We need a key position forward. ASAP

[sylvinator 96]

I agree, we do need a key forward in the team, and our forward line needs improving.

BUT, we are dealing with injuries. We have at least 4-5 strong forward options out of the team with injury! I don't any team in the afl could be a strong forward line with that many forwards out. See how StKilda do with one forward option out.

In 4 weeks time, I think our forward line will look like this: (with Jurrah to be added to this forward set up later in the year)

Green, Bate, Sylvia

Watts, Pettard, Wonaeamirri

...also chuck through Bennell, Morton

Our forward line today:

Green, Newton, Dunn

Bate, Pettard, Bennell

With Jones running through there.

Thats IN: Sylvia, Watts, Wona, Morton.... OUT: Newton, Dunn'

Those additions will make us MUCH more dangerous up forward. Honestly don't know how anyone can expect us to kick 15 goals a game with Newton and Dunn as our main forwards.

[Redleg 40,926]

Next week Sylvia should return with Rivers. Martin kicked three for Casey and he is a better option both up forward and supporting Jamar in the ruck, than Newton. Bit of work for the first time for the selectors.

Edited April 11, 2010 by Redleg

[Trengove_is_God 0]

Cant wait to get Sylvia back vs the Tigers.

What a boost that will be.

And he can hit the scoreboard.

Good times.

[Akum 2,660]

i watched the game at casey last nite, JW played very well, when the balls around hes knees he pretty good ,hes ready to walk into our side, hes disposals first class for a boy his size, its time for him to step up.

Yeh the signs were good, I felt for the first time he really seemed to be picking up the pace of the game. Presented particularly well and gave them a lot of drive, especially in the second half, decision-making and disposal very good (even in traffic & under pressure) and once or twice sublime. One piece of play he led up past the wing to receive a kick out of defence, baulked around the guy on his mark, then a perfectly-weighted kick over about 40m to a teammate with an opponent right on his hammer who hardly had to break stride, which led to a goal. And he seems to be working out how to put his draft-camp pace-off-the-mark & agility to advantage during a game, backed himself a few times. Uncharacteristically missed some gettable goals though. IMO if he had another week or two at Casey he'd be even better for it.

But Martin was very good too, in the air and on the ground, very lively, again missed some he could have got, could have easily had 5 or 6 instead of 3. We saw last year a few of the 'fringe' players go back to Casey for a week or two and then perform much better when they came back to the Dees, can see the same happening to Stef over the next few weeks. He'll probably be needed against Brisbane because Jamar will need some help against their rucks.

Edited April 11, 2010 by Akum

[praha 11,240]

Worst thread ever

When he comes in he needs to be one of 22 and not "the saviour"

Happy to see him at Casey for anotehr 3 weeks

I guess you've never visited Bay 13 then?

[e25 5]

After a good game against Collingwood where Melbourne played man-on-man and left players in the forward line, why did Bailey revert back to not having players to kick it to up forward?

During the Before the Bounce session a very good reason was put forward for why this wouldve eventuated, but as I did sign a confidentiality agreement...

All I can do is recommend signing up for it. Very enlightening in terms of the tactics employed and the games within a game.

[DeeVoted 583]

wolfy' date='11 April 2010 - 06:36 PM'

Another 1st half with only one goal. I know the win was great and all that, but it was against another winless side.

Throw Watts in at the deep end and let him sink or swim. If he's up to it he will show it. If not, move him on.

I can understand your frustration, you are NOT alone.

BUT Watts and Co really need to show something at Casey before they get into the seniors. Make them ALL earn a selection, the same applies for keeping a spot in the 1sts.

He probably need 1/2 dozen good games on end.

IF he comes back before he shows more than 2 good games, if he doesnt fire in the 1sts, he will be canned for being a spud No1 draft.

[Trengove_is_God 0]

Another 1st half with only one goal. I know the win was great and all that, but it was against another winless side.

Throw Watts in at the deep end and let him sink or swim. If he's up to it he will show it. If not, move him on.

Relax bro.

Things are coming together nicely.

Watts will be in soon, and Jurrah will be return.

[CarnTheDees 52]

Hmm, I don't think that was Bailey's doing. Adelaide insist on playing a terrible brand of football when they come to the MCG. It's not just against us. They always have 1-2 extra players down back, and the Melbourne players that are on those players don't want to enter the 50 so as not to flood our own forward line. It's pretty simple and a tactic Sydney used in 05-06. So suddenly, whenever they get the ball out they stream forward, bringing our players with them. When/if we rebound from our defensive 50, we have no one up forward.

No.

We played about 90% game-time without a MFC player within 30m of goal (including nearly every centre bounce) and I counted two occasions where centre-wing boundary throw-ins were contested with NOT 1 SINGLE PLAYER FROM EITHER SIDE IN EITHER 50m ARC. Both coaches were as bad as each other in playing defensively and both sides continually coughed the ball up in the middle with over-possession of the ground because there were no options inside 50 to kick to.

[DeeSpencer 25,713]

No.

We played about 90% game-time without a MFC player within 30m of goal (including nearly every centre bounce) and I counted two occasions where centre-wing boundary throw-ins were contested with NOT 1 SINGLE PLAYER FROM EITHER SIDE IN EITHER 50m ARC. Both coaches were as bad as each other in playing defensively and both sides continually coughed the ball up in the middle with over-possession of the ground because there were no options inside 50 to kick to.

And at the end of the day we won!

Also at half time we really should have been 3 or 4 goals. The wind wasn't that bad to kick 1.8 or whatever it was.

[Pipefitter 2,159]

I think most people forget how tall Morton is. Once he fills out i see him and Watts both playing as athletic talls in our forward line and will pose nightmares to defenders for the next 10 years. Jurrah with a supporting cast of crumbers such as Bennell, Wona (fingers crossed), Marric and flankers in Sylvia and Bate. That there is the future.

[jayceebee31 761]

I think most people forget how tall Morton is. Once he fills out i see him and Watts both playing as athletic talls in our forward line and will pose nightmares to defenders for the next 10 years. Jurrah with a supporting cast of crumbers such as Bennell, Wona (fingers crossed), Marric and flankers in Sylvia and Bate. That there is the future.

Excellent points you raise- I see this as well.However I feel Gawn will also play a massive role in our forward line.But I still would like us to pick up at least a couple more Talls..

Edited April 11, 2010 by jayceebee31

[wolfy 0]

Excellent points you raise- I see this as well.However I feel Gawn will also play a massive role in our forward line.But I still would like us to pick up at least a couple more Talls..

I would love to think that Wonna will be with us for the long term, but really, it's just not going to happen. Too many injuries.