MFC Best & Worst of 2008

[Whispering_Jack 30,173]

Best:

1. Hawthorn (the second time)
2. Comeback v Freo Round 7
3. Brisbane Lions at the G

Worst:

1. Hawthorn Round 1
2. Bulldogs Round 2
3. Richmond Round 22

[Al`s DEMONS 0]

for mine it was the emergance of some promising young talnt. then picking up Watts and Jurrah. the indiginous boys all bring the x factor , i cant wait to see him in the forward 50 with Aussie and the Flash. as Big Kev (R.I.P) would say , Im excited

[Trisul 664]

Best:

1. Comeback v Freo

2. Lions at the G

3. Hawthorn (2)

Worst:

1. Geelong (2)

2. Bulldogs (1)

3. Hawthorn (1)

[wisedog 352]

Best:

The Fremantle game was just incredible. I decided to drive down from Ballarat after lunch and didn't arrive until half time.

What timing!

Worst:

Western Bulldogs in Round 2. The worst game I've ever been to.

[Guest JACKtheRIPPER]

best, garland, aussie , morton ,martin, and i think simon buckley is going to be a lot better than we thought, that lads got a fair bit of dash. worst by a long shot was the last game of season , whitey and ooze deserved better than that.

[LeBron James 41]

Best:

1. Comeback v Freo

2. Lions at the G

3. Hawthorn (2)

Worst:

1. Geelong (2)

2. Bulldogs (1)

3. Hawthorn (1)

Ding ding ding - winner!

[Bring-Back-Powell 14,842]

BEST:

Fremantle (rd 7) - One of the best wins I've experienced since 1989. Fancy coming back from 51 points.

Brisbane (rd 14) - Gutsy comeback from being 11 points down at the 28 minute mark. Beat a team in form.

West Coast (rd 20) - Sorry but even though this was one the worst wins I can remember, it still beats an honorable loss.

The Collingwood, Geelong (rd 3), Hawthorn (rd 9) and Essendon games were games where we could hold our heads high as a club.

WORST:

Geelong (rd 19) - Probably the reason we didn't get any home Fri night games next year.

Richmond (rd 22) - Pitiful disgraceful display. [censored] way to send MFC greats out. The players didn't play for the coach. The players should be made to watch this game over and over again to install in their heads that this type of performace cannot be tolerated at the MFC.

St Kilda (rd 10) - The players were not interested, pure and simple. Robbo set the tone in the first minute with his fluff up in the goal square. I guess it didn't help that St Kilda were beaten up all week by the media (after a bad loss to Brisbane)

[Big Kev 369]

for mine it was the emergance of some promising young talnt. then picking up Watts and Jurrah. the indiginous boys all bring the x factor , i cant wait to see him in the forward 50 with Aussie and the Flash. as Big Kev (R.I.P) would say , Im excited

Rumours of my death are exagerated

[Rolling Stone 157]

Best:

Hawthorn (the second time)

I agree with that one because it was the first sign we showed of the value of our emerging youth and especially down back. We worried the ultimate premiers all day and were still within striking distance just 8 rounds after the same opposition had pantsed us in the opening game. If we can build on that with further team and individual improvement, a healthy team and the introduction of some more skillful young players then we have a future.

[52k2 0]

By far the best single event was PJ run down of the Brisbane player. This happened just in front of us, the look on his face said the Brisbane

was never going to get away.

His attitude should be taken up by all the players.

[joeboy 3,166]

Wona's grabbing of the ball and thrilling dash forward in the last seconds against The Loins was the most spine tingling episode IMO, not to mention his ' war dance ' celebrations .

[Al`s DEMONS 0]

Rumours of my death are exagerated

sorry mate, in that case can i get a carton of shower power and easy off bam

[Al`s DEMONS 0]

Rumours of my death are exagerated

sorry mate, in that case can i get a carton of shower power and easy off bam

[Slartibartfast 17,297]

The Best

1. Cale Morton

2. Colin Garland

3. Stef Martin

4. Jack Grimes overcoming a significant injury, playing a game and doing a full PS to Christmas.

5. Dean Bailey's composure under pressure.

The Worst

1. Round 19 (Geelong)

2. Round 21 (PA at AAMI)

3. Round 22 (Richmond)

Wins and losses mean nothing in a year like 2008. Players are our future and I think we have 4 rippers.

I'd nearly include round 20 in the worst (where we beat WC) but the last four games of the season were the most painful I've had to sit through.

[Hards 2]

Best

From an individual standpoint, Garland's improvement, some flashes from Wona, Martin, Morton and Buckley, and just Brad Green in general.

In terms of games, probably the second Hawthorn loss and the first Geelong loss

Worst

The same mistakes from Round 1 were being made in Round 22

Green not winning the B+F

The one man forward line

Three wins - all at the MCG, all against interstate sides, one of which was tanking, and the other two against sides with a combined away record of 3-19 (and the only win of those three in Melb was at TD, not the G).

[hillie 41]

Best

From an individual standpoint, Garland's improvement, some flashes from Wona, Martin, Morton and Buckley, and just Brad Green in general.

In terms of games, probably the second Hawthorn loss and the first Geelong loss

Worst

The same mistakes from Round 1 were being made in Round 22

Green not winning the B+F

The one man forward line

Three wins - all at the MCG, all against interstate sides, one of which was tanking, and the other two against sides with a combined away record of 3-19 (and the only win of those three in Melb was at TD, not the G).

yeah i thought green was bloody fantastic this year. constantly running back with the flight of the ball to take contested marks. definately thought he shoulda won the b&f. one of the few playes to stand up and want to play for the jumper. despite the trade week rumours. really only proved he wanted to play for the jumper in the end.

i can't put an honourable loss in the best 3, and i can't put in a win against a team that didn't really want to win. i can only really say there were 2 'best' games.

the freo comeback and the brissy game (which we deserved to win all day mind you)

but to say there was only 2 is really sad.

i think hawthorn in round 1 was the most disappointing. to go into round 1 with the hope of the season ahead and to come out of that game with a 100 point loss was extremely disappointing.

R19 geelong and R 22 richmond, to roll over and not even give a whimper, whilst sending off club champions is really a disgrace and an absolute embarassment.

[montasaurus 0]

The best moments have already been well covered, - Jimmy taking the presidency would also have to be well up there.

for me the best thing I took away from 08 was nov-dec. Suddenly, almost overnight the club turned around poor off field performance. We signed a living legend as a coach. Drafted as well as we could have done so and suddenly there seems to be a real belief around the place. Debt demolition would also have to be right up there, with out this we may not have had a club.

The single moment though - PJ how could you go past that.

The worst for me would have been our performance off field. At times more embarrising then any of our performances. Also add all the injuries sustained early in the year.

Best moment in 09 - Jurriah to kick one after the siren to beat the filth and knock them out of the 8.

Worst in 09 - no major sponser?