Its Time to go.....

[godees 873]

Anyone who wants to trade Green is stupid. Full-stop!

And as btdemon said - you have decided you want to trade anyone going well. Although, I do understand where you are coming from with Jones, he is young, committed and we can work around his deficiencies IMO.

And I think a lot of people on this forum have no understanding of how trading works. It's highly unlikely we will be involved in more than one or two trades in a normal year. This year, with a very good batch of U18s and GC17 coming in next year to plunder the draft in 09, clubs are going to be very very reluctant to trade.

[godees 873]

Retirements - Neitz, finalised

--------------- Yze he must have recognised the games too quick for him now.

--------------- Holland writings very much on the walls

--------------- White I hope he's decided to go so we can give him a good farewell.

--------------- McDonald not sure yet, but with Green & Miller stepping up as leaders & McLean, maybe don't need Junior so much.

McDonald won't/shouldn't retire. the rest...yeah probably

[Paul Gardner 6]

McDonald won't/shouldn't retire. the rest...yeah probably

Yeah I know, but we have to make space on our list to recruit this year from the U/18's & to have a crack at RWarnock.

[beelzebub 23,383]

Id like to think there will still be room for Junior to add depth next year. Probably only next year..but he is terrific. Others can learn from him.

[Mono 455]

After seeing our 'Captain' shirk a contest today just 5 minutes into the game, I will be very surprised if he isnt shipped off by Dean Bailey during trade week.

Hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha

[Nicho 1]

Retire - Yze, Whelan, J Mac & White (If not traded)

Trade - White (hopefully will have wither Warnock or Natanui to fill the gap), Wheatley (not as good as people seem to think), Bruce (still has some value), Carroll

Delist - Weetra, Messon,

Promote - Wooz & Valenti

Captain - Brad Green with VC Jonsey & Bruce if still on list

[Beamer 1]

Promote - Wooz & Valenti

Captain - Brad Green with VC Jonsey & Bruce if still on list

What about Brock.

I would much rather see Brock and Green co-captains.

I think its something the club could really promote. Having two young players as club captains.

[Yze_Magic 3]

Hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha

Whats so funny?

Check out the replay.

[Jaded No More 68,974]

Newton has ability, absolutely no doubt about it.

What Newton doesn't have is the attitude to make it at this level, as far as I can see anyways.

Above the shoulders he is weak, he has clear selfish tendencies and he doesn't work hard enough.

The contrast between Miller and Newton is huge. Newton has more natural talent, but Miller works incredibly hard and puts in all game long even when the delivery is crap and the ball is not coming his way. That's why Miller will still be playing into his late 20's, but Newton probably won't make it beyond next season... and I desperately wish he would.

[Tex 68]

Sign up Newton for the next 5 years, while we can get him cheap.

Tall lquick eading forwards who can take contested marks are hard to find.

Newton has just turned 21 and is at an age where he will start to improve at`a rapid rate.

Newton was bottom age when recruited and is coming on as expected.

I cannot fathom the morons on this site that want to get rid of him.

Who do you propose we replace him with?

I see a future forward line of the following:

HF: Miller Watts Davey

For: Sylvia Newton Wona

Bate and Maric as back up support.

[Tex 68]

As for trades, i would put up for trade Frawley, Bell and Bruce.

All three have some value.

Bell is the only one i would keep if we couldn't get something decent for as if he eventally gets his head right he could be a gun.

Frawley is now surplus to our needs and is well and truely behind Garland, Warnock, Rivers and Martin as tall key backs.

Bruce isn't in our future plans. Trade him now for anything while we can.

[Yze_Magic 3]

As for trades, i would put up for trade Frawley, Bell and Bruce.

All three have some value.

Bell is the only one i would keep if we couldn't get something decent for as if he eventally gets his head right he could be a gun.

Frawley is now surplus to our needs and is well and truely behind Garland, Warnock, Rivers and Martin as tall key backs.

Bruce isn't in our future plans. Trade him now for anything while we can.

I agree definitely with Bell and Bruce.

Frawley a possibility, although I am reluctant to trade a young key back taken with pick 12 in just his 2nd season. However, he looks to be a very limited footballler unfortunately.

