I'll sue ( removes tongue from cheek )

[45HG 1,559]

Rivers - not best 22

[loges 6,767]

Can anyone explain to me why Grimes kicked sideways almost every time he had the ball? Even right at the end of the game, when North Melbourne had the game won he went sideways when he could of attacked and he sprayed the kick too.

Obvious instuction after 1/2 time was to spread the ball more, had to try something we were getting smashed up the middle, worked too

[loges 6,767]

I disagree about Warnock. I thought he was poor.

Petterd: Always playing behind

Dunn: Too many errors

Warnock was good, Martin learn to mark

[heartbeatstrue 57]

Sylvia - was quiet

McDonald - worked tirelessly

Scully - the kid can handball

MacDonald - was good with errors

3 words?

Quick fix:

Bruce- disappointing 2nd half

Sylvia- just not sharp

McDonald- safe and sure

Macdonald- too many mistakes

Jamar- big hearted improver

Scully- kid can play

[3Dee 1,153]

martin back to casey thanks