[deanox 9,989]

some very strange suggestions and opinions in this thread for sure.

regarding newton: i have only seen the first half of the game (had to get to work, and the other half is on tape for tomorrow) but from what i saw never did he get good delivery, a number of times did he look to chase, attempt to tackle and put pressure onto the player with the ball. he was obvously instructed to play deep, with miller and co pushing up the ground. in the first half, how many times did the ball get past the 50? no wonder newton wasn't seen much...yes he has stuff to work on, but if davey and mclean were playing would the disposal to him have been better?

and on that point i move on to jones.

lets first remember some facts about jones. he is 20. he has played less than 50 games. he is a tough, hard, in and under midfielder. he is not a silky outsider finisher, and it shows in his disposal. he obviously has a lo to learn, and has a number of areas he can work on in his game, especially disposal.

but, if you were someone who bagged jones' game today, id like you to tell me who our number 1 midfielder was today (not best on) and the answer is probably jones. he led that mifield today and struggled hard for it all day. when you add brock and davey to the midfield, jones falls down the pecking order. he gets less attention and he can be more effective.

he is just a kid. and he stepped up and threw his heart and soul into it today, never said die and didnt shirk the issue. ever. what more can you ask?

[Yze_Magic 3]

I thought Newton was good today. Would have had close to 10 marks?

He is a natural aerialist, no doubt about it.

[H_T 3,049]

JUICE--- Not got enough, too slow, poor decision making, no 2nd efforts. Good mark but thats it, clearly not up to AFL level, and has had his chances to show what his made of... Dont like lazy footballers, his work rate is poor!!! Get rid of him...

No way. You can't say that based on today's game. There was barely a forward 50 entry in the first half. Prefer to wait and see. Remember it was his first game back from injury and niggles.

[Pipefitter 2,168]

Must be persisted with.

He took 4 contested marks today: I think that is a good sign.

Has ability and hopefully over the coming weeks we will all see it.

4 contested marks is what we need. If you look at the stats at some games this year, that number is usually our total for the whole team.

[Tex 68]

4 contested marks is what we need. If you look at the stats at some games this year, that number is usually our total for the whole team.

I would be interested to know how many inside 50's we had yesterday. Does anyone know?

[The Emblem 1]

I would be interested to know how many inside 50's we had yesterday. Does anyone know?

46 v 56 Haydo

[Tex 68]

So not only was the quality of ball inside 50 poor, but the total supply was also low.

Newton took 8 marks, including 4 contested.

Pretty damn good for his first game back in the seniors since Rd 1.

The Bulldogs only had 5 contested marks for the whole game.

Dare i say it, but Newton, in my very humble opinion, has the potential to be a more dominant Key Forward than Neita.

[Beamer 1]

Frawley a possibility, although I am reluctant to trade a young key back taken with pick 12 in just his 2nd season. However, he looks to be a very limited footballler unfortunately.

Alot of backmen have limited games but at this stage his development has been excellent. He's had some big jobs this year and done some well.

Things like Skill and Strength which are his weaknesses can be worked upon.

[LeBron James 41]

I can't beleive anyone would think of writing off Frawley at this early stage. Garland ring a bell anyone?

[Tex 68]

I can't beleive anyone would think of writing off Frawley at this early stage. Garland ring a bell anyone?

From all reports Frawley was well beaten on the weekend for Sandy.

He is surplus to our needs.

Trade him while he still has value for something we need like draft picks or some pace in the midfield.

[The HuLK 139]

I can`t believe the lack of intensity Newton shows... Such a hack.. How long do we gota give this guy?

[praha 11,240]

I can`t believe the lack of intensity Newton shows... Such a hack.. How long do we gota give this guy?

He's a total waste of space. There is no room for improvement in this kid. Seriously. I'd rather have Carroll or White playing instead of him, because gives absolutely nothing and there's no positivity coming from him being in the seniors.

[sylvinator 96]

He's a total waste of space. There is no room for improvement in this kid. Seriously. I'd rather have Carroll or White playing instead of him, because gives absolutely nothing and there's no positivity coming from him being in the seniors.

Newton has no real future.

he may be good in the air, but no afl player can expect to be successful when he is completely useless once the ball hits the ground.

i dont like Newton at all i see very little if any promise in him becoming a good afl